Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about Kate Forbes becoming first minister

620 replies

Creatine11 · 24/02/2023 10:01

Abortion and LGBT rights have been something that have largely not been part of political debate for at least the last 10 years. Gay marriage was enacted in 2014 and was broadly supported. The last serious challenge to abortion rights was at the start of the coalition government with Nadine Dorries et all. However, broadly gay rights and abortion rights have been settled issues- it has almost been taboo for politicians to oppose them. Certainly, there hasn’t been any serious possibility over the last decade (at least) of any rowing back on abortion, gay marriage, gay adoption, divorce law etc.

However, it is clear that in the heart of hearts of Forbes she disagrees with all these things due to her beliefs as an evangelical Christian. By all accounts she was very competent as a minister and has been a good MSP. However, as first minister she will be a figurehead for Scotland as well as setting the tone for policy and political discourse. Also, unlike Rees-Mogg and DUP types, Kate Forbes seems like an otherwise sensible, competent, ‘normal’ politician.

My concern is Forbes being the leader of Scotland could normalise her views on these issues. While I don’t believe abortion or gay marriage face immediate threat, if it’s brought into mainstream politics it will become a party political issue and may well shift public opinion, especially given the current culture war. Politicians, journalists, activists and others who have held these views quietly may be emboldened to launch a new campaign against abortion, LGBT rights or some other issue. I don’t know this would necessarily just be limited to Scotland as Nicola Sturgeon and her policies had a very high profile in the rest of the UK and influenced policy.

Aibu to worry about Kate Forbes becoming SNP leader and first minister?

OP posts:
Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:09

@Eyerollcentral

Yes because lying about why you're against it would never happen

Why were stonewall against it?

What possible non homophobic reason could there be for being against gay marriage?

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:07

@picklemewalnuts

Thats like saying guns don't kill people, people do.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:07

@picklemewalnuts

Sorry. I don't get your argument

I never understood the point of civil partnership though so maybe that's why

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:06

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:43

@HBGKC

Do you honestly believe people voted against gay marriage because of a word?

🤣

Many people are on record saying exactly that. As I said before even stonewall were previously opposed to gay marriage. Are they homophobic now too? I don’t think the real test of whether someone is anti gay or not is whether they support gay marriage but then I tend to view people by the sum of their actions rather than deploy an ideology purity checklist to measure them against

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:04

Workerbeep · 24/02/2023 16:59

It’s not completely the same though is it. Isn’t there some loophole that you can’t cite adultery as a reason for divorce between same sex partners?

The legal application is exactly the same in terms of the rights, recognition and responsibilities to one another between spouses and civil partners. The adultery exception is now moot surely in any event with the advent of no fault divorce.

Workerbeep · 24/02/2023 16:59

It’s not completely the same though is it. Isn’t there some loophole that you can’t cite adultery as a reason for divorce between same sex partners?

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 16:53

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:24

@HBGKC

Pretty much, yeah.

The world would hopefully be a much better place

You'll be sorely disappointed. People men cause wars, not religions.

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 16:52

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:43

@HBGKC

Do you honestly believe people voted against gay marriage because of a word?

🤣

Why do you think people accepted Civil Partnership (legally identical, afaik) before same sex marriage?

It took a really long time for people to grasp the idea that marriage could include two people of the same sex.

I'm totally liberal, but really struggled with the language.

FKATondelayo · 24/02/2023 16:47

Tony Blair was high Anglican (married to a Catholic) in office. He only converted to Catholicism after he stopped being PM.

museumum · 24/02/2023 16:46

I believe she can separate personal religious believe and politics. Tony Blair was catholic wasn’t he? Don’t remember him being ripped apart for it.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:43

@HBGKC

Do you honestly believe people voted against gay marriage because of a word?

🤣

FKATondelayo · 24/02/2023 16:39

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 15:17

🙄

Biden hasn’t done anything to row back on abortion rights - faith or no faith.

Biden was vice president under Obama - who promised to enshrine abortion rights in federal law - and then changed his mind because it wasn't a 'priority'.
www.reuters.com/article/obama-abortion-idUKN2946642020090430

The Democrats occupied office for 16 years under Clinton and Obama - they could have protected abortion law across all states in that time. They didn't because the Democrats dangle abortion rights to make sure women keep voting for them.

HBGKC · 24/02/2023 16:39

@TeaKlaxon in response to your assertion "Of course opposing gay marriage is homophobic. It doesn't become not homophobic because it's wrapped up in a religious belief."

I'll quote @picklemewalnuts' excellent riposte:

"To be fair, many many people voted against gay marriage simply because it was a redefinition of an existing word. Many people felt that Civil Partnership addressed all the inequities and practical issues without redefining the word marriage."

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 16:38

FrostyFifi · 24/02/2023 16:34

Because Yousaf voted for marriage equality at all other stages except the one where he had a meeting about a Scottish man on death row in Pakistan

A meeting he himself set up despite knowing the date of the vote:
www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-did-humza-yousaf-miss-the-vote-on-gay-marriage/

So what's your view? That Yousaf had some moral objection to voting for marriage equality? But only on that one specific day? Why did he not have this moral objection for all prior stages? Why does his moral objection not extend to advocating for marriage equality at the time? Or to advocating for it now?

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 16:36

CatSpeakForDummies · 24/02/2023 16:32

She has said that she herself would never get an abortion but that she protects the right of other women to make that choice for themselves. She also supports banning protesters from harassing women at clinics.

Have we got so used to the American model of both politics and religion that we can't see that it's possible for someone to hold their own beliefs, not expect others to have the same beliefs and behave professionally without these belief's dominating their job.

I would never become a nun, but wouldn't vote against other people being allowed to. I would never call a child Tequila, but wouldn't enshrine it in law. I wouldn't want to read Mills and Boon but I'm not going to burn them. Etc.

Kate Forbes must be held to account if she does try to enforce her faith on others as a politician, but to say she must never get the chance - that we can't allow anyone with beliefs to be in politics - is a worse stance. I'm an atheist, but it isn't relevant.

But the point is that she said she would have imposed that belief if she'd had the chance, by voting in line with her personal belief.

Why on earth should gay people be expected to shut up and say nothing about someone who thinks our relationships are inferior, and would have used her vote in Parliament to deny our rights?

Why on earth should we be expected to pretend that we think there's nothing wrong with that?

FrostyFifi · 24/02/2023 16:35

If I were the suspicious sort I'd even go so far as to wonder if the deliberate smears are continuing here rather than this being a thread posted in good faith, by a specific group with a specific agenda.

Good thing I'm not though so I'm not saying such a thing.

HBGKC · 24/02/2023 16:35

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:24

@HBGKC

Pretty much, yeah.

The world would hopefully be a much better place

Fascinating.

You might find you're left with rather a lot of vacant posts to fill.

FrostyFifi · 24/02/2023 16:34

Because Yousaf voted for marriage equality at all other stages except the one where he had a meeting about a Scottish man on death row in Pakistan

A meeting he himself set up despite knowing the date of the vote:
www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-did-humza-yousaf-miss-the-vote-on-gay-marriage/

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:33

@CatSpeakForDummies

If only you could guarantee it would work out that way and not the way it actually does with religious beliefs being forced on everyone

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 16:33

HBGKC · 24/02/2023 16:23

Wow; that's a few billion people you've just called homophobes and mysogynists.

So, do you think everyone who adheres to any of the main world religions (all of which prohibit abortion and same-sex marriage, last I checked) should be barred from holding public office?

Of course opposing gay marriage is homophobic. It doesn't become not homophobic because it's wrapped up in a religious belief.

I've been around this block and I've never heard a single reason to oppose gay marriage that isn't homophobic. Of course, many adherents to religions don't actually subscribe to their religions' homophobic teaching.

CatSpeakForDummies · 24/02/2023 16:32

She has said that she herself would never get an abortion but that she protects the right of other women to make that choice for themselves. She also supports banning protesters from harassing women at clinics.

Have we got so used to the American model of both politics and religion that we can't see that it's possible for someone to hold their own beliefs, not expect others to have the same beliefs and behave professionally without these belief's dominating their job.

I would never become a nun, but wouldn't vote against other people being allowed to. I would never call a child Tequila, but wouldn't enshrine it in law. I wouldn't want to read Mills and Boon but I'm not going to burn them. Etc.

Kate Forbes must be held to account if she does try to enforce her faith on others as a politician, but to say she must never get the chance - that we can't allow anyone with beliefs to be in politics - is a worse stance. I'm an atheist, but it isn't relevant.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 16:24

@HBGKC

Pretty much, yeah.

The world would hopefully be a much better place

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 16:24

FrostyFifi · 24/02/2023 15:43

Do you think it has anything to do with the fact that Kate Forbes opposes gay marriage and Humza Yousaf supports it?

Supports it by conveniently being "busy" when the vote took place?
Apparently due to pressure from his mosque?
He "supports" whatever is expedient.

When you say he skilled 'the' vote, which vote are you referring to?

Because Yousaf voted for marriage equality at all other stages except the one where he had a meeting about a Scottish man on death row in Pakistan.

HBGKC · 24/02/2023 16:23

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:11

@HBGKC

My comments were general, not about Forbes directly.

But yes, I think if you're actively against gay marriage you are homophobic and mysoginist if you are pro life.

Lots of women are mysoginist

Wow; that's a few billion people you've just called homophobes and mysogynists.

So, do you think everyone who adheres to any of the main world religions (all of which prohibit abortion and same-sex marriage, last I checked) should be barred from holding public office?

Aphrathestorm · 24/02/2023 16:08

islamism.news/2023/02/23/the-troubling-islamist-connections-of-scotlands-next-leader/

More on HY and his cousin.

His ex wife also left the party telling a newspaper it is a 'cult'.