Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL reaction seems cold

58 replies

Asummersday · 25/02/2023 09:59

Not sure whether i’m just being overly sensitive and reading too much into things or if MIL is being insensitive.

I am early 30s for reference. Husband text MIL in our group chat to tell her the sad news that my sister had died.

she replies “sending hugs & our love”

then a couple of hours later a funny pic of her dog.

then nothing about it, for weeks. If it was me, I would at least send a card or check in with the person showing some empathy and care.

Am I overthinking this??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ColadhSamh · 25/02/2023 17:14

Sorry for the loss of your sister. When I read posts like yours I am glad I come from a culture that has a very different response to death and bereavement.
That your MIL hasn't reached out to you in your grief to offer you support is unbelievable to me. What kind of a relationship do you normally have? Even if the excuse is she doesn't know what to say she could send a card or some flowers to say she is thinking of you. Anything to show she cared.
Your husband's way of informing her doesn't look good either.

Sarain · 25/02/2023 16:35

It's a very odd thing to put in a group chat.....there's no etiquette for such things and perhaps she just felt very awkward? Context of the greater relationship is everything on this one but also your husband is an idiot! Who informs close family of a death on a group chat!

ThinWomansBrain · 25/02/2023 15:51

Sorry for the loss of your sister.
It seems a bizarre thing to inform her by way of a group whatsapp chat TBH.
Did she know your sister?
Personally I'd have called or sent a card - but have given up on trying to predict others' behaviour.

cafenoirbiscuit · 25/02/2023 15:47

My MIL and SIL are yet to acknowledge my mums death 10 months ago.
insensitive twats. And I’m done with them.
love to you, OP xx

DancingDaughter50 · 25/02/2023 15:24

Did you expect more? Are you close? Have u seen her rally around other people with loss?

Mine was Vile at both times I had a loss

CharlotteStreetW1 · 25/02/2023 15:22

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/02/2023 11:06

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · Today 10:41
Sorry for your loss OP.

I don't think your husband sending a text to let MIL know about the loss of your sister has helped the situation. It's quite a shocking way to receive such news. Perhaps as the way she received the message was so flippant MIL didn't see the importance?“

This. Almost as bad as a Facebook announcement.

Very true. I'm still shocked that I received the news of my sister's death via an eight word text from my (adult) niece.

bussteward · 25/02/2023 14:56

I read the OP too fast initially and thought MIL had revived the group chat a couple of weeks later. A couple of hours! What an irredeemable cunt.

Topseyt123 · 25/02/2023 14:25

I am very sorry for your loss. This must be a very difficult time.

I can see why you found the picture of the dog insensitive, and to an extent it was. However, I do wonder whether it was really appropriate that your DH announced the death of your sister on the group chat in this way?

I tend to think that this sort of thing is better done via personal messages than group chats. Group chats are for groups to chat about anything they like including pictures of dogs . Personal messages are better for this sort of bereavement in my opinion, leaving the group chat free for general chatting.

I would have wanted to send you flowers, maybe a card and some personal phone calls and messages if I were your MIL, but would have appreciated also being able to still use the family group chat for general chitchat.

Marjoriesdoor · 25/02/2023 14:01

I pressed YABU by accident. Sorry for your loss and yes, that is very insensitive.

SomeMonstersEatTelly · 25/02/2023 13:58

Gosh, OP, I am so terribly sorry. Losing a sibling must be really difficult.

You aren’t being unreasonable at all. That is a very cold reaction from your MIL and somewhat trivialises your loss. My MIL text me photos of her new kitchen after hearing I had lost a pregnancy and I can remember being such in the throws of grief that I had to check with DH that I wasn’t going mad to think it was a batshit response. It was three months later (actually at the point when the darkness was beginning to lift) that she sent me a card, but only after I had failed to respond to all communication from her.

Needless to say MIL and I are not close and it is behaviour like this which is the reason why.

Do you have a friend to talk to? It might be helpful to hear their outrage. What does DH think?

FrostyFifi · 25/02/2023 13:38

I'd expect a group chat to be appropriately solemn if the news of a major loss had just been shared, even if they weren't well acquainted with OPs sister they presumably are with OP herself.

Quveas · 25/02/2023 13:23

tulips27 · 25/02/2023 11:44

If her dog message was recent I'd be tempted to reply and say you think it's insensitive, otherwise it will be on your mind for years. "Nice pic but I feel this was a bit insensitive considering that I've just lost my sister".

Not sure I agree with that. I'm assuming this picture was in the group chat. So weirdly OP's husband sends a text in a group chat about the death, MIL responds in the group chat, and then later posts a photo to the group chat. That's how I read it. So the photo wasn't, as I am reading it, personal to the OP, and there is no reason why the group chat goes into solemn mode even if everyone in it is sad at the news.

Honestly I think the odd thing was the OH posting something like that in a group chat, and I am not sure, beyond the response the OP got, what was expected. Not everyone is into cards and flowers these days. I might act differently, but not everyone does act the same. And I do see so many people who think that texting / group chats etc replaces other types of contact. So I am not sure that I would be making a judgement based on a single thing that is open to misinterpretation.

Inkpotlover · 25/02/2023 13:14

I would be disappointed with the lack of interest and her not checking in with you. For contrast, my parents only see my DP's brother once a year around Christmas but I know they'd attend send a card and call and even possibly attend the funeral to show support for my DP. Are you close to your MIL?

DaisyDays123 · 25/02/2023 13:02

Unfortunately some people just don’t have the emotional capacity to be there for other people. She may be suffering from depression or it could have triggered her own feelings of loss about a sibling, whatever she is going through doesn’t really matter, the fact is she doesn’t have the energy/capability to be emotionally supportive to you right now. It’s not right or wrong, it’s just the situation.

If it was me I would make a mental note of it, and if she is ever in the same situation give her back the same emotional distance she is giving you. trauma and loss can either bring people closer or further apart - she’s chosen to distance herself. It’s sad.

SerafinasGoose · 25/02/2023 12:29

I'm sorry, OP.

My SiL made the death of my darling mum even more painful than it needed to be. She came to my home the day after the funeral and had a long telephone conversation with my MiL right in front of me, in which she said 'what would I do if I didn't have my mum to talk to?'

She has never been invited back.

Mil and SiL ostracized me when I had a particularly nasty miscarriage (one of several).

Last year I almost died (DVT clots and two huge emboli, one in each lung). When MiL visited over the Christmas break, and I'd cooked for her, not only did she not bother to ask how I was (I wasn't expecting concern) but for some reason best known to herself refused even to speak to me.

She won't be seeing me again. I am through.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 25/02/2023 12:20

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/02/2023 11:06

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · Today 10:41
Sorry for your loss OP.

I don't think your husband sending a text to let MIL know about the loss of your sister has helped the situation. It's quite a shocking way to receive such news. Perhaps as the way she received the message was so flippant MIL didn't see the importance?“

This. Almost as bad as a Facebook announcement.

This is a horrid way to look at it and very judgemental of a grieving person.

I told my closest friends about the loss of my dm via text on our group chat. I didn’t feel able to get the words out over the phone and we don’t all live close together to do so in person as we had with relatives. Dh offered to speak to them but he was also upset and I preferred that they were all told at the same time.

They were quite able to understand the importance of the news of my dm’s death in spite of the fact it was delivered by text and it certainly didn’t stop them being the lovely supportive friends they have always been. Perhaps because they are good people and not insensitive twats.

There is no excuse for the mil’s behaviour and lack of support.

FrostyFifi · 25/02/2023 12:13

I'm also shocked that more people on this thread aren't offering their condolences.

girlfriend44 · 25/02/2023 12:13

WandaWonder · 25/02/2023 10:40

This seems to be a regular thing on here, you control how people act towards you of because of news etc.

Everyone does not read the same rule book 'what to do when x happens'

If people are looking for things to be upset or offended about they always will find then

Exactly we can't please everyone all the time.
That's how she dealt with it whether it's right for you or not.
Stop the group text about people dying if you don't like it. Speak to people on the phone.

bussteward · 25/02/2023 12:12

The dog picture is awful and so is her initial message, which is a bit of a bland nothing as if he’d told her your boiler had broken down or something.

But! What was he thinking, sending that news to a group chat? There is no possible way that group can follow up the news and get back to talking normally (and it is OK for them to get back to normal) without it seeming cold. He should have phoned MIL and other family, or messaged them individually.

FrostyFifi · 25/02/2023 12:11

I honestly feel like everyone on here is also weirdly under-reacting, as if OP is talking about a very elderly great-aunty dying not her own sibling who has passed away at a tragically young age.

Surely a DIL suffering a major bereavement is a big deal within a family?

Neverknowinglyunderbold · 25/02/2023 12:03

Is it a family group with mainly his side of the family? How well does that family know your sister and why are you upset only with your MIL? What about others in the chat?

Testina · 25/02/2023 12:00

I’m not sure that my MIL would send me a card, or even reach out to me directly, if my sister died. She’s never met my sister though, and actually I’m not sure she could tell you how many siblings I even have - certainly couldn’t name them. Is that the same here?
I think sending only a message reply to him in the group chat is fine. Sure it’s a “could do better” situation, but if he dropped it into a group chat, he set the tone - he clearly didn’t think his mother was close to you.

I do think the dog picture was insensitive though! There’s no clear etiquette on how soon to start using a group chat again after sad news - but I’d say same day is out!

LuckySantangelo35 · 25/02/2023 12:00

WandaWonder · 25/02/2023 10:40

This seems to be a regular thing on here, you control how people act towards you of because of news etc.

Everyone does not read the same rule book 'what to do when x happens'

If people are looking for things to be upset or offended about they always will find then

@WandaWonder

its not about controlling how someone acts, it’s about showing some basic human emotion and empathy!

Timeforachangeisitnot · 25/02/2023 11:57

That seems rather insensitive to me, however my late MIL was similar.
If something did not affect her directly she ignored it.

So sorry you lost your sister , that would be unbearable for me.💐

BurtonsRevenge · 25/02/2023 11:57

What was the dog doing that was funny? Or was it just a funny looking dog?

Swipe left for the next trending thread