Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

As a teacher to be surprised at how many in my class have SEN?

319 replies

Floatingcactus · 25/02/2023 09:01

I teach a reception class of 26. 4 of them have an EHCP plan, 6 are waiting assessment and at least another 4 are showing possible signs of SEN including speech delay.

I’ve been teaching for 10 years and I personally believe there is an increase.
I don’t know if lockdown plays a part or whether it’s down to other factors.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DancingDaughter50 · 25/02/2023 12:48

@Choconut

@Cocobutt everything you said goes agaisnt all sense with regards to sen. That "label" is actually the code, the key to help a child through their barriers with support to learn.

Monstermoomoo · 25/02/2023 12:46

I personally think it's because teachers are so ridiculously overworked and classes so big that the only way for kids to get the individual attention they need is to have an EHCP.

In schools at least in England, kids are not individuals. Everyone is working on the same thing at the same time regardless of what knowledge they already have. This was not the case where I grew up - we were all given slightly different work to do dependent on our knowledge, and what we personally needed to work on. If I was behind in maths I got maths homework whereas my friend who was behind in English was told to focus on that.

We need more teachers per classroom so the children get the academic help they need, which will in turn help them emotionally as they won't be considered behind their peers already in KS1 🙃

Rant over

elliejjtiny · 25/02/2023 12:45

@MeMyCatsAndMyBooks we had a similar situation with my 9 year old. His teacher called us in for a meeting and suggested he might have sensory issues as he kept repeatedly doing things like banging drawers and rolling pencils across the table. I pointed out that as he was deaf and just got hearing aids he was probably discovering things that he didn't realise made a noise.

Fameinaframe · 25/02/2023 12:45

Class of 30.
11 SEND
7 EAL - 5 of which had no spoken English when they first started.
5- severe behavioural issues
87% Pupil premium.
No support. 🙄😔 LKS2

BungleandGeorge · 25/02/2023 12:45

Poor eating and sleeping are pretty common in young children, parent blaming isn’t particularly helpful. And it’s always been the same. And there’s been poor parents throughout time. You can’t force a child to eat or sleep, it’s usually people without children or lucky enough to have easy children who do the whole parent blaming thing. Some children just have more difficulties inbuilt

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:45

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:36

You think the 4 DC with EHCPs might not have SEN? Or the the DC with speech delay?

Parents don’t need a lawyer. Many parents successfully navigate the SEN system without.

However, that wasn’t the point of my posts. The thing I was rebutting was the pp’s claim the threshold for what SEN is has been massively lowered. It hasn’t.

The PP wasn’t talking about the legal definition because deciding who does and doesn’t have SEN is not as simple as that.

YetAnotherBeckyMumsnet · 25/02/2023 12:40

Hi all - thanks for the reports. We've removed posts that break our guidelines but we wanted to make a wider point about comments relating to diagnosis of SEN. A cursory look at the SN children board will illustrate just how difficult, stressful and disheartening it is for parents to navigate the system in order to get the necessary support in place for their child. Suggesting it's easy to get a diagnosis or that it's the parent's fault for too much screen time would be pretty hurtful to say the least if you're actually in that situation and all too aware of the realities.

We're going to close this thread now while we go through it.

Whatthebarnacles · 25/02/2023 12:37

It's called awareness. And thankfully these kids are getting help they need in their younger years these days instead of struggling or being made to look stupid or naughty.

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:36

You think the 4 DC with EHCPs might not have SEN? Or the the DC with speech delay?

Parents don’t need a lawyer. Many parents successfully navigate the SEN system without.

However, that wasn’t the point of my posts. The thing I was rebutting was the pp’s claim the threshold for what SEN is has been massively lowered. It hasn’t.

User8646382 · 25/02/2023 12:33

I own a nursery which has a higher than average intake of funded 2 year olds. I would say the majority are 10-12 months delayed when they start nursery. A lot have parents whose health visitors have encouraged them to take up nursery places. When we contact the health visitors to ask if they are aware that the children appear to have significant needs, the answer is always that we think the parents need help and that the children need to be in nursery. In most cases, they are right and the children do much better when away from the parents. The children who attend full time really thrive.

There is an issue with modern parenting, and it’s dishonest to pretend there isn’t. Children need clear boundaries, routine and structure - to eat at regular times, to go to bed at a decent time and get 12 hours uninterrupted sleep. You only have to read some of the comments on here to understand that modern parents think it is normal for children not to sleep properly until they are primary school age. They don’t believe it’s right to enforce any type of structure or discipline, so the children’s lives are chaotic. A child who doesn’t sleep or eat properly is going to have behavioural issues - that’s just common sense.

So poor parenting is definitely a contributing factor. But the biggest issue (and I bet in 20 years, it’s found to be the cause of SEN in the majority of cases) for me is/are screens. I think they scramble children’s brains and destroy their attention spans. I also think that children thrive when they are at nursery full time not just because they have structure and routine, which they don’t have at home, but because they don’t have access to screens.

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:32

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:20

I never said it was simple, that was your language, but ultimately the buck does stop with the legal definition and case law. The fact LAs and some schools act unlawfully is a separate point.

So how do you know that any of the children in the OP actually do have SEN? Unless she’s consulted a lawyer how do you know she has applied the definition correctly?

How do you know any of the children on this thread described as SEN actually have it?

Until every single one of us is assessed against the legal definition by an independent body and given a yes/no answer, in a completely objective way which does not lead to any dispute (which would be impossible) there won’t be a clear cut group of “people with SEN” and “people without”. It is all about interpretation.

Thindog · 25/02/2023 12:28

Far more babies born with difficulties or born prematurely are now saved. Many of these will have some developmental delays. There is also a much greater awareness of possible diagnosis, ADHD and OD, and even dyslexia just weren’t heard of years ago.

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:20

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:19

Yes, but the reality is that it’s not as simple as taking a legal definition and then deciding who does and doesn’t have SEN.

We seem to be going round in circles now and I don’t think either of us is going to convince the other one so perhaps best we just leave it.

I never said it was simple, that was your language, but ultimately the buck does stop with the legal definition and case law. The fact LAs and some schools act unlawfully is a separate point.

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:19

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:15

The PP was talking about what SEN is. The original post stated “The bar has massively lowered as to what SEN is.” Well SEN is defined in law, so it is fact that it hasn’t been “massively lowered.”

Yes, but the reality is that it’s not as simple as taking a legal definition and then deciding who does and doesn’t have SEN.

We seem to be going round in circles now and I don’t think either of us is going to convince the other one so perhaps best we just leave it.

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:15

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:13

A lot of parents/teachers/TAs talk about children having SEN. They have not all taken the legal definition and applied it to those children. And even if they had, it’s not an exact science.

The PP was not talking about the legal definition of SEN. They were talking about the range of behaviours which are now attributed to SEN when in the past they wouldn’t have been. In my view there’s no doubt that range has widened significantly.

That’s not to say that improved awareness and other external factors haven’t also had an impact as they probably have. It is a combination of factors and very complex.

The PP was talking about what SEN is. The original post stated “The bar has massively lowered as to what SEN is.” Well SEN is defined in law, so it is fact that it hasn’t been “massively lowered.”

OneInEight · 25/02/2023 12:15

It probably reflects that your school has a better reputation for SEN support than others in the area so parents who know their child has difficulties are more likely to choose your school. Certainly what happens in our town.

Weallhaveavoice · 25/02/2023 12:13

OP
Heres some stats from the Govn

As a teacher to be surprised at how many in my class have SEN?
As a teacher to be surprised at how many in my class have SEN?
As a teacher to be surprised at how many in my class have SEN?
As a teacher to be surprised at how many in my class have SEN?
Newstartonwards · 25/02/2023 12:13

And I do think funding is a huge issue - cost of special speech and language school for my son via LA £22,000 cost for a TA in the school 15 minutes 1-2-1 literally nothing for county. They were keen to push him to main stream asap

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:13

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:03

Whether they are assessed by at a school level, the LA or SENDIST the definition is still the same and doesn’t mean the threshold has been lowered as per the pp. And ultimately for all cases it can be decided by SENDIST.

I know loads of kids whose parents think they have SEN but the school doesn’t, or vice versa.

Of course, but that doesn’t change what is classed as SEN or mean the threshold has been lowered. Many parents have LAs &/or schools claiming their DC doesn’t have SEN &/or doesn’t need an EHCP but the parents go on to successfully apply themselves.

A lot of parents/teachers/TAs talk about children having SEN. They have not all taken the legal definition and applied it to those children. And even if they had, it’s not an exact science.

The PP was not talking about the legal definition of SEN. They were talking about the range of behaviours which are now attributed to SEN when in the past they wouldn’t have been. In my view there’s no doubt that range has widened significantly.

That’s not to say that improved awareness and other external factors haven’t also had an impact as they probably have. It is a combination of factors and very complex.

Cocobutt · 25/02/2023 12:11

I think as a society we feel we need labels for everything.

In the past few years things like ‘asexual’ and ‘non-binary’ have increased.

The facts are that most asexual people (especially teens) just aren’t interested in dating yet and the non-binary people just don’t fit a gender stereotype which is the same for most of us.

When my DD was little the school classed her as potential SEND and recognised that she may need a bit of help in some areas (like most kids do).
They didn’t push to get a diagnosis or use it as an excuse.

There is no such thing as ‘normal’ and if you did a SEN test you would more than likely have a few of the things that they look for.
But so many people feel like they need a label.

It seems the ones that need it the most don’t get the help and the ones who don’t need as much additional help get it all.

Newstartonwards · 25/02/2023 12:09

slamfightbrightlight · 25/02/2023 09:08

It really hasn’t. Local authorities don’t have the kind of budgets to accommodate redefining the threshold of need. In most cases the bar for an EHCP has never been higher.

This. It is harder than ever.
lockdown - massive affects partly parents having to work whilst young children in the house means they didn’t get the same level of child in child interaction. Interaction with other adults etc children learn from all sorts of activities eg cubs and rainbows - they stopped meeting and that has a huge impact.

lack of children in nurseries due to costs, children, Covid, family illness etc

some parents have little or no time or resources to ‘teach’ their children never mind skill sets

my children were very very lucky- both SEN. One had hyper mobility and actually no PE helped her ironically as she could just focus on her physio during PE slots. I had brought all her gcse revision guides, texts, flash cards when she was in year 8 so she got on with them when she had no on line lessons (6months). She’s very bright and academic and working alone or with my support played to her strengths. I asked a languages teacher we were friends with to tutor her online in French and Spanish.

son was at a special speech and language school and it just closed. No work set. No SALT online just nothing - it shut for 6 months. I got hold of the teacher and she provided me with his speech programme and I literally taught myself how to do it. He was year 1, and he did CGP books and salt with me etc 1-2-1 for 4 hours a day 7 days a week. By the time they went back to a school 6 months later instead of being 2 years behind he was 2 months behind. Now he is on track.

many parents didn’t have that luxury that I did of being able to do my work on line, no zoom calls. The kids worked from 7 am until 2 pm with break for lunch etc and then they went out whatever the weather and played in the garden and I did my work online for the next day. We did it same on same every day.

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:07

No one gets an EHCP naming a SS or including an ARP if it isn’t necessary.

AlienatedChildGrown · 25/02/2023 12:06

It’s not just the U.K.

Here in Italy, a stone’s throw from Codogno, DS (a coach) asked me to come and observe a couple of his practices with his two teams of teeny tinies because he felt something was very off considering how late into the season it is. I came along and he’s not wrong. About 1/3 appear very delayed in on all levels. Another 1/3 somewhat delayed.

They didn’t get the same sort of exposure to unmasked, non-distanced people of all kinds, including their peers, as well as being penned up at home, for a lot of their little lives. They simply can’t do what their age group can typically do in that sport. Which is very basic obviously, because they are so little. As a group they are going to need a couple of extra coach-aides or he’ll be herding cats (well… kittens) for the rest of this season at the very least.

Cocobutt · 25/02/2023 12:04

I don’t think covid had a massive impact.

Yes it would have had less people diagnosed in that time but a lot of behaviours like anxiety that were due to covid, aren’t SEN.

I work in a secondary SEND school and the amount of parents who try and get their child in to our unit because they think they have SEN is crazy.

They think because their child doesn’t want to go to school and would rather stay at home and play on their PlayStation all day - must mean they have SEN.

What’s worse is there is obviously a lot of SEN in mainstream who for some reason cannot get an EHCP and a place.

We have a boy come to us for an hour a week who has Tourette’s. He really struggles in a mainstream setting and he disrupts the class and the teacher. He absolutely should not be in mainstream.
We also have a few students who could easily be in mainstream and cope well.

We are over subscribed as well as every other unit in our county.
2 new units are being built and the waiting list is already full.

I think we need to save the SEND units for those who really need it and have much smaller classes in mainstream and more TAs so the students individual needs can be met.

JustKeepBuilding · 25/02/2023 12:03

pennylanestrawberries · 25/02/2023 12:00

How many cases are assessed by SENDIST? The vast majority aren’t.

And even then I’m sure there’s an element of subjectivity given that the assessment is done by human beings. And I know loads of kids whose parents think they have SEN but the school doesn’t, or vice versa. And parents who have had differing views from different medical professionals.

It’s not like you can take a blood test and get a yes/no answer.

Whether they are assessed by at a school level, the LA or SENDIST the definition is still the same and doesn’t mean the threshold has been lowered as per the pp. And ultimately for all cases it can be decided by SENDIST.

I know loads of kids whose parents think they have SEN but the school doesn’t, or vice versa.

Of course, but that doesn’t change what is classed as SEN or mean the threshold has been lowered. Many parents have LAs &/or schools claiming their DC doesn’t have SEN &/or doesn’t need an EHCP but the parents go on to successfully apply themselves.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.