Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cont (2) autism diagnosis and descriptions

137 replies

OneFrenchEgg · 25/02/2023 14:27

Continued from previous thread

OP posts:
RitaBea · 02/03/2023 13:34

@Itisbetter So maybe he did/does have language delay?

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 12:20

He was never considered to have a language delay because he spoke words. Speaking words is not always communication. Language is the putting together of words, speech is the saying of words. Your description is of delayed and disordered language. A SALT once told me that ds had the severest language disorder she had seen. It was one of the most helpful things she could have told me because he has beautifully clear speech and echolalia. His language has improved and he can now use it to communicate though it is obvious he has difficulty.

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 12:10

PearCrumbleCustard · 02/03/2023 02:10

I don’t think whether or not someone is verbal is a good indicator of how severe their autism is. forgive the irony but I have no words to this! Honestly I feel myself rage and these kind of statements. How dare you say that not being able to understand or speak language is not a major, significant, severe and horrible issue for people. I myself could always speak but DS…

and so many others like him. Of course he is more severe than someone who can talk. Because they can talk! Huge bloody difference in severity.

Completely demeans my sons difficulties. You spend years with a poor kid who is trying to talk but can’t, trying to understand but can’t, then come back and say it isn’t as severe as someone who can. 😞

@PearCrumbleCustard I think you have misunderstood me, or perhaps I did not explain myself correctly.

When I said ‘verbal’ I meant the ability to say words. I don’t think the ability to say words is the same as communicating and it can mislead.

People assume my child’s communication to be more advanced than it is because he says words but he is mostly just repeating things he has previously heard or read. It’s very difficult to actually communicate with him in the here and now because the understanding isn’t there (or maybe it is because he can’t verbalise it). He can’t communicate his needs, it’s like a guessing game everyday to work out what he needs.

He was never considered to have a language delay because he spoke words. Speaking words is not always communication.

I didn’t mean that people who can’t speak words verbally, ever, are not affected severely. I was more meaning the assumption that being able to verbalise words means you are not severe because you can ‘talk’. Repeating words isn’t really talking.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 10:54

as it depends on the definition of severe autism and this is really our difficulty. If we don’t know what the words mean, how can we communicate effectively about what the problem is.

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 10:47

I would suggest that not all severely autistic children can be accommodated in MS and those that really can’t are in ss or out of education and to me ARE severe.

Many of the DC that fit this sentence would, under the old system, have been described as having high functioning autism or Asperger Syndrome. I’m not saying they can’t have severe autism as it depends on the definition of severe autism, but I’m just wondering how that fits with some people on here thinking those with high functioning autism or Asperger Syndrome can’t have severe autism?

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 10:38

MS is an option for most disabled children unless they impact others education massively or can’t be kept safe. I would suggest that not all severely autistic children can be accommodated in MS and those that really can’t are in ss or out of education and to me ARE severe.

Pira · 02/03/2023 10:37

@PearCrumbleCustard I really do think we need another word for less severe autism - or autism which does not have any significant developmental issues. Whether it’s Asperger’s or another term I think we need it as everything - research, support, articles, media is centred on the functioning more adult or later ‘diagnosed’. Centred being the word.

I completely agree. My DS is stereotypical Aspergers, when I use the term Autism or Autistic I get one of two responses:

  • The assumption he must be far more unable and severe than he is. This leads to people attributing traits and struggles to him which he doesn't have.
  • The belief that he can't possibly be autistic because he doesn't present in the stereotypical or 'severe' way, whatsoever.

It's problematic for everyone...

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 10:35

I don’t think MS or SS is a good definitive indicator of need. It forms part of the bigger picture to inform needs, but on its own isn’t a good indicator. I would agree with this, it’s a bit like late diagnosis in middle/old age is an indicator that someone isn’t as impacted (because they’ve flown under the radar for so long) BUT there are those that are seriously impacted and have flown under the radar because they were thought to “just” have LD or because their life was so supportive it was less obvious what the difference was.

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 10:34

Sirzy sounds like DS3. He is in MS but has a huge amount of support and therapies (more than some in SS), and he has a personalised timetable.

Sirzy · 02/03/2023 09:52

The only reason Ds is in a mainstream school is because it is the only school in the area that could come close to meeting his needs. The specialist provisions would have been even worse for him (although fantastic for some)

if this placement fails then EOTAS will be the only viable option

Spendonsend · 02/03/2023 09:46

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 09:23

@percypercypercy oh please don’t, I think your input is welcome and just as valid as anyone else’s. (And I have a recovering SM at home so am always interested in others who have that experience).

@Spendonsend yes of course there are many fairly severely impacted kids in MS but they are managing in ms school with support, there are autistic (and otherwise disabled) children who can’t do that, and I think they are likely to be more severely disabled.

Perhaps in a world with enough special school places that is so. I honestly think people would be surprised at the severity of some children in mainstream and the level of support in place, particulary up to 7.

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 09:41

I don’t think MS or SS is a good definitive indicator of need. It forms part of the bigger picture to inform needs, but on its own isn’t a good indicator. There are many DC in MS, for many reasons, who have more significant needs and require more support than some (not all!) in SS.

Unless you think everyone with EOTAS has more significant needs than those in MS or SS? Because, using your theory, anyone in MS or SS is managing in school, those with EOTAS can’t.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 09:23

@percypercypercy oh please don’t, I think your input is welcome and just as valid as anyone else’s. (And I have a recovering SM at home so am always interested in others who have that experience).

@Spendonsend yes of course there are many fairly severely impacted kids in MS but they are managing in ms school with support, there are autistic (and otherwise disabled) children who can’t do that, and I think they are likely to be more severely disabled.

HeidiWhole · 02/03/2023 09:09

My DC has autism that wasn't picked up until secondary school because of extreme masking.
I haven't read the previous thread so not sure if this has been shared already but this document on autistic girls/women who present 'internally' and cope well until very suddenly they don't is extremely informative.

autisticgirlsnetwork.org/keeping-it-all-inside/

I hope it's been shared with schools as some of the advice is invaluable. Whether or not they act on any of it is another matter.

Spendonsend · 02/03/2023 09:04

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 00:19

Asperger’s implies an IQ over 70 and that you are verbal. People who hold down jobs, aren’t diagnosed till adult, or can manage in a ms primary school may have very hard lives but are not (imo) ever going to be “severe”.

I am interested in the 'manage in a mainstream primary school' bit. There is a child in my mainstream primary who is non verbal, doubly incontinent and has 1:1 support and does a totally different thing to all the other children with visiting salt and ot everyday You'd be amazed who is in mainstream primary!

percypercypercy · 02/03/2023 09:03

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 08:47

@percypercypercy I think it’s been stated multiple times that you can be very disabled by autism/Asperger’s even if HFA. I’m sure you can imagine that your dds life would be very very different if she couldn’t communicate at home either? I’m not minimising her difficulties by saying that there are autistics who have even higher needs (quite a lot of them).

I'm not actually trying to argue her into a box here. It's the fluidity that I was meaning. That said I realise I am far out of my depth here so I shall step back.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 08:47

@percypercypercy I think it’s been stated multiple times that you can be very disabled by autism/Asperger’s even if HFA. I’m sure you can imagine that your dds life would be very very different if she couldn’t communicate at home either? I’m not minimising her difficulties by saying that there are autistics who have even higher needs (quite a lot of them).

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 08:42

Ca1mingC1arySag3 · 02/03/2023 08:35

Itisbetter

I’d suggest parents of those with LD or language delays aren’t the best advocates for “ aspergics” as you put it.

What an unpleasant way or referring to those of us with autism. My children and I are people who have autism. We r never been diagnosed as being an “ aspergic”

I’d suggest parents of those with LD or language delays aren’t the best advocates for “ aspergics” as you put it. I agree

What an unpleasant way or referring to those of us with autism. My children and I are people who have autism. yes lots of people are keen on people first language and lots see their disability as part of who they are so prefer to name it. Neither is intended to be unpleasant (I assume). Asperger’s is a diagnosis that is in active use in the UK if you haven’t received that dx then either your dx is very recent or you don’t have Asperger’s and aren’t who I was identifying.

Ca1mingC1arySag3 · 02/03/2023 08:35

Itisbetter

I’d suggest parents of those with LD or language delays aren’t the best advocates for “ aspergics” as you put it.

What an unpleasant way or referring to those of us with autism. My children and I are people who have autism. We r never been diagnosed as being an “ aspergic”

percypercypercy · 02/03/2023 08:25

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 00:19

Asperger’s implies an IQ over 70 and that you are verbal. People who hold down jobs, aren’t diagnosed till adult, or can manage in a ms primary school may have very hard lives but are not (imo) ever going to be “severe”.

DD went through a main stream primary school.

She is now unable to leave the house at 13.

She has never spoken a word to anyone but immediate family for years. Her IQ isn't low but her autism affects her severely.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 07:41

Not being able to communicate is obviously going to negatively impact anyone and is going to impact the effectiveness of any support. IF Asperger’s is autism without LD or language delay then aspergics must surely see that there are people dealing with everything they do in addition to LD and/or language delay??
I would assume unless proved otherwise (and I doubt anyone will bother) that depression and other MH difficulties are across the board not unique to those that can tell you about it.
Are aspergics who have no direct experience of severe autism good advocates for those that are LD or language delayed? I’d suggest not.

SouthCountryGirl · 02/03/2023 07:23

PearCrumbleCustard · 02/03/2023 02:10

I don’t think whether or not someone is verbal is a good indicator of how severe their autism is. forgive the irony but I have no words to this! Honestly I feel myself rage and these kind of statements. How dare you say that not being able to understand or speak language is not a major, significant, severe and horrible issue for people. I myself could always speak but DS…

and so many others like him. Of course he is more severe than someone who can talk. Because they can talk! Huge bloody difference in severity.

Completely demeans my sons difficulties. You spend years with a poor kid who is trying to talk but can’t, trying to understand but can’t, then come back and say it isn’t as severe as someone who can. 😞

Some of us talk but we do have great difficulty making ourselves understood and understanding language

Toomanysquishmallows · 02/03/2023 07:10

I got told off for describing my dd2 as having moderate autism. She was diagnosed at two and attends a special school. But she is verbal and can do schoolwork, albeit for children three to four years younger , so I don’t consider her autism to be severe .

Ca1mingC1arySag3 · 02/03/2023 06:56

I thought research indicated the opposite,that those with an autism diagnosis are more likely to have depression and mental health difficulties - that is not a good quality of life . My dc’s diagnosis is hugely tied up with not being able to understand, articulate and express emotions, needs etc. Some people with autism can be mute without learning disabilities. There are also processing issues. That is not going to change, she has autism.

Fifi0102 · 02/03/2023 06:18

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 00:40

That’s exactly the point I was trying to make

Asperger’s implies an IQ over 70 and that you are verbal

My child has an IQ over 70 and had no language delay he would’ve been diagnosed Aspergers under the old system. I feel this would’ve given people the misconception that his autism is mild. It is not mild.

I do understand what you are saying about people who get diagnosed as adults who held down jobs never being ‘severe’. It does frustrate me sometimes that there is no descriptor to distinguish between the autism of someone like say for example myself and then my child. My child is clearly more severely affected.

However, the elderly gentleman I referred to is at this time sectioned under the MH act as he is currently severely affected by his autism. But I guess you could argue his relatively ‘mild’ autism has severely affected his MH which is perhaps not quite the same thing as ‘severe’ autism. I don’t know - is that just semantics?

Also the whole verbal/non verbal thing. What does that even mean. You can be verbal but unable to communicate or you can be nonverbal but able to communicate well through nonverbal means of communication. I don’t think whether or not someone is verbal is a good indicator of how severe their autism is.

It's never semantics , I work professionally in this field . People with Autism can have other MH conditions including schizophrenia for example. Being unable to communicate effectively is severely damaging. The difference is someone verbal with an average to high IQ eventually will be able to share what is wrong and have a higher chance of good quality of life this is backed by research. Imagine the frustration of being unable to communicate your needs, PECs and communication boards only work so well.

There's also processing speeds , being only able to understand certain bits of information. It simply doesn't compare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread