Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most parents would be unhappy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice?

190 replies

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 06:44

schoolsweek.co.uk/dfe-developing-teaching-apprenticeship-for-non-graduates/

The DfE are developing an apprentice scheme for teaching for people without degrees.

I think there are some serious problems with this idea, but this isn't about those, really.

I'm just thinking about the attitude that some posters have towards NQTs (IE they don't want their child taught by them) and I'm curious as to what posters think.

In terms of voting, I'd like people to vote not on whether they think it's a good idea overall, but just on whether they would be happy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice who's just left college/sixth form.

YABU - I would be happy with this for my children.
YANBU- I would not be happy with this for my children.

I do assume at least at the start, it would be under the supervision of an experienced teacher, hopefully with them in the classroom full time. But to make it viable for schools the apprentice would likely have to be unsupervised at least some of the time pretty quickly. I do think it would be much more involved than initial placements on primary teaching degrees AND this specifically targeting secondary level.

OP posts:
DrHousecuredme · 24/02/2023 07:32

I'd love to see a scheme where a good LSA/TA without a degree could stay in the classroom and be an apprentice teacher.
So many of them are amazing but don't get the opportunity to develop due to not having a degree.

HedwigIsMyDemon · 24/02/2023 07:30

It’s a desperate attempt to get new teachers. My DC are frequently taught by supply teachers with no relevant qualifications in the subject - it’s just an adult in the classroom to stop all hell breaking out. State education is fucked but what do this bunch of Tory toffs care?

LolaSmiles · 24/02/2023 07:29

I don't like the idea because I don't believe for one second it's being done in the children's best interest and that the government will ensure it's high quality training.

They've already removed the right of children to a qualified teacher and classes are already being taught by whoever they can get in a room, regardless of specialism or qualifications.

Certain academy chains are already very corporate in their approved approach and already have a monopoly on job based ITT.

This poster hits the nail on the head:
I agree with teachers who are less knowledgeable about educational theory being unable to argue with management. Drones.

If you're only trained in your academy chains method, delivering centrally dictated PowerPoint and plans from several layers of 'directors of...' in central management, then you're not going to have the broad knowledge to ask questions.

All I can say is I doubt the children of MPs will be subjected to the narrowing curriculum, revolving door of teachers, teachers without relevant degrees or industry experience.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 07:29

Mumof1andacat · 24/02/2023 07:08

So how do you expect young people to start a career?

I'd expect them to go to university and get a teaching qualification, or get a teaching qualification after their degree which is the current route now....

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 24/02/2023 07:27

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/02/2023 07:12

There has been no such thing as 'teacher training college' since the 1970s but you are correct that a student doing an Education degree at university will be in the classroom in their first year. They would, however, be under supervision at all times.

I'm not in favour of teachers learning entirely on the job though as they will be learning only the ways of that school which, in some Academies, can be questionable imo. Its better to have studied the subject at University with a broader knowledge of philosophies of education etc and then apply them in practice.

that is ridiculously pedantic - any teacher training university department is called a "teacher training college", just like any doctor training university department is called a "medical school"

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 07:26

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 24/02/2023 07:14

When this question came up before, you could hear the laughter of all of us teaching graduates who were at Uni & in the classroom at 18/19 in the first year of our degree!

Teaching is a vocational qualification. There is absolutely no substitute for a student to have practical learning experience in a classroom.

As I’ve said before, DS’s Dad is an old sod who did his BEd specialising in secondary teaching (back when it was possible in the old days). Being born in July, at his first placement in October, in a secondary school, he would’ve been just 18.

See, I would have major concerns about that.

BEd routes into secondary are very rare and I don't know any schools with sixth forms who take BEd trainees.

And the placements on the first year of a BEd degree are different to being in a school full time.

OP posts:
Changechangechanging · 24/02/2023 07:26

its no different to "teach first" or "now teach"

erm….yes, it’s different. Those people have a degree for a start.

FeinCuroxiVooz · 24/02/2023 07:25

I would have no problem with it at all at primary level.

In senior school I would be fine with an apprentice who got an A at A-Level in a particular subject teaching that subject in y7-9 but would be very unhappy if they were being taught at that age by someone who either didn't have an A-level in that subject or had a low grade. For GCSE and A-Level classes I would feel being degree-qualified is indispensable. Not just for the more in-depth understanding of the subject (I know that fully qualified teachers are licenced to teach in any subject not just their degree subject) but for the independent study skills and additional experience of complex learning that ensures the teacher is definitely well ahead of the students they are teaching.

When my mum became a teacher, it was possible to become a teacher without any teaching qualifications at all if you held a masters degree in any subject. she didn't want to do a PGCE so did an MA on a subject she was genuinely interested in, and was then considered sufficiently qualified despite no knowing a thing about education theory of learning techniques that might be the syllabus for a formal teaching qualifications.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 07:24

MaryShelley1818 · 24/02/2023 07:02

Can only see this as a huge positive! It's the ideal type of job that lends itself to an apprenticeship, which has a far more extensive and challenging workload than the traditional route. I'm unclear why you think the apprenticeship will be 19 though?

I'm just coming to the end of my Social Work Degree Apprenticeship. I'm 44 and there are 30 of us in the group, don't think any are under 25 with ages mostly being 30/40/50's. We cover everything academically that the traditional Degree route covers plus about 30% more work due to the Apprenticeship side. We generally have a huge amount of experience and expertise between us, I worked in Children's Services for almost 10yrs prior, plus another 15yrs experience of working with children and families. This is also my second degree.

I'm thinking a lot of people who oppose don't understand the Degree Apprenticeship route.

I don't think all the apprentices would be young, I'm sure some would be older.

But I think it's very likely some of the candidates would be younger and schools wouldn't be allowed to discriminate on the basis of age.

In secondary, I genuinely do think having people work there who are only a little older than the oldest students raises issues for everyone, and this is a major part of my concern.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 07:22

Nimbostratus100 · 24/02/2023 07:02

its no different to "teach first" or "now teach"

Well it is, because those people have a degree and are therefore nearly always at least 22 when they start.

A significant part of my concern is the potential lack of age gap (and maturity) in secondary.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 07:20

JodiePants · 24/02/2023 07:02

It would be under the supervision of a qualified teacher, just like it is when people are training for via PGCE or BEd. Many of those on a BEd course would be 18 and 19 as well. I have trained many student teachers over the years and had a teacher apprentice before I went on maternity leave (albeit one with a degree) and she had all her planning checked and taught under my supervision. If anything, the children in my class benefitted from having two adults teaching them. My concern is more for the apprentices who would do all the work to become a teacher but would not have the same level of qualification which could put them at a disadvantage when looking for jobs here and would unlikely be able to teach abroad.

You are assuming this, but how would that be viable for schools?

People who do salaried routes are not supervised in the same way.

BEd degrees aren't used widely at secondary level - part of my concern is the lack of age gap.

OP posts:
Singleandproud · 24/02/2023 07:18

At the moment children are taught by people without a traditional teaching degrees all the time suchas TAs, cover supervisors and unqualified teachers you just aren't aware of it.

I taught as an unqualified teacher for years having started as a TA although I do have a degree, my department were supportive and I had more regular lesson observations and feedback than other teaching staff, in the end I decided not to go into teaching. However being in the workplace gave me a more realistic understanding of what teaching required instead of those who go straight back to the classroom from Uni with a mountain of student debt (I still have student debt but didn't fork out for a PGCE) then leave before the end of their training which is happening frequently. I enjoyed the teaching part of the job but left for a job with better work-life balance. Teaching lends itself well to work based learning providing the apprentice has time off timetable to catch up and cover their own training too.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 07:17

Those saying it would be under the supervision of a qualified teacher, I don't think it would be viable for schools to pay someone an apprenticeship wage and have a class teacher in the class too full time.

Accademies and free schools don't have to have a qualified teacher in front of the class. There's nothing that necessarily says the apprentice would be supervised all the time.

With current ITT routes, the provider sets requirements for supervision. In the case of paid routes such as teach first, the trainee is often left unsupervised pretty quickly. But at least they are in their 20s and have a degree.

In terms of TAs teaching, yes HLTAs especially teach a lot BUT they have experience and are older. Part of the issue for me is the potential lack of age gap between the students and the apprentice.

If you read the article this is specifically targeting secondary level.

OP posts:
CaptainMyCaptain · 24/02/2023 07:16

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/02/2023 07:16

I agree with teachers who are less knowledgeable about educational theory being unable to argue with management. Drones.

Missing full stop after 'agree'. Sorry.

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/02/2023 07:16

Everydayimhuffling · 24/02/2023 06:53

It's a way of further devaluing teaching. It won't be a profession, just a poorly paid job along with the rest of childcare. You can guarantee that these apprentices won't be in the schools of the MPs kids.

I agree with teachers who are less knowledgeable about educational theory being unable to argue with management. Drones.

Edumacator · 24/02/2023 07:15

There are currently education degrees where 18yo are teaching in a classroom. The only difference with the apprentice is that they don’t get an academic qualification in the theory of education as a discipline, which is, to be frank, absolute codswallop voodoo bullshit anyway.

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 24/02/2023 07:14

When this question came up before, you could hear the laughter of all of us teaching graduates who were at Uni & in the classroom at 18/19 in the first year of our degree!

Teaching is a vocational qualification. There is absolutely no substitute for a student to have practical learning experience in a classroom.

As I’ve said before, DS’s Dad is an old sod who did his BEd specialising in secondary teaching (back when it was possible in the old days). Being born in July, at his first placement in October, in a secondary school, he would’ve been just 18.

calimali · 24/02/2023 07:14

So the work of the universities and teacher training tutors is to be dumped on teachers. How do they expect teachers to find the time to train these apprentices? I help to train many PGCE teachers over the years - and that was very time consuming and difficult to juggle along side my full time teaching. There is no way I could have trained an apprentice.

I can foresee these apprentices being used in place of qualified teachers in front of classes. Not good.

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/02/2023 07:12

Swiftswatch · 24/02/2023 06:47

It’s not really much different to now though is it?
If you attend a teacher training college you will be in a classroom during that time.
If you do a PGC you will be in the classroom after your standard degree but those 21 and 22 year olds are equally inexperienced.

There has been no such thing as 'teacher training college' since the 1970s but you are correct that a student doing an Education degree at university will be in the classroom in their first year. They would, however, be under supervision at all times.

I'm not in favour of teachers learning entirely on the job though as they will be learning only the ways of that school which, in some Academies, can be questionable imo. Its better to have studied the subject at University with a broader knowledge of philosophies of education etc and then apply them in practice.

Sindonym · 24/02/2023 07:12

I think it’s a great option.

I recently retrained (have degree & postgrad degrees) and had to do yet another undergrad (& take on a student loan - I really really really wanted to retrain). The profession I retrained in has just started to develop degree apprenticeships & I absolutely would have taken that option over returning to uni.

My youngest doesn’t want to go to uni. I suspect he’ll end up doing a degree apprenticeship or employer sponsored OU type approach eventually.

Hard to recruit/retain professions do tend to have multiple ways to train. Teaching, social work, nursing spring to mind.

Mumof1andacat · 24/02/2023 07:08

So how do you expect young people to start a career?

Iamnotthe1 · 24/02/2023 07:07

DorisParchment · 24/02/2023 07:06

I would absolutely do this as a second career in my 50s! I don’t have a degree but have quite a lot of tutoring experience and have got kids through their MFL GCSEs. Why would someone with a degree in something modern and useless like Mime be any better as a teacher than someone with a lot of life experience?

Given current rules and regulations, you could already teach in any academy or free school if they wished to employ you. You don't need a degree nor a teaching qualification.

DorisParchment · 24/02/2023 07:06

I would absolutely do this as a second career in my 50s! I don’t have a degree but have quite a lot of tutoring experience and have got kids through their MFL GCSEs. Why would someone with a degree in something modern and useless like Mime be any better as a teacher than someone with a lot of life experience?

neverendinglauaundry · 24/02/2023 07:06

In primary school maybe. For a GCSE class, no.

MaryShelley1818 · 24/02/2023 07:05

PinkPantherPaws · 24/02/2023 07:00

I think it's fine for Primary teachers.

Learning the skills of teaching is far more important than the content IMO - you don't need to be degree educated to understand the content at primary level.

At secondary level I don't see how it would work at all.

It's a Degree Apprenticeship. They study the exact same degree PLUS additional work as part of the Apprenticeship.

Swipe left for the next trending thread