Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cont (2) autism diagnosis and descriptions

137 replies

OneFrenchEgg · 25/02/2023 14:27

Continued from previous thread

OP posts:
DiagnosisAlley · 02/03/2023 06:13

PearCrumbleCustard Flowers wishing you and your son all the best. Your experience confirms to me why it inevitably causes avoidable problems and burdens when a single umbrella term is used to describe a circumstance with huge variations.

Naturally among those affected, those who have the most ability to advocate for themselves will come to dominate the discussion, because they are literally the most able to do that.

There’s nothing wrong with anyone talking about it but that’s the effect of what they are doing that, its literally impossible that all voices can be heard equally. And then from that point the full variation of experience and disability lumped in under the umbrella term becomes less visible. Over time the external perception and therefore definition of the circumstance by the wider world naturally becomes focused on the ‘more able to advocate’ group.

Its just basic human nature, group dynamics or whatever, repeated everywhere through the ages. I don’t understand why it’s not thought possible that this could be happening in regards to the full variation of personal experience and also disability, found within the modern usage of ‘autism’. Or why that isn’t though to have created risks for autistic people.

It’s not even that (in some cases) that the ‘most able to advocate’ or the most visible group are winning from this situation. My diagnosed autistic DC are told by peers, as am I by friends and close relatives that the DC ‘can’t be autistic’ because they can eg speak and briefly look people in the eye. That ignorance has a gaslighting effect on my DC who do have substantial challenges in other areas.

I feel it’s just yet another aspect of the avoidable burdens and inaccurate wider expectations that using too-wide labels creates for the people affected. I’d be really surprised if this current naming cycle doesn’t move on and new more-specific terms don’t become used, in a few years’ time.

PearCrumbleCustard · 02/03/2023 02:10

I don’t think whether or not someone is verbal is a good indicator of how severe their autism is. forgive the irony but I have no words to this! Honestly I feel myself rage and these kind of statements. How dare you say that not being able to understand or speak language is not a major, significant, severe and horrible issue for people. I myself could always speak but DS…

and so many others like him. Of course he is more severe than someone who can talk. Because they can talk! Huge bloody difference in severity.

Completely demeans my sons difficulties. You spend years with a poor kid who is trying to talk but can’t, trying to understand but can’t, then come back and say it isn’t as severe as someone who can. 😞

PearCrumbleCustard · 02/03/2023 02:04

I really do think we need another word for less severe autism - or autism which does not have any significant developmental issues. Whether it’s Asperger’s or another term I think we need it as everything - research, support, articles, media is centred on the functioning more adult or later ‘diagnosed’. Centred being the word.

I have been on several influential groups in neurodiversity and it’s like banging my head. I’ve been on some groups that were specifically set up (talking high level professional groups) for non-verbal or non-speaking - and then just ended up being about masking and older women.

I have gone on until I made myself hoarse talking about learning disabilities - and the neurodiversity movement absolutely does not include this group. They say it is a ‘co occuring condition’ - which for sensory or anxiety issues is OK but apparently not learning disabilities which are very rarely even mentioned.

I’ve been on these groups to represent kids like my son, severe (told not to use that word by neurodiversity forums), non verbal (told not to use that word again even though no my child did not understand language either so was not non-speaking), major delays such as motor delays (people in neurodiversity movement actually look at me strangely when I say how prevalent motor skill issues are in autism).

And the tragedy is these are not awful people, everyone I’ve met in the neurodiversity ‘camp’ including many autisitic people, professionals, teachers, researchers, are well meaning, capable nice people. Yet I see any ‘place’ for my DS being crushed. Even though I am autistic myself I don’t really bring this up as what I have is not the same as DS, I didn’t spend most of my life in nappies or trying to hold a pencil. My DS should be centre stage of autism.

RiceMakesGoodConfetti · 02/03/2023 01:02

Hope no one minds me joining in.
DD began secondary school this academic year and is really struggling. She didn’t find KS2 easy (fine when she was little) but this is whole different level tricky.

She has a real aversion to growing up and is trying to hold onto things younger children enjoy (tv programmes, desperately wanted build-a-bear recently and so on). Is this linked to the dislike of transition in the short term (school to home, etc)?
There are wider issues, but I wondered if anyone had thoughts on clinging onto childhood?

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 00:40

That’s exactly the point I was trying to make

Asperger’s implies an IQ over 70 and that you are verbal

My child has an IQ over 70 and had no language delay he would’ve been diagnosed Aspergers under the old system. I feel this would’ve given people the misconception that his autism is mild. It is not mild.

I do understand what you are saying about people who get diagnosed as adults who held down jobs never being ‘severe’. It does frustrate me sometimes that there is no descriptor to distinguish between the autism of someone like say for example myself and then my child. My child is clearly more severely affected.

However, the elderly gentleman I referred to is at this time sectioned under the MH act as he is currently severely affected by his autism. But I guess you could argue his relatively ‘mild’ autism has severely affected his MH which is perhaps not quite the same thing as ‘severe’ autism. I don’t know - is that just semantics?

Also the whole verbal/non verbal thing. What does that even mean. You can be verbal but unable to communicate or you can be nonverbal but able to communicate well through nonverbal means of communication. I don’t think whether or not someone is verbal is a good indicator of how severe their autism is.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 00:19

Asperger’s implies an IQ over 70 and that you are verbal. People who hold down jobs, aren’t diagnosed till adult, or can manage in a ms primary school may have very hard lives but are not (imo) ever going to be “severe”.

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 00:11

That paragraph was illustrating how someone’s needs may change over time. I wasn’t trying to describe severe autism. I didn’t discuss the individual particulars so not sure how you can say it doesn’t sound severe when I’ve not actually described anything. It doesn’t ‘sound’ anything.

Fifi0102 · 01/03/2023 23:23

RitaBea · 01/03/2023 19:14

Under the old system my child would have been given an Asperger’s diagnosis because they didn’t have a language delay - they were actually early with speech. However, nothing about the way their autism presents is stereotypical ‘Aspergers’. I feel like often people see as Aspergers as a less severe form of autism which isn’t always the case. My child’s autism affects them severely in all areas of their life. For that reason I was pleased that they were given an autism diagnosis

I also think it’s hard to categorise someone as high or low functioning or mild or severe because needs can change over time. The child who thrived in primary school may fall apart at secondary school. I know an elderly gentleman not diagnosed until he retired. When able to focus on his incredibly niche complex job he coped well but once retirement hit his world fell apart. My childhood friend had selective mutism and required 1:1 support at school but is now very articulate and successful.

I must admit though I get frustrated sometimes when people don’t understand how hard I find it at times because they know/have a child with autism who does xyz. That’s great but my child is like a 15 year old toddler.

Sorry none of these sound severe. I've just spent an entire day supporting someone who cannot cope with any "imperfections" in the environment inside and outside. Even a branch falling can set off major anxiety They have destroyed everything in the immediate area the whole room is bare , they were pulling up the lino floor bare handed for hours because it feels wrong. There's nothing I can do if I attempt to physically stop them I will get punched and bitten.
Some cannot abide wearing clothing they rip everything and will sit naked they have to wear specially made rip proof clothing out in public.

This is the side of autism people don't see.

Itisbetter · 01/03/2023 21:05

I also think it’s hard to categorise someone as high or low functioning or mild or severe because needs can change over time. The child who thrived in primary school may fall apart at secondary school. I know an elderly gentleman not diagnosed until he retired. When able to focus on his incredibly niche complex job he coped well but once retirement hit his world fell apart. My childhood friend had selective mutism and required 1:1 support at school but is now very articulate and successful. None of these sound anything like someone I would imagine when someone says “severe”.

RitaBea · 01/03/2023 19:14

Under the old system my child would have been given an Asperger’s diagnosis because they didn’t have a language delay - they were actually early with speech. However, nothing about the way their autism presents is stereotypical ‘Aspergers’. I feel like often people see as Aspergers as a less severe form of autism which isn’t always the case. My child’s autism affects them severely in all areas of their life. For that reason I was pleased that they were given an autism diagnosis

I also think it’s hard to categorise someone as high or low functioning or mild or severe because needs can change over time. The child who thrived in primary school may fall apart at secondary school. I know an elderly gentleman not diagnosed until he retired. When able to focus on his incredibly niche complex job he coped well but once retirement hit his world fell apart. My childhood friend had selective mutism and required 1:1 support at school but is now very articulate and successful.

I must admit though I get frustrated sometimes when people don’t understand how hard I find it at times because they know/have a child with autism who does xyz. That’s great but my child is like a 15 year old toddler.

Merrymumoftwo · 28/02/2023 15:39

Thank you! Will look into trusts

BessieFinkNottle · 28/02/2023 15:08

JustKeepBuilding · 28/02/2023 12:00

Under the old system there were people without a LD who had an autism diagnosis rather than Asperger Syndrome because Asperger Syndrome was only for those without a LD and without a language delay as a young child. Those who had a language delay as a young child but had an IQ over 70 were still diagnosed with autism.

Yes, agree with this. Aspergers and autism were merged because it was realised that there was an overlap between the two. Some of those who had language delay as well as other issues as young children (and who were consequently diagnosed with autism) had IQs in the normal range and developed speech later on. They were then pretty well indistinguishable from the group who had no early speech delay and who were diagnosed as Aspergers.
The widespread public awareness about Asperger's link to the Nazis was somewhat subsequent to this - it wasn't the reason Aspergers was merged into autism.
I do agree 'autism' on its own is too broad a descriptor to be very useful.

JustKeepBuilding · 28/02/2023 14:49

@Pira yes, the first step is to request an EHCNA. IPSEA have a model letter you can send the LA.

@Merrymumoftwo my DSs who won’t be independent are still young teens but we set up disabled person’s trust in preparation.

Pira · 28/02/2023 12:46

@JustKeepBuilding Thanks, this information is invaluable. You are absolutely correct; I have nothing to lose by applying, other than irritating the school, which I don't care about if it means DS gets support he may need!

I guess the first step is to apply for an assessment from the LA? Is this correct, an EHCNA?

Sorry, I realised this has gone off topic slightly!

OneFrenchEgg · 28/02/2023 12:34

I think he has a trust which pays for big things like rent.

OP posts:
OneFrenchEgg · 28/02/2023 12:34

Merrymumoftwo · 28/02/2023 12:02

For those who have children who are unable to manage basic daily tasks, not just cleaning themselves but adult tasks such as money management, managing a home. What provision do you have in the event of your death?
apologies for the morbid question I’m trying to sort a will and plan for the reality there is no family member who could help.

My auntie was a single parent and really worried about this. She ended up finding a group home/supported living before she died where my cousin still lives. I don't know the exact terminology for it. He is able to come and go with friends/relatives, has privacy and does his own washing etc . I know that's not right for everyone but just wanted to answer you.

OP posts:
Merrymumoftwo · 28/02/2023 12:02

For those who have children who are unable to manage basic daily tasks, not just cleaning themselves but adult tasks such as money management, managing a home. What provision do you have in the event of your death?
apologies for the morbid question I’m trying to sort a will and plan for the reality there is no family member who could help.

JustKeepBuilding · 28/02/2023 12:02

@Pira progress is about far more than academic progress or behaviour. Sadly schools often say DC don’t need/won’t get an EHCP, but parents go on to successfully apply themselves. Not all with ASD/ADHD will need an EHCP, but you have nothing to lose by applying.

The provision in EHCPs is taken from assessments so what is included depends on them. From your posts I would suggest OT (including sensory OT) and SALT (which is about more than the ability to speak) would be helpful.

Also things like regular movement breaks, a wobble cushion, sensory bands on chair legs or exercise/peanut ball or a rocker/bouncy chair, time out card, social skills support, instructions written down, checking DS has taken in instructions, placement within the classroom. You don’t need an EHCP for these, but the only way of guaranteeing it is via an EHCP.

Even without an EHCP the school must make their best endeavours to meet a pupil’s SEN, which is about far more than just behaviour and academics.

The EHCNA also often highlights hidden needs because no one can truly know all needs without a comprehensive assessment. To give an example, everyone thought DS3 had an excellent memory, and he does have a superb long term memory, but that was masking a very poor working memory that was contributing to some of his difficulties.

An EP assessment would be part of an EHCNA. Personally, unless money is no object now I wouldn’t seek an EP assessment prior to applying because if e.g. the LA agree to assess but not issue any report will be out of date by the time you get to an appeal hearing. Reports used to be considered up to date for around 2 years but over the last few years SENDIST have considered reports much younger out of date. It may also be that the LA’s EP is OK but you need to prioritise independent SALT and EP.

JustKeepBuilding · 28/02/2023 12:00

Plenanna · 28/02/2023 11:45

aibu to think the diagnosis/description should be changed for high functioning people, as opposed to those who have serious disabilities.
Well we used to have a really useful label called Asperger’s Syndrome, which specifically described people who had social and behavioural difficulties but no intellectual disability. Then they decided we weren’t allowed to use that word because it wasn’t politically correct enough, so they took it away and now we are all just “on the autism spectrum”. Which really isn’t helpful because people’s difficulties can be vastly different depending on how they’re affected.

Personally I would like a word to replace Asperger’s. Or yanno, just keep calling it Asperger’s like we did for decades before the woke came along and started whinging about it.

Under the old system there were people without a LD who had an autism diagnosis rather than Asperger Syndrome because Asperger Syndrome was only for those without a LD and without a language delay as a young child. Those who had a language delay as a young child but had an IQ over 70 were still diagnosed with autism.

DiagnosisAlley · 28/02/2023 11:55

I agree that it doesn’t seem to serve anyone’s needs if it’s just one name covering a vast variation of needs/issues.

Plenanna · 28/02/2023 11:45

aibu to think the diagnosis/description should be changed for high functioning people, as opposed to those who have serious disabilities.
Well we used to have a really useful label called Asperger’s Syndrome, which specifically described people who had social and behavioural difficulties but no intellectual disability. Then they decided we weren’t allowed to use that word because it wasn’t politically correct enough, so they took it away and now we are all just “on the autism spectrum”. Which really isn’t helpful because people’s difficulties can be vastly different depending on how they’re affected.

Personally I would like a word to replace Asperger’s. Or yanno, just keep calling it Asperger’s like we did for decades before the woke came along and started whinging about it.

Pira · 28/02/2023 11:38

I've just read this on the Ipsea website:

“the local authority should consider whether there is evidence that despite the early years provider, school or post-16 institution having taken relevant and purposeful action to identify, assess and meet the special educational needs of the child or young person, the child or young person has not made expected progress”.

This doesn't apply to my DS, so he's unlikely to qualify?

Pira · 28/02/2023 11:31

@Sirzy Is it worth getting an Educational Psychologist in or someone who can assess need first, before applying for the EHCP so I have evidence?

Pira · 28/02/2023 11:28

@Sirzy Thank you, I'll have a look at Ipsea. I'm not sure if I do think he needs extra help at school or not, It's difficult to ascertain as a parent when school consistently says he doesn't need an EHCP or extra support.

Sirzy · 28/02/2023 11:27

the bar for an ehcp needs assessment is very low. It’s MAY have special educational needs and MAY need extra support in school .

schools don’t decide who gets it. Schools are often fed lies from local authorities. If you think your child needs extra help then please apply yourself. Ipsea have a very good guide