Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So Camilla is Queen now?

269 replies

cakeorwine · 24/02/2023 07:10

Headlines in the papers talking about what the Queen said yesterday at a reception.

I thought we had a King and a Queen Consort.

Phillip wasn't a King.

AIBU to think calling Camilla the Queen instead of the Queen Consort is going too far?

OP posts:
Sceptic1234 · 24/02/2023 15:56

....had not been set out....

Sceptic1234 · 24/02/2023 15:56

MidgeHardcastle · 24/02/2023 15:29

William III was in the line of succession anyway so I assume that was why he was asked. His mother was the eldest daughter of Charles I.

Mary was above him in the line of succession, daughter of james stewart. However, the rules of succession had been set out then so the question of who had precedence is really arbitrary. William arrived with an army and could have fought to claim the crown for himself, the "joint monarchs" thing was a compromise solution to keep the peace (at least in England). Once William and Mary were installed the rules of succession were formalised so it was clear who could / could not be king / queen.

The Stewarts were not happy with this and made two big attempts to come back and claim their throne by violence. Quite strange to think we'd have an entirely different king if they'd succeeded.

BigMadAdrian · 24/02/2023 15:44

She is queen - the wife of a king.

QEII was queen regnant - Camilla is queen consort - both are referred to as ‘the queen’. Kate will also be ‘the queen’ when William ascends the throne, but I bet far fewer people will Moab about that.

Guis · 24/02/2023 15:39

She is a Queen consort. But as is the way of things, I am sure over time it will be dropped. It is easier to just say Queen.

Kinneddar · 24/02/2023 15:34

AIBU to think calling Camilla the Queen instead of the Queen Consort is going too far

A step too far?? No it's the title she should be using as wife of the Monarch

I think the Consort part has been used initially while we get used to the new Monarchy. I know for the first few months after her death I still thought of QEII when anyone mentioned the Queen.

Its time the Consort bit was dropped, it always has been in the past

MidgeHardcastle · 24/02/2023 15:29

William III was in the line of succession anyway so I assume that was why he was asked. His mother was the eldest daughter of Charles I.

TangledWebOfDeception · 24/02/2023 15:27

Sorry, one way and the other at once! Not getting my words out today but in my defence I do have an excuse as I’m not well.

TangledWebOfDeception · 24/02/2023 15:26

Surely by that reasoning all of it is fabricated rubbish, which was my point. Your premise is flawed. It’s either all made up nonsense, or it’s valid within the system. You can’t really have it one way or the other...

Hont1986 · 24/02/2023 15:20

Nah, it's made up. It's based on a flawed premise, that someone has a birthright to rule a country. In reality, the King and Queen is whoever the army says it is. At the moment they say it is Philip, so he gets to wear the fancy hat, good for him, and his wife is considered to be a/the Queen. All the rest of it, royal stylings and titles and so on, is fabricated rubbish, and I recommend that OP doesn't get too fussed about it.

TangledWebOfDeception · 24/02/2023 15:09

Regnant and Consort definitely means something (I mean if we work on the assumption that King means something and Queen means something...).

Queen in her own right is an important distinction, and certainly not arbitrary!

ArcaneWireless · 24/02/2023 15:06

YABU.

YABMU for starting a frothy thread.

Hont1986 · 24/02/2023 15:03

She's married to a King so she's a Queen. Everything else, regnant and consort and dowager and all that bollocks, is just arbitrary styling for a bunch of made-up titles.

Hbh17 · 24/02/2023 14:52

She has been Queen Camilla or The Queen since the day that Queen Elizabeth II died.
But I think Queen Consort was used initially to avoid confusion as "The Queen" still only meant one person to all of us.
But as time passes, of course the clumsy Queen Consort thing will be dropped. Camilla is the wife of The King - therefore she is The Queen.
Oh, and she is fabulous!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/02/2023 14:49

Yousee · 24/02/2023 14:37

Maybe Camilla should have been known by her most senior title all these years. She was Camilla, Princess of Wales. And now her husband is King, she is known as Queen Camilla, not Duchess of Edinburgh or another more junior title, some people seem rather put out.

Being pedantic - she was HRH The Princess of Wales.

Camilla, Princess of Wales suggests the divorced wife of the POW (as Diana was post divorce).

Technically Camilla (and Catherine, Sophie etc) didn’t use her first name in any title from marriage until she became HM Queen Camilla.

Nanny0gg · 24/02/2023 14:43

cakeorwine · 24/02/2023 07:10

Headlines in the papers talking about what the Queen said yesterday at a reception.

I thought we had a King and a Queen Consort.

Phillip wasn't a King.

AIBU to think calling Camilla the Queen instead of the Queen Consort is going too far?

Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother was always just Queen Elizabeth when her husband was still alive.

LolaSmiles · 24/02/2023 14:40

I thought she was going to be Queen Camilla because she's the wife of a King.

Queen Elizabeth was a queen regnant, ranking equivalent to king.

Queen Camilla is a queen consort because she is the wife of a king.

ConfusedNT · 24/02/2023 14:37

Sceptic1234 · 24/02/2023 14:13

This was done for a specific reason
.... the Stewart dynasty had run out of non catholic heirs. Cant remember which monarch was which, but parliment declared that James Stewart could not be King as he was a catholic. Also....he would have ruled as an absolute monarch, and parliment had acquired powers that it was reluctant to give up.

William came from Holland and he and Mary ruled as joint protestant monarchs, but accepted the authority of parliment.

Effectively we kicked out one king and replaced him with a joint King / Queen. The laws governing how the crown was to be passed on were formalised (which prevented future wars of succession) and Britain became a constitutional monarchy. The "non violent, Glorious Revolution". Although, as Lucy Worsely said so beautifully, the revolution was anything but non violent and glorious if you happened to be Scotish or Irish!

That's really interesting thank you, I've not done a whole lot of reading around this specific period of time in history but I think I am going to now off the back of this

I really appreciate you taking the time to explain it

Yousee · 24/02/2023 14:37

Maybe Camilla should have been known by her most senior title all these years. She was Camilla, Princess of Wales. And now her husband is King, she is known as Queen Camilla, not Duchess of Edinburgh or another more junior title, some people seem rather put out.

Sceptic1234 · 24/02/2023 14:13

ConfusedNT · 24/02/2023 10:14

I didn't know that, I wonder why that couldn't have been done for Philip?

Although I would have been concerned if I were her that although he still wouldnt have outrank her, in some places and with some people they would have acted like he did just because he was referred to as King

This was done for a specific reason
.... the Stewart dynasty had run out of non catholic heirs. Cant remember which monarch was which, but parliment declared that James Stewart could not be King as he was a catholic. Also....he would have ruled as an absolute monarch, and parliment had acquired powers that it was reluctant to give up.

William came from Holland and he and Mary ruled as joint protestant monarchs, but accepted the authority of parliment.

Effectively we kicked out one king and replaced him with a joint King / Queen. The laws governing how the crown was to be passed on were formalised (which prevented future wars of succession) and Britain became a constitutional monarchy. The "non violent, Glorious Revolution". Although, as Lucy Worsely said so beautifully, the revolution was anything but non violent and glorious if you happened to be Scotish or Irish!

MrsClatterbuck · 24/02/2023 13:40

MidgeHardcastle · 24/02/2023 07:13

King Edward VII and Queen Alexandra
King George V and Queen Mary
King George VI and Queen Elizabeth

THIS IN SPADES

Queen is the title and consort is the job description

LaMarschallin · 24/02/2023 13:35

Same as HM Queen Mary and HM Queen Alexandra were after being widowed.

Queen Mary was always "old Queen Mary" to my mother; as a child, I actually thought that was part of her title.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/02/2023 13:06

FeinCuroxiVooz · 24/02/2023 09:31

it's totally normal for the "consort" to be dropped. it would only be necessary if needing to distinguish between her and any other nearby queens. we used to have "Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth and Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother" which set me wondering what Camilla's title will be when Charles is dead and William is king, with Queen Katherine. Is "Dowager Queen" a thing?

Dowager Queen is a thing, but unless William marries a new wife called Camilla it won’t be necessary. She’ll just be HM Queen Camilla. Same as HM Queen Mary and HM Queen Alexandra were after being widowed.

The onky change will be that she would no longer be HM The Queen, which she is at the moment as the King’s wife.

The only time Dowager, Queen Mother PE Consort are used is too differentiate between people. Mary and Alexandra were Queen Mothers but never needed to use the title. The only QEQM did was because her daughter had the same name.

That’s the only reason consort is being used sometimes atm. It would have been confusing if the BBC had announced that “King Charles will return to London tomorrow accompanied by the Queen. Princess Anne will accompany her mother’s body on the return to London” for example.

once people get into the way of thinking that HM The Queen = Camilla the consort bit will vanish.

JenniferBarkley · 24/02/2023 12:48

Yes I can't imagine many of those demanding that Camilla retain "Consort" in her title will be calling for the same when it's Kate's turn, nor that they would have been for Diana.

ConfusedNT · 24/02/2023 12:47

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/02/2023 12:40

Because its a woman, a 'fallen' woman at that in some peoples eyes so obviously it's dar to inconvenient for them if they can instead insist on calling her consort to emphasise her lesser status

Consort just means wife of the king, as opposed to Queen Regnant, i.e ruling in her own right. It isn't a lesser title because she didn't give birth to the heir to the throne, it isn't a lesser title because she's a 'fallen woman,' it's because she's the wife of the king and Queen Consort is her official title - which will no doubt be dropped in time once everyone's got used to the fact we now have a king, not a queen regnant.

I'm copying and pasting my answer to a different poster below so I appreciate some of it doesn't apply to your post but it's essentially the same thing

*I know she would be a queen consort regardless

But as you say, it's the unhinged Diana worshipers that seem to be so focused in her being 'consort'

Hence my point it's because she is a 'fallen' woman so they want to try to make her sound lesser by insisting on the consort bit being used because they think it makes her sound less that Queen would by itself

I understand the press using it to start off with to make things less confusing but I am talking about the people now who are adamant it should remain Queen Consort because otherwise its 'going too far'

The only way it can be going too far is if those people think Queen sounds 'more' than Queen consort - hence they want her to have the 'lesser' title*

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 24/02/2023 12:40

Because its a woman, a 'fallen' woman at that in some peoples eyes so obviously it's dar to inconvenient for them if they can instead insist on calling her consort to emphasise her lesser status

Consort just means wife of the king, as opposed to Queen Regnant, i.e ruling in her own right. It isn't a lesser title because she didn't give birth to the heir to the throne, it isn't a lesser title because she's a 'fallen woman,' it's because she's the wife of the king and Queen Consort is her official title - which will no doubt be dropped in time once everyone's got used to the fact we now have a king, not a queen regnant.