Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Murdaugh Murders - to believe Alex didn't shoot his wife and son?

162 replies

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

OP posts:
KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:42

It's the title, not the discussion.

savoycabbage · 26/02/2023 19:41

The way he just lies and lies and lies is so confronting. He just seems to think he can say and do whatever he wants.

He's lived his whole life in this strange sort of bubble, doing exactly west he wants. Putting blue lights in his veh-hickles, getting fake IDs for his son, stealing three million dollars from the family of the woman who had run his home for two decades.

On the stand he was as slippery as an eel. 'I know that for a fact'.

LittleBrenda · 26/02/2023 19:26

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:21

Yes I'm serious. I don't recall it from the news in 2021, haven't seen any recent and just started watching today.

That's your responsibility though! You can't expect people to not discuss current affairs because you haven't watched a documentary on it. Confused

QuillBill · 26/02/2023 19:23

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 18:28

Thanks for the spoiler. For fuck sake!

I don't think it's our fault that you haven't read or watched the news for twenty one months.

Or FOUR YEARS if you want to count from the boat crash.

Or seven years since the hit and run.

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:21

Yes I'm serious. I don't recall it from the news in 2021, haven't seen any recent and just started watching today.

XelaM · 26/02/2023 19:12

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 18:28

Thanks for the spoiler. For fuck sake!

Are you serious? It's in the news and happened in 2021

OP posts:
Baconking · 26/02/2023 18:45

XelaM · 24/02/2023 22:22

Yes, I saw that they placed him near the scene of death. I just don't get it. Why?! Why would he shoot his son at point blank range? He tried so hard to make all of his son's problems "disappear". How could he have just shot him in cold blood seemingly for no reason?! Unless he was in some drug-induced state of psychosis

Paul was a liability.

How many times could he save him? He was probably going to prison for 25+ years for killing Mallory and lots of lies and cover ups would have come out in the trial.

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 18:28

Thanks for the spoiler. For fuck sake!

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 26/02/2023 14:11

XelaM · 26/02/2023 13:05

I wonder how his family - Buster and Alex's brother in particular must really be feeling about this. Even by their standards, Alex must have gone too far!

That whole trying to get someone to shoot him was also totally insane on another level!

Yeah he admitted that. He paid someone to shoot him. That gain looks like
Motive, for death insurance and to keep his name clear
The act of a desperate man

Anyway all these facts will be out to a jury in US justice system - so if there's other explanations and facts , hopefully it'll all be heard and deliberated on carefully

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 26/02/2023 14:08

'Early on' not Esstleigh doh!

PhillySub · 26/02/2023 14:08

Minou 123 has got it

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 26/02/2023 14:07

Netflix documentaries aren't known for giving all the facts

But Alex lied about being at his parents visiting them at time of their deaths, was placed near them and his voice is recorded on his sons mobile just before their time of death and he has shotgun residue on his clothes in a pattern that indicates he was near when they were shot. Now whether that was from this incident or another of firing weapon he lied about his whereabouts at the time they were killed. You don't lie if you don't have anything to cover up.

So from info on Netflix doc, it appears right that he was arrested and charged with their murders. I don't know about Gloria and Stephen as to why he was charged for their murders.

There may have been others with motive to kill at least Paul. The fact it was Gloria and Paul and she was looking at divorcing him and he turns out to have been embezzling funds from his firm... and was embarrassed professionally by his sons actions in relation to death of Mallory which seems straight forward, all of that makes a strong case as to motive. And to blame others.

However it is going to court and I am sure they will disclose full facts at court and a jury will deliberate on those facts. Was suss that police said eastleigh on there was no danger to others in community- tells me they never believed Alex's version very early on.

We'll have to wait to see what US justice system makes of all the facts once they re put forward in prosecution case

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 26/02/2023 13:57

MySugarBabyLove · 26/02/2023 08:54

Fuck me. Why even bother having criminal trials now when all they have to do is to let netflix do a sensationalist documentary.

I haven’t watched any of this but personally I find it despicable that this has been allowed to be turned into entertainment before there has been an actual verdict.

By contrast there is currently a fairly high profile trial in the news ATM regarding a nurse charged with murdering multiple babies, and there is absolutely no way mn would allow a thread to stand where people acted as judge and jury to decide beyond their own reasonable doubt whether she is guilty or not before an actual verdict has been reached.

But we aren't the jury. We can discuss whatever we please.

winningeasy · 26/02/2023 13:44

@XelaM didn't really pull it off - he's deranged

I wonder if they dig in further to the family if they will find generations and generations of them bumping off people who posed a threat to them. Clearly this type of behaviour is being passed down.

People who think they are above the law

XelaM · 26/02/2023 13:42

But*

OP posts:
XelaM · 26/02/2023 13:41

sydneysunset · 26/02/2023 13:37

That whole trying to get someone to shoot him was also totally insane on another level!

Make sense to me. He knew he was backed into an inescapable corner ad he wanted the lookalike golden child - Buster - to inherit the life insurance & rebuild the family legacy.

It he didn't actually intend to die. He intended it to look like he and his family were being targeted by people (most likely) trying to avenge Mallory's death.

OP posts:
sydneysunset · 26/02/2023 13:37

That whole trying to get someone to shoot him was also totally insane on another level!

Make sense to me. He knew he was backed into an inescapable corner ad he wanted the lookalike golden child - Buster - to inherit the life insurance & rebuild the family legacy.

XelaM · 26/02/2023 13:05

I wonder how his family - Buster and Alex's brother in particular must really be feeling about this. Even by their standards, Alex must have gone too far!

That whole trying to get someone to shoot him was also totally insane on another level!

OP posts:
winningeasy · 26/02/2023 12:27

I think by this point Alex had fully lost the plot. I mean the fake suicide / paying someone to shoot him was a sign that he wasn't in a good mental state.

I mean if he didn't kill them, who did? There's never been any other suspects

Bare in mind there's also a tonne of people who prob want to protect him out of loyalty/fear, so the odds have not been in the favour of the prosecution of this case from the beginning

Crimsonripple · 26/02/2023 12:19

I think if it was pre-planned then it would have been covered up and thought out a little more throughly? I think this was more of a panic killing.

Crimsonripple · 26/02/2023 12:18

Didn't they say the type of weapon used the Murdagh's had but they weren't in their gun room? Then there was that weird drone footage of Buster and one of Alex's brothers removing guns from the room?

JMSA · 26/02/2023 12:17

Better that the ugly wee bastard died before his reckless behaviour caused someone else to be killed.

thesearetherichesofthepoor · 26/02/2023 11:50

Pretty sure Paul was killed first so that he couldn't defend Maggie

XelaM · 26/02/2023 11:46

I would question though the evidence. Have they done reenactments with both weapons to see if it was physically possible to swap weapons and kill? Assuming the distance would there have been blood splatters/residue? Although I suspect he's quickly got rid of any of that evidence when he went on that jaunt to his parents I've just recently been following it after watching the Netflix documentary.

I also don't understand the issue with the guns and why two different guns were used, and although the shell casings were left at the scene anf it appears the family owned the same type of guns, the weapons were never traced to Alex as far as I understand?

OP posts:
anyoneanyoneanyone · 26/02/2023 11:33

This is just truly horrific

Swipe left for the next trending thread