Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about Kate Forbes becoming first minister

620 replies

Creatine11 · 24/02/2023 10:01

Abortion and LGBT rights have been something that have largely not been part of political debate for at least the last 10 years. Gay marriage was enacted in 2014 and was broadly supported. The last serious challenge to abortion rights was at the start of the coalition government with Nadine Dorries et all. However, broadly gay rights and abortion rights have been settled issues- it has almost been taboo for politicians to oppose them. Certainly, there hasn’t been any serious possibility over the last decade (at least) of any rowing back on abortion, gay marriage, gay adoption, divorce law etc.

However, it is clear that in the heart of hearts of Forbes she disagrees with all these things due to her beliefs as an evangelical Christian. By all accounts she was very competent as a minister and has been a good MSP. However, as first minister she will be a figurehead for Scotland as well as setting the tone for policy and political discourse. Also, unlike Rees-Mogg and DUP types, Kate Forbes seems like an otherwise sensible, competent, ‘normal’ politician.

My concern is Forbes being the leader of Scotland could normalise her views on these issues. While I don’t believe abortion or gay marriage face immediate threat, if it’s brought into mainstream politics it will become a party political issue and may well shift public opinion, especially given the current culture war. Politicians, journalists, activists and others who have held these views quietly may be emboldened to launch a new campaign against abortion, LGBT rights or some other issue. I don’t know this would necessarily just be limited to Scotland as Nicola Sturgeon and her policies had a very high profile in the rest of the UK and influenced policy.

Aibu to worry about Kate Forbes becoming SNP leader and first minister?

OP posts:
Clarabell77 · 26/02/2023 21:33

jcyclops · 25/02/2023 23:09

It's funny how none of the candidates for SNP leader (and thus First Minister) have promised a Scottish election if they win. This is despite every SNP MP and MSP calling for a general election after both Johnson and Truss resignations. They bleated that it was undemocratic for just party members and/or MPs to select a new PM and the new one would have no mandate, but it is suddenly fine for SNP to elect a FM without an election.

This is just the latest example of the SNPs hypocrisy. John Swinney claims that there can be no election as Holyrood operates on a fixed-term basis, but this is disingenuous as there are ways to dissolve the Scottish Parliament and hold an extraordinary general election.

And did we get our general election?

Clarabell77 · 26/02/2023 21:17

Workerbeep · 24/02/2023 10:32

Holyrood should be suspended, the snp choose there new leader and then we should have a general election for holyrood.

there are not very many actual card carrying members of the SNP left and they are the ones choosing the first minister of Scotland.

The nonsense my SNP member friends comes out at the moment and her fragile state of mind with the chief mammy resigning (spent two days crying!) I wouldn’t trust her judgment.

Goodness you sound like a lovely friend!

The SNP has over 100,000 members. Not far off the two main UK parties.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 21:13

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:50

It’s not though. That’s not what discrimination is. If you have access to the same rights you aren’t being discriminated against. The term used is not the instructive bit. The rights conferred are. You are reflecting your own internalised homophobia as you don’t see civil partnerships as equal to marriage when of course legally they are.

If the NHS decided the term nurse should only apply to white nurses but nurses of colour should instead be called ‘care providers’ - but their jobs and salaries were identical, do you think that would amount to discrimination?

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 21:08

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:48

Yes, the concept of civil marriage is based on the concept of religious marriage which was a union between man and woman. Civil marriage has existed for centuries. It is ludicrous to contend that not making civil marriage open to gay couples centuries in the past was an exercise in homophobia. The State simply reflected the institution as it already existed in society.

It was homophobic then as it is now. The idea that the state just reflected pre-existing homophobia and so the state itself wasn’t actually homophobic is nonsense.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 21:03

twelly · 26/02/2023 19:47

Its not homophobic, its not hatred or fear, again using this type of terms is aimed at silencing those who might disagree and not helpful

I’ve already pointed out that homophobia encompasses prejudice.

Believing that gay couples relationships were unworthy of protection and recognition and status most certainly was prejudice.

HBGKC · 26/02/2023 20:22

@TeaKlaxon no one is trying to 'silence you'; why are you saying that they are?

Everyone is free to hold whatever views they like. Kate Forbes is free to run for SNP leader; the electorate are free to vote for her, or not. You can call her whatever you like, but she has clearly stated that she has no intention of attempting the (impossible) task of repealing rights to gay marriage.

Frabbits · 26/02/2023 20:01

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 13:38

Or you think marriage is between a man and a woman, as it has been for thousands of years. Civil partnerships have all the same rights and responsibilities of marriage. They are equal to marriage. I have yet to hear even the most right wing or religiously conservative politician advocate for the removal of gay marriage - and I live in NI where the DUP are a thing. Even they have not proposed that gay marriage should be repealed.

You can think that, and accept you are a homophobe.

What someone can't do is think that gay people do not deserve equal rights and claim that they are not a bigot - even if you don't actively campaign to remove or deny rights.

Botw1 · 26/02/2023 20:00

@Eyerollcentral

If you can't get married you don't have access to the same rights

Botw1 · 26/02/2023 19:59

@twelly

First hits on Google

To worry about Kate Forbes becoming first minister
Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:50

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:41

Of course it is.

Have the same rights but don’t use the term is of course discrimination.

It’s not though. That’s not what discrimination is. If you have access to the same rights you aren’t being discriminated against. The term used is not the instructive bit. The rights conferred are. You are reflecting your own internalised homophobia as you don’t see civil partnerships as equal to marriage when of course legally they are.

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:48

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:40

We’re specifically talking about civil marriage.

There was never any requirement for states to adopt the homophobic approach of religions. That was a choice. A discriminatory one.

Yes, the concept of civil marriage is based on the concept of religious marriage which was a union between man and woman. Civil marriage has existed for centuries. It is ludicrous to contend that not making civil marriage open to gay couples centuries in the past was an exercise in homophobia. The State simply reflected the institution as it already existed in society.

twelly · 26/02/2023 19:47

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:40

We’re specifically talking about civil marriage.

There was never any requirement for states to adopt the homophobic approach of religions. That was a choice. A discriminatory one.

Its not homophobic, its not hatred or fear, again using this type of terms is aimed at silencing those who might disagree and not helpful

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:41

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:31

What you have described is not discrimination though. It might be if there were no means by which gay relationships could be recognised in equal terms, but there is.

Of course it is.

Have the same rights but don’t use the term is of course discrimination.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:40

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:35

The concept of marriage was understood until very recently to only apply to heterosexual couples. The state did not come up with the idea of marriage, across the world states have provided a legal and non religious means of recognising relationships legally based on the concept of marriage as it already existed. The concept was entirely based on male-female couples wherever it existed in any society, meaning the implementation of it could necessarily only apply to heterosexual couples.

We’re specifically talking about civil marriage.

There was never any requirement for states to adopt the homophobic approach of religions. That was a choice. A discriminatory one.

PriOn1 · 26/02/2023 19:37

Given that she seems to be a decent, truthful person, I’d be happy to see her win, given that she has expressly stated that she will not be seeking to impose her religious views on others.

Let’s face it, given that many politicians aiming for leadership seem to lie easily and regularly demonstrate a complete lack of moral fibre, simply being a decent human being, religious or not, would make her better than most.

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:35

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:28

The ‘concept’ of marriage is merely the concept that the State should provide legal recognition called marriage to couples. There’s nothing inherent in that ‘concept’ that means it should only be between a man and a woman.

It is the implementation of that concept that limited to opposite sex couples for a long time.

The concept of marriage was understood until very recently to only apply to heterosexual couples. The state did not come up with the idea of marriage, across the world states have provided a legal and non religious means of recognising relationships legally based on the concept of marriage as it already existed. The concept was entirely based on male-female couples wherever it existed in any society, meaning the implementation of it could necessarily only apply to heterosexual couples.

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 19:31

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:26

This makes no sense.

I’ve clearly explained that there was discrimination and it was never OK.

Also there are good reasons most men will not need a smear test. There is no good reason that gay couples shouldn’t have the right to marry.

What you have described is not discrimination though. It might be if there were no means by which gay relationships could be recognised in equal terms, but there is.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:28

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 17:49

How is the concept of marriage (union of a man and woman) not homophobic but the implementation (getting married) is? Makes no sense.

The ‘concept’ of marriage is merely the concept that the State should provide legal recognition called marriage to couples. There’s nothing inherent in that ‘concept’ that means it should only be between a man and a woman.

It is the implementation of that concept that limited to opposite sex couples for a long time.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:26

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 17:47

So there is no discrimination then, you just don’t like that marriage was not believed to include gay couples. It’s fine to think that but one minute you say it’s discriminatory and then the next you say separate but equal isn’t acceptable. A man can be denied access to a smear test provided by a state institution because it doesn’t apply to him, he can of course have access to prostate examinations. What’s the difference?

This makes no sense.

I’ve clearly explained that there was discrimination and it was never OK.

Also there are good reasons most men will not need a smear test. There is no good reason that gay couples shouldn’t have the right to marry.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:24

PearsOfWisdom · 26/02/2023 18:24

This.

People of faith should be welcome in Politics, same as atheists , humanists, agnostics etc

And people who think they are homophobes and that they should not be First Minister for that reason should be free to say so.

TeaKlaxon · 26/02/2023 19:23

twelly · 26/02/2023 18:11

Disagreeing with someone still allows people to have that view - it also depend what you believe is a right. The same is true of both gay marriage and abortion - do you call both a right?

Why do you keep throwing this red herring in that people are ‘allowed’ to hold their views.

No one has claimed otherwise. Not a single person says she shouldn’t be allowed her views or that she shouldn’t be allowed to be in politics.

Kate Forbes or anyone else can be as homophobic as she likes. But free speech and freedom of belief cuts both ways and your efforts to silence those who think her views are homophobic or who wouldn’t welcome someone with her values as First Minister show that you’re the one who seems to think certain views shouldn’t be allowed.

watmel · 26/02/2023 18:36

HBGKC · 26/02/2023 17:26

This argument is at cross purposes; some people are approaching it personally, whilst others are approaching it philosophically.

One last try, on why people might object to the concept of "gay marriage":

It's a bit like vegetarians demanding the right to describe themselves as carnivores, even though they won't eat meat. The term isn't relevant or applicable to them, so that demand doesn't make sense - unless and until you change the meaning of the words involved. But why would you?

I still haven't heard a good argument as to why words need to change meaning, particularly when it's only to please a very small minority of people who don't like the fact that a word/concept exists that doesn't include them (despite the fact that that's precisely how language & meaning works - by a process of exclusion. A chair isn't a table; a sofa isn't a sideboard; doesn't mean they're not all equally useful pieces of furniture though).

@watmel you can call me anything you like. I haven't actually stated a personal view on this thread. I copied and pasted Church teaching in the interests of clarity, because it was being mis-represented.

@TeaKlaxon your constant misrepresentation of views with which you disagree is...trying.

Your views are perfectly clear. You think gay people have "inclinations" and "tendencies" and should not have the legal right to get married.

PearsOfWisdom · 26/02/2023 18:24

GrumpyPanda · 24/02/2023 10:19

FWIW - Angela Merkel voted against marriage equality when chancellor. While making it very clear this was her own personal opinion and vote not along party lines. There are ways, even in top politics, to handle differences of belief in a civilized fashion.

This.

People of faith should be welcome in Politics, same as atheists , humanists, agnostics etc

Botw1 · 26/02/2023 18:17

I didn't say they didn't

Id totally be in favour of scrapping/ banning marriage in favour of civil partnerships

But until that happens it should be available to all

Eyerollcentral · 26/02/2023 18:12

Botw1 · 26/02/2023 18:11

Because as long as its available for straight couples it should also be available for gay couples

Why do civil partnerships not meet that need, with the added bonus of not representing a misogynistic institution? Civil partnerships are equal to marriage.