Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

9yr old and knife

193 replies

Rabbitheadlights · 25/02/2023 11:18

So ... My 9yr old just picked up a butter knife and threatened my 7yr old with it ... In a half joke half serious manner (they were bickering about something or other) Well, I absolutely lost it. I told him to go get dressed and that I was taking him to the police station, that he should say goodbye to his siblings, and take one last look at his bedroom because he was going to jail for a very long time and he would be an adult by the time he got out!

I was kind of lost in how angry I was, for context a friend's son was murdered age 16 in January last year and although we aren't very close it was just far too close to home for me and it's something I think about often.

So my AIBU is should I have been able to control my reaction?

He was really scared, crying asking me not to take him etc ... But all I could think was good, I'm glad he's scared.

We have spoken now and I have told him that I won't be taking him to the police station but that if he ever was to do do anything like that again I absolutely will! but I haven't apologised for my reaction because I need him to understand how serious this is.

But I don't know, was it too much?

Tia

OP posts:
ThepicofmyhairymingeprovesIamsober · 25/02/2023 15:39

oakleaffy · 25/02/2023 15:06

Most kids HAVEN’T. Threatened siblings with blades-Where the heck do you live?!
OP is quite right to come down hard on this behaviour.

Blades? It’s a fucking butter knife! I would say that at least 2 of my 5 children have threatened to stab one of their siblings with a butter knife or fork while bickering at the breakfast table. Your job,as a parent, is to teach them not to mess about with potentially dangerous instruments, in a calm and collected manner. This should never involve emotionally abusing them!

tiggergoesbounce · 25/02/2023 15:38

I doubt the gangs are carrying butter knives to be fair

Misses the point massively.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 25/02/2023 15:35

So you gave your kid the potentially permanent psychological link between the police and his mum losing her temper. And the inclination to believe that any future threats of consequences might be part of an elaborate theatrical mind game. Not ideal going forward.

Discipline shouldn't involve lies and acting.

Pianoaccordian · 25/02/2023 15:33

I doubt the gangs are carrying butter knives to be fair.
I would check what he's watching on tv and computer OP. And talk to him.

tiggergoesbounce · 25/02/2023 15:18

@LittleBearPad no, the stations wont be full of parents at all. As its not common for 9 year olds to threaten a sibling with a knife after being told not to and the reasons why

But i do know the police would definitely take the time to speak to a 9 year old about knife crime. Especially one who has continued to threaten his sibling with a knife after being told of the dangers.
A 9 year old is old enough to understand the seriousness after being told by its parents, so if it were to happen again, they would speak with them.

At 9, there are already kids that age in gangs carrying. So again yes, they would take the time for a chat to educate them.

oakleaffy · 25/02/2023 15:06

ThepicofmyhairymingeprovesIamsober · 25/02/2023 14:48

Jesus your poor son. You treated him appallingly for something that most kids have probably done at some point. The correct reaction would have been “Put that knife down at once, and don’t you ever ever wave it around at anyone again, whether in a jokey manner or otherwise”. And then you could have given him a talk on the danger of playing with knives inappropriately. Your reaction was downright cruel, and must have made your child (and probably his brother too) feel very unsafe, which is quite ironic really.

Most kids HAVEN’T. Threatened siblings with blades-Where the heck do you live?!
OP is quite right to come down hard on this behaviour.

ThepicofmyhairymingeprovesIamsober · 25/02/2023 14:48

Jesus your poor son. You treated him appallingly for something that most kids have probably done at some point. The correct reaction would have been “Put that knife down at once, and don’t you ever ever wave it around at anyone again, whether in a jokey manner or otherwise”. And then you could have given him a talk on the danger of playing with knives inappropriately. Your reaction was downright cruel, and must have made your child (and probably his brother too) feel very unsafe, which is quite ironic really.

FictionalCharacter · 25/02/2023 14:42

YABU because you told him an absolute lie to frighten him. Reminds me of the kind of stories parents and grandparents used to tell kids when I was little to keep them in line. The police will come to take you away, you’ll get taken to the children’s home etc. It made some kids of my generation feel their parents made things up all the time and you couldn’t trust anything they told you.

And no, of course a “cuddly chat” as you put it wasn’t appropriate either. You can give a child a serious talking to without making up outlandish stories. A child his age is capable of understanding that someone could be badly hurt and threatening someone is a very serious matter.

Indigoshift · 25/02/2023 14:32

BiggerBoyMadeMeDoit · 25/02/2023 11:31

YABU @Rabbitheadlights

I’m late 40’s and I still remember my parent threatening to take me and my two siblings to a childrens home when I was about ten because we had been naughty. It’s cruel.

Explaining the potential consequences is different to threatening.

This. While it needed a 'strong' response. To outright lie isn't good. He will likely remember this as a teen or adult and not believe what you say. Hopefully not but as a parent of a teen now going through a bad time. They can hold everything against you.

I think being annoyed as you were without saying he would be in jail for years age 9 would have been better.

Bubbinsmakesthree · 25/02/2023 14:28

YANBU to want to underscore the seriousness of messing about with knives, even blunt knives in a half-joking way.

But losing it with your children is never OK. It’s understandable in the circumstances why you reacted with such anger, and we all overreact sometimes. But it doesn’t make it OK.

I think an apology for the overreaction is in order, but you can do that while explaining why you reacted the way you did and underscoring the seriousness of knives.

Choconut · 25/02/2023 14:19

I think you were projecting what happened to your friend's son onto your son's situation.

Ranting and raving at a child and making idle threats is not the way to teach them anything - apart from that they should fear you and your reactions and to not trust you. Be cross, be clear it's unacceptable and calmly explain why - having a personal anecdote is a brilliant way to bring the message home. You were out of control and good parenting never happens when you're out of control.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/02/2023 13:51

I think you reacted fine- I’d have the calm chat later but sometimes the sheer horror of your reaction is needed to send a message.

Livinginanotherworld · 25/02/2023 13:46

Rabbitheadlights · 25/02/2023 11:18

So ... My 9yr old just picked up a butter knife and threatened my 7yr old with it ... In a half joke half serious manner (they were bickering about something or other) Well, I absolutely lost it. I told him to go get dressed and that I was taking him to the police station, that he should say goodbye to his siblings, and take one last look at his bedroom because he was going to jail for a very long time and he would be an adult by the time he got out!

I was kind of lost in how angry I was, for context a friend's son was murdered age 16 in January last year and although we aren't very close it was just far too close to home for me and it's something I think about often.

So my AIBU is should I have been able to control my reaction?

He was really scared, crying asking me not to take him etc ... But all I could think was good, I'm glad he's scared.

We have spoken now and I have told him that I won't be taking him to the police station but that if he ever was to do do anything like that again I absolutely will! but I haven't apologised for my reaction because I need him to understand how serious this is.

But I don't know, was it too much?

Tia

I think you are a bloody star Mum, just what was needed to nip this in the bud, that is the opposite of lazy parenting. I applaud you !

Ironingboardofdoom · 25/02/2023 13:42

Well my 9YO knows that he's under the age of criminal responsibility so wouldn't be arrested or taken to prison. So I think you ridiculously over reacted to say that.

Bollocking him fine. Punish him is fine. But don't make ridiculous threats you can't follow through with.

ItsOKToFeelProud · 25/02/2023 13:38

SilkenDisorder · 25/02/2023 12:32

Fantastic!

I wish more people would come in and do this. Prevention is a huge part of policing.

Thank you.
He still says now. I never thought you'd do that mum he remembers it vividly.

Rabbitheadlights · 25/02/2023 13:38

@2bazookas thanks for the considered response will bear that in.minf when we chat later

OP posts:
Mumskisail · 25/02/2023 13:31

Good for you he will never do it again

Rabbitheadlights · 25/02/2023 13:30

@Cocobutt nobehaviour like this before, and he picked it up.

OP posts:
Rabbitheadlights · 25/02/2023 13:29

No I've never reacted like this before, to anything. I have 2 older children but they never gave me cause to.
@LittleBearPad he's not a small child though? He starts high school next year?

I'm happy to admit in hindsight I might have handled it differently but, I'm not sorry perse. I still think I would have told him that the police would be very unhappy and I still will absolutely take him if anything like this were to happen ever again in the hope that they would talk to him etc.

He's never shown any inclination to this kind of thing before and he is a good kid generally.

We are going to have a chat later and I will see where we are at afterwards. Right now he's happily playing with the aforementioned 7yr old and requesting pizza for tea so I don't think any long term damage has been done.

Thanks for the differing perspectives ALL of them it's food for thought.

OP posts:
Cocobutt · 25/02/2023 13:23

Has he ever shown any behaviour like this before?

Did he pick the knife up or was it already in his hand?

LittleBearPad · 25/02/2023 13:21

tiggergoesbounce · 25/02/2023 13:19

Yes, it was a fine response, and yes, if he does it again, take him to the station. Someone will absolutely talk to him about knife crime.

Those saying its just a butter knife are ludicrous. The 9year old didn't stop and weigh up the sharpness of the knife, he grabbed the nearest knife to scare his sibling. He needs to know it is not the "go to" thing to do as they are not toys. Its not a joke.

I can imagine all these people saying it ok, when the head tells them another child dod it to their kid in the school canteen, but he was only joking and it was only a butter knife 🙄🙄

We have a real knife problem in this country its not ok

Good on you OP. Dont apologise at all, but do sit calmly with him later and explain why it evoked that reaction in you.

Police stations are going to be busy with all these parents making a point to their small children.

saleorbouy · 25/02/2023 13:19

He needs to understand the severity of his actions. Threatening with a weapon could lead to awful consequences, what if it was a sharper knife or escalated further. You have been heavy on him and rightly so, he's old enough to understand your reaction was from the heart and if he's never seen you react like this before then he'll not be wanting to repeat the behaviour.

tiggergoesbounce · 25/02/2023 13:19

Yes, it was a fine response, and yes, if he does it again, take him to the station. Someone will absolutely talk to him about knife crime.

Those saying its just a butter knife are ludicrous. The 9year old didn't stop and weigh up the sharpness of the knife, he grabbed the nearest knife to scare his sibling. He needs to know it is not the "go to" thing to do as they are not toys. Its not a joke.

I can imagine all these people saying it ok, when the head tells them another child dod it to their kid in the school canteen, but he was only joking and it was only a butter knife 🙄🙄

We have a real knife problem in this country its not ok

Good on you OP. Dont apologise at all, but do sit calmly with him later and explain why it evoked that reaction in you.

oakleaffy · 25/02/2023 13:19

Rabbitheadlights · 25/02/2023 11:22

@aSofaNearYou I think I'm going to have to, but should I apologise for it?

No!
Don’t apologise.
Well done for being strong.
Knives are not something to be waving about, even butter knives.

Robyn847 · 25/02/2023 13:18

BiggerBoyMadeMeDoit · 25/02/2023 11:31

YABU @Rabbitheadlights

I’m late 40’s and I still remember my parent threatening to take me and my two siblings to a childrens home when I was about ten because we had been naughty. It’s cruel.

Explaining the potential consequences is different to threatening.

Did they ever drive you there and leave you in the car while they went "to check if there was any places available"? Mine did. They probably just stood round the corner chuckling for 30 seconds while we shat our pants in the car. As a family we laugh about it now so it's not done that much harm. But flippin eck, at the time it worked!

Swipe left for the next trending thread