Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Murdaugh Murders - to believe Alex didn't shoot his wife and son?

162 replies

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

OP posts:
XelaM · 25/02/2023 07:42

OntarioBagnet · 25/02/2023 07:29

I think Buster is very aware of what happened, even if his dad hasn’t confessed to him he can’t be stupid enough to believe him. I think that Apple has not fallen far from the tree. And it’s looking very possible he had something to do with his friends death.

Id say Buster is also prioritising money and the family name over any morals or feelings.

I wonder if Buster doesn't want to believe it's true. He appears to also be an awful person, but how do you get to terms with your father murdering your younger brother and mother in cold blood for seemingly no real reason?

OP posts:
BernadetteIsMySister · 25/02/2023 07:33

He wasn't protecting them for their own good, he was protecting them from harming his reputation and to cover the financial misconduct.

Even Buster was being charged for Paul's underage drinking and use of his ID.

safeplanet · 25/02/2023 07:33

He tried so hard to make all of his son's problems "disappear".

was this to protect the son or actually himself & the family dynasty?

BernadetteIsMySister · 25/02/2023 07:31

mummabubs · 25/02/2023 03:26

I've only finished episode one, so wish this thread title hadn't contained what I assume is a whopping soiler. 🤦🏻‍♀️

It's not fiction! The actual court case is going on right now. Maybe don't watch the news ever, there's soilers [sic] every day on there.

Heads up - have you seen the episode about the pandemic yet? That's a good one 🙄

OntarioBagnet · 25/02/2023 07:29

I think Buster is very aware of what happened, even if his dad hasn’t confessed to him he can’t be stupid enough to believe him. I think that Apple has not fallen far from the tree. And it’s looking very possible he had something to do with his friends death.

Id say Buster is also prioritising money and the family name over any morals or feelings.

safeplanet · 25/02/2023 07:28

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later?

Arrogance, entitlement, greed. Protecting your family from something else doesn't mean you won't harm them.

Paturday · 25/02/2023 07:26

QuillBill · 25/02/2023 07:24

Apparently that's a southern accent thing. The woman on Pretty Little Lies and Alibi's explained it at the start.

Ok fair enough 😁 I did wonder if I was a tad harsh there. He’s just overall gross.

QuillBill · 25/02/2023 07:24

Paturday · 25/02/2023 07:22

Also annoyed me that he pronounces Alex Alec 😵‍💫 what a twat.

Apparently that's a southern accent thing. The woman on Pretty Little Lies and Alibi's explained it at the start.

Paturday · 25/02/2023 07:22

Also annoyed me that he pronounces Alex Alec 😵‍💫 what a twat.

QuillBill · 25/02/2023 07:22

They have tallied the movements of Maggie's phone, which was taken from scene and found by the side of the road, which the movements of Alex's car which is pretty damning.

He had been confronted at work that day about the financial crimes and the boat case trial was scheduled for the same week.

Paturday · 25/02/2023 07:21

Paul wasn’t the heir, Alex and Maggie (?) werent interested in raising him (Gloria did). So no probs to get rid of him so that 1) Alex doesn’t any longer have a murderous son in prison and 2) buster can get all the inheritance I guess. Alex soooo arrogant and used to getting his own way, he thought he’d just be able to get away with it, saying he wasn’t at the house when it happened.

That’s my theory! The way the murdaughs intercepted the other boat passengers and their families at the hospital and tried to pin it all on Connor was abhorrent.

YellowDots · 25/02/2023 07:18

mummabubs · 25/02/2023 03:26

I've only finished episode one, so wish this thread title hadn't contained what I assume is a whopping soiler. 🤦🏻‍♀️

It happened it 2021. It's a live court case in the news not Love Island,

ILProbs · 25/02/2023 06:37

The behaviour panel on YouTube have an analysis of his behaviour during his initial interview. It's interesting.

I think I read somewhere that Maggie had seen a lawyer about divorce. But in his initial interview, he didn't mention this. He also seemed to switch between making sort of disparaging comments about Paul to saying he was great, which was quite strange.

WeWereInParis · 25/02/2023 06:18

mummabubs · 25/02/2023 03:26

I've only finished episode one, so wish this thread title hadn't contained what I assume is a whopping soiler. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Seriously? I've never seen the Netflix show but this case has been very widely reported. Maybe bbc news should add a spoiler warning as well

Threee · 25/02/2023 04:50

I. Didn’t know anything about this till yesterday, it’s very shocking

Spencerfloral · 25/02/2023 04:18

mummabubs · 25/02/2023 03:26

I've only finished episode one, so wish this thread title hadn't contained what I assume is a whopping soiler. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Are you serious? Regardless of the documentary being on Netflix, this is real life and real people, not your Sunday night entertainment to get annoyed about being spoiled on.

knittingaddict · 25/02/2023 03:38

thecatsthecats · 24/02/2023 21:23

Because a powerful and hubristic man is ESPECIALLY likely to act so to his nearest and dearest?

My rule is that people don't have exceptions for their bad behaviour. If they do it to other people, they will do it to you under the right circumstances.

This.

TheAustralian · 25/02/2023 03:31

hattie43 · 24/02/2023 21:02

This has now reached Netflix .

🙄 it’s on Netflix. Has been for a while

mummabubs · 25/02/2023 03:26

I've only finished episode one, so wish this thread title hadn't contained what I assume is a whopping soiler. 🤦🏻‍♀️

MyMumSaysALot · 25/02/2023 03:07

So, he decided to testify in his own defense.

”Ok, so I lied before but I’m totally telling the truth now.”

Sure, pal.

PortiasBiscuit · 25/02/2023 02:59

FFS, this is a real crime, with real people, not an episode of CSI for you all to slaver over.
How can you possibly know whether he’s guilty or not?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 25/02/2023 02:55

It's his son Paul that he's referring to ad PauPau.

Clearly he is guilty.

ShippingNews · 25/02/2023 02:53

RonnieMcdonnie · 24/02/2023 21:24

I definitely think he did it, he has lied so much throughout, I can’t see it being anyone else. He’s going for an Oscar with his performance testifying with the fake tears and cringy nicknames like ‘paw paw’ 🙄

I also think he did it, but just to mention ......maw maw and paw paw are commonly used Southern names for grandparents.

Saffronpotatoes67 · 25/02/2023 02:47

Does everyone think his story about being addicted to pills is real?
I am not convinced and having heard the testimony of the colleague he cheated out of money, Alex wouldn't have been able to handle his work load and win so many cases had he been spaced out all of the time. Has it been proven that he went to rehabilitation, or rather did the doctors there confirm that he was addicted? Presumably they would have tested his blood at various points. And wasn't his blood on the night of the murder shown to be free of drink and drugs?

Also being addicted to prescription pain killers because of an old sports injury is more 'respectable' and less demeaning than just admitting you were greedy and living way beyond your means. Also, I suspect more corruption will reveal itself; I wouldn't be surprised if he used some of the money to pay off people to keep them quiet. His close friend of many years who was also a lawyer of similar status (the one he left with hideous debt) said he didn't earn nearly the same as Murdaugh.

Saffronpotatoes67 · 25/02/2023 02:30

He's as guilty as sin and in addition to the murders has cynically betrayed so many people close to him in such a vile and blatant way: his in-laws, his friend and colleague who took on a burden of debt for him, his extended family.

You can also see the stresses building up to the point of murder: strain of boating accident, discovery of fraud, sacking from law firm and aligned scandal, loss of status in community, then possible rejection by wife.

The murders were definitely planned though given that he summoned his wife to the property. He must be a psychopath in my view to get up there on the stand and try and insist in all seriousness that he did not commit these murders and to put his remaining family and friends through the pain of this trial. As I understand it, his wife's elderly parents are still alive and he is willing to put them through this?

And surely his son Buster must have some suspicions but maybe he has to believe in his father's innocence in order to maintain his sanity?

The whole saga is like a sordid, gritty and deadly version of Dallas, And it has a serious element in it too in that the trial exposes the shocking divisions in status in American society between the rich and poor, the connected and the not so well connected and the different ways these two groups are treated by the justice system.

The casual sprinkling of guns is pretty hair-raising too!