Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pre-teen looking after toddler?

34 replies

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 13:09

We live in a European country. My DD just told me that her 9 year-old school friend looks after her 1 year-old sibling for hours at a time. School finishes at 12 and then someone is home early evening. DD thinks around 6. I am unsure if it is everyday. Both parents are immigrants (Chinese and Vietnamese background) and I wondered if this was something more acceptable in these countries. Regardless, I am going to have to do something.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 17:24

@NoKnit ha! Nope. Went past twice that day to see if she could play. After school and then later that afternoon, and the parents still weren't home.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 25/02/2023 17:20

And to those citing that childcare is cheaper in many countries, it is IF you can get a place. So often the subsidised care is not available because you don't know the system, there's a waiting list or simply it's too far away and you don't have a car. My French friend is always complaining when British newspapers talk about the amazing preschool childcare system stating "try getting a place!"

gogohmm · 25/02/2023 17:15

I don't know about the laws in your country but it's certainly more lax in some European countries than the U.K. attitude wise. We had to actually tell a German friend of ours living in the U.K. that leaving her 2 children home alone at primary school age is not acceptable because her sister routinely left the cousins at the same age, (they would have been 8&10). Sane goes for children walking to school alone etc. There's obviously a balance to be struck between need for a childcare solution and safety, probably over protective in the U.K. in middle class circles, but in this case it seems unfair on the older child to take on the responsibility though I have less issue with a 9 year old being home alone (it's sad that it's necessary but I'm a realist)

NoKnit · 25/02/2023 17:06

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 17:03

Actually, was with her when she was looking after her sister.

You allowed your dd to be alone at a friend's house for 6 hours?

NoKnit · 25/02/2023 17:04

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 16:53

Thanks, all. For what it is worth, the mother and I are loosely friends. (we get along well when we see each other around). The first thing I will be doing is gently asking the DD what is going on, and then I will chat with the mum and see if there is anything I can do. If it remains concerning, I will report it.

Child-care is cheap here from age 3 (maybe 50 euros or so a month) but it is more expensive for babies. There is a lot of immigrant support here, too, but the mum generally presents as anxious and harried, and I doubt whether she would access it.

I also have some concerns about what is happening at home due to a few strange things my DD has told me. The worst thing is, is that knowing about the daughter being responsible for the baby confirms my gut feeling that something is wrong.

If your friends with the mother surely it makes sense to ask her outright? Yep not the British thing to do but she isn't British so probably won't be offended.

Just say 'oh your dd says she looks after sibling all afternoon I can't imagine mine doing that she must be very responsible '

You will then get the full story

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 17:03

I mean, DD was with her

OP posts:
Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 17:03

Actually, was with her when she was looking after her sister.

OP posts:
NoKnit · 25/02/2023 16:58

I don't think it's right but you can't really be certain thus is true or not. You're getting it third hand from your daughter who heard it from a friend. It could be completely different to what actually happened. Say for example adult leaves them for 5/10 minutes to pop to the shop. Can be fabricated in a nine year olds mind plus they want to sound grown-up

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 16:53

Thanks, all. For what it is worth, the mother and I are loosely friends. (we get along well when we see each other around). The first thing I will be doing is gently asking the DD what is going on, and then I will chat with the mum and see if there is anything I can do. If it remains concerning, I will report it.

Child-care is cheap here from age 3 (maybe 50 euros or so a month) but it is more expensive for babies. There is a lot of immigrant support here, too, but the mum generally presents as anxious and harried, and I doubt whether she would access it.

I also have some concerns about what is happening at home due to a few strange things my DD has told me. The worst thing is, is that knowing about the daughter being responsible for the baby confirms my gut feeling that something is wrong.

OP posts:
YouSoundLovely · 25/02/2023 16:19

Not all workers are eligible for childcare/income support.

Of course, that is possible, depending on system, and no doubt it's true of the UK, but in the European countries I'm aware of it certainly isn't. In mine you got four hours a day from age 1 without even having to prove you worked, and more if you demonstrated you worked hours that needed it. Parental contribution for the lowest incomes was in low double figures/month, and some were exempt.

Given the situation described in the OP, I think it's a bit of a stretch to insist this is going to be happening because there are no affordable childcare options. There may be a cultural preference not to use childcare and to expect the older sibling to do it, perhaps. But others who interact with that older child aren't going to think that's okay, so the plan needs rethinking.

LetThemEatTurnips · 25/02/2023 16:15

She might be trying to gauge if she should have a polite word with the parents to let them know before doing something like reporting. This would be the better way to do things because reporting will cause a whole load of problems.

LetThemEatTurnips · 25/02/2023 16:14

YouSoundLovely · 25/02/2023 15:24

The OP's in a European country, though, and the hours the child is looking after the sibling are in the daytime.

The idea that childcare is affordable is just not realistic.

People don;t leave their children when they have better options.

Not all workers are eligible for childcare/income support.

YouSoundLovely · 25/02/2023 15:49

But whether it is normal in China or not is irrelevant in a way to the situation in the OP. It's unlikely to be normal or acceptable in the country it is happening in.

BertieBotts · 25/02/2023 15:49

Yes but I think that's more of a query of whether the parents might genuinely not know that it's frowned upon/that there are other options, rather than if it's normal in China then it's fine.

If she's in a European country chances are the local authorities would find it very much not fine. She might be trying to gauge if she should have a polite word with the parents to let them know before doing something like reporting.

Untitledsquatboulder · 25/02/2023 15:49

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 14:10

Is it a normal thing in some countries?

Of course. In Nigeria 4 and 5 year olds are put in charge of toddlers and slightly older children supervise them. Doesn't make it ideal.

SheeshPawowa · 25/02/2023 15:45

The op isn't talking about whether it's normal in the European country. She's asking if it's normal in China.

YouSoundLovely · 25/02/2023 15:24

The OP's in a European country, though, and the hours the child is looking after the sibling are in the daytime.

LetThemEatTurnips · 25/02/2023 15:14

YouSoundLovely · 25/02/2023 15:11

In a lot of European countries, certainly in mine, there is available and affordable state-subsidised childcare for 1yos, with parental contributions based on income.

Yes, but you will know that in all countries there are some people do not have this option. We know this because we can observe the issue.

For example - is there access to childcare for shifts in the late evening or very early morning? If you look at cleaning jobs, hotel work - these can ber very unsociable hours. Not many nruseries open overnight.

YouSoundLovely · 25/02/2023 15:11

LetThemEatTurnips · 25/02/2023 14:57

It is a normal thing in ALL countries where parents have to work and have no affordable childcare options.

It is extra hard for recent immigrants as they are often without informal childcare support of any type and may be in lower paid work or working unsocial hours.

You can report, and maybe you will have to, but please do so knowing that you are likely to make the family's lives harder as a consequence because there is no support.

In a lot of European countries, certainly in mine, there is available and affordable state-subsidised childcare for 1yos, with parental contributions based on income.

ThepicofmyhairymingeprovesIamsober · 25/02/2023 15:10

Blimey it would be bad enough a 9 year old having to fend for themselves for 6 hours per day, let alone have to be responsible for a 1 year old! Please report.

LetThemEatTurnips · 25/02/2023 15:09

Ihatethenewlook · 25/02/2023 15:05

I’ve read a lot of articles about the poor treatment of children in china. Apparently it’s common for parents to leave children barely older than toddlers (4/5) out on the streets while they go to work. They don’t even let them stay in the house.

Probably safer. If a child falls inside the house no one will see. If a child falls outside the house hopefully a neighbour will see.

It is 'poor treatment' but important not to judge - most people the world over love their children, just some have better options than others.

Ihatethenewlook · 25/02/2023 15:05

I’ve read a lot of articles about the poor treatment of children in china. Apparently it’s common for parents to leave children barely older than toddlers (4/5) out on the streets while they go to work. They don’t even let them stay in the house.

LetThemEatTurnips · 25/02/2023 14:57

Spanisheomellletttes · 25/02/2023 14:10

Is it a normal thing in some countries?

It is a normal thing in ALL countries where parents have to work and have no affordable childcare options.

It is extra hard for recent immigrants as they are often without informal childcare support of any type and may be in lower paid work or working unsocial hours.

You can report, and maybe you will have to, but please do so knowing that you are likely to make the family's lives harder as a consequence because there is no support.

BertieBotts · 25/02/2023 14:50

That's not right, I think you'd have to report it. It's the fact that the younger child is so much younger.

I live in Germany and the attitudes towards children's independence are very different to the UK judging by MN - but we have only left DS1 in charge of DS2 for very brief periods, from about DS1 being 12 / DS2 being 2 - he would take him to the park (nearby but not in view of our house) for half an hour for example.

Being left in sole charge for hours is not right. Even now at 14 I wouldn't expect DS1 to do things like nappies, provide food, take DS2 to toilet etc.

I think for example 7 + 9 year old together might be considered fine for a couple of hours after school (which I know is much younger than this would be seen as OK in the UK.)

DaveyJonesLocker · 25/02/2023 14:45

My niece is 9, my son is 1. Not a chance in hell I'd trust her to look after him alone. My nephew is 13 and I wouldn't trust him either, but he hasn't spent alot if time around kids so I don't know if it would be different if he did.

I actually don't think a 9yo should be home alone, never mind with a toddler.

Swipe left for the next trending thread