Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH constant comments & moaning about stuff

191 replies

CostoflivingDH · 24/02/2023 20:52

Like most others our family have had to rethink budgeting. We can no longer afford to buy all branded stuff and I’ve made quite a few changes to our grocery shop.

DH is constantly ‘commenting’ and really annoying me.

’oh can’t we afford Charmin anymore this toilet roll is not very good, you need to use twice the amount’

’This bacon is so thin it all breaks up and you can’t cook it properly’

’I don’t like this brown sauce, why can’t we have HP?’

’Are you sure this detergent cleans as well as Ariel?’

’I need Heinz beans, these taste like shit’

’Are these the cheap, basic range eggs? We should get free range where the chickens can roam’

’The chocolate on these biscuits tastes cheap, where’s the chocolate hobnobs?’

and on and on. I’ve explained as he well knows that everything costs more, he obviously knows this but just responds with ‘it’s a false economy though as most of this is either shit or you have to use twice the amount’. I’ve suggested he does the shopping but he refuses.

I’m a savvy shopper and am good at finding offers and bargains.

Does this cause friction in your household? He’s otherwise a reasonable human being and not bad husband.

OP posts:
TangledUpInDreams · 01/03/2023 12:53

@CostoflivingDH I agree with others in a way - where it really matters, such as good quality meat, I would rather eat the better stuff less often or have smaller portions. So we buy good bacon but are sparing with it (we don't have much anyway for health reasons). He may have different priorities, as might you.

We economise wherever it doesn't make any/much difference to us. Aldi baked beans are much cheaper and actually nicer, we both agree on that, so we save there without making a big deal of it. And lots of other examples. But we won't buy cheap pasta because it tastes too nasty. etc etc. We rarely buy based purely on brand anymore, barring a few favourites, and always, always choose nicest we can but cheaper/best value for money on staples.

If your situation is such that you really do need to economise on everything across the board with no leeway then that's a shitty place to be in and I'm sorry. I know how hard that is. And in that case he needs to get a grip, or do something to change your financial situation.

What he doesn't get to do is whinge/whine/complain and want it every which way - everything to stay exactly the same but not cost any more money. If he thinks he can do so much better, let him. For at least a month.

diddl · 01/03/2023 12:48

If you have a budget & he wants certain brands then surely he has to decide what he will do without to stay within budget?

Chocolate/cake/biscuits/alcohol/cigarettes?

When you've never really bought brands then you have to decide what to do without!

thymee · 01/03/2023 12:43

roarfeckingroarr · 01/03/2023 12:30

I'm actually with him. I would prefer to eat less bit better quality. Caged chicken eggs are nasty, as is cheap bacon. it's true about buy cheap, buy twice.

OK but in his shoes would you whinge at OP or would you say "show me the shopping list and budget, I'll have a look at what cuts are OK with me and what I can't compromise on"?

You know, like an adult human?

It's not so much about him not liking cheaper/ supermarket brands, but about his behaviour.

The situation is what it is. They don't have enough money and so have to make some cuts.

If he cares what those cuts are then he needs to be pragmatic and get involved rather than throwing his toys out of the pram.

TangledUpInDreams · 01/03/2023 12:42

I voted YANBU. But buying the cheapest loo roll is a false economy IME.

I don't by any means buy the most expensive, I just shopped around until I found a cheaper one that was of good enough quality to be good value for money.

thymee · 01/03/2023 12:40

If he cares this much then why isn't he getting more involved in shopping and making these decisions with you, rather than complaining like a whiney toddler?

This would be enough to make me question the relationship to be honest. He sounds extremely immature.

Iyjd · 01/03/2023 12:39

Send him a few links for a part time job to do on top of his usual work so that he can cover the difference. He will be out more too so you won’t need to hear the moaning.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 01/03/2023 12:38

HollyGolightly4 · 24/02/2023 20:59

He sounds like a child. Tell him if he doesn't like it, to source his own!

I'd go further than @HollyGolightly4, @CostoflivingDH. I'd tell your dh that it is his responsibility to plan the week's meals and to do the shopping for everything that is needed within the family's budget. I think that is the only way he will realise that he can't have everything he wants right now!

magicstar1 · 01/03/2023 12:35

I'd tell him he either needs to make more money, or come up with ways of saving. Seeing as he won't do the shopping, these are his only options.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/03/2023 12:30

I'm actually with him. I would prefer to eat less bit better quality. Caged chicken eggs are nasty, as is cheap bacon. it's true about buy cheap, buy twice.

Allergictoironing · 01/03/2023 12:29

Dreamstate · 01/03/2023 11:53

I'd rather cut back elsewhere then on the quality of food I buy. I don't want to put shit into my body.

But for many things, the quality is exactly the same. Same product, made in the same factory, with the same ingredients/materials, just packaged and marketed differently. And sometimes a cheaper product can actually be better quality, as they aren't spending a fortune on advertising and expensive packaging.

FriendofDorothy · 01/03/2023 12:29

I would buy the cheaper stuff and hide the tins and packaging.
I bet most things they wouldn't notice the difference.

Led9519 · 01/03/2023 12:25

He’s right about the eggs. No need to buy them from caged hens to save £1.

Scottishskifun · 01/03/2023 12:21

Well the marketing companies will be happy to know their campaigns have been so successful!

I do agree with him on toilet paper we still buy branded but when it's on offer - same with kitchen towel.
Most other stuff he is being ridiculous about. Get the cash out for the weekly shop put it in his lap and say off you go here's the list don't give him the choice!

bonzaitree · 01/03/2023 12:17

My OH occasionally does this. Comes to me with a perceived problem. Usually one that I don’t give a shit about.

I say « ok tell me how we can solve it then. Come to me with a solution, not a problem. »

if he says he doesn’t know I say « I’m sure you can work something out so happy to discuss when you’ve thought of a solution. »

Repeat.

Hate hate hate people coming to me with a problem. Solve it then tell me.

For example « I’ve noticed the food prices have gone up so I’ve spoken to my boss and got some overtime on Thursday evenings. I’ll earn £x extra after tax. Can we put this extra towards the food shop? I really liked the way we used to eat/ shop. »

Job done. Stop whinging- Fanny clamp shut!!

MrsLighthouse · 01/03/2023 12:05

I get what everyone’s saying but if he really wants the stuff he likes , then sit down and see if he can come up with savings in other areas. I might be in a minority but l would forgo other stuff to only have Heinz beans and Chocolate Hobnobs ! Depends how skint you really are ?

BigSkies2022 · 01/03/2023 11:59

I would find the moaning very irritating, unattractive and unsexy. And I would tell him this. Positive contributions to budgeting dilemmas, please, and if you can't contribute something useful (which an adult should be capable of doing, btw), then button up, buttercup.

That said, food is one of those areas of daily comfort where changes are keenly felt. We've cut down a lot on meat, fish, dairy and eggs, and when we do eat these things, we stretch them with lots of veg and pulses. We have the hummus we like, rather than switching to a cheaper version (which tastes mostly of vinegar), but no more than one pot every other month. I will still buy a pot of jam and cream, and they will stretch over a month to have with home-made scones (1 egg, 50g of butter per batch of 8, so cheaper on ingredients than other cakes, and only 10 minutes in the oven) at the weekend. Walls ice-cream with a dollop of creme fraiche or a drop of coffee is a good pudding. We don't buy salted cashews or peanuts or crisps anymore, I roast nuts for a snack, and use them also as protein component in stir fries and roasts. Aldi and Lidl biscuits (Lidl shortbread rounds are insanely good) are fine, IMO, as are their chocolate bars.

We're empty nesters now, though, and it's harder in bigger households to get everyone happy. Your OH should be part of the solution though, not the problem!

Stuff where compromises don't work for us: bread; coffee; tinned tomatoes; decent spaghetti. So I do spend more than, say, my mother would ever dream of doing, on these items. But we don't buy coffee or sandwiches out, so it probably evens out.

I've bought cheap loo roll for years though. You literally wipe your bum with it, and flush it away. How expensive does it need to be to fulfil that function?

YouJustDoYou · 01/03/2023 11:54

Years before current cost of living situation my then fiance (now dh) was like that. I'd grown up with very little money so branded stuff was always insanely expensive to me. He however was adamant that branded was best, would moan if he saw I'd bought sainsbos own brand etc (we didn't have any Aldi's/Lidls near us at that time). I was fed up of it when it cleaned just as good, so one day bought the stupid expensive branded stuff, made sure he saw it being used. When it came time to get more I just kept the old box and filled it with the own-brand stuff. Used own brand for over half a year before he made some sort of comment in the supermarket about "branded is best". I then told him he'd been using own brand for the past half a year, I'd just been refilling a branded box. He never complained again.

TerribleInsomniac · 01/03/2023 11:53

YANBU
Give your dh the shopping budget…in cash so he can’t overspend,….. and send him out to do the shopping.

That should do it.
Actions speak louder than words

Dreamstate · 01/03/2023 11:53

I'd rather cut back elsewhere then on the quality of food I buy. I don't want to put shit into my body.

justasking111 · 01/03/2023 11:51

I'm so glad we share the shopping. DH is even more careful than me and can come a cropper. Some of the cheap instant coffee he has bought himself has gone in the bin because he says it's undrinkable

haveyoutriedturningitoffandthenonagain · 01/03/2023 11:34

Tell him to make more money then

IHateFlies · 01/03/2023 11:31

Maybe he'd like to work more hours or take a second job so he can have those things again?

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 01/03/2023 11:26

he was outraged that he only got half a tin of beans with his egg and chips the other day!

Christ, how much does he eat?

Give him the weekly budget and send him off to the shop to do it himself.

Puffalicious · 01/03/2023 11:24

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 01/03/2023 11:17

I have and it was OK-ish but not enough to convince me to change. DH isn't fussy what brown sauce he has so I might send him to Aldi for his!

I'm definitely trying it, HP was £4.50 the other week!

Puffalicious · 01/03/2023 11:21

Allergictoironing · 01/03/2023 10:20

I'm on a budget, though not an exceptionally tight one. I spent ages trying different brands/own brands and in the majority of cases I've ended up with supermarket own brand either by preference or because they taste the same for less cost. Some examples are:

I used to bake a fair bit. Shopping for ingredients one day when money was tight I realised that own brand flour was less than half the price of branded. It's just milled wheat, I can't really see how there could be any difference.
Sugar is sugar is sugar. It's just about all beet sugar these days unless exceptionally expensive & marked as such. don't think I even see Tate & Lyle rather than silver spoon these days.
ASDA own brand butter for block (cooking) butter. Again, no difference & tastes fine for much less money.
Own brand oat flakes rather than Ready Brek - identical.
Milk, unless you're drinking it cold, no difference between own brand & brands. I gather that Cravendale filtered can taste very slightly different, but I didn't notice.
Off the shelf basic medications are identical to branded ones e.g. Panadol contains 500mg paracetamol, so does supermarket own brand.

On the other hand, some things really do taste different e.g. some teas (though I would love to find a cheap one identical to Yorkshire), coffee I can mostly understand. Most of ASDA bakery goods I prefer to branded. Chocolate still trying to find an own brand I really like. ASDA own brand cheddar won taste tests over branded ones, as do many other similar items.

Looking back at these examples, I notice that the basic and staple foods seem to all be much of a muchness. It's only the more "luxury" end of the market where I can really tell any difference and often even then the cheaper product is as good.

Try Aldi Chunky Chocolate (blue wrapper). It's very nice. DH loves his chocolate and approves. They do a Whole Nut in a brown wrapper and Fruit and Nut in purple - also get the thumbs up.

Their Specially Selected Chocolate Chunk Cookies are the 'Best on the market' according to him too (better than Fox's and M&S apparently).

He's still a Lavazza guy for night-time coffee, but rates Tesco everyday beans (strength 3) as fabulous for daytime. Says they're better than Taylor's. He does buy other beans locally, but they're more of a treat.