Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Murdaugh Murders - to believe Alex didn't shoot his wife and son?

162 replies

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

OP posts:
Crimsonripple · 26/02/2023 11:19

The timeline totally skews the whole thing as there's no way he would be at the kennels if a/ he didn't do it, or b/ if he didn't do it, then he would have heard the gunshots which would have meant a 911 call much earlier.

Motive to me are his fraud issues and drug addiction. Both of those are powerful enough to want to gain back control what he was clearly losing because of Paul and Maggie. Buster doesn't strike as any threat just bumbling along in the background.

I would question though the evidence. Have they done reenactments with both weapons to see if it was physically possible to swap weapons and kill? Assuming the distance would there have been blood splatters/residue? Although I suspect he's quickly got rid of any of that evidence when he went on that jaunt to his parents I've just recently been following it after watching the Netflix documentary.

XelaM · 26/02/2023 10:01

Reminds me of the Robert Durst case on the series The Jinx.

Ohh, I loved The Jinx!! But I found Robert Durst strangely likeable (I know there's something wrong with me 🫣). But Alex Murdaugh is so evil it's almost beyond belief like a poster above said. And it appears the whole family was evil. Maggie's 999 call about the housekeeper's death was so chilling and Paul was just a horrible human being and caused Mallory's death and then didn't seem to have any remorse afterwards. In fact, there is a video shown in the Netflix documentary of Mallory's boyfriend shouting at him to rot in hell because he was laughing when the divers were looking for Mallory in the immediate aftermath of the crash. All Paul was concerned with was calling his grandfather to help him get away with it. I don't know much about Buster, but if the rumours about Stephen's death are true, he's just as horrible as his whole family.

I agree with the poster above about the timeline of Alex being near the kennels just before they died. It makes no sense unless he's the killer/mastermind. And I'm starting to think the cash motive is probably true given that Paul was being sued for the Mallory crash (and as I understand it, the boat crash started the financial investigation that led to Alex's downfall). Maggie was also after Alex's cash in any divorce. Plus, she knew that they killed the housekeeper for the insurance money.

OP posts:
MySugarBabyLove · 26/02/2023 08:54

Fuck me. Why even bother having criminal trials now when all they have to do is to let netflix do a sensationalist documentary.

I haven’t watched any of this but personally I find it despicable that this has been allowed to be turned into entertainment before there has been an actual verdict.

By contrast there is currently a fairly high profile trial in the news ATM regarding a nurse charged with murdering multiple babies, and there is absolutely no way mn would allow a thread to stand where people acted as judge and jury to decide beyond their own reasonable doubt whether she is guilty or not before an actual verdict has been reached.

Saffronpotatoes67 · 26/02/2023 08:48

I only saw snippets over the past few days but I think the prosecution did a good job of defining the time line with his questioning to Alex.

His comment along the lines of “so you are asking us to believe that a stranger, who knew Maggie and Paul were going to be at Moselle that night, and specifically at the kennels, was able to sneak in minutes after you had been there previously, between the times of x and x (it was only about 15 minutes or so) and turned up to kill them assuming that a loaded gun would be available to do the job?!” was the line that destroyed Alex’s case.

And the fact that somehow this fictitious killer’s movements exactly matched those of Alex’s afterwards!

Very sad and ironic that the son he murdered unknowingly provided a significant part of the evidence to convict his father by innocently uploading a Snapchat video of a dog!

There may not be a lot of hard evidence , because the cops cocked it up, but the circumstantial evidence is overwhelming.

I think Alex is due to be incarcerated for quite a few years because of his financial crimes alone and I sincerely hope he will be given sufficient sentencing for the murders to ensure he will never leave jail ever again. He’s wicked beyond belief.

Busybody2022 · 26/02/2023 08:43

I think he 100% masterminded it. I'm not convinced he physically pulled the trigger. I have been watching the trial live, he will be in prison a very long time regardless.

user1471538283 · 26/02/2023 08:35

His wife was going to leave him and he hadn't been paying the bills despite embezzling large amounts of money. His son was there and maybe saw him kill his wife. The insurance would have been huge on his wife.

Then to set up his own murder to make the police think someone was out there.

I think he was broke and he chased money. And he's got dead eyes.

winningeasy · 26/02/2023 08:33

I think Alex wanted Paul dead because Mallory's family were about to start a 40m lawsuit for wrongful death against Paul. The wife also was seeking a divorce. To Alex they just became cost centres. Absolutely hideous man. Doubt we know the half of it.

Buster also needs to be called in for the murder of Stephen.

Reminds me of the Robert Durst case on the series The Jinx.

superplumb · 26/02/2023 08:28

The wife was going to leave him as she had been seeing a divorce lawyer so he could potentially lose what he had left. Killed his son as maybe he witnessed mother's death or got fed up of his son being a liability. None of them are normal functioning people. Their family photos give me the creeps

QuillBill · 26/02/2023 08:26

If anywhere it should be in news.

minou123 · 26/02/2023 08:17

follyfoot37 · 26/02/2023 07:00

Jesusxanother who cuts and pastes the plot of a tv programme in lieu of an actual discussion.
Whay is this in aibu rather than telly addicts?

Your post is confusing.
Are you aware this isn't a TV programme?

The Op isn't asking us if we enjoyed the Netflix documentary.

She is asking why a man, who is on trial in the US, killed his son and wife and if we think he is guilty.

follyfoot37 · 26/02/2023 07:00

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

Jesusxanother who cuts and pastes the plot of a tv programme in lieu of an actual discussion.
Whay is this in aibu rather than telly addicts?

Catmuffin · 25/02/2023 23:41

I liked how some of them were pronouncing the H in vehicle. Think it was Vee-hickle

Hawkins003 · 25/02/2023 13:55

Could be a hired specialist to take care of business so to speak but to then make it look like x perspectives

XelaM · 25/02/2023 12:20

There was also a rumour that Paul was one of the guys in Buster's car when Stephen died. In the Netflix documentary Paul's ex (Morgan) was talking about it.

OP posts:
XelaM · 25/02/2023 11:27

Tribollite · 25/02/2023 09:41

What is the theory behind Buster killing Stephen?

Stephen was gay in a very conservative community. There was some implication that maybe Buster was too. At least they were friends.

Stephen's car ran out of gas and he called Buster for help. Buster turned up with a bunch of his friends who it appears all ganged up on Stephen (whether for some particular reason or just "for fun" and killed him). Then they left him in the middle of the road

OP posts:
Saffronpotatoes67 · 25/02/2023 11:08

PortiasBiscuit · 25/02/2023 02:59

FFS, this is a real crime, with real people, not an episode of CSI for you all to slaver over.
How can you possibly know whether he’s guilty or not?

I think it’s fairly apparent if you watch the live testimony that he’s guilty.

I don’t think people on here are “slavering” actually: pps including myself have called Alex vile, arrogant, nasty, and hubristic. Many people are posting precisely because they cannot comprehend how a man could kill his wife and his child in this way.

I think it’s fairly natural that there is a general horrified interest in the case as more and more crimes and corruption came to light as the murders were investigated. And because it details the collapse of a previously powerful
family dynasty.

As mentioned below, I personally think the interest is legitimate because, hideous murders aside, it sheds light on human nature, greed and the inequalities of modern America. It’s also, very unfortunately, a perfect study in how the uncontrolled power and privilege of the white middle aged male leads to corruption: the victims in all of these cases being women, or young adults.

Heddaga · 25/02/2023 09:45

I watched this last night. I think maybe they all got into some sort of huge argument and Paul got the shotgun, they tussled and he killed Paul. Maggie then ran and he grabbed the assault rifle (the assault rifle is a more precision weapon and she was shot in the back as if she was running away) or the other way round. I think one of them was collateral. Most likely he killed his wife and his son got in the way.

Tribollite · 25/02/2023 09:41

What is the theory behind Buster killing Stephen?

XelaM · 25/02/2023 08:57

Ah, the theory that he intended to kill Maggie and Paul grabbed a gun to protect her could explain why they were killed with two different guns. @Starlitestarbright @SunshineAndFizz

I do agree with @BelindaBears and all the other posters about him being an absolutely despicable person (and his sons were just as despicable) but usually these type of people tend to protect their kids at all costs. It just seems hard to believe he could just shoot his son at close range - just like that

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 25/02/2023 08:31

I haven’t seen the Netflix documentary. From the trial footage I’ve seen/heard (including his own testimony on the stand the other day) I absolutely believe he did it and is a pathological liar. He was caught out in lies while on the stand and clearly didn’t give a shit.

The evidence all points to him having done it. I can’t understand either how anyone could do that to their son, but sometimes they do.

Starlitestarbright · 25/02/2023 08:28

I think he did it, his world was spiralling he couldn't cover up his sons crimes, they were looking into what happened with Gloria, he lost his job at his families law firm. His wife was looking to leave him and in a rage he killed his wife. I think Paul got a gun to protect himself couldn't do it so his dad grabbed it off him and killed him. This was a man who was power hungary who thought he was above the law and was well respected. He couldn't handle the world around him crashing down.

SunshineAndFizz · 25/02/2023 08:03

XelaM · 25/02/2023 07:49

The phone evidence that places Alex in near the kennels just before they died, is pretty damning. I just can't get my head around his "reasoning" for this. And Paul was killed at point blank range. How can he be protecting the "dynasty" when he is killing his own son? I get that Buster was the heir, but two sons makes a stronger dynasty and up until that point, Alex was always trying to protect Paul from facing any consequences for all his antics.

Paul and Maggie were killed with two different firearms. Were there two shooters? Maybe Paul really was collateral damage and only Maggie's murder was planned?

I think he killed Maggie as crime of passion - she was leaving him - Paul grabbed another gun to try and defend his mum/himself and ended up being killed.

XelaM · 25/02/2023 07:50

Paturday · 25/02/2023 07:22

Also annoyed me that he pronounces Alex Alec 😵‍💫 what a twat.

Hah I noticed this too. Paul's ex-girlfriend was always pronouncing his name as "Alec". I didn't know it was a Southern thing.

OP posts:
XelaM · 25/02/2023 07:49

The phone evidence that places Alex in near the kennels just before they died, is pretty damning. I just can't get my head around his "reasoning" for this. And Paul was killed at point blank range. How can he be protecting the "dynasty" when he is killing his own son? I get that Buster was the heir, but two sons makes a stronger dynasty and up until that point, Alex was always trying to protect Paul from facing any consequences for all his antics.

Paul and Maggie were killed with two different firearms. Were there two shooters? Maybe Paul really was collateral damage and only Maggie's murder was planned?

OP posts:
Enko · 25/02/2023 07:47

mummabubs · 25/02/2023 03:26

I've only finished episode one, so wish this thread title hadn't contained what I assume is a whopping soiler. 🤦🏻‍♀️

How can it be a spoiler that 1 person thinks he is innocent?