Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Murdaugh Murders - to believe Alex didn't shoot his wife and son?

162 replies

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

OP posts:
Catmuffin · 27/02/2023 11:09

Catmuffin · 27/02/2023 11:06

Might have been already mentioned, but his family member Randolph Murdaugh is suing him for 90K for unpaid debts and Alex has had him moved to the front of the queue of potential debtors. Seems like a ploy to keep money in the family. The guy who is suing him has given him money while he's in prison for prison purchases
www.fitsnews.com/2022/01/19/cant-afford-underwear-4-mayonnaise-alex-murdaughs-commissary-receipts-tell-different-story/

He gave him the prison pocket money after suing him for unpaid debts

Catmuffin · 27/02/2023 11:06

Might have been already mentioned, but his family member Randolph Murdaugh is suing him for 90K for unpaid debts and Alex has had him moved to the front of the queue of potential debtors. Seems like a ploy to keep money in the family. The guy who is suing him has given him money while he's in prison for prison purchases
www.fitsnews.com/2022/01/19/cant-afford-underwear-4-mayonnaise-alex-murdaughs-commissary-receipts-tell-different-story/

XelaM · 27/02/2023 10:20

BelindaBears · 27/02/2023 09:39

They don’t have to prove “beyond a shadow of a doubt”, they have to prove “beyond reasonable doubt”. They don’t have to prove there’s no way anything other than him killing them could have happened, that’s not what “beyond reasonable doubt means”.

Yes, I don't know how the Jury can get past the fact that he was by the kennels minutes before they were shot and then lied about it. He also neither heard them getting shot nor saw anyone else there. It makes no sense

OP posts:
XelaM · 27/02/2023 10:19

Catmuffin · 27/02/2023 09:19

Buster didn't sound very impressed with Alex's soup and meat stick prison achievements.

😂

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 27/02/2023 09:39

momtoboys · 27/02/2023 01:27

I am somewhat obsessed with this trial. I have no doubt he killed them and I think he killed the housekeeper too. He was in a full blown panic. All of his secrets were going to come out. With that being said, I am not certain the prosecution has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.

They don’t have to prove “beyond a shadow of a doubt”, they have to prove “beyond reasonable doubt”. They don’t have to prove there’s no way anything other than him killing them could have happened, that’s not what “beyond reasonable doubt means”.

Catmuffin · 27/02/2023 09:19

Buster didn't sound very impressed with Alex's soup and meat stick prison achievements.

Frankola · 27/02/2023 09:10

I've been following this and all the evidence points to him. This is one of those truly horrific and absurd cases that exposes what someone can gain from power and money.

XelaM · 27/02/2023 08:46

Does anyone know if Buster was more of a good person? and did the documentary on Netflix say that Buster & Steven Smith “were fooling around”, was Buster gay?

I think Busters' antics probably paled in comparison to his brother's so he was considered the more normal one. He also showed promise by going to Law School (although the documentary said he was kicked out eventually). There was an implication in the documentary that he may have been something other than friendship between Stephen and Buster but it's not been confirmed. But Stephen called Buster the night he was killed because his car had run out of petrol. If Buster was involved in Stephen's death then clearly he is just like his father and brother.

OP posts:
Littlebummybums · 27/02/2023 03:19

Do you not think he shot his wife and the son witnessed it by mistake and so it left him no option. ? He had a heavy opiod addiction too. His son had a video in his phone if an altercation between Alex and his wife prior to the shooting.

momtoboys · 27/02/2023 01:27

XelaM · 24/02/2023 20:58

The trial is currently ongoing in the US and has been the subject of a Netflix documentary The Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal.

It's almost unbelievable this case is real and not some movie script for a tragic thriller. It involves the very powerful Murdaugh family- a dynasty of many generations of prosecutors/lawyers who had almost unlimited power and money. They appeared to be above the law. The father was Alex (the heir to the dynasty) and he was married to Maggie with whom he had two sons- Buster and Paul. The younger son Paul appeared to be as appalling a human being as his father (at least according to the documentary).

Five people are dead who were connected to this family:

*Mallory Beach - a young teenage girl who was on a boat that the younger Murdaugh son (Paul) crashed at night being drunk out of his mind. His father Alex tried to initially claim that someone else was driving the boat but then did absolutely everything to make this case "go away" even after Paul had been charged. Paul never faced any consequences for Mallory's death. Her family were pursuing a civil suit.

*Stephen - the elder son's (Buster's) friend who was found dead in the middle of a road in very odd and suspicious circumstances. No one ever faced any consequences for his death.

*Gloria - the Murdaugh housekeeper who allegedly fell down the stairs at their property. Alex collected a $4.3 million insurance payout for her death (on a policy he had taken out a month earlier) and never paid it to her family.

*And now the younger son Paul and his mother (Alex's wife) Maggie were found shot dead on their property with two different firearms.

Alex has been charged with the murders of his son and wife (in addition to having been found to have embezzled huge funds from his law firm and his clients).

But I just don't understand how someone who was so concerned with protecting the family dynasty and whitewashing his son of any responsibility for Mallory's death- why would he shoot the same son two years later? The motive that the prosecution put forward was that he tried to gain sympathy when he was being prosecuted for embezzlement and trying to delay Mallory's family's civil suit. I just don't understand that this is a strong enough motivation for shooting his son?

I am somewhat obsessed with this trial. I have no doubt he killed them and I think he killed the housekeeper too. He was in a full blown panic. All of his secrets were going to come out. With that being said, I am not certain the prosecution has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt.

GothicViolence · 27/02/2023 01:15

I think that regardless of what happened Alex Murdough isn’t going to get a fair trial now this (one sided) account of events has been all over Netflix.

BonnyLassie99 · 27/02/2023 01:13

Maggie Murdagh (or “Maggie Murder” as the locals called her) was rumoured to have been leaving & divorcing Alex and he knew she would be entitled to half his money etc, this is why imo she was shot, maybe Paul witnessed it or was a total liability in Alex’s eyes, after the boat crash etc.

BonnyLassie99 · 27/02/2023 01:11

sydneysunset · 24/02/2023 21:32

@Fridaysgirl17
i agree, I watched some of his evidence earlier and was surprised to find him credible. Perhaps it’s all an act

Sociopaths/Psychopaths/Narcissists are known for sounding credible, it’s how they manipulate everyone around them.

IMO Alex is clearly guilty, everything about him points to him having some sort of antisocial personality disorder, and his own father was close with Paul & he made sure that Paul never faced consequences too, the narcissism probably stemmed from him & it’s just a cycle that has been repeated throughout the generations. Throw in money & power then these types of families are very dangerous, as we see here.

Does anyone know if Buster was more of a good person? and did the documentary on Netflix say that Buster & Steven Smith “were fooling around”, was Buster gay?

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 20:59

@Withnailandeye well, no... because I haven't watched it. I'm only aware of the poor girl that was missing in the boat and that OP doesn't believe that Alex shot his wife and son. But you are aware and are on a thread discussing it for your entertainment.

userxx · 26/02/2023 20:44

@Withnailandeye Well said.

Withnailandeye · 26/02/2023 20:30

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:54

The screenshot you've used doesn't give any information. Simply a title that you'd click if you wanted to know more. I was the news daily and this hasn't been on at all. The title of this thread is a spoiler.

Sorry I wasn't up on the news of American teenagers in a small town in 2021.

Anyway, I'm sure you'll all get over my comment.

Are you aware these are actual murders, not just a bit of telly for your entertainment?

Jedsnewstar · 26/02/2023 19:58

You are assuming he protected his son for his sons benefit. If he cared for his son he would have actually wanted to help him not let him get away with whatever he wanted. Also he had massive anger issues, that stemmed from somewhere. Realistically Alex was protecting his own family legacy.

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:54

Watch*

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:54

The screenshot you've used doesn't give any information. Simply a title that you'd click if you wanted to know more. I was the news daily and this hasn't been on at all. The title of this thread is a spoiler.

Sorry I wasn't up on the news of American teenagers in a small town in 2021.

Anyway, I'm sure you'll all get over my comment.

savoycabbage · 26/02/2023 19:50

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:47

@savoycabbage yes but the title isn't a spoiler is it

I don't know what you mean really.

I don't think you can have spoilers in news stories and using the word spoiler about murders is awful.

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:47

@savoycabbage yes but the title isn't a spoiler is it

userxx · 26/02/2023 19:46

The man is a sociopath.

QuillBill · 26/02/2023 19:45

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:42

It's the title, not the discussion.

It's news. People are allowed to have an opinion on a current news story. Well, one that happened over a year ago.

It's not a 'spoiler' because it's not a soap. Keep yourself more up to date so you can have opinions on things that happened in 2021 too.

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:43

Oh wait... serious that you've spoilt it for me. Not seriously mad! 🤣

savoycabbage · 26/02/2023 19:42

KendrickLamaze · 26/02/2023 19:21

Yes I'm serious. I don't recall it from the news in 2021, haven't seen any recent and just started watching today.

It's absolutely being covered 'recently' it's on the main page of the BBC right now.

The Murdaugh Murders - to believe Alex didn't shoot his wife and son?