Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want MIL for lunch tomorrow?

337 replies

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 15:23

I will say I do like my MIL generally. PIL died about 8 months ago so I feel mean about resenting her coming for Sunday lunch - but this will be the 5th time since Christmas. Everytime we have a free Sunday DH invites her over. Dh has said he will cook so really I have nothing to worry about. Dd and I were looking forward to a chill day tomorrow though. I'm just a bit sick of it. We are also quite skint - all PILs assets went to MIL but she never brings anything not even a bottle of wine.

Just a bit bored with it tbh.

OP posts:
Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 20:16

Mammyloveswine · 25/02/2023 20:08

Op I think if you had put in your original post about caring for your terminally ill brother all week then you would have had totally different responses from those that have been less than kind.

Have you had a frank discussion with your DH? What has he said?

I'm so sorry about your brother, I'm pleased that he is currently doing well and that you all cherish the time you have and make some lovely memories.

Perhaps.

I didn't originally want to go into so much detail.

OP posts:
Mammyloveswine · 25/02/2023 20:08

Op I think if you had put in your original post about caring for your terminally ill brother all week then you would have had totally different responses from those that have been less than kind.

Have you had a frank discussion with your DH? What has he said?

I'm so sorry about your brother, I'm pleased that he is currently doing well and that you all cherish the time you have and make some lovely memories.

aloris · 25/02/2023 20:02

diddl · 25/02/2023 19:52

I just couldn't. Maybe that's where my problem lies, but if I have anyone round I like to act like a host.

Even if you managed to not act like a host, depending on what a "chill" day is for you & your daughter it still might not work with MIL there.

That is how I would feel. I just can't relax with people around who are not the nuclear family. Even if they are lovely people.

LookItsMeAgain · 25/02/2023 19:56

I'm so sorry that I misunderstood who was terminally ill.
Sending you strength to get through the difficult times ahead.

Hellybelly84 · 25/02/2023 19:55

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:29

Some of these posts are really cruel and makes you think what makes people want to be like that?

But lots are understanding and some more firm and practical. It's good to have a reality check. Thanks.

Just to say again that I really like my MIL. We've always got on well. When my PIL was in hospital I visited twice a day - he wouldn't let anyone feed him but me. The day he died my brother told me his cancer had spread and he was not expected to recover. He is actually doing really well at the moment but needs a lot of support which I am helping him and my SIL (who I think is on here!) with, not to mention my nieces and nephews. He also lives almost 3 hours away. My work has been brilliant. Dd has been brilliant. Dh has been brilliant. I just want a Sunday with absolutely no commitments except dd and dh.

Some people really are cruel 😩and you are doing nothing wrong wanting a day just for your family. You totally deserve it.

I would block out weekends in your diary (or at least Sundays) that are absolutely just for your family. Nothing at all to be booked/arranged. We do this anyway (without juggling all the things you have going on). Time with your own family (doing nothing) is so important especially for mental health.

Does your MIL have friends near her she could see on weekends you dont see her? Does she go to any groups (church groups, coffee mornings etc). You could try and encourage these aswell to help with loneliness as much as possible.

aloris · 25/02/2023 19:55

To me this seems like a marriage problem. Your dh presumably knows you are burnt out and that you have your own brother to worry about but he's still using up all your Sunday downtime with his mum, spending family money on expensive roasts, and having everything the way she likes it without really accounting for your reasonable needs, e.g. roast instead of pasta bake, hosting and entertaining her instead of asking her to blend in around what the family is doing that day, etc.

In the big picture where your needs matter as a person, and to your husband, this is a problem that should be easy to solve. How hard is it to just decide together with your husband, ok next weekend we will have a chill day, no visitors, then back to the grind of caring for family the following weekend. It's not a lot to ask frankly. You should be able to say, "I'm burnt out, I need a weekend of no hosting" and his response should be, "Understood, let's take a weekend off next week." And yet you are in this situation where you want a chill Sunday, one chill Sunday, and you can't get it. Why?

EL8888 · 25/02/2023 19:53

I don't know what she's dictating so much for other people, even though it's not her house e.g. what everyone wears, what food is served, what time it is served etc 🙄. Last time l had dinner at MIL's she served what she wanted, l was polite and ate it

She's never worked so is lucky enough to not realise weekends are typically for a mix of chores and trying to recharge batteries. But that is the reality for most people. Plus the situation with your brother, which must be really hard. Your MIL and husband should be more understanding

diddl · 25/02/2023 19:52

I just couldn't. Maybe that's where my problem lies, but if I have anyone round I like to act like a host.

Even if you managed to not act like a host, depending on what a "chill" day is for you & your daughter it still might not work with MIL there.

bussteward · 25/02/2023 19:50

TangledWebOfDeception · 25/02/2023 19:41

But she’d really be perfectly fine, wouldn’t she!

She might even secretly enjoy doing something completely different and out of the ordinary with you and DD.

Yes, I was going to say this! She might enjoy the distraction/change of pace/“bending the rules”. She might surprise you.

TangledWebOfDeception · 25/02/2023 19:41

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:36

Yes. MIL is quite old fashioned (well she's 80!) so already has a hard time accepting that dh cooks lunch
I think she'd have a conniption if I left him to it and sat on the sofa with dd watching Physical 100 on Netflix 😄

But she’d really be perfectly fine, wouldn’t she!

She might even secretly enjoy doing something completely different and out of the ordinary with you and DD.

ReneBumsWombats · 25/02/2023 19:41

I'd actually feel very sad if I had been in a family a long time and thought we all got on, but someone still didn't feel able to relax around me and thought they had to be "on" as a host rather than treating me as family.

I don't say that to have a go. I just mean you may be surprised at how fine MIL is likely to be with you not being "on" and how she may even prefer you not to be. You say she's nice.

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:38

Dishwashersaurous · 25/02/2023 19:37

I really think that you need to think about not doing what is expected, and doing what you are able to do comfortably.

Just because someone is over, doesn't mean that you have to be 'on' and hosting

Yes especially as this is going to be a long term thing and at some point my lovely brother will die.

I'm actually quite worried about myself.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 25/02/2023 19:37

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:32

I just couldn't. Maybe that's where my problem lies, but if I have anyone round I like to act like a host.

In the kindest way, if MIL isn't pressuring you, then you're doing it to yourself. You obviously know her and get on with her, and she's not there for you to wait on her, she's there to spend time with her son while they grieve her husband/his father.

It isn't fair to do something like this because you "like" to feel you're doing a certain thing and then get resentful towards the person who isn't demanding it of you. She's long term family and your husband's mother, try to trust her a bit.

I'm very sorry about your brother. She might prove to be a good support to you in future when you need it.

If the cost of the roast is a problem, I don't think it's unreasonable to explain that you're struggling and would she mind chipping in a bit.

Dishwashersaurous · 25/02/2023 19:37

I really think that you need to think about not doing what is expected, and doing what you are able to do comfortably.

Just because someone is over, doesn't mean that you have to be 'on' and hosting

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:36

TangledWebOfDeception · 25/02/2023 19:34

Try to shift this a little in small steps so that you get used to not pouring out so much. You need to prioritise other things now, rather than being silly about things that don’t really matter all that much.

Yes. MIL is quite old fashioned (well she's 80!) so already has a hard time accepting that dh cooks lunch
I think she'd have a conniption if I left him to it and sat on the sofa with dd watching Physical 100 on Netflix 😄

OP posts:
HazyDragon · 25/02/2023 19:35

If had a 'lazy pjs Sunday' snatched away from me at the last minute, I'd feel aggravated too! Even if it was someone I really like and enjoy spending time with.

OP isn't even saying she can't come, just having a bit of a moan, what's the big deal? I also had a good laugh at the posters telling her to go 'run errands' or book into a hotel 😅.

I would definitely tell DH that the next free Sunday is a guest free zone. Everyone needs a bit of time to themselves.

TangledWebOfDeception · 25/02/2023 19:34

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:32

I just couldn't. Maybe that's where my problem lies, but if I have anyone round I like to act like a host.

Try to shift this a little in small steps so that you get used to not pouring out so much. You need to prioritise other things now, rather than being silly about things that don’t really matter all that much.

TangledWebOfDeception · 25/02/2023 19:33

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:29

Some of these posts are really cruel and makes you think what makes people want to be like that?

But lots are understanding and some more firm and practical. It's good to have a reality check. Thanks.

Just to say again that I really like my MIL. We've always got on well. When my PIL was in hospital I visited twice a day - he wouldn't let anyone feed him but me. The day he died my brother told me his cancer had spread and he was not expected to recover. He is actually doing really well at the moment but needs a lot of support which I am helping him and my SIL (who I think is on here!) with, not to mention my nieces and nephews. He also lives almost 3 hours away. My work has been brilliant. Dd has been brilliant. Dh has been brilliant. I just want a Sunday with absolutely no commitments except dd and dh.

It’s completely okay for you to feel this way @Moonphantom - you are running on empty and soon you will be completely burnt out.

You need to communicate this very clearly to your DH until he gets it, and agree that you must have one weekend a month, absolutely with no exceptions, to rest and recuperate on whatever way you need. This is really important for your wellbeing and that of those you are doing so much for.

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:32

ReneBumsWombats · 25/02/2023 19:30

I've read OP's posts but I don't see where she said MIL makes slobbing about not an option? She likes a roast, but the husband is making that so I don't see why OP can't relax on the sofa in front of the box?

I just couldn't. Maybe that's where my problem lies, but if I have anyone round I like to act like a host.

OP posts:
Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:31

Out of interest, did your PIL help you with childcare or house stuff when they were younger?

Actually, practically no. FIL was financially generous but MIL never babysat.

OP posts:
ReneBumsWombats · 25/02/2023 19:30

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 25/02/2023 19:09

OP has already said that this isn't the case that they could just slob about.

I've read OP's posts but I don't see where she said MIL makes slobbing about not an option? She likes a roast, but the husband is making that so I don't see why OP can't relax on the sofa in front of the box?

Moonphantom · 25/02/2023 19:29

Some of these posts are really cruel and makes you think what makes people want to be like that?

But lots are understanding and some more firm and practical. It's good to have a reality check. Thanks.

Just to say again that I really like my MIL. We've always got on well. When my PIL was in hospital I visited twice a day - he wouldn't let anyone feed him but me. The day he died my brother told me his cancer had spread and he was not expected to recover. He is actually doing really well at the moment but needs a lot of support which I am helping him and my SIL (who I think is on here!) with, not to mention my nieces and nephews. He also lives almost 3 hours away. My work has been brilliant. Dd has been brilliant. Dh has been brilliant. I just want a Sunday with absolutely no commitments except dd and dh.

OP posts:
Salome61 · 25/02/2023 19:25

I'm widowed and the meal I miss the most is Sunday lunch. In seven years no-one has ever invited me. I did go to a local pub once with my beloved late dog and had a pea risotto but felt so self conscious - and the curly pea shoots nearly choked me! My aunt is widowed and really jealous of her widowed friend, her NDN gives her a roast dinner on a plate every Sunday.

I think once a month would be a treat, on the last Sunday maybe?

MachineBee · 25/02/2023 19:24

OP - you’re getting a hard time on here. You have so many caring responsibilities and there is precious left for your self or even you and your DH.

I remember when my inlaws moved house in their late 60s. We helped them moved but then every weekend after there was something else they needed us for. After about 3 months I said we wouldn’t be round the following weekend as we had things we needed to do on our own house. My goodness, you would have thought we’d said we planned to cook puppies and kittens on a bbq! The emotional blackmail that came out was dreadful.

I would try to relax this arrangement a little month by month - perhaps as suggested by PP have a weekend a month off to begin with, then make it an arrangement for a different time of the weekend etc. You are doing your MIL no favours by having this very regular arrangement- it could stop her seeing friends or adapting to her new life. Try to help her remain as independent for as possible as possible.

CherryHouse · 25/02/2023 19:22

You sound thoughtful and kind OP. 5 out of 8 Sundays so far is a lot to be hosting!!

Out of interest, did your PIL help you with childcare or house stuff when they were younger?

I’m massively resentful that we end up with 1 weekend a month dominated with a PIL visit for 2-3 nights 🤦🏽‍♀️ That’s 25% of weekends per year 😭 (I don’t have parents, so it’s all them). They’re not the type to help and expect to be entertained, fed and watered (actual make that “wined and dined”). Their contribution is the petrol cost to come to our house 😂 Awesome, what a treat!!

I’m resentful as I’ve got only so many years till my DC leave home. I’d hate to be an imposition. Hopefully I’ll be actually helpful, kind and non-judgemental to DCs’ other halves.

Like bugger am I sharing mother’s day this year!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread