Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I think I've just been accused of racism at work

410 replies

Imlookingatapicture · 24/02/2023 17:58

Panicking somewhat..

For context I'm the only Welsh person in our London office. Lots of banter around the football World Cup.

Chat started on teams (chat not video) re the 6 nations game tomorrow. Collegue (huge football fan, most vocal in the world cup) said 'I don't care about rugby. I'm half Welsh anyway'

I replied

'Oh I'm half English too. We all have our crosses to bear ;)'

Manager has just emailed me to say collegue above has complained, and it's not acceptable, especially given recent discussions around inclusion and diversity.

It was honestly just a joke, in the same vein as the world cup 'banter'

I know I shouldn't have put it on teams. Maybe context didn't come across.

How much shit am I in?

OP posts:
VladmirsPoutine · 25/02/2023 12:29

@belleager That's very interesting! I had no idea the origins of some of those phrases which I use in casual conversations day to day! I genuinely thought another one bites the dust was from that Rocky film where he's a boxer! Grin

Peachy2005 · 25/02/2023 12:10

Unless I’m mistaken (as I read the bulk of the thread late last night), why did the same guy start a post asking what people think about the rugby and then go on to say he doesn’t care about the rugby?

“We all have our crosses to bear” is a very common phrase signifying shared misfortune but in this instance it’s totally unclear whether the shared misfortune is being half-English, half-Welsh or the fact that both the teams are doing badly in the 6 Nations.

In the circumstances, I think it’s really suspect that the guy has complained - he may have started the thread looking for trouble, knowing from World Cup time the type of banter that would likely ensue. The only thing for that HR to do now is ban all non-work-related topics from the work intranet!

hangonsnoopy · 25/02/2023 12:00

One of the problems on this thread is that posters seem to think that employers follow the equality act to tackle real racism. They don't. It is just used to protect employers from being taken to tribunal.

Harassment is one of the four categories of breaches under the equality act and includes banter about protected characteristics as one of the cited examples in the guidelines.

It is not the same thing as the criminal offence of harassment.

The vast majority of people don't care about banter and never report breaches to their employer. Some people, due to sensitivity, a grudge against a colleague, a chance to step over someone for promotion, a desire to bring down a colleague a boss dislikes, or a genuine case of poor treatment, will use the equality act to make a complaint.

Once that happens, as the person being investigated, you try and get out of it as quickly as possible. I wouldn't apologise as that implies guilt which could be used as an admission of intent. Most likely the employer won't take disciplinary action but will request the employee doesn't repeat the action and reads the relevant policy document.

Posters knowing what the equality act says does not imply that those posters are in agreement with the law.

There are hills I am prepared to die on regarding authoritarianism. The right to mock the English or Welsh at work isn't one of them. OP should keep her head down and keep to the line that this was all about sports teams not about national groups.

Emotionalsupportviper · 25/02/2023 10:31

YouOKHun · 24/02/2023 22:49

dylai eich ymddiheuriad ysgrifenedig gael ei ysgrifennu hanner yn Gymraeg a hanner yn Saesneg. Yna ni fydd unrhyw flodyn bach gwerthfawr yn teimlo wedi'i eithrio.

syniad da

(The joy of Google translate 😄)

EarthlyNightshade · 25/02/2023 09:44

wombat1a · 25/02/2023 05:46

Sorry OP but you are going to get a lecture over this one. Think of it like this, if you had said you are half black African but we all have our crosses to bear then you can see immedietaly you would be bang out of order.

Racism is racism regardless of the person you are being racist too. I agree that far too many people are far too sensitive about small things but on this one you are rightly in hot water.

Would you have reported this exchange if you had been the man in question?

AgentJohnson · 25/02/2023 09:38

Don’t waste more energy on this man baby. Apologise, if possible I would do it in a teams call with the same people. Make sure the verbal and written apology are exactly the same. Was the team call recorded? This guy’s twattery will come back to haunt him because I would make it clear why in future why I wouldn’t be engaging in any form of non work related communication with him.

TheOrigRights · 25/02/2023 09:37

The next natural step would be to ban all competitive sports, or to ban any sort of spectators, lest someone be offended by...I don't know...anything?

Could Norwich fans deduce that I am being 'racist' because I have been known to join in with the 30,000 other people at Portman Road singing, how shall I put it...denigrating chants?

HarrietPierce · 25/02/2023 09:23

I'm half English and half Scottish married to an Egyptian with Canadian nationality. My kids are obviously mixed race and my eldest daughter has just married an Australian. I would have felt like telling that man child to "Get tae fuck".

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 09:10

wombat1a · 25/02/2023 05:46

Sorry OP but you are going to get a lecture over this one. Think of it like this, if you had said you are half black African but we all have our crosses to bear then you can see immedietaly you would be bang out of order.

Racism is racism regardless of the person you are being racist too. I agree that far too many people are far too sensitive about small things but on this one you are rightly in hot water.

Oh FFS - do you seriously lack the skills to distinguish between those two scenarios? I fucking give up!! I pray to God you don’t hold any position of responsibility.

5 years ago I would have assumed you were taking the piss! Unfortunately I actually think you’re serious (although most people would thankfully still laugh at your comments)

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 09:04

ZombieMumEB · 25/02/2023 08:44

I am from Australia - so don't understand the Welsh/English issues.
My workplace has a lot of banter about the AFL (Australian Football League) - and a lot of sledging amongst each other - it's all part of the sport. What's said isn't really offensive, but reading this thread, if it were to happen in the UK, there would be a lot of complaints from precious snow flakes.

I would prepare myself for various scenarios as to what the complaint is about.

Is it possible to turn it back on him, and make a complaint?

'I don't care about rugby. I'm half Welsh anyway' - is he actually half Welsh? Or could you say you found that offensive - you felt he was mocking you?

I would ask them to explain exactly how it's offensive, and would ask for time to reflect on what's said, before you respond, and also ask for a summary to be emailed to you.

If they push for you to apologise - then push back and insist you also receive an apology from him.

I would also suggest that they ban talking on the chat about non-related work topics, so that this sort of incident can be avoided in future. ;) Make them regret making this an issue.

Good luck with dealing with this ridiculous complaint.

Great response

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 09:03

CheersForThatEh · 25/02/2023 08:17

I'd go in on Monday and say you're really sorry for causing offence and on reflection can see how you could cause offence and want to apologise here and directly to the individual if they would be open to that and I'd ask if the company has any diversity and inclusion training you can undertake to refresh yourself.

My advice would be to take responsibility, apologise, try to make amends and try to do better.

WTAF???? Do you actually think she’s done anything wrong?

ZombieMumEB · 25/02/2023 08:44

I am from Australia - so don't understand the Welsh/English issues.
My workplace has a lot of banter about the AFL (Australian Football League) - and a lot of sledging amongst each other - it's all part of the sport. What's said isn't really offensive, but reading this thread, if it were to happen in the UK, there would be a lot of complaints from precious snow flakes.

I would prepare myself for various scenarios as to what the complaint is about.

Is it possible to turn it back on him, and make a complaint?

'I don't care about rugby. I'm half Welsh anyway' - is he actually half Welsh? Or could you say you found that offensive - you felt he was mocking you?

I would ask them to explain exactly how it's offensive, and would ask for time to reflect on what's said, before you respond, and also ask for a summary to be emailed to you.

If they push for you to apologise - then push back and insist you also receive an apology from him.

I would also suggest that they ban talking on the chat about non-related work topics, so that this sort of incident can be avoided in future. ;) Make them regret making this an issue.

Good luck with dealing with this ridiculous complaint.

user68901 · 25/02/2023 08:41

Wow this thread just leaves me so disheartened. Some of my best friends were made through work ( including finding my husband ). We used to form tight bonds through so many shared experiences- good and bad and we still regale over some of the more hilarious post work drinks etc . Is this all over now ?

thismamayogi · 25/02/2023 08:41

MissTrip82 · 25/02/2023 08:23

This is the opposite of ‘woke’ you muppet.

This is bog-standard screeching about ‘reverse racism’ by exactly the kind of people who use the term ‘woke’: complete arseholes who hilariously think everyone else is a ‘snowflake’.

Destroying families 😂😂😂😂😂. Get a grip.

I beg to differ.

This is merely emblematic of the “take offence” culture that ironically categorises some people as worthy of abuse and others as worthy of “protection”.

as in for example - the media tries hard to “protect” trans women who are men who go on to rape women in women’s prisons, and feminists scream about women’s rights - but if I choose to be a stay at home mum and cook for my husband every night i am allowed to be ridiculed and told I am letting the side down and that I “don’t work”.

you have been taken in. OP points out the tip of the iceberg.

my step grandkids are some of my most precious people, they are mixed race, the second anyone is racist towards them I would know and bloody hell I would deal with it straight away. You have lost perspective.

woke is the pretence that we cannot have opinions and must reduce everything to bland fence sitting in order that any opinion at all does not offend. It’s nothing at all to do with racism, sexism or anything else.

NoSquirrels · 25/02/2023 08:34

Imlookingatapicture · 24/02/2023 18:34

Yes, sorry if that wasn't clear. Other person is English and quite patriotic.

I think the complaint is coming from an anti English angle.

Friday afternoons we all work from home. Started with a 'what do we think about tomorrow's game' (from him)

I posted a 'as long as we beat the English meme'

That was when he said doesn't care about rugby and half welsh.

Then my comment which I need to discuss on Monday

Sounds like he deliberately baited you.

Rise above.

MissTrip82 · 25/02/2023 08:23

thismamayogi · 24/02/2023 18:25

Bl*dy f**ing hell. Woke has totally destroyed humour, life, society, families, everything.

you have done NOTHING wrong, but they’ll probably remove this post, just like they censored Dahl and are paying people thousands to waft hot air about diversity in the workplace that is meaningless shite.

honestly. I can’t cope. It’s nonsense.

racist is deliberately demeaning someone considered to be racially different to oneself. Telling a Welsh joke is gentle banter. Blinking heck.

This is the opposite of ‘woke’ you muppet.

This is bog-standard screeching about ‘reverse racism’ by exactly the kind of people who use the term ‘woke’: complete arseholes who hilariously think everyone else is a ‘snowflake’.

Destroying families 😂😂😂😂😂. Get a grip.

CheersForThatEh · 25/02/2023 08:17

I'd go in on Monday and say you're really sorry for causing offence and on reflection can see how you could cause offence and want to apologise here and directly to the individual if they would be open to that and I'd ask if the company has any diversity and inclusion training you can undertake to refresh yourself.

My advice would be to take responsibility, apologise, try to make amends and try to do better.

comedycentral · 25/02/2023 08:12

SammyScrounge · 24/02/2023 22:53

Apologise? What on earth for?

I was responding to the original post. I meant helpful to her to apologise as it might make her feel less worried as she asked 'How much shit am I in?' so I felt she sounded worried. Personally, I don't think she did anything wrong.

comedycentral · 25/02/2023 08:09

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 05:27

What do you suggest? Carting the OP off the room 101 and attaching a cage of rats to them???

I was responding to the OP's original question 'how much shit am I in?' I was trying to guess the company response. It's not my own response, I don't think she did anything wrong.

lljkk · 25/02/2023 06:21

Once this has past, remember that whoever complained is an utter twat and needs to be 100% avoided except when actually necessary.

^ That. I'd have serious trust (lack of rapport) issues with whole office going forward, tbh.

wombat1a · 25/02/2023 05:46

Sorry OP but you are going to get a lecture over this one. Think of it like this, if you had said you are half black African but we all have our crosses to bear then you can see immedietaly you would be bang out of order.

Racism is racism regardless of the person you are being racist too. I agree that far too many people are far too sensitive about small things but on this one you are rightly in hot water.

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 05:35

marchella · 25/02/2023 05:12

Sorry, I'm yet to be convinced about Donald Trump or Tom Cruise ( tangerine is an issue)

What’s wrong with David Dickinson?

OMG12 · 25/02/2023 05:27

comedycentral · 24/02/2023 18:03

I'd say that some retraining or inclusion and diversity awareness might be suggested. It might be helpful to ask if you can issue an apology.

What do you suggest? Carting the OP off the room 101 and attaching a cage of rats to them???

belleager · 25/02/2023 05:23

Why would an atheist be offended by "cross to bear"? It's a figure of speech, not a statement of religious belief.

Do people get upset by lamb to the slaughter, fly in the ointment, fall from grace, apple of my eye, (wo)man after my own heart, another one bites the dust? Because they might want to check out the King James Bible ...

marchella · 25/02/2023 05:12

VladmirsPoutine · 25/02/2023 00:09

Black or white, green, blue or tangerine orange we're all one human race!

Sorry, I'm yet to be convinced about Donald Trump or Tom Cruise ( tangerine is an issue)