Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cont (2) autism diagnosis and descriptions

137 replies

OneFrenchEgg · 25/02/2023 14:27

Continued from previous thread

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lougle · 03/03/2023 06:20

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 23:33

Yes, people expect less from younger children and you can strap them in a buggy, pick them up, dress them, bath them.

You can’t do that with a 15 year old. How can you make them change their clothes, wash, eat, leave the house? You can’t. People (family) tell me I need to ‘make him’ but I don’t know how.

I'm lucky, I guess, that the combination of DD1's multiple voices ('her' voice, the sing-song voice, and the American accent voice), her slightly odd gait, her 'floaty arms', and her total disregard for social convention, means that people around us who know her well just accept that she's DD1 and she marches to the beat of her own drum. If we go to my Sil's, she says hello, then marches straight up to their bedroom and we don't see her until we go home. To expect anything else is disaster.

I never have to explain that DD1 has SEN anymore. Everyone seems to just clock it immediately.

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 23:33

Yes, people expect less from younger children and you can strap them in a buggy, pick them up, dress them, bath them.

You can’t do that with a 15 year old. How can you make them change their clothes, wash, eat, leave the house? You can’t. People (family) tell me I need to ‘make him’ but I don’t know how.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 22:41

In lots of ways it was harder for ds when he was younger because he couldn’t communicate but younger children can still be picked up when overwhelmed, they can be in a pushchair when tired, no one is scared when they shout, and nobody thinks they will be safe with knives or roads or in the path of swings. People are kinder to little ones. And there’s puberty and “what will you do next”.

LaBelleSauvage123 · 02/03/2023 21:32

Lougle I guess life is simpler when you’re very young anyway. There’s not as much difference between you and your peers even if you do have learning disabilities. And then there’s all the added complexities of hormones and changing relationships with parents. DS2 has actually become more able in some ways - he’s much more assertive and able to communicate his basic needs and wants - while at the same time being much more disabled.

Lougle · 02/03/2023 21:27

@LaBelleSauvage123 DD1 was definitely 'milder' when she was young. 'Complex' is used a lot with her.

LaBelleSauvage123 · 02/03/2023 20:46

doadeer · 27/02/2023 06:59
Those of you with older children, when did you know the autism was severe?

Opposite to some, when DS2 was early teens. He was diagnosed at 3.5, but the general opinion from professionals at first was that his autism was moderate. Puberty and the onset of epilepsy coincided with a regression of sorts, in that he just became ‘more autistic’. At 20 his communication has improved in that he has enough spoken language to make his needs known to those who know him well, but he is far more ‘disabled’ by his autism than he ever was, and has also developed severe anxiety which is equally, if not more, debilitating. No one would ever describe him as anything other than severe now, though the word most often used is complex. I do sometimes mourn the carefree little boy he was, but we have accepted that this is our reality now and work to support him as much as we can.

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 20:25

A diagnosis requiring a ton of additional information, caveats, corrections, doesn't seem particularly helpful.

Maybe not, but that isn’t unique to autism and wouldn’t change even if you broke the autism diagnosis down into different groups.

What is it you think they all have in common that is useful either for funding, research, treatment, support or prognosis?

Well they all meet the diagnostic criteria - “persistent difficulties with social communication and social interaction” and “restricted and repetitive patterns of behaviours, activities or interests” that “limit and impair everyday functioning”.

Obviously prognosis, support and treatment varies depending on individual needs. But that would be the same even if you broke the diagnosis down into different groups. I’m not sure what funding you mean, but if you mean e.g. funding linked to an EHCP then it is dependent on need, not diagnosis. Even if the diagnosis was broken down researching one particular group will still have a wide range of presentations.

Pira · 02/03/2023 20:22

@Itisbetter I spend my life explaining to teachers/parents/friends that DS has 'x' trait but not 'x' trait, struggles with 'x' but not 'x'. So far his ASD diagnosis is proving to be a waste of £2,000 in terms of practical day-to-say support and understanding.

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 20:22

Oh I see thanks. My DS3 has VCB. Although interestingly I consider his autism to less severe than DS1. I think it’s because DS3 has better communication, manages ok in MS, and in the future I can see him being able to work and live independently. He’s much harder work on a day to day basis though.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 20:12

What is it you think they all have in common that is useful either for funding, research, treatment, support or prognosis? I mean what on Earth is the point of the dx at all if it has no internal boundaries? Even the levels are so open to interpretation that most people say at some point “well I kinda fit all of them some of the time”.

Spendonsend · 02/03/2023 20:12

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 19:59

What is VCB?

Violent and Challenging Behaviour.

Pira · 02/03/2023 20:11

I'm not sure what the solution is, but at present 'Autism' seems too broad to be of much use to anyone. A diagnosis requiring a ton of additional information, caveats, corrections, doesn't seem particularly helpful.

Lougle · 02/03/2023 20:10

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 19:59

What is VCB?

Very challenging behaviour.

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 19:59

What is VCB?

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 19:52

But that would still happen even if you split the diagnosis up. Even if you split the diagnosis into e.g. low functioning autism, high functioning autism, Asperger syndrome (or other similar descriptions) there will still be vast differences. And just saying the diagnosis is never going to be enough for anyone to know an individual’s needs even if you refine the diagnosis.

For example, just saying e.g. HFA isn’t going to give information on an individual’s needs. Some will be verbal, others won’t. Some will have significant sensory needs, others won’t. Some will display VCB, others won’t. Some will be incontinent, others won’t be. Some will need significant support with ADL, others won’t. Some will be in MS, others in SS or other provision…

Perhaps I am not explaining myself well.

Pira · 02/03/2023 19:43

Every human being shares some similarities and differences though, the same could be said for any two people. Is it really beneficial for two people who share 'some similarities' but have more differences, and vastly different needs, to share a diagnosis which is so broad it really says nothing about the individuals?

I could say my son has Autism, or I could say he is hyperactive, struggles to listen and with organisation at times, and his social skills are unusual. The former is largely unhelpful and uninformative.

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 19:37

I’m not sure people did know the difference between autism and Asperger syndrome. You only have to look at this thread and the previous one to see that. Many certainly don’t know what high and low functioning actually mean.

I’m also not sure people in each category always have more similarities than differences. To give an example, DS3 and my neighbour’s DS would both have been said to have HFA, but they have vastly different needs, more differences than similarities, although obviously they do share some similarities as they both meet the diagnostic criteria.

RitaBea · 02/03/2023 19:02

I don’t know what the solution is. I do think that part of the problem is not having a definitive understanding of what words like ‘severe’ and ‘functional’ actually mean. ‘Severe’ appears to be very subjective.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 18:48

Yes there will never be anyone exactly like someone else, but I don’t think that means we have to just leave an unhelpful lump. I think being able to clearly describe yourself is important and not being able too (particularly if getting it wrong draws anger and upset) is crippling progress.

How you do it, I honestly don’t know. There wasn’t brilliant clarity before the merging but I really don’t think that means their can’t be.

Pira · 02/03/2023 18:47

@JustKeepBuilding This is a good point; although I feel that people, broadly speaking, knew the difference between 'Autism' and 'Aspergers', and typically people in either category had more similarities than differences.

Due to my son's presentation, there is very little point in saying he is on the Autism Spectrum, I may as well do away with the diagnosis and instead have a list of traits and behaviours?

JustKeepBuilding · 02/03/2023 18:23

Adding descriptors such as high or low functioning, Asperger Syndrome or the levels used in the DSM-5 or other similar descriptors wouldn’t solve that though. Even within different ‘categories’ there will still be differences, different needs, verbal and non-verbal , early and late diagnoses, DC in MS/SS/other provision…

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 17:46

But there are lots of diagnosis where severity is added to the dx (and there are levels attached to asd anyway).

Let’s look at it another way. How is it helping NOT to be able to discuss different groups?

I guess my thinking is that good robust descriptors would make conversations easier. It would be nice not to have to stop what you are discussing to redraw lines on the meaning of functional or play guessing games about are they in ss or ms or early diagnosed or late and if they can talk is it functional and what do we mean by functional?

Snaketime · 02/03/2023 17:17

I whole heartedly disagree with you OP, because if you start adding different labels for people with varying severity of autism, you will need to do the same with ADHD, DCD, Dyslexia, Cerebral Palsy, Torettes etc where does it stop?

I'm not saying this as someone with no knowledge my DH has Dyslexia and DCD, my brother has Cerebral Palsy (all 4 limbs are effected, he is non verbal and needs 24 hour care) and Autism, my DD has DCD, ADHD (medicated) and is borderline for Autism.

Lougle · 02/03/2023 16:56

I don't think age of diagnosis is an indicator, either. I've found that once a child has one diagnosis, professionals are quite relieved and happy to let that sit, even if presentation can't be explained by it.

DD1 went from global developmental delay (2.9) to GDD+ brain malformation and epilepsy (3.4) to MLD + brain malformation and epilepsy (5).

Then she sat with those diagnoses for 10 years. At 15, finally ASD was added. Now at 17 they are thinking ADHD needs assessment, too. But only because she's struggling so much. The traits have been there since she was born, pretty much.

Itisbetter · 02/03/2023 13:46

If his language didn’t develop in line with his chronological age then he is language delayed, if it came on a different developmental path then he is also language disordered. Typically this might be, knowing lots of nouns or chunk phrases but not being able to put them together, not using verbs or pronouns at all or misusing them, not managing past or future tense, struggling with under/over/behind/above yet knowing colours numbers etc etc. Interestingly although Aspergic children talk early they often have subtle markers in their language (or so a SaLT told me). Language deficits in the greater population (ie non autistic) are more commonly associated with LD, damage, or extreme neglect.