Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I've fucked up?

116 replies

meanderyes · 24/02/2023 16:37

I'm a student social worker. Today I was working with a service user who had no food or money to get food. Tried different resources but none available being a Friday afternoon. No opportunity of loan or advance etc.

I took them to the shop and spent about a tenner getting them the basics, milk, bread, butter, eggs etc.

However, now I'm thinking that was really unprofessional of me. It's not something I can do for everyone. I have informed my manager but she's now finished for the weekend.

Really worried I will get into trouble for this or struck off my placement? Will I? Or am I worrying over nothing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThomasinVye · 25/02/2023 10:22

Sorry OP I would also question whether you had someone you could have called to ask what to do or for any other suggestions once you had exhausted your options?
Maybe not just learning for you but for the PE

ThomasinVye · 25/02/2023 10:17

Relieved your manager has reassured you. Social Worker here and we have all done it. As suggested above use it as an opportunity to reflect and learn. There is in my experience usually a way of getting food/vouchers/resources you being a student just are not aware of all the resources and support available (to be expected!). I worked in an adults duty team for years, in these situations If you genuinely have exhausted all options, give duty a call, duty manager may have food parcels in a cupboard or authorise you supporting if you have the funds and reclaiming back with the receipt as an exceptional circumstance. With my student I would encourage them to use this as a learning objective to find out what resources are available that you can share with the team at a team meeting? Not just external, but internal, I know I could contact our financial inclusion team in this circumstance and they would have texted the person a voucher for food even on a Friday (before 5pm). Maybe you will identify an area for improvement you could feedback to the principal social worker?

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 10:13

Yes I also think the manager would she said this, however the OP didn’t say or even hint Thea she’d said she shouldn’t do it for any other reason than she couldn’t afford to

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 25/02/2023 10:11

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 10:01

OP you said your manager said not to do it again as I can't afford it

so the only reason she said for not doing it again was because you couldn’t afford it?

Of course that's not the only reason her TM said that , she would have said more and will take it up in supervision or ask the work based supervisor to.

It's a reminder however that it's not for a student to subsidise her clients.

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 10:01

OP you said your manager said not to do it again as I can't afford it

so the only reason she said for not doing it again was because you couldn’t afford it?

Jazz12 · 25/02/2023 09:17

Next time you could perhaps speak to someone at your local food bank? They might be able to help as an exception without referral etc

Shayisgreat · 25/02/2023 08:55

I'd have done the same. Glad your supervisor has that attitude.

The next steps will be to ensure that the family isn't in that position every week and that there is a plan in place if it happens again!

poppetposieandfun · 24/02/2023 23:31

Please don't worry @meanderyes we all do this sometimes and for good reason. Yes, of course we can't do it for everyone and of course boundaries is part of the job, but that doesn't mean there isn't situations where we do need to be one of the 'helpers' in the world.

I think you will be a great social worker.

GoodChat · 24/02/2023 22:02

meanderyes · 24/02/2023 20:55

It's crazy, I was on the way home from work and my daughter is at her dads this weekend, he called and said she's unwell with a temperature and could I please pick up calpol. Had a fiver cash on me and left bank card at home so went to Sainsbury's and grabbed calpol. Tried 100 times to put the bloody fiver in the self service check out, wouldn't go in. Member of staff said they couldn't get me change as only one on the tills. The man beside me then said to put it through with him, I offered him my fiver a few times but he wouldn't take it, just said, 'it's never a good night when you're buying calpol'. I thanked him and told him that was so kind and I appreciated it and he said he hoped my little girl felt better soon. I feel like it's a wee bit of pay back for my good deed - not that I expect it.

Oh that's lovely. What goes around!

Lysianthus · 24/02/2023 22:02

Gwen82 · 24/02/2023 16:40

It was not professional and you should not have done.

Your manager will explain this to you and should explain why.

But you should not the correct thing to have done from your training surely?

I'm so glad the tone and content of your response turned out to be in the minority. What an unpleasant reply. OP has fortunately had much better advice and thank goodness they are training as we need far more people like this in the world.

TellySavalashairbrush · 24/02/2023 22:01

Oh bless you. Social worker here and have done the same thing several times . You definitely won’t lose your job/placement over this. You are human- I worry more about the social workers that wouldn’t entertain the idea under even the most dire situations for the service user. Our job is about helping others .

KarmaStar · 24/02/2023 22:01

It was very kind of you and I would do the same,have done the same(not as a s.w.).
Did professional boundaries training last week,this was highlighted as a big no no,I'm glad your manager was so understanding.
But please,protect yourself,service users do talk to each other and word might get round so try not to take cash or cards to work when seeing service users,to protect yourself and to reinforce that it won't be happening again.Good luck in your new career op.🌈

AnneElliott · 24/02/2023 21:47

I think it's a completely human thing to do. I know so many cops that have done the same when they've found someone without food/ electric and everyone at the council has left early on the Friday.

Glad your manager was supportive. Nothing wrong with a compassionate public servant.

RobertJohnsonsShoes · 24/02/2023 21:31

Senior practitioner here. See that it's all resolved. We've all done it but remember you're a student and you should be able to call on someone if you're not sure about something. Use supervision to go back over the chain of command because you do need to be supported, especially in situations where you're not sure. Hope you're enjoying your placement!

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 24/02/2023 21:25

Here are some links for you

www.communityfridgemap.org.uk/

To find out about your areas Food Banks, use google

Cakeyface123 · 24/02/2023 21:19

meanderyes · 24/02/2023 20:55

It's crazy, I was on the way home from work and my daughter is at her dads this weekend, he called and said she's unwell with a temperature and could I please pick up calpol. Had a fiver cash on me and left bank card at home so went to Sainsbury's and grabbed calpol. Tried 100 times to put the bloody fiver in the self service check out, wouldn't go in. Member of staff said they couldn't get me change as only one on the tills. The man beside me then said to put it through with him, I offered him my fiver a few times but he wouldn't take it, just said, 'it's never a good night when you're buying calpol'. I thanked him and told him that was so kind and I appreciated it and he said he hoped my little girl felt better soon. I feel like it's a wee bit of pay back for my good deed - not that I expect it.

Awww 🥰 this is just magic

Hendric · 24/02/2023 21:19

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 24/02/2023 21:13

As you're a student social worker use this case to reflect upon provisional boundaries, social work values of empowerment and how it clashed with your own personal values (wanting to help) and the ethical dilemma you found yourself in late on Friday with no one to ask, you being a professional not a friend or charity, that it was your money, and how that may impact on your relationship with that client & family going forward.

Use supervision and reflection as the method

The outcome you will come to, if it's good SW practice, in your write up and response next time (your learning needs) will be

  • seek advice from senior colleagues / line manager - don't act if you are unsure

-do research if local community resources - look up alternatives- find out where the community pantry, the community fridges are (literally Google your town address and those words), usually these are open part of each day for emergencies such as this, often run by church groups or voluntary agencies, and look up how to refer to Basics Bank (usually one in each town) which will do 7 days worth of basic supplies (but aren't open each day and SWs can refer to takes few days to organise) ; where are the "soup kitchens" ; and ask your colleagues for info on these community resources

  • find out more about crisis money from DWP and what the criteria are

What an insane level of overkill.

I agree OP should reflect but possibly more about her anxiety about this than the act itself and how to contextualise her anxiety about decision making in future.

The whole empowerment vs wanting to help thing is fucking weird given that the person had no money. Sometimes people just need fucking help.

Sometimes a student just needs practical advice.

This thread is full of professionals with collective decades of experience saying they have done and would do the same.

It's not that deep.

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 24/02/2023 21:13

As you're a student social worker use this case to reflect upon provisional boundaries, social work values of empowerment and how it clashed with your own personal values (wanting to help) and the ethical dilemma you found yourself in late on Friday with no one to ask, you being a professional not a friend or charity, that it was your money, and how that may impact on your relationship with that client & family going forward.

Use supervision and reflection as the method

The outcome you will come to, if it's good SW practice, in your write up and response next time (your learning needs) will be

  • seek advice from senior colleagues / line manager - don't act if you are unsure

-do research if local community resources - look up alternatives- find out where the community pantry, the community fridges are (literally Google your town address and those words), usually these are open part of each day for emergencies such as this, often run by church groups or voluntary agencies, and look up how to refer to Basics Bank (usually one in each town) which will do 7 days worth of basic supplies (but aren't open each day and SWs can refer to takes few days to organise) ; where are the "soup kitchens" ; and ask your colleagues for info on these community resources

  • find out more about crisis money from DWP and what the criteria are
Praying4Memory · 24/02/2023 21:11

I had a social worker buy me lunch once and bring it to my house when my main carer was suddenly taken into hospital and my other two backup carers were unavailable (one on holiday and one had the flu).

I don't think you've done anything very unusual. I'm very grateful to him for making a shitty day just a little bit easier as I was in to much of a panic after watching my carer collapse and be loaded into an ambulance to make any kind of plan.

purpledalmation · 24/02/2023 21:05

Don't make a habit of it or you'll have no money, but well done you for being kind and thoughtful

meanderyes · 24/02/2023 20:55

It's crazy, I was on the way home from work and my daughter is at her dads this weekend, he called and said she's unwell with a temperature and could I please pick up calpol. Had a fiver cash on me and left bank card at home so went to Sainsbury's and grabbed calpol. Tried 100 times to put the bloody fiver in the self service check out, wouldn't go in. Member of staff said they couldn't get me change as only one on the tills. The man beside me then said to put it through with him, I offered him my fiver a few times but he wouldn't take it, just said, 'it's never a good night when you're buying calpol'. I thanked him and told him that was so kind and I appreciated it and he said he hoped my little girl felt better soon. I feel like it's a wee bit of pay back for my good deed - not that I expect it.

OP posts:
Colourinsidethelines · 24/02/2023 20:24

I was a teacher in a very deprived area. I bought a child a pair of shoes once. I’ve bought loaves of bread to keep in my classroom to give them toast for breakfast when they haven’t been fed at home. DH is a police officer and had to forcibly take some kids into care once. He said there was absolutely no food in the house so he took them to McDonalds on the way to the police station. I would have done the same. It’s not ideal, you can’t make it a habit but sometimes needs must.

ClairDeLaLune · 24/02/2023 20:09

Good lesson about boundaries OP. But you sound like a lovely person, and I’m sure you’ll make an excellent social worker. Because you care.

GoodChat · 24/02/2023 19:59

You did a good thing OP and I'm glad you got the ok from your manager before the weekend.

Has she told you what you should do the next time?

RedRose36 · 24/02/2023 19:55

Hendric · 24/02/2023 19:43

You're presuming OPs in LA CSC, she could be adults. We don't even know if she's in stat.

Ah fair point, yes I was.