Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

As a teacher to be surprised at how many in my class have SEN?

319 replies

Floatingcactus · 25/02/2023 09:01

I teach a reception class of 26. 4 of them have an EHCP plan, 6 are waiting assessment and at least another 4 are showing possible signs of SEN including speech delay.

I’ve been teaching for 10 years and I personally believe there is an increase.
I don’t know if lockdown plays a part or whether it’s down to other factors.

OP posts:
Moonicorn · 25/02/2023 11:41

a parent who let their 11 year old, toilet trained child poo in a nappy at the computer and changed him, while he sat there, because she didn’t want to place any restrictions on screen time

Shocking.

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 11:41

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 11:38

But not all children who are thought to have SEN have an EHCP? The OP even said that only 4 of the children in her class with additional needs have an EHCP currently.

Not all DC with SEN have or need an EHCP, but the definition of SEN still hasn’t been lowered. It is defined in law and has been the same since the CAFA 2014 was introduced. The previous legislation had the same definition.

spanieleyes · 25/02/2023 11:39

We have just had a local authority questionnaire round basically asking how we can ensure we are able to take and retain more children in mainstream school rather than specialist provision" without any change in resource levels" . We have said we can't. We have children where it has been agreed they need specialist provision but have been waiting well over 12 months. We also have many children who NEED specialist provision but the LA won't agree.
The number of children with additional needs, not just ASD/ADHD but, has already been said, SALT, SEMH, or just " low ability" is escalating.

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 11:38

daffodilday · 25/02/2023 11:31

Try get an EHCP from your LA and then try repeating that without laughing at yourself.

But not all children who are thought to have SEN have an EHCP? The OP even said that only 4 of the children in her class with additional needs have an EHCP currently.

KillingLoneliness · 25/02/2023 11:35

doadeer · 25/02/2023 11:28

My son is non verbal autistic, he struggles with all aspects of day to day life. We are having to fight for him to have a specialist school place as the LA want him in mainstream. This would be a terrible decision. So if there are other families like mine... Children who need specialist support are being forced into mainstream.

This is very important point as well! There’s so many children who need a place in a specialist school but they aren’t able to get one so they have to go into mainstream, surely that also part of the increase? Also if the school is known for providing excellent support for those with SEN then more parents will be applying for a place.

AliceinSlumberland · 25/02/2023 11:33

doadeer · 25/02/2023 11:28

My son is non verbal autistic, he struggles with all aspects of day to day life. We are having to fight for him to have a specialist school place as the LA want him in mainstream. This would be a terrible decision. So if there are other families like mine... Children who need specialist support are being forced into mainstream.

I so, so feel for you and I’m seeing this more and more. The LA I work for has absolutely no socialist places left to give and has requested to extend existing sites but the government mostly says no. We absolutely need a national specialist school provision building programme.

AliceinSlumberland · 25/02/2023 11:31

Youainttheonlyone · 25/02/2023 11:20

I think “parenting” Is definitely contributing to some of those lower level sens. And I think the way the world is in terms of what you described in lack of provision is exacerbating this in terms of you just don’t have the resources to “school” this out of children.

but for sure the higher level “born with” issues (sorry for my crass wording) - this is a whole new ballgame and has to be something environmental. would you say you are seeing an uplift in numbers of these kids too? X

Yes absolutely, to an insane degree, and all my colleagues agree. There is a huge increase in children with very obvious, very complex needs, who sail through the ehcp process at 3 years old because it’s so obvious and no one can argue otherwise. We have slightly more specialist school places in the past but the demand on these places is 10x more, and all are children who genuinely need these spaces. If schools hunk they have high numbers now, brace themselves because I’ve never seen anything like the reception/nursery cohort that’s coming up. It must be something environmental, perhaps in pregnancy. But research into this area is super controversial - a bit study looking at environment factors was paused recently due to a massive outcry on Twitter that it was disabilist.

kindercup · 25/02/2023 11:31

imsoannoyed · 25/02/2023 11:30

@Myjobisanightmare but marrying within families has been going on for decades surely?

I'm not saying it doesn't lead to SEN or other genetic conditions in children - it most certainly does.

But is it responsible for the increase?

People simply were not recognised or acknowledged many years ago as needing help. The increase may be smaller then we think.

I needed help. I got punishment.

EmmaDilemma5 · 25/02/2023 11:31

Covid has resulted in far less diagnosis and treatment being offered, so I guess early intervention doesn't really exist now. Hence, ongoing needs where perhaps otherwise they'd be less.

That's our experience anyway. Been on the waiting list for SALT for 3 years now.

daffodilday · 25/02/2023 11:31

Moonicorn · 25/02/2023 09:06

The bar has massively lowered as to what SEN is.

Try get an EHCP from your LA and then try repeating that without laughing at yourself.

Youdoyoubabe · 25/02/2023 11:31

I blame the parents.
……and the hormones in the chicken
…….and the phones
…….the parents on the phones
…….and Teletubbies.

imsoannoyed · 25/02/2023 11:30

@Myjobisanightmare but marrying within families has been going on for decades surely?

I'm not saying it doesn't lead to SEN or other genetic conditions in children - it most certainly does.

But is it responsible for the increase?

doadeer · 25/02/2023 11:28

My son is non verbal autistic, he struggles with all aspects of day to day life. We are having to fight for him to have a specialist school place as the LA want him in mainstream. This would be a terrible decision. So if there are other families like mine... Children who need specialist support are being forced into mainstream.

AliceinSlumberland · 25/02/2023 11:27

MarshaBradyo · 25/02/2023 11:19

I know it’s not right to make blanket statements but just to go against idea it’s a type of parent. As what I see makes me feel that’s unfair on some.

In my job I’d say it’s about 30% of parents are hugely invested, attentive, really support their child’s development. 50% poor parenting but not intentionally, often due to the parents own needs, what they’ve experienced as a child, cultural norms etc. and 20% genuinely shit parenting where the parent isn’t arsed. I see children every week where the parenting is shocking, eg a 3 year old who spends literally all day in a high chair in front of the TV, or a parent who let their 11 year old, toilet trained child poo in a nappy at the computer and changed him, while he sat there, because she didn’t want to place any restrictions on screen time. But I also see incredible parents - I remember one mum who seemed almost embarrassed that she had made this incredible scrap book filled with car logos (her child’s special interest) that also sneaked in some letters/numbers/opposites etc. I thought it was incredible and told her so.

If you have a class of 30, if you have 2-3 with additional needs whose parent are totally on board, they’d have always been the ones with SEN in the class. But you now add in the children with poor speech due to lcokdown, the children that only access iPads, the children who are screamed at and then pnisjed for screaming when they’re distressed, when it’s the only model they have, the children who’s parents do nothing with them or don’t want to impose any boundaries, and that’s how you get the increase. Suddenly the 2-3 goes up to 10, and in that group you have incredible parents and poor ones.

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 11:25

Myjobisanightmare · 25/02/2023 11:23

I’m sure I saw an article about this this week, saying that there’s a lot of marrying relatives in some ethnic communities and it’s causing a disproportionate amount of SEN

Yes this is an issue in my part of London where there are a lot of marriages within families.

Phineyj · 25/02/2023 11:25

That's really interesting @fukuraptor. There may be something in that. Certainly when I look at my 80-something parents, they are not "elderly" in the way their own (surviving) parents were at 80. In the Pilates class I go to, there is an 80 and 90 year old. The 90 year old is much bendier than me...

Goldenbear · 25/02/2023 11:25

Where it is environmental factors surely the literacy levels have an impact. Reading books has declined and in some households there are 'no' books. A PP mentioned Rhyme time and not accessing those services under 5, this must have an impact. Not going to libraries, not having a library nearby! Reading for pleasure is more important for children's cognitive development than their parents' level of education and is a more powerful factor in life achievement than socio-economic background. I am truly shocked at the number of Extra curricular software providers my youngest was asked to use in her primary years compared to my son who is 4 years older. She is in year 7 now and it continues, all the homework is in need of a tablet and no textbooks. Even English literature seems to be summarising books/plays(Shakespeare needs to be read, performed and seen on stage, it is not a novel) which you can easily do from looking on YouTube or the internet, no need to actually 'read' anything. I work with varying age ranges and I have discussed the books like Julia Donaldson or the Julia Donaldson song books which my DC would listen to and sing along with, we would also do small performances with the songbooks which was excellent for their vocabulary, most colleagues with toddlers has never heard of her and I work in the education sector!

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 11:24

Moonicorn · 25/02/2023 09:06

The bar has massively lowered as to what SEN is.

I’m not sure why people are taking offence at this, I think it’s very obviously true. Surely most of us remember children in our class at school who were written off as “naughty” or who struggled with their reading, spelling etc. Many of them would have been diagnosed with SEN if they were at school today.

I think there are a lot of other factors as well though.

SeekingBalance · 25/02/2023 11:23

Absolutely, I'm a senco and the work load is unbelievable...we're all scratching our heads at this increase!
I do have some personal ideas regarding the matter which I would never post but as someone whose been in the job many years external/environmental factors must be playing a part.

Myjobisanightmare · 25/02/2023 11:23

Twiglets1 · 25/02/2023 10:26

I'm a TA in a large secondary school and we have noticed this trend also. Not just in the number of pupils with special needs but in the severity of their issues.

There is also an ethnic element that people don't talk about much (including me but I'm anonymous on here). About 2/3 of the pupils in our Inclusion unit with autism/adhd are Asian. A noticably larger percentage than in the general school population though it is a multicultural school.

I’m sure I saw an article about this this week, saying that there’s a lot of marrying relatives in some ethnic communities and it’s causing a disproportionate amount of SEN

Meandfour · 25/02/2023 11:21

Mammyloveswine · 25/02/2023 09:16

I had a similar class in reception last year, I think a lot of children missed their 2 year check so diagnosis was sometimes delayed and some children who would have otherwise not been in mainstream or would've had 1-1 support didn't have it before starting. It was tough but now in year 1 support is in place snd a lot of those children are thriving.

This year my reception class hardly have any additional needs.

I do think there is an increased awareness which is a positive thing as strategies can be put in place much earlier.

Why did they miss their 2 year review?

Youainttheonlyone · 25/02/2023 11:20

AliceinSlumberland · 25/02/2023 11:01

I think it is hugely likely that there is something environmental having an impact. The huge increase I’m seeing, as a professional, is in children with profound difficulties, non-verbal, huge sensory needs, incontinent. Screen time, parenting etc isn’t causing these needs, these children were born this way, but why? I’ve got a horrible, horrible feeling in 50 years time well find out something we all use, every day, massively increases the liklihood. I’ve already seen a couple of studies about paracetamol having an impact. Interestingly, having a high fever also increases the liklihood.

But in addition to those children, there’s also an increase in the number of children with what might have been called ‘lower level‘ needs once upon a time. For these children, lack of support, over stretched resources, technology and poor parenting absolutely do have an impact. I see it every day in my job - people would be astounded at the parenting that goes on. If you’re on MN, it’s probably not relevent to you. I also see lots of parents with their own significant needs, some who attended specialist school themselves, who naturally genetically have children with higher levels of need.

Controversially in my field, I’m massively pro specialist provision. I think every primary school and secondary school should be required to have a ‘specialist base’, and we should built more specialist provision. But the LA isn’t allowed to built new special schools, the Tory government only allows for new ‘free’ schools. We have begged for funding to extend our existing specialist provision but the government says no. So we’re stuck.

I think “parenting” Is definitely contributing to some of those lower level sens. And I think the way the world is in terms of what you described in lack of provision is exacerbating this in terms of you just don’t have the resources to “school” this out of children.

but for sure the higher level “born with” issues (sorry for my crass wording) - this is a whole new ballgame and has to be something environmental. would you say you are seeing an uplift in numbers of these kids too? X

MarshaBradyo · 25/02/2023 11:19

PrincessCalley · 25/02/2023 11:17

I don't think you can say that children won't have additional needs (educational or otherwise) have anything to do with parents being motivated or not. Some needs are totally aided by cotton wool parenting and others are obviously caused by external factors.

I totally agree with the OP about the huge increase in the level of need in young children. I have been a teacher for 15 years and in the last 2 to 3 years the level of need has exploded. Last year out of 27 kids in my class (8 and 9) 17 of them had some extra requirements. This year I also have 17 and the numbers would be similar. I teach in Ireland so it's definitely not just a UK problem. I've no idea what is causing it but in certain areas screens are not helping.

I am very interested in what will eventually come out in relation to the cause of it.

I know it’s not right to make blanket statements but just to go against idea it’s a type of parent. As what I see makes me feel that’s unfair on some.

nolongersurprised · 25/02/2023 11:19

MissyB1 · 25/02/2023 11:09

Nobody said anything about screens causing Autism though?? 🤷‍♀️

But not enough time interacting with adults or other people can be part of speech delay in young children .After all if you don’t get to converse with anyone how do you learn to talk? I’m currently supporting a year one child who has poor speech and limited vocabulary. The whole family (and both mum and admit this) are addicted to screens. Dad said to me “we know we need to talk to him more but we forget”.

Screens and autism in infant boys

This study noted a statistically significant association between screen time and in infant boys and a subsequent ASD diagnosis though. I posted it upthread.

It may well be that babies with ASD are less settled and are put in front of screens more or there may be another confounder

PrincessCalley · 25/02/2023 11:19

*I also have 27

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.