Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about Kate Forbes becoming first minister

620 replies

Creatine11 · 24/02/2023 10:01

Abortion and LGBT rights have been something that have largely not been part of political debate for at least the last 10 years. Gay marriage was enacted in 2014 and was broadly supported. The last serious challenge to abortion rights was at the start of the coalition government with Nadine Dorries et all. However, broadly gay rights and abortion rights have been settled issues- it has almost been taboo for politicians to oppose them. Certainly, there hasn’t been any serious possibility over the last decade (at least) of any rowing back on abortion, gay marriage, gay adoption, divorce law etc.

However, it is clear that in the heart of hearts of Forbes she disagrees with all these things due to her beliefs as an evangelical Christian. By all accounts she was very competent as a minister and has been a good MSP. However, as first minister she will be a figurehead for Scotland as well as setting the tone for policy and political discourse. Also, unlike Rees-Mogg and DUP types, Kate Forbes seems like an otherwise sensible, competent, ‘normal’ politician.

My concern is Forbes being the leader of Scotland could normalise her views on these issues. While I don’t believe abortion or gay marriage face immediate threat, if it’s brought into mainstream politics it will become a party political issue and may well shift public opinion, especially given the current culture war. Politicians, journalists, activists and others who have held these views quietly may be emboldened to launch a new campaign against abortion, LGBT rights or some other issue. I don’t know this would necessarily just be limited to Scotland as Nicola Sturgeon and her policies had a very high profile in the rest of the UK and influenced policy.

Aibu to worry about Kate Forbes becoming SNP leader and first minister?

OP posts:
Mammut · 24/02/2023 16:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I’m pretty sure the inspectorate upheld the whole complaint. His subsequent litigation is a separate matter. The nursery was found to have acted unfairly in their admission procedures.

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 16:00

triforcetotem · 24/02/2023 14:16

Yes the legislation was passed. I was responding to the claim she wouldn't impose her views on others, which she woukd be by voting thay way. I personally feel uncomfortable with the idea of a FM who does not think gay people should have the legal right to get married.

Sorry I don’t follow. She can’t enforce her views that gay people should not be permitted to enter in to legal marriage to one another because the legislation did not pass. I don’t think someone’s stance on gay marriage is relevant to their ability to lead Scotland or run a party, the matter is settled law. Tbh you are also barring any Christian or Muslim from being FM as both religions do not recognise gay marriage. Angela Merkel didn’t agree with gay marriage either. She didn’t vote for it either. She still managed to pretty ably run the country and I haven’t seen her branded a massive homophobe. The current Irish Taoiseach himself was not pro gay marriage until he saw the popular tide was turning that way, and he is a gay man. Accordingly many people now recognise that he is a person of limited principles, which they don’t particularly like or trust in a leader.

Lizziet64 · 24/02/2023 15:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FrostyFifi · 24/02/2023 15:43

Do you think it has anything to do with the fact that Kate Forbes opposes gay marriage and Humza Yousaf supports it?

Supports it by conveniently being "busy" when the vote took place?
Apparently due to pressure from his mosque?
He "supports" whatever is expedient.

Workerbeep · 24/02/2023 15:35

@TeaKlaxon i didn’t say biden had rowed back on reproductive rights but it’s happened under his presidency.

Mammut · 24/02/2023 15:34

DrMarciaFieldstone · 24/02/2023 11:13

Yep, and was suing a local nursery because they were full and didn’t have space were racist.

Conveniently dropped the case a few days before Sturgeon resigned, after he’d got the head up.

His complaint about the nursery was upheld by the Care Inspectorate.

Yes I do worry about a leader who holds these views. Although it does look like her bid is dead in the water there’s a worrying poll in the Guardian today saying she’s still top candidate amongst SNP voters (not members). None of the three are great tbh.

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 15:29

Missy865 · 24/02/2023 15:25

I dont understand this narrative against Kate Forbes and her strict Christian views.

Humza Useless is Muslim, his views are not going to be too dissimilar but the msm cant tear him apart the same way or they risk being lablled rascist.

Do you think it has anything to do with the fact that Kate Forbes opposes gay marriage and Humza Yousaf supports it?

Missy865 · 24/02/2023 15:25

I dont understand this narrative against Kate Forbes and her strict Christian views.

Humza Useless is Muslim, his views are not going to be too dissimilar but the msm cant tear him apart the same way or they risk being lablled rascist.

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 15:17

Workerbeep · 24/02/2023 15:09

@MrsFinkelstein Scotland and Great Britain are very different countries to the USA, with vastly different relationships with faith and political set up, governance and laws. it’s perhaps misleading to suggest that some states removal of women’s reproductive rights would happen here.

the removal of abortion rights in some America states happened under Biden not trump who I would argue is more vocal about his faith. Surprising eh?

the fundamental Christianity movement is huge in the USA. My uncle, Wisconsin born and bred, and reads the bible. Not flashy with his faith at all but it plays a massive part in many many American lives.
ever heard of the Bible Belt in USA?

🙄

Biden hasn’t done anything to row back on abortion rights - faith or no faith.

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 15:13

Everyone claiming Humza Yousaf missed ‘the’ vote on gay marriage should get their facts right.

He was present for most votes and voted in favour of marriage equality. When he missed a vote he explained why and made clear that he backed marriage equality.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 24/02/2023 15:13

every time a politician votes they are only representing some constituents unless all constituents think the same which they don't
so an MSP voting against nuclear weapons is not representing those in favour,
if the MSP's had voted like their constituents though the GRR would not pass as approx 66% of Scots don't support it, so voting in accordance with representing constituents is something they do or don't do as they see fit, sometimes they toe party line even when they know for sure it is against the wishes of the vast majority of their constituents
for example some labour MPs voted against brexit ( as per party line) despite their constituents being in favour in some cases by a considerable margin this may account for losing their seats to the collapse of red wall, sometimes you can ignore constituents and it's fine but sometimes it doesn't go well

Workerbeep · 24/02/2023 15:09

@MrsFinkelstein Scotland and Great Britain are very different countries to the USA, with vastly different relationships with faith and political set up, governance and laws. it’s perhaps misleading to suggest that some states removal of women’s reproductive rights would happen here.

the removal of abortion rights in some America states happened under Biden not trump who I would argue is more vocal about his faith. Surprising eh?

the fundamental Christianity movement is huge in the USA. My uncle, Wisconsin born and bred, and reads the bible. Not flashy with his faith at all but it plays a massive part in many many American lives.
ever heard of the Bible Belt in USA?

Christmascracker0 · 24/02/2023 14:42

Come on. If you are going to bash Katie for this then you need to bash Humza as well. Conveniently booked an appointment so that he would miss the gay marriage vote.

Humza was also convicted for driving without insurance. Caught whilst heading to an overnight stay with a woman in the car not his then wife.

He and his wife could not secure a space in a nursery, so resorted to shysters phoning up the nursery masquerading as parents trying to entrap the nursery. And the nursery was then mysteriously turned over by the Scottish Government inspectors and put through the mill.

Humza’s cousin, a one time candidate for Ayrshire very much in the circle of knowledge and advanced vetting, trading under a different name from the name he was known by when hundreds of thousands of pounds of Government Grant to an Islamic charity could not be accounted for. And a wife who also sailed through vetting whilst others struggled.

At least Katie is being upfront about her beliefs and not trying to hide anything. Perhaps I am biased because I was brought up a wee Free!

DixonD · 24/02/2023 14:31

BMW6 · 24/02/2023 10:16

Do you think a Muslim, Sikh, Jewish or Hindu First Minister would want the general population to adhere to their own religious creed??

If not - why? What's the difference?

This. YABU.

Marths · 24/02/2023 14:29

BMW6 · 24/02/2023 14:23

So OP who do you prefer as First Minister as you are against those with Religious beliefs?

Is OP against those with religious beliefs? That's not my impression. Plenty of religions people are not anti-gay and anti-choice.

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 14:24

WinkHalo

BMW6 · 24/02/2023 14:23

So OP who do you prefer as First Minister as you are against those with Religious beliefs?

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 14:18

@picklemewalnuts

Ask God to fix it for you.

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 14:16

It doesn't feel very powerful when you're shivering in a little church with a big ol holey roof.

triforcetotem · 24/02/2023 14:16

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 13:42

But the legislation was passed? Every politician imposes their views on others every time they vote on legislation. How else would you expect any one to cast a vote if not based on their own views??? If she was anti gay marriage but not religious would you have the same problem?

Yes the legislation was passed. I was responding to the claim she wouldn't impose her views on others, which she woukd be by voting thay way. I personally feel uncomfortable with the idea of a FM who does not think gay people should have the legal right to get married.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 14:03

@picklemewalnuts

Because religion is powerful

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 13:42

triforcetotem · 24/02/2023 13:28

But by voting against same-sex marriage she would impose her own religious beliefs on the rest of the population. And yes that applies to everyone who voted or would've voted the same way.

But the legislation was passed? Every politician imposes their views on others every time they vote on legislation. How else would you expect any one to cast a vote if not based on their own views??? If she was anti gay marriage but not religious would you have the same problem?

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 13:28

Genevieva · 24/02/2023 11:58

I am not worried at all about her personal religious views. It is clear she has no intention of imposing them on others. It is perfectly possible to uphold the law and oversee the provision of public services while belonging to a religion that promotes traditional family values. Most practicing Muslims would agree with her and do not get picked apart when seeking public office.

It is also very Christian to believe simultaneously both that sex is for procreation within a stable married relationship and that children conceived should be treasured, and that all humans are fallible, people should not judge others (that is for God to do) and that we should welcome everyone.

So, while I don't share her religious views or practices, I do think she is perfectly capable of being First Minister of Scotland. In fact, she comes across as extremely competent.

Lovely balanced post.

triforcetotem · 24/02/2023 13:28

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 13:09

No, that’s not how democracy works. You abide by the will of the majority. She wasn’t the only person to vote against gay marriage, do you think she is the only one of that cohort that wants to impose her views on others?

But by voting against same-sex marriage she would impose her own religious beliefs on the rest of the population. And yes that applies to everyone who voted or would've voted the same way.