Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy DD a present between birthday and Christmas.

513 replies

Rainallnight · 25/02/2023 08:09

DD is desperate for a Rainbow High doll. She’s 6. I think it’s a bit tied up with friendship issues because it’s become a thing on her friendship group and she feels left out when they play with them.

Her birthday isn’t until June.

We usually don’t buy ‘big’ presents outside of birthdays or Christmas.

We can afford it, I just worry about spoiling. What do other people do about toys outside of birthdays or Christmases.

YABU - Buy her the bloody doll.
YANBU - hold out till Christmas

OP posts:
Flickfifo · 25/02/2023 10:12

The fact you’re even asking this, are we to then presume that you never buy yourself anything unless it’s at Christmas or birthday?

Moveoverdarlin · 25/02/2023 10:11

If you’re good and I don’t have to tell you off in the Easter holidays you can have the doll, if you get every word right in your next spelling test, you can have the doll, if you make your bed every morning for the next month, you can have the doll. Use it to your advantage. Works for us. My DD birthday is in Nov, so she’d go without all year if we just relied on birthday and Christmas.

namechange3394 · 25/02/2023 10:11

Rainallnight · 25/02/2023 08:16

For people who buy tous all year round, do you worry about spoiling? Ours will get something small from eg a National Trust shop on a day out, but not on a ‘can I have this thing I want’ basis.

We’re quite comfortably off and I want her to understand things cost money.

How is never buying her anything going to teach her that though?! That's not teaching her about making choices with money, or that things cost money.

Buy her the doll and then perhaps:

  1. Start giving her pocket money so that she can learn how to save up for things.
  2. Start explaining about choices with money. If you want to go to the trampoline park, that costs three times as much as X cheap day out, so we could do X 3 times or the trampoline park once, that sort of thing.
shakeitoffsis · 25/02/2023 10:10

Only on Mumsnet. Get the doll, you've said you can afford it.

MTIH · 25/02/2023 10:08

Start the practice of saving towards. She could even earn some extra😉

Having control of your own money is a really important life skill, taking seriously the choices you make.

We gained massively from this once they became teens. Funny how sometimes the need for the latest £100 trainers, dissipated when they were given the maximum amount I was prepared to spend (£50.00) but could add the extra themselves if the £100 ones were ‘essential’

And, if they decided to go ahead with their £100 choice and added the extra money from savings, at least they had made a considered decision about their own money. ( and also gained a sense, sometimes of regret too, informing the next decision).

It has resulted in young adults who manage their money really well, work hard to earn and only ask for support when it is absolutely essential.

Abraxan · 25/02/2023 10:07

Rainallnight · 25/02/2023 08:16

For people who buy tous all year round, do you worry about spoiling? Ours will get something small from eg a National Trust shop on a day out, but not on a ‘can I have this thing I want’ basis.

We’re quite comfortably off and I want her to understand things cost money.

There is a big difference in spoiling a child and the child being in a privileged position to receive toys outside of birthdays/Christmas.

Spoiling involves expectation.
Does your child think they should be able to,get what they want when they want? And will express that view to you and others, for example?

Some children are privileged in that their parents can buy/give them things outside of special events. But so long as it is not done in demand, it's not an expectation and it isn't grabby then it's fine imo.

Wellthatwasweird · 25/02/2023 10:05

I only ever got gifts for Christmas and birthdays (generally). Even then it was within a budget so I definitely wasn't spoiled. My parents couldn't afford it and that was just that. I can afford it and I do get my kids toys and clothes through the year. All I really learned was that my parents were broke and that I wasn't really worth getting anything the rest of the year. I know they didn't mean to make me feel like that, but I did. I didn't go without, don't get me wrong, but things sometimes felt meagre. My kids get stuff throught he year, as and when, and are very well behaved, kind, thoughtful and caring so it hasn't done them any harm.

As an aside, I think spoiling children really comes when parents put kids at the centre of the universe in all apsects. This is a scary and unhealthy place for children to be and which leads to entitled adults. More damage is done when the child never learns that there are systems which they have to fall in line with, that other people have feelings and needs, and that certain things have to be done that we don't like.

For example, there is a philosophy that we shouldn't insist that our children say 'please' or 'thank you' because it should feel authentic to the child. In my opinion, using these terns is for the benefit of the recipient, and not to make the person saying it feel good about thanking someone. Parenting which places the child as the sun in their solar system in every aspect of their lives is how children get spolied imo. A few toys mid way through the year, within a context of balanced parenting, is totally fine. Sorry for the digression!

Fuzzyblank · 25/02/2023 10:04

Buy the doll. My children have bday in Feb and I can’t imagine the only toys they got to be what was received in December and February! We’ve always picked up bits, whether that’s a toy, a magazine, craft stuff when they have asked/needed.
They are teens now, one is a splurger and one is a saver but they both understand how money works.

tillyoumakeit · 25/02/2023 10:03

All these people saying Easter presents. Easter is still ages away - especially if you are 6. OP - I hope you and your DD are already on your way to a toy shop and then on for a piece of cake together to just celebrate her being awesome, which I am sure she is!!

Totally agree with PP saying this is a lovely bit of parenting - parenting isn't just about being as strict and joyless as possible to 'teach' you children constants (weird) lessons.

MarvelMrs · 25/02/2023 10:01

Make it a special beautiful memory day with your DD. Take her out for the day, let her chose the doll and have lunch/treats/cinema. It will likely end up being a special day you both remember. It isn’t spoiling her it is just enjoying life together. Parenting is hard work, grab the joyful moments when you can.
Spoiling is saying yes to everything all the time and never saying no or buying things the kids don’t need or truly want.

H34th · 25/02/2023 10:01

I'd buy it.

I wouldn't turn it into a reward. We don't do rewards/ punishments as then the behaviour is linked to external expectations rather than internalised values.

The way not to spoil her is more about modelling being grateful and educating about the world in general (poverty, war, etc), which I'm sure you do already in small ways in your everyday life.

Guis · 25/02/2023 10:00

Please buy her the doll.
Spoiling children isn't always about providing material things.

But emotional spoiling. Not telling them how to behave. Not encouraging them to share, or how to look after things. Allowing them to understand and expect to be number one wherever they go. Not teaching them consideration for other people.

Spending £10 on a dolly once in a blue moon won't spoil her.

tara66 · 25/02/2023 10:00

Why deny your child happiness? I don't see the point.

MusicWithRocksIn · 25/02/2023 10:00

I would buy the doll, and start giving pocket money.

My DC (7 &9) get £10 a month each straight into their bank accounts, to begin with they spent it all on magazines and crappy £1 toys but they soon realised it was better to save most of it towards things they really want. I buy things like art supplies and the odd book throughout the year and usually let them spend £10 in the gift shop if we go to e.g. a theme park, but that's only about 3x a year. Anything else they want they buy themselves. It means they don't pester for stuff any more and think carefully about what they really want.

StoppinBy · 25/02/2023 09:59

Personally I would give her the ability to do chores for cash so she can work towards saving for it herself.

Nanny0gg · 25/02/2023 09:58

Rainallnight · 25/02/2023 08:09

DD is desperate for a Rainbow High doll. She’s 6. I think it’s a bit tied up with friendship issues because it’s become a thing on her friendship group and she feels left out when they play with them.

Her birthday isn’t until June.

We usually don’t buy ‘big’ presents outside of birthdays or Christmas.

We can afford it, I just worry about spoiling. What do other people do about toys outside of birthdays or Christmases.

YABU - Buy her the bloody doll.
YANBU - hold out till Christmas

We always did Easter presents...

FourFour · 25/02/2023 09:57

It seems like you've gone the complete opposite to spoiling. We buy toys all year round for ds, he isn't spoilt and when we say no at times he understands. Growing up we couldn't afford anything so we only got toys at Christmas or birthdays and it was sad even back then as I remember. If you can afford it now why wouldn't you?

DisforDarkChocolate · 25/02/2023 09:56

Why does she need to earn?

Honestly, give her a gift for no other reason than you love her and it will make her happy.

Avacadoandtoast · 25/02/2023 09:55

Buy the doll! It will bring so much joy to her. As someone has said above, is her reading really coming on? Or her maths? Or has she done a good painting or learnt to swim recently, you could buy it as a well done! If not, I still think being bought something away from when you ‘have’ to is a lovely thing.

AdoraBell · 25/02/2023 09:55

Buy the doll, make up a reason.

Drizzlepeacefully · 25/02/2023 09:53

I was a kid who never had the popular toys .. or a tiny version .. inch tall care bear and key ring rubic cube .. occasionally it’s nice to get a toy if it’s not expensive .. I’m sure you can make it a reward for something

Newyearnewmeow · 25/02/2023 09:53

It’s not even a ‘big’ present IMO. It’s not as if she asked for a hundred pound bike or something equally expensive it’s just a little treat.
You sound a bit uptight about not spoiling her and only buying nice things for birthdays or Christmas. If my kids really wanted something on occasion and I could afford it I would just buy it to make them happy and see the absolute delight on their faces when I gave it to them.

WinterMusings · 25/02/2023 09:52

@Rainallnight

I definitely agree with your general approach to buying toys.

I was a 70's child. I didn't get toys between birthday (Feb) & Christmas. It made Christmas SO exciting. We didn't make a 'list' of things to get, we made a list of things we hoped to get & it was for Santa to choose which.

I remember one game I got outside of that, but it was rather extreme circumstance and I remember getting colouring books & new pens/pencils when I had my tonsils out.

those things Wouk's be the great memories they are if I had got toys all the time!!

I had plenty of toys/art stuff and my parents made stuff with me, played with me etc. I had a very happy childhood.

buying kids toys all the time takes away some of the excitement of Christmas and the opportunity to learn about delayed gratification IMO and toys aren't played with as much because they have too many/are overwhelmed.

if her birthday is May, she won't need to wait until Christmas would she!

Anyway, I don't have as much self control as my parents & cash is a bit less tight, so I'd take her out to choose one as a special treat.

category12 · 25/02/2023 09:51

Dareisayimonetoo · 25/02/2023 09:45

Find a reason and get the doll

I don't think there needs to be a reason.

OP, don't you ever treat your husband or him you just because you want to see him smile and vice versa? Even little things like a chocolate bar or book, anything you might say "I saw this and thought of you"?

Don't you ever just do something for yourself to make you feel good?

If you don't, maybe you bloody well should.

Life isn't all about being austere and teachable moments.

It's a about doing little things for each other to make each other happy. This applies to children too.

colasoca · 25/02/2023 09:49

Spoiling is buying unnecessary stuff that no one wants and needs and appreciates. This is something she'd really like and is making her feel left out. That's quite a big difference.
And £20 is not huge to you (different if you were talking £100s.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread