Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about Kate Forbes becoming first minister

620 replies

Creatine11 · 24/02/2023 10:01

Abortion and LGBT rights have been something that have largely not been part of political debate for at least the last 10 years. Gay marriage was enacted in 2014 and was broadly supported. The last serious challenge to abortion rights was at the start of the coalition government with Nadine Dorries et all. However, broadly gay rights and abortion rights have been settled issues- it has almost been taboo for politicians to oppose them. Certainly, there hasn’t been any serious possibility over the last decade (at least) of any rowing back on abortion, gay marriage, gay adoption, divorce law etc.

However, it is clear that in the heart of hearts of Forbes she disagrees with all these things due to her beliefs as an evangelical Christian. By all accounts she was very competent as a minister and has been a good MSP. However, as first minister she will be a figurehead for Scotland as well as setting the tone for policy and political discourse. Also, unlike Rees-Mogg and DUP types, Kate Forbes seems like an otherwise sensible, competent, ‘normal’ politician.

My concern is Forbes being the leader of Scotland could normalise her views on these issues. While I don’t believe abortion or gay marriage face immediate threat, if it’s brought into mainstream politics it will become a party political issue and may well shift public opinion, especially given the current culture war. Politicians, journalists, activists and others who have held these views quietly may be emboldened to launch a new campaign against abortion, LGBT rights or some other issue. I don’t know this would necessarily just be limited to Scotland as Nicola Sturgeon and her policies had a very high profile in the rest of the UK and influenced policy.

Aibu to worry about Kate Forbes becoming SNP leader and first minister?

OP posts:
TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 18:42

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:52

Anyway I have a life. Kids to feed etc. I'll let you continue in your discrimination against a woman with religious beliefs.

Lol - it’s not discrimination for people committed to equality for gay people to not want to vote for someone who doesn’t share that commitment.

That is literally how politics works. If you hold positions that voters disagree with, they are free to disagree with you and refuse to support you.

triforcetotem · 24/02/2023 18:38

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:52

Anyway I have a life. Kids to feed etc. I'll let you continue in your discrimination against a woman with religious beliefs.

Not liking or supporting a politician is hardly discrimination.

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 18:34

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:50

Honestly the whole TWAW fiasco has completely undermined my conviction that we should marry gay couples in church. I was rooting for it. I was at one of the first (pretty sure it was day 1) gay weddings, and very lovely it was too.

Recently I've been more thoughtful about it, and more understanding of the perspective of people who believe in the words of the wedding service 'marriage is between one man and one woman for the procreation of children'.

And of course I know some people choose never to have children, before you ask.

It's complete balls and ignorance to assume that people who oppose same sex marriage must be nasty old bigots. Very bigoted about religious people, frankly.

Do you also think post-menopausal women should not be allowed to get married in the church?

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 18:31

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:50

I am a pedant so I will only say that even the Catholic Church is not anti gay people. They just think gay sex is a sin. They expect gay people to be celibate and of course gay marriage is out of the question in catholic theology but it is wrong to say that they preach being gay itself a sin. I do appreciate to many people that’s the same thing but there is a distinction.

Catholic teaching is that gay people are ‘intrinsically disordered’.

Thats pretty damn anti-gay.

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 18:30

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:25

Many gay activists rejected and continue to reject gay marriage as they view it as heteronormative. They could support civil partnerships for gay people and oppose gay marriage for example because the former provides all the rights of being married without being imbued with the heteronormative trappings of conventional marriage. It’s the idea of different but equal. They didn’t want to be seen as coalescing with the viewpoint that straight is the standard and that forms of straight relationships should be co-opted in to gay relationships. Many gay activists were opposed to the opening up of civil partnerships to straight people as well for the same reason. It’s not as cut and dry as saying if you oppose gay marriage you are a homophobe. You can fully support gay rights and recognise that marriage before legislation was introduced to amend the legal meaning was exclusively for straight couples and that civil partnerships provided an equal legal means of recognising the relationships between gay people.
Some people, like Kate Forbes, may simply disagree with gay marriage on religious grounds. I know religious parliamentarians who have justified their personal votes in favour of gay marriage legislation (which is in opposition to their personal religious beliefs) on the basis that it is only a civil marriage and many religions do not recognise civil marriages devoid of a religious ceremony as a proper marriage. So if they voted for gay marriage but due to their faith don’t really believe in the validity of those marriages, are they a homophobe or not?

Sorry but this is nonsense.

Marriage being heteronormative was often a reason that some gay people didn’t actively seek or campaign for marriage rights.

Ive never seen any gay person argue that no gay person should be allowed to marry on that basis.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:58

@picklemewalnuts

How can you not be homophobic if you believe marriage should only be for men and women?

I disagree with her, I'm not discrimating against her.

Shes free to practice her religion. I just don't think she should have the power to force those beliefs on anyone else

The CofE can't rewrite the bible

Unfortunately

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:52

Anyway I have a life. Kids to feed etc. I'll let you continue in your discrimination against a woman with religious beliefs.

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:52

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:47

@picklemewalnuts

Their religions are though

Who are they to say their religion is wrong?

That would be why the CofE has been discussing and debating this for years, is it? And is now offering blessings for same sex couples?

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:50

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:41

@Eyerollcentral

The motivation is clearly very different.

Who am I to say a gay person who opposed gay marriage on heternormative grounds was wrong?

Being against gay marriage because you're against being gay at all is not the same

And is definitely homophobic.

But thanks for the info. I had no idea that's how some gay people feel.

I am a pedant so I will only say that even the Catholic Church is not anti gay people. They just think gay sex is a sin. They expect gay people to be celibate and of course gay marriage is out of the question in catholic theology but it is wrong to say that they preach being gay itself a sin. I do appreciate to many people that’s the same thing but there is a distinction.

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:50

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:41

@Eyerollcentral

The motivation is clearly very different.

Who am I to say a gay person who opposed gay marriage on heternormative grounds was wrong?

Being against gay marriage because you're against being gay at all is not the same

And is definitely homophobic.

But thanks for the info. I had no idea that's how some gay people feel.

Honestly the whole TWAW fiasco has completely undermined my conviction that we should marry gay couples in church. I was rooting for it. I was at one of the first (pretty sure it was day 1) gay weddings, and very lovely it was too.

Recently I've been more thoughtful about it, and more understanding of the perspective of people who believe in the words of the wedding service 'marriage is between one man and one woman for the procreation of children'.

And of course I know some people choose never to have children, before you ask.

It's complete balls and ignorance to assume that people who oppose same sex marriage must be nasty old bigots. Very bigoted about religious people, frankly.

Simonjt · 24/02/2023 17:49

BMW6 · 24/02/2023 10:16

Do you think a Muslim, Sikh, Jewish or Hindu First Minister would want the general population to adhere to their own religious creed??

If not - why? What's the difference?

No.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:47

@picklemewalnuts

Their religions are though

Who are they to say their religion is wrong?

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:45

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:41

@Eyerollcentral

The motivation is clearly very different.

Who am I to say a gay person who opposed gay marriage on heternormative grounds was wrong?

Being against gay marriage because you're against being gay at all is not the same

And is definitely homophobic.

But thanks for the info. I had no idea that's how some gay people feel.

And many, many religious people are not against being gay at all.

picklemewalnuts · 24/02/2023 17:42

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:07

@picklemewalnuts

Thats like saying guns don't kill people, people do.

Well I'd be a hell of a lot more concerned if my neighbour had a gun, than a Bible or Koran. But you do you.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:41

@Eyerollcentral

The motivation is clearly very different.

Who am I to say a gay person who opposed gay marriage on heternormative grounds was wrong?

Being against gay marriage because you're against being gay at all is not the same

And is definitely homophobic.

But thanks for the info. I had no idea that's how some gay people feel.

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:39

twelly · 24/02/2023 17:35

I think the comment that these issues are "settled" implies that no-one can have a view once a law has been changed. I think these are issues that are not defined by party, people who can vote in the SNP election will decide which candidate they will support.

They are settled in law. It would be quite an amazing turn around, actually unprecedented in any legislature in the UK for rights such as this to be overturned and would require a majority of parliamentarians to support it which again seems hugely unlikely. It would be like someone now trying to overturn women’s right to vote. People can still have their own personal views.

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:37

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:29

@Eyerollcentral

Homophobe.

Being against gay marriage as a gay person because you think it's heternormative isn't the same as being against gay marriage because you think being gay is a sin.

Im not even really sure it counts as being against gay marriage.

It's not wanting to prevent gay rights just asking for different ones

You’re not sure if a gay person saying I oppose gay marriage is exactly opposing gay marriage? What is it then? The reasoning may be different but the outcome is the same. It seems like you are determined that the only possible people who opposed gay marriage were religious homophobes and that’s simply not true.

TeaKlaxon · 24/02/2023 17:36

I’m not sure why you think this rebuts my claim.

If someone’s reason for opposing marriage equality is they just don’t want gay couples to be able to use the word, how is that not homophobic?

twelly · 24/02/2023 17:35

I think the comment that these issues are "settled" implies that no-one can have a view once a law has been changed. I think these are issues that are not defined by party, people who can vote in the SNP election will decide which candidate they will support.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:29

@Eyerollcentral

Homophobe.

Being against gay marriage as a gay person because you think it's heternormative isn't the same as being against gay marriage because you think being gay is a sin.

Im not even really sure it counts as being against gay marriage.

It's not wanting to prevent gay rights just asking for different ones

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:28

weatherthestorms · 24/02/2023 17:16

Gay rights groups supported ‘civil partnerships’ as a stepping stone to marriage equality because they knew there was little to no chance of marriage equality happening back in 2005.
Sometimes you have to accept something that’s not quite what you want in order to achieve an ultimate aim.

look how many people, churches etc opposed civil partnerships even.
when we had ours when they first came in we weren’t allowed ANY religious element of any kind as part of the ceremony, including any piece of music that could be considered religious or a hymn.

My family commented how great it was to NOT have any of that religion stuff at our civil ceremony and I did have to explain it’s because it wasn’t allowed rather than we decided to do away with all readings, quotes, songs etc

You can’t have a religious civil partnership ceremony as, as far as I am aware, no church recognises civil partnership as a sacrament of their church. The state doesn’t allow religious elements in civil marriages either. A civil marriage also has to be devoid of religion because it is legal marriage only.

Eyerollcentral · 24/02/2023 17:25

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 17:09

@Eyerollcentral

Yes because lying about why you're against it would never happen

Why were stonewall against it?

What possible non homophobic reason could there be for being against gay marriage?

Many gay activists rejected and continue to reject gay marriage as they view it as heteronormative. They could support civil partnerships for gay people and oppose gay marriage for example because the former provides all the rights of being married without being imbued with the heteronormative trappings of conventional marriage. It’s the idea of different but equal. They didn’t want to be seen as coalescing with the viewpoint that straight is the standard and that forms of straight relationships should be co-opted in to gay relationships. Many gay activists were opposed to the opening up of civil partnerships to straight people as well for the same reason. It’s not as cut and dry as saying if you oppose gay marriage you are a homophobe. You can fully support gay rights and recognise that marriage before legislation was introduced to amend the legal meaning was exclusively for straight couples and that civil partnerships provided an equal legal means of recognising the relationships between gay people.
Some people, like Kate Forbes, may simply disagree with gay marriage on religious grounds. I know religious parliamentarians who have justified their personal votes in favour of gay marriage legislation (which is in opposition to their personal religious beliefs) on the basis that it is only a civil marriage and many religions do not recognise civil marriages devoid of a religious ceremony as a proper marriage. So if they voted for gay marriage but due to their faith don’t really believe in the validity of those marriages, are they a homophobe or not?

weatherthestorms · 24/02/2023 17:16

Gay rights groups supported ‘civil partnerships’ as a stepping stone to marriage equality because they knew there was little to no chance of marriage equality happening back in 2005.
Sometimes you have to accept something that’s not quite what you want in order to achieve an ultimate aim.

look how many people, churches etc opposed civil partnerships even.
when we had ours when they first came in we weren’t allowed ANY religious element of any kind as part of the ceremony, including any piece of music that could be considered religious or a hymn.

My family commented how great it was to NOT have any of that religion stuff at our civil ceremony and I did have to explain it’s because it wasn’t allowed rather than we decided to do away with all readings, quotes, songs etc

FrostyFifi · 24/02/2023 17:11

Are they homophobic now too?

Stonewall? Tbf yes.

weatherthestorms · 24/02/2023 17:11

It’s the ‘evangelical’ bit that worries me… still she said she wouldn’t try to roll back marriage equality- so kind.