Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cont (2) autism diagnosis and descriptions

137 replies

OneFrenchEgg · 25/02/2023 14:27

Continued from previous thread

OP posts:
Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 19:10

@OneFrenchEgg I think the difficulties are more aligned than in other areas, both groups fail to access medical support/treatment due to their disability.

Pira · 27/02/2023 19:07

@OneFrenchEgg That's really interesting, thanks for sharing. My DS doesn't have any issues at school, so far. Any issues he had during the younger years have sorted themselves out as he's matured... for instance, he doesn't squabble anymore, if he doesn't fancy doing what his friends are, he goes and plays with someone else or is happy to do his own thing. My DS is a sensory seeker (class clown) so doesn't have any particular aversions to activities, and as far as I am aware, he follows classroom rules well and is doing exceptionally well academically.

What did you do when it all fell apart, if you don't mind me asking?

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 19:02

Your response suggested I was elevating the struggles of one cohort above another. Not mentioning the average mortality age for people with an LD /A doesn't mean I don't recognise it. I was reflecting on the hidden disability nature of the cohort previously referred to as HFA or Asperger's.

OP posts:
Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 18:49

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 17:19

I think you should consider my post in the spirit of this and the previous thread - there is no suggestion I think life is easily navigated for others with an autism diagnosis. Let's not start being snippy.

I wasn’t and am slightly nonplused that you think I am.

kindercup · 27/02/2023 18:12

I wouldn’t agree with this at all @kindercup i do think people occupy different places on the spectrum

You don't have to agree. You are wrong though.

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 18:04

He did but it was more daily with falling out with friends that could be put down to squabbles (like choosing a game) and noone seemed to bully him or actively injure his sense of self or wellbeing. He couldn't really follow classroom unspoken rules, and didn't like some activities ('dirty' like sand or mud) but there was nothing ringing bells. Secondary it all fell apart.

OP posts:
Pira · 27/02/2023 18:02

@OneFrenchEgg Did your child struggle with much at primary school? We are finding DS is very self-assured with high self-confidence. I have already thought about home schooling him through secondary (I'm teacher).

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 17:44

I think secondary and adulthood is where the masking and social difficulties really became a problem (if they are going to become one). For us primary was easier and more forgiving, any differences were overcome by a shared love of Pokémon etc.

OP posts:
Pira · 27/02/2023 17:40

Where my DS struggles is with his social skills and hyperactivity. I'd say his hyperactivity (associated with his ADHD), is the thing that impacts him the most. I still would struggle to describe DS as 'disabled' though, when he leads such a normal life, compared to my friend's DS who is profoundly autistic.

Pira · 27/02/2023 17:26

@OneFrenchEgg Neurodiversity may work better when we are discussing it in the future. He's at an age where he hasn't noticed his differences yet, and there's no reason he would. He has friends, a large supportive family, he is very independent and doesn't struggle with age appropriate activities, does not need extra assistance at school, can participate in all areas of 'regular life.' It does seem wrong, at present, to describe him as disabled. Nobody who comes into contact with DS would consider him disabled, and he certainly wouldn't identify as being disabled or much different from his peer group.

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 17:21

Pira · 27/02/2023 17:16

@OneFrenchEgg I don't necessarily think going back to Asperger's or quirky characteristics is the answer, but it's the only terminology we can currently use which describes DS, and which people understand. Not just member's of the public, but care givers, teachers etc. Using the terms 'ASD' or 'autistic' lead to people making unhelpful assumptions, like school stating he has problems with routine change (he categorically does not). Which is why I question how much the diagnosis is currently helping him at present, and how much it will help him in the future, when his traits definitely fall under the 'unusual social skills' rather than anything else that is associated with autism.

So does the neurodiversity conversation work for you/ him? The idea that it's a minority grouping along with other neurodiversities, rather than a disabling condition in itself due to impairment? I'm curious about all of this and how we see ourselves and others.

OP posts:
OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 17:19

Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 16:50

Life expectancy for individuals with autism, learning disability is I think 40 so while it’s in a different way I would imagine life isn’t well navigated for them either.

I think you should consider my post in the spirit of this and the previous thread - there is no suggestion I think life is easily navigated for others with an autism diagnosis. Let's not start being snippy.

OP posts:
Pira · 27/02/2023 17:16

@OneFrenchEgg I don't necessarily think going back to Asperger's or quirky characteristics is the answer, but it's the only terminology we can currently use which describes DS, and which people understand. Not just member's of the public, but care givers, teachers etc. Using the terms 'ASD' or 'autistic' lead to people making unhelpful assumptions, like school stating he has problems with routine change (he categorically does not). Which is why I question how much the diagnosis is currently helping him at present, and how much it will help him in the future, when his traits definitely fall under the 'unusual social skills' rather than anything else that is associated with autism.

Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 16:50

Life expectancy for individuals with autism, learning disability is I think 40 so while it’s in a different way I would imagine life isn’t well navigated for them either.

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 16:41

I think the suicide rates amongst non LD autistic women speak for how difficult navigating life can be for people who are expected to participate in mainstream society. It's a completely different challenge, and not comparable to the disabled people with limited communication, physical challenges, no sleep and their carers. I do think more nuance would help, but not going back to Asperger's and the 'little professor' and quirky characteristics associated with it because that denied any disability.

OP posts:
Pira · 27/02/2023 16:09

I posted about my DS on the previous thread, and how autism or ASD doesn't seem to fit him. I feel fraudulent using the diagnosis and it also doesn't help him. People, not just the public but teachers, assume he will have stereotypical autistic traits (rigid thinking, repetitive behaviours or interests, meltdowns/shutdowns, routine oriented, needing extra help at school, being fearful to try new things - he's trying a tea cake for the first time as I type this!) He doesn't have any of these 'traits', so describing him as being autistic does not seem to help him or the understanding of people around him. People seem to understand him much better when I say he struggles with his social skills, or he is Aspergers or 'aspie'.

I think the current system fails both ends of the 'spectrum'. And whilst the autistic spectrum isn't linear, in my opinion there are clear differences in functioning between what most people would describe as 'high' and 'low'.

Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 15:49

It’s the interaction of the deficits (and gifts) that makes it a spectrum.

SouthCountryGirl · 27/02/2023 15:43

Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 14:45

I wouldn’t agree with this at all @kindercup i do think people occupy different places on the spectrum and that it refers to the intertwining of their deficits and gifts so the whole cane be more than the sum of the parts. Eg if we used three disabilities like deaf, blind, and mute, someone who was very visually impaired, partially deaf, with no speech would have very different needs to someone with mild VI, totally deaf, but verbal.

The disabilities you've mentioned are easier to separate though. I'm lumped in with friends of mine who work full time, have long term partners, kids etc. They don't have the sensory issues I have. I can't unlike them attend groups because I can't cope with noise or crowds

I'm classed as partially sighted. Like my friends with a different visual impairment who are registered partially sighted, neither of us are able to drive and struggle with things like reading. Yes we see differently but our needs aren't wildly different.

Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 14:46

Having a diagnosis of Asperger’s isn’t offensive, as it is still in use.

ISaySteadyOn · 27/02/2023 14:46

Artemi · 27/02/2023 12:31

I was diagnosed with Aspergers as an adult.

Whilst it does affect my life, (I was diagnosed following a significant breakdown and in hindsight I've been "weird" all my life) I obviously present very differently to more severe autism.

I understand there's an argument for promoting better understanding of the range of severities that now fall under the ASD umbrella, but I also feel uncomfortable that more functional people are the ones dominating the discussion, when we are in a position of privilege

Personally I prefer using the old fashioned term of Aspergers to explain myself, as I find people tend to understand it better. But then I've been told that's offensive and I'm distancing myself from other autistic people out of abelism. But I've also been told off for saying "high functioning autism" too

So I don't know what the more correct/PC/better language to use is :(
People have different needs and I think it's not necessarily a bad thing for language to reflect that

That's what I was trying to get at in my post but you articulated it so much better. Thank you!

Itisbetter · 27/02/2023 14:45

kindercup · 27/02/2023 08:37

@ISaySteadyOn

I don't know what's really the correct word for where I am on the spectrum.

Start by learning about what the spectrum refers to. It's not something people are placed upon. There is no me here and you over there line. The spectrum is about how your autism affects you.

I wouldn’t agree with this at all @kindercup i do think people occupy different places on the spectrum and that it refers to the intertwining of their deficits and gifts so the whole cane be more than the sum of the parts. Eg if we used three disabilities like deaf, blind, and mute, someone who was very visually impaired, partially deaf, with no speech would have very different needs to someone with mild VI, totally deaf, but verbal.

Artemi · 27/02/2023 12:31

I was diagnosed with Aspergers as an adult.

Whilst it does affect my life, (I was diagnosed following a significant breakdown and in hindsight I've been "weird" all my life) I obviously present very differently to more severe autism.

I understand there's an argument for promoting better understanding of the range of severities that now fall under the ASD umbrella, but I also feel uncomfortable that more functional people are the ones dominating the discussion, when we are in a position of privilege

Personally I prefer using the old fashioned term of Aspergers to explain myself, as I find people tend to understand it better. But then I've been told that's offensive and I'm distancing myself from other autistic people out of abelism. But I've also been told off for saying "high functioning autism" too

So I don't know what the more correct/PC/better language to use is :(
People have different needs and I think it's not necessarily a bad thing for language to reflect that

squashedalmondcroissant · 27/02/2023 09:15

@doadeer also 2. We started having investigations at 18 months because we thought he might be deaf, he had no interest in interacting with anyone and was non verbal.

It was very hard at first because the only way he could communicate was through his behaviour and it took a lot of trial and error to work out what behaviour meant what. We're still working on that now!

At 4ish he learnt to sing. Then he learned to use quotes from Disney movies as communication. Again, it took a while to figure out what he was trying to tell us. Now he can read and write basic things and is verbal-ish, to the extent where he can tell you he wants or doesn't want something but he still can't hold a conversation or answer most questions. If he got lost for example he could tell you his name but not where he lives or who/where his caregivers are.

It's still very challenging now but it is easier now he is able to communicate a bit more, sadly I don't he'll progress much more than where he is now, we just have to work with what we have.

OneFrenchEgg · 27/02/2023 08:50

Reading Judy Singer's book is actually really interesting. It is the 90s so context is emerging recognition of ASC in people and Asperger's is a newly discussed diagnosis amongst people.

OP posts:
kindercup · 27/02/2023 08:37

@ISaySteadyOn

I don't know what's really the correct word for where I am on the spectrum.

Start by learning about what the spectrum refers to. It's not something people are placed upon. There is no me here and you over there line. The spectrum is about how your autism affects you.