Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my DH sounds like an dick

230 replies

SandroSandra · 24/02/2023 09:55

Opinions on this conversation pls. We live in a small old scruffy cottage and have 2 small kids

I commented to DH that restoration isn't so much of a joy when you have to work full time and you've got kids (inspired by a thread on here i was reading this morning) and that isn't it frustrating our cottage is still so scruffy and broken even though we've been here 3 years.

He said "ah well that's the thing about feminism innit. Women want to work but guess what there isn't enough time to make a nice home too"

I said "well it's more that most couples both need to work these days to pay the bills"

He said "sure of course but just odd all these women stressing that they want perfect homes, following restoration accounts and Mrs hinch on Instagram. But no woman has time to do any of it so just make you all feel guilty. It's almost like it was a good idea to have someone stay at home because guess what making a beautiful home is a full time job and adding restoration on top of it - it's impossible"

And I said "but men could stay home if they wanted"

He said "but we don't want to really. You were the ones that wanted to change the model and set up and then you're all stressing out you don't have time to do it all"

He then started saying

"Oh course there is a theory that the Rockefella family made feminism a success just to get 50% of the working people working their arse off and paying tax. And women fell for it"

Does he sound like a dick? It really wound me up but he insists whats he's saying is just logical.

OP posts:
FinallyHere · 24/02/2023 12:58

He is not completely wrong, is he?

However, another relevant question is what level of reward do you each receive for your work?

Very different if he is earning loads, in which case outsource the renovations.

Is your work 'just' a vanity project or are your earnings required to cover your costs. What pension contributions are you making ?

I'd want to know the answer to these questions before commenting.

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 12:58

Mark19735 · 24/02/2023 12:53

Not bullshit.

The anti-capitalist posters on here will confirm that if working 1.5 jobs was sustainable in the long run, corporates would be lobbying for a standard 60hr working week. (In salaried roles that are exempted from the working time directive, that is already the norm anyhow - hence so many people, men and women, being burnt out).

And, as a point of order, he does get to decide he doesn't want to do the 0.5. That is what autonomy means. It's the OP who wants to divorce him for it ... her choice. Her bed. She can lie in it. He still get's to decide whether or not to do the extra 0.5.

The only bullshit I'd call out is the myth that running a household really is a 1.0 role. A very diligent and fussy person could probably find things to do to occupy 40hrs, but in reality anyone who outsources this work will find that 2-3hrs cleaning, 2-3hrs laundry, 1hr shopping, and 15hrs wraparound childcare is plenty to live in a clean, respectable house. That's about 20hrs ... the bullshit comes from MN users pretending the other 20 consist of 'mental load' which is in some way equally exhausting to actual work, when in reality it's just procrastination masquerading is inefficiency.

I'd just like to thank you for calling yourself Mark. I was absolutely expecting FlowerLadyMarilynTheGirl when I checked the name and the honesty is truly refreshing.

Babooshka1990 · 24/02/2023 12:57

Could you quit your job and let him pay for everything then? I bet he wouldn’t like that either.

Also traditionally men would do al the DIY and major decorating (whilst working full time providing for their family) so what is he even on about?

Weallhaveavoice · 24/02/2023 12:57

GloomyDarkness · 24/02/2023 12:19

He sounds like a dick and as PP say it economics not feminism that led to most now needing two wages as as otehr note in most past times working women worked for economic and ramp capitalists reasons.

but just odd all these women stressing that they want perfect homes, following restoration accounts and Mrs hinch on Instagram. But no woman has time to do any of it so just make you all feel guilty

I do wonder if this is an issue though* *- is this something you do ?

I do find it's other women who judge the state of my house and that seems to related just to me - even though DH and 3 teens also live here all just as capable as me of doing house stuff.

I used to eye roll when people commented on my then young kids having toys out when they came in but it's only in recent years I've managed not to go into cleaning frenzy when MIL is about to visit.

You’re right
It isn’t male visitors that give that look of ‘ judgement ‘ about the house. It’s other women.

I still go into a cleaning frenzy tho if anyones about to visit.
Even for the gas man🤣

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:57

@Mark19735

No, it's not impossible to work and do housework and parent

lots of people do it.

And no, it's not OK to enter into family life and then decide you cba to do any of the work related to family life. It is not optional.

Not without consequences any way.

Cherrysoup · 24/02/2023 12:55

SandroSandra · 24/02/2023 10:11

I told him he sounded sexist.

He said "I'm not blaming women. I'm just saying that two people working full time with kids doesn't leave enough time to restore or redecorate or do much of anything really and there is a reason we used to have on person at home. Not about it being women. I'm just being logical"

He's massively back pedalling there because he knows that his first statement was hugely misogynistic. Asshole.

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:55

@ReneBumsWombats

No, I didn't respond. It did make me eye roll though

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 12:53

I read a comment yest that said, feminism has gone too far.

There has never, ever been a time when there weren't complaints that feminism had gone too far. It's not even worth responding to any more. It's just a waste of time.

Mark19735 · 24/02/2023 12:53

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:33

@Mark19735

Except its bullshit that you can't work 1.5 jobs.

He doesn't get to decide that he doesn't want to do the. 5

He lives in the house, he agreed to enter into family life

The. 5 is as much his responsibility as hers and he doesn't get to absolve himself from it

Not bullshit.

The anti-capitalist posters on here will confirm that if working 1.5 jobs was sustainable in the long run, corporates would be lobbying for a standard 60hr working week. (In salaried roles that are exempted from the working time directive, that is already the norm anyhow - hence so many people, men and women, being burnt out).

And, as a point of order, he does get to decide he doesn't want to do the 0.5. That is what autonomy means. It's the OP who wants to divorce him for it ... her choice. Her bed. She can lie in it. He still get's to decide whether or not to do the extra 0.5.

The only bullshit I'd call out is the myth that running a household really is a 1.0 role. A very diligent and fussy person could probably find things to do to occupy 40hrs, but in reality anyone who outsources this work will find that 2-3hrs cleaning, 2-3hrs laundry, 1hr shopping, and 15hrs wraparound childcare is plenty to live in a clean, respectable house. That's about 20hrs ... the bullshit comes from MN users pretending the other 20 consist of 'mental load' which is in some way equally exhausting to actual work, when in reality it's just procrastination masquerading is inefficiency.

category12 · 24/02/2023 12:49

There's greater pressure socially to have a show-home, I think. All these telly programmes about decor and doing up houses constantly.

In my granny's generation, if you were lucky enough to afford it, you had one smart room (the drawing room, she called it) basically for the purpose of receiving the vicar/posh visitors and you didn't use it otherwise. I was sometimes allowed in there to play but it was a Big Deal. The rest of the house was a bit scruffy and run-down.

There's never been a halcyon time where working class women stayed home and kept a show-home. They worked, just not in as visible ways as the men.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 24/02/2023 12:48

He sounds great! Tell him he is absolutely right and that you are quitting your job tomorrow, but of course he'll need to cover all the bills and expenses to make the house nice...

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:46

@Blossomtoes

What is the downside to equal rights for women?

I read a comment yest that said, feminism has gone too far.

Yeah right. We haven't even managed to achieve the main aims but it's definitely gone too far

🙄

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 12:45

He has some good points about Instagram and impossible standards

Perhaps, but I doubt his sexism didn't exist before social media.

Napmum · 24/02/2023 12:44

He has some good points about Instagram and impossible standards, especially with people working full time.

Also, the idea of 'work life' balance, which is a feminist theory, was a way for employers to make burn out and stress the employees' problems.

My DH can be critical of 'the feminists' when I challenge him on this he often backs down saying 'not you and not all feminists'. He means the women campaigning for stuff that is naturally occurring, such as, now more women are working full time and getting promoted it is starting g to equalise. Sometimes, I get annoyed as our politics are not totally aligned, and expecting that would be impossible.

However, we do have shared values, like not lying to ourselves and trying to be fair and kind to others. I would suggest working on what your shared values are and what our your goals for the family. Like saving up to pay for renovation work to the cottage. If you can't agree on those then there's an issue

Itismycircus · 24/02/2023 12:43

I’d say that if your husband can only trace women in paid employment and the growth of ‘feminism’ (!) to a US industrialist he’s a wee bit thick. This is an Andrew Tate/incel theory.

Goldenbear · 24/02/2023 12:43

You are clearly not married to an Architect (joke) as it is my DH who is better/obsessed the aesthetic of our domestic environment. I actually don't care enough and since when have women who were housewives in the past ended up on restoration projects! Not really comparative to keeping a tidy house!

Blossomtoes · 24/02/2023 12:42

And funnily enough all the posters on here who know nothing about feminism (except that it's to blame for all the world's ills

I take it that’s parody. Feminism has achieved a huge amount in my lifetime and I’m a second wave feminist but I’m not going to pretend it’s been an unadulterated success with no downside. This is the downside.

JackiePlace · 24/02/2023 12:41

(hence the push to euthanasia and to try to eradicate disability).

I prefer to believe that 'push' is more about trying to ensure human beings have a decent quality of life @VictorStrand ,

ReneBumsWombats · 24/02/2023 12:41

Thoughtful2355 · 24/02/2023 12:37

May have been said in a wrong way but actually I agree with him

Feminism was responsible for house prices/rent and living costs escalating far beyond wages?

Thoughtful2355 · 24/02/2023 12:37

May have been said in a wrong way but actually I agree with him

VictorStrand · 24/02/2023 12:36

I agree with the PP about the toxic websites. You just need to read some of the posts on here to see how much misinformation exists and how insidious it is. People are completely misunderstanding history, feminism, the labour market, - opting instead for a hugely sexist interpretation that blames everything on women and feminism - even though they clearly haven't read a single feminist theory or a single history book about the women's rights movement.

Your DH wanted to avoid any discussion about expectations on him. And funnily enough all the posters on here who know nothing about feminism (except that it's to blame for all the world's ills Hmm ) are harking back to a halycon time where women stayed home ... but aren't remembering that in any household with strict gender roles, your DH would have been responsible for renovation work and would have been expected to be the highest earner. He's not fulfilling any of his traditional roles.

Groutyonehereagain · 24/02/2023 12:35

My grandfather had that view. “Women should stay at home to look after the house and the children, then there would be more jobs for men and women don’t want to work anyway and they don’t even need a good education.”

Such outdated crap! I’m shocked that your DH thinks like my grandfather did @SandroSandra .

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:34

@RemoteControlDoobry

'The ideal situation surely would be that one half of the couple stayed at home making the home beautiful and creating a relaxing environment for everyone.'

Absolutely not my ideal.

Could not think of anything worse

Botw1 · 24/02/2023 12:33

@Mark19735

Except its bullshit that you can't work 1.5 jobs.

He doesn't get to decide that he doesn't want to do the. 5

He lives in the house, he agreed to enter into family life

The. 5 is as much his responsibility as hers and he doesn't get to absolve himself from it

Ladybug14 · 24/02/2023 12:32

Hope551 · 24/02/2023 10:49

I'd tell him, he better get a better paying job then to provide and be a proper man to make it viable. 😂

This. Although much more than this.

What a fucking bellend

His wife has to work because he doesn't earn enough

Wanker