Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset partner was planning on lying

64 replies

Burntoutandfedup · 25/02/2023 10:09

So long story short me and my partner are trying to save for a lot of things atm. Holiday, buying our house plans we have throughout the year. He went halves on a scrap run he did with his mate recently and I overheard a conversation between him and said friend where he told him the amount and asked if he still wanted him to hold £300 back for later. Because he was planning on telling me they got X amount and then hiding the rest from me and spending it on himself. When I overheard and confronted him he laughed it off and said he was only kidding. But I don't think he was kidding and he would have done that if I hadn't overheard. The thing is I'm not unreasonable and I would have let him spend it on himself anyway, as long as a decent amount when in savings I'm not a dragon, I'm just hurt he had a pre planned thing with his mate to lie to me. Would you be annoyed at this?

I said to him to see it from my perspective. If I lied and said I didn't get a works bonus. But actually I did and I spent it on makeup for myself, would he not be a bit hurt by that. We're supposed to be a team.

OP posts:
Oohhhh · 25/02/2023 11:22

@GoodChat I agree, but I'd be more concerned about why he felt he had to lie rather than the actual lie. It suggests a problem of some sort.

PoppyFleur · 25/02/2023 11:21

@Oohhhh Please can you highlight where the OP has said that she controls what her husband spends because I must have missed that statement.

It doesn’t sound as though you are very fond of your friend. Are you usually very intimately aware of the finances of all your friends?

GoodChat · 25/02/2023 11:20

Oohhhh · 25/02/2023 11:07

@GoodChat but she's asking him to be honest about his earnings and control what he spends. This is probably why he has held off telling her.

My good friend works PT, her DH earns about 6 times her salary. He gets bonuses too. And she dictates to him what the money is being spent on. Its painful to watch when she chooses not to work more hours (I'm not saying this is the case with OP as she's looking after chilldren). But my friends DH is my DH's friend, and the things he tells him about what he's purchased but don't tell her. I actually don't blame him because she's so controlling over their finances when I really don't think she has a right to be.

I don't know - I feel if he said to her "I'm getting £500 but I'm thinking about buying x, y and z out of it then the rest will go in the family pot" she'd be ok with that. It's the overhearing him hiding it that's the problem as she's in a vulnerable position if he's hiding money regularly.

PoppyFleur · 25/02/2023 11:14

It’s the lack of transparency and the attempt to hide the extra money that would upset me. Adults in a loving and trusting relationship don’t lie about earning and spending money, you either have certain financial priorities or you don’t.

Particularly when there are children involved and one of the priorities is saving for a housing deposit. Also, we are in the middle of a cost of living crisis, surely now more than ever, money should be a joint conversation.

OP I would be seeking to review if I was on the same page with my OH with regards to financial priorities. I would also be reviewing my current work situation and considering returning to work full time.

Oohhhh · 25/02/2023 11:07

@GoodChat but she's asking him to be honest about his earnings and control what he spends. This is probably why he has held off telling her.

My good friend works PT, her DH earns about 6 times her salary. He gets bonuses too. And she dictates to him what the money is being spent on. Its painful to watch when she chooses not to work more hours (I'm not saying this is the case with OP as she's looking after chilldren). But my friends DH is my DH's friend, and the things he tells him about what he's purchased but don't tell her. I actually don't blame him because she's so controlling over their finances when I really don't think she has a right to be.

emptythelitterbox · 25/02/2023 11:06

Burntoutandfedup · 25/02/2023 10:29

My earning penny's allows him to earn a proper wage and move up in his career. In 5 years when our kids are all at school and I can go back to work full time I'll be 10 years behind him career wise. I'm making a massive sacrifice so he can better his career and prospects. I don't think it's unfair to expect transparency. I've watched so much career progression opportunity's pass me by because I don't have the opportunity to work the hours needed because he does.

Please don't tell us you're being barb the builder for a man! Please don't do that to yourself.

With all these lost career opportunities, it sounds like it would have been better for him to invest in building your career.

GoodChat · 25/02/2023 11:02

PuttingOnTheKitsch · 25/02/2023 10:48

Would most people really be so sanguine about £300 being kept back from the family? I'm not so sure. That's not a small amount of money to most people.

Exactly. We don't have pooled resources but pay proportionate bills to our earnings. We both had extra bonuses this month and have discussed what we're doing with the extra. We're not bothered what the other does but it's a normal conversation, surely?

GoodChat · 25/02/2023 11:00

Char1otte · 25/02/2023 10:30

So go to work and put your kids in childcare. Don't blame him for your choices! Did he force you to work part time? Or did you make that choice?

Are you serious? It's a decision they made together for her to work part time and him to work full time and them to pool their resources.

She's just asking him to be honest about what he's earning - not controlling what he spends.

Oohhhh · 25/02/2023 10:57

I think he's felt he wanted to keep some back because of your phrases like "letting him" spend it on things.

Nanny0gg · 25/02/2023 10:52

DontLikeMenthols · 25/02/2023 10:44

And I’m sure that works fine when it salary/wages but it sounds like OP’s partner did something extra with his mate and are splitting the earnings from that. Why is the OP demanding what he does with that money?

Clearly the couple made a choice for one of them to stay home and the other to go to work, the OP didn’t have to do that. It’s not fair to agree to that together and then complain about it when it doesn’t suit you.

as long as the DP is putting the same amount of money into savings as before then what he does with his bonuses or little extras is his business.

But many people wouldn't do that.

Neither my DH or I would get a good lump sum and spend it on ourselves without some discussion first.

GabriellaMontez · 25/02/2023 10:51

Now you know he's not honest or transparent.

Perhaps you need to consider taking some of the opportunities you've been missing. Because he doesn't sound entirely committed to your partnership. And I'm not sure I'd be relying on him in 10 years.

What is your housing situation?

KievsOutTheOven · 25/02/2023 10:51

Char1otte · 25/02/2023 10:49

We share finances. Our normal job finances. That's what our bills, luxuries, living within our means is based on.

Anything on top like scrap money with his mate, my hobby generating some money....we do what we want with that which often is family or pooled stuff anyway, but at no point would each other try and control that! We are adults.

And that’s completely valid and okay. It depends what the norm in the relationship is though. It isn’t fair if OP pools the finances and then her partner keeps them for himself. As long as both couples are on the same page then it’s all good.

KievsOutTheOven · 25/02/2023 10:49

DontLikeMenthols · 25/02/2023 10:44

And I’m sure that works fine when it salary/wages but it sounds like OP’s partner did something extra with his mate and are splitting the earnings from that. Why is the OP demanding what he does with that money?

Clearly the couple made a choice for one of them to stay home and the other to go to work, the OP didn’t have to do that. It’s not fair to agree to that together and then complain about it when it doesn’t suit you.

as long as the DP is putting the same amount of money into savings as before then what he does with his bonuses or little extras is his business.

Yes but presumably during that time that he was earning that money, op was left with extra responsibility to look after the children?

Like in the example from the OP, it sounds like the OP is paid bonuses which are considered “family money” - in which instance the ops partner should also pay his “extra” money into family finances.

Char1otte · 25/02/2023 10:49

KievsOutTheOven · 25/02/2023 10:39

A lot of these responses come from people who obviously don’t have pooled finances. Pooled finances makes perfect sense when one person is working in a reduced capacity to save on childcare costs.

When finances are pooled, all money belongs to both parties and one person keeping money for themselves is not okay.

We share finances. Our normal job finances. That's what our bills, luxuries, living within our means is based on.

Anything on top like scrap money with his mate, my hobby generating some money....we do what we want with that which often is family or pooled stuff anyway, but at no point would each other try and control that! We are adults.

PuttingOnTheKitsch · 25/02/2023 10:48

Would most people really be so sanguine about £300 being kept back from the family? I'm not so sure. That's not a small amount of money to most people.

KievsOutTheOven · 25/02/2023 10:46

Fixed · 25/02/2023 10:39

My DH has come home with scrap money a few times, mentioned it and threw it in his draw for a later date like when the car might need tyres, something might come up that he wants that's a big expense, etc etc.

I have a hobby that I make money from. On top of my FT job. That money doesn't go in to our blended monies. If I want something I get it, if my DH has his eye on something I'll treat him, it might go on a family holiday.

Point being....in both cases that's our choice. He would never try and say what mines for and I'd never try and say what his is for. After all we are adults. We share all other finances.

That’s fine if it’s your choice. It’s also fine to consider all “extra” money as part of the household finances.

I have my salary, my partner has his.

On top of his, he can get overtime payments, which are added into his salary payment.

On top of mine, I can do paid exam marking and tutoring. These are paid separately to my main job.

My marking money goes towards a family holiday. My tutoring money goes into a piggy bank for spending on “fun” things which benefit the family.

For each of us to be able to earn the “extra” money, the other parent is required to support them by providing childcare.

Its not exactly fair if I do tutoring five days a week and leave my partner to do dinner and bedtime and then I use that money to buy myself a handbag, is it?

DontLikeMenthols · 25/02/2023 10:44

KievsOutTheOven · 25/02/2023 10:39

A lot of these responses come from people who obviously don’t have pooled finances. Pooled finances makes perfect sense when one person is working in a reduced capacity to save on childcare costs.

When finances are pooled, all money belongs to both parties and one person keeping money for themselves is not okay.

And I’m sure that works fine when it salary/wages but it sounds like OP’s partner did something extra with his mate and are splitting the earnings from that. Why is the OP demanding what he does with that money?

Clearly the couple made a choice for one of them to stay home and the other to go to work, the OP didn’t have to do that. It’s not fair to agree to that together and then complain about it when it doesn’t suit you.

as long as the DP is putting the same amount of money into savings as before then what he does with his bonuses or little extras is his business.

KievsOutTheOven · 25/02/2023 10:39

A lot of these responses come from people who obviously don’t have pooled finances. Pooled finances makes perfect sense when one person is working in a reduced capacity to save on childcare costs.

When finances are pooled, all money belongs to both parties and one person keeping money for themselves is not okay.

Fixed · 25/02/2023 10:39

My DH has come home with scrap money a few times, mentioned it and threw it in his draw for a later date like when the car might need tyres, something might come up that he wants that's a big expense, etc etc.

I have a hobby that I make money from. On top of my FT job. That money doesn't go in to our blended monies. If I want something I get it, if my DH has his eye on something I'll treat him, it might go on a family holiday.

Point being....in both cases that's our choice. He would never try and say what mines for and I'd never try and say what his is for. After all we are adults. We share all other finances.

toomuchlaundry · 25/02/2023 10:34

Are you married?

Bunnyishotandcross · 25/02/2023 10:34

Ime such men thrive on giving limited information. My exh wasn't working. I did. Tbh he benefited mostly from my wages. Including expensive hobby. When he got a job it was apparently his money.. A year on I ltb.

Bunnyishotandcross · 25/02/2023 10:31

Ime such men thrive on giving limited information. My exh wasn't working. I did. Tbh he benefited mostly from my wages. Including expensive hobby. When he got a job it was apparently his money.. A year on I ltb.

WandaWonder · 25/02/2023 10:31

We each have spend money on ourselves on occasions to me that is what adults do

Char1otte · 25/02/2023 10:30

So go to work and put your kids in childcare. Don't blame him for your choices! Did he force you to work part time? Or did you make that choice?

Burntoutandfedup · 25/02/2023 10:29

My earning penny's allows him to earn a proper wage and move up in his career. In 5 years when our kids are all at school and I can go back to work full time I'll be 10 years behind him career wise. I'm making a massive sacrifice so he can better his career and prospects. I don't think it's unfair to expect transparency. I've watched so much career progression opportunity's pass me by because I don't have the opportunity to work the hours needed because he does.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread