Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Murdaugh Murders - to believe Alex didn't shoot his wife and son?

162 replies

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

OP posts:
RuppyDa · 25/02/2023 02:07

There’s an excellent podcast “The Murdaugh Murders” by Mandy Matney, which gives loads of info of all the various crimes and investigations.

been watching the trial / one witness, the lawyer for the boat incident , said when Paul died so the case against him - which gave a motive. No real motive given for Maggie.

also - when he has admitted being at the kennels, he states he “got out of there” because he was so hot and didn’t want to do any work. Would you not say “I wish I hadn’t left” or “if only I had stayed maybe I could’ve saved them”…..

I feel it’s all a huge act he’s putting on, time will tell , I hope the jury see through it all

QueenCamilla · 25/02/2023 00:45

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later?

You just answered it. The "whitewashing" shows his faulty character. One doesn't need a deep meaning motive when he's an ill-tempered arsehole.

Is the trial done? Was going to watch it when it's over, so I can skip the nothing parts.

SunshineAndFizz · 25/02/2023 00:36

The documentary said Alex was a heavy drug user (he uses that excuse himself for where all his money was going).

It also says it was rumoured the wife had hired a divorce attorney and a forensic accountant (as bills were going unpaid and she didn't know why).

They blatantly killed the house keeper and covered up at least one other death. Who knows what other secrets she knew about him.

Drug addict + murderer + wife leaving him.

Tinner01 · 25/02/2023 00:00

Wow, i hadn’t heard of this, how awful. It sounds more like the plot of Knives Out or similar than real life events! There are some dreadful goings on in the world.

OntarioBagnet · 24/02/2023 23:13

Guilty as hell. He was at the kennels when the shooting occurred, he’s lied and lied and lied. Maybe he shot Paul on purpose to try and stop the financial investigation. Maybe he just planned to shoot his wife who was reportedly planning to divorce him and Paul was in the wrong place at the wrong time.

SeriouslyLTB · 24/02/2023 23:03

The working theory is the son was collateral damage. He wasn’t supposed to be killed.

BrightPurple · 24/02/2023 22:51

It’s a weird one.

Wasn’t his wife thinking of divorcing him? That could have something to do with him flipping? Maybe?

Think he just thought he was above the law. He liked a drink too so maybe this was also a factor if he’d been drinking that night.

minou123 · 24/02/2023 22:43

The whole thing is such a complex, tangled web of lies.

Just looking at Alex's embezzlement is, by itself, absolutely awful.

He was a personal injury lawyer. He used his power and money to steal from his clients. And a lot of his clients were his friends.
The case with the housekeeper is the most shocking.
She died at his house. He sued his own insurance company on behalf of her sons, for her death

He then kept the $4.3million compensation and didn't give a penny to the sons.

He is currently serving a prison sentence.

twoandcooplease · 24/02/2023 22:43

twoandcooplease · 24/02/2023 21:46

I wondered why I was recognising the Murdaugh name. I've just finished watching a doc recently on
ITVx - The Speedboat Killer - victim Mallory Beach

Baby brain apologies this is wrong. I have this muddled with another I've watched recently both involving boats... Will come back with the actual name when I remember

minou123 · 24/02/2023 22:36

XelaM · 24/02/2023 22:22

Yes, I saw that they placed him near the scene of death. I just don't get it. Why?! Why would he shoot his son at point blank range? He tried so hard to make all of his son's problems "disappear". How could he have just shot him in cold blood seemingly for no reason?! Unless he was in some drug-induced state of psychosis

I've been following the trial (although I have missed a few days)

The way I have understood it is:
The younger son Paul had the drunken boating accident which killed Mallory and severely injured the other friends.

Because of this boating accident, Paul was being charged with death by drunk boat driving (OK, not the exact charge but you know what I mean)
And, he was also being sued by the friends in a Civil case.

As a result the dad, Alex, financial affairs and his work financial affairs started to be investigated.

It was during this time, I believe he killed Paul and his wife Maggie, thinking that it will stop all the investigations. Especially stop the investigations into his embezzlement. Which if course it didn't as he was convicted of embezzlement.

So, using my very credible arm chair detective work, I think he did do it. He did it thinking, in his strange little brain, that by killing the son it would cover up all the others crimes he, the dad, had committed. I.e covering the tracks of all the money he stole was worth more than his sons and wife's life.

Weird , I know, but people do very horrible things for money.

XelaM · 24/02/2023 22:35

AdditionalCharacter · 24/02/2023 22:27

I've watched the Netflix one tonight. I think he did it.

What really struck me was the 911 call the mother made about the housekeeper falling down the stairs. She didn't sound shocked or panicked, more like it was an inconvenience.

Yes, I thought so too! She sounded so mean

OP posts:
AdditionalCharacter · 24/02/2023 22:27

I've watched the Netflix one tonight. I think he did it.

What really struck me was the 911 call the mother made about the housekeeper falling down the stairs. She didn't sound shocked or panicked, more like it was an inconvenience.

XelaM · 24/02/2023 22:22

Yes, I saw that they placed him near the scene of death. I just don't get it. Why?! Why would he shoot his son at point blank range? He tried so hard to make all of his son's problems "disappear". How could he have just shot him in cold blood seemingly for no reason?! Unless he was in some drug-induced state of psychosis

OP posts:
Throwncrumbs · 24/02/2023 22:02

He lies to get out of a lie, he can’t keep his story straight and yesterday admitted to being at the kennels after lying about it since the murders. He’s as guilty as it gets!!

Simonsaysitschristmas · 24/02/2023 22:02

Only on episode two but have vaguely followed the news.

My thoughts are:
I think Alex did it and didn’t want to kill Buster because he was a much better heir to the dynasty whereas Paul was causing trouble for the family to clean up

Didn’t Alex get shot himself a few months later? (Although I thought they had proved he shot himself but staged it like it was a hitman)

What I don’t really understand is why Buster is supporting his dad? Does he truly believe he didn’t do it or is he just trying to save the last of his family unit?

VivaLesTartes · 24/02/2023 21:55

I was stuck with this. Can see he had means and opportunity but didn't get the motive mind you he did alot of weird stuff after.

Popping my armchair deceive hat on, they said it was 2 different murder weapons, maybe son lost it whilst drunk and killed the mum and dad killed him in revenge/ self defence.

Or one of them knew something about the previous murders and threatened to go to the police - the son doted on the nanny maybe found out.

We could come up with a lot of theories I bet.

LemonSwan · 24/02/2023 21:46

Of course he did it. Even tried to fake his own shooting and set up that bloke.

twoandcooplease · 24/02/2023 21:46

I wondered why I was recognising the Murdaugh name. I've just finished watching a doc recently on
ITVx - The Speedboat Killer - victim Mallory Beach

Swiftswatch · 24/02/2023 21:39

Classic Netflix documentary roping in multiple plot lines and making absolutely zero credible conclusions.

WoolyMammoth55 · 24/02/2023 21:36

So this is from today - Alex Murdaugh has admitted being at the scene of the murders, the dog kennels, which he had previously denied. It came to light after prosecutors found a video of the dogs taken by his son 'about 4 minutes before he died' where Alex's voice can be heard talking to the dogs off camera.

So now we know that he was with his wife and son minutes before they were shot to death, and has lied about it for the past 20 months.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/24/alex-murdaugh-trial-testimony

Innocent people don't lie. And that is powerful circumstantial evidence that he was involved in their deaths.

I imagine his motive was either an insurance payout (like his poor housekeeper) or to stop the civil case against his son going anywhere by killing him. Or just to stop all the drugs and embezzlement stuff from coming to light?

The overwhelming majority of female murder victims are killed by a man they are in a relationship with. It's just like poor Emma Pattinson and Lettie, except WAY more obvious red flags with Alex Murdaugh.

BernadetteIsMySister · 24/02/2023 21:35

Fridaysgirl17 · 24/02/2023 21:26

I've actually been watching the trial,& the prosecution has proved very little never mind murder,the investigation was terrible,one investigator lied to the grand jury that indicted him about the blood spatter evidence,they left evidence behind,walked all over the crime scene with no protective gear on,let water fall onto the bodies,it was farcical.
He has been testifying the last few days & honestly his love for his family shines through. Yes he's a terrible human for his financial crimes & deserves punishment for that but that is not this & it's what the state is hanging it all on. Even if convicted,he has plenty of grounds for appeal, according to lawyers on You tube
The standard is beyond a reasonable doubt & there is plenty of doubt.

And I think this might be a problem.

Doesn't mean he didn't do it though.

Lentilweaver · 24/02/2023 21:35

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 24/02/2023 21:30

Men quite frequently kill their kids. Google 'family annihilation'.

The only unusual feature here is that one son was left alive - but maybe something went wrong with the original plan?

Familiar with family annihilation of course, but this is not that. This is a planned cold-blooded murder for gain.
Perhaps he left the other kid alive so he could testify about what a good dad he was. Ugh.

sydneysunset · 24/02/2023 21:32

@Fridaysgirl17
i agree, I watched some of his evidence earlier and was surprised to find him credible. Perhaps it’s all an act

TwoMonthsOff · 24/02/2023 21:31

hattie43 · 24/02/2023 21:02

This has now reached Netflix .

It’s on Discovery + thats where i watched it

The father has evil eyes I think

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 24/02/2023 21:30

Lentilweaver · 24/02/2023 21:01

I have been vaguely following this and am baffled too. Men kill their wives all the time but not their sons.

Men quite frequently kill their kids. Google 'family annihilation'.

The only unusual feature here is that one son was left alive - but maybe something went wrong with the original plan?