Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most parents would be unhappy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice?

190 replies

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 06:44

schoolsweek.co.uk/dfe-developing-teaching-apprenticeship-for-non-graduates/

The DfE are developing an apprentice scheme for teaching for people without degrees.

I think there are some serious problems with this idea, but this isn't about those, really.

I'm just thinking about the attitude that some posters have towards NQTs (IE they don't want their child taught by them) and I'm curious as to what posters think.

In terms of voting, I'd like people to vote not on whether they think it's a good idea overall, but just on whether they would be happy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice who's just left college/sixth form.

YABU - I would be happy with this for my children.
YANBU- I would not be happy with this for my children.

I do assume at least at the start, it would be under the supervision of an experienced teacher, hopefully with them in the classroom full time. But to make it viable for schools the apprentice would likely have to be unsupervised at least some of the time pretty quickly. I do think it would be much more involved than initial placements on primary teaching degrees AND this specifically targeting secondary level.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 24/02/2023 09:17

Well MIL, who has a June birthday went to Homerton to do the two year teaching cert in 1954. She was barely 20 when she started teaching. She also knew the positions of the x and y axes, how to spell and is a grammar nut - unlike some of the degree educated 30 to 40 year old who taught my DC at an outstanding primary.

DD who is 24, got a job as a TA the September after graduating and was swiftly promoted to unqualified teacher and is doing her teaching quals on the job through the apprentice route. It's a secondary school. She had a pile of Christmas cards from parents thanking her for the support given to their children.

creekingmillenial · 24/02/2023 09:12

Depends on the apprentice!
BEd placement students might not be much older for primary.
I’d reserve my judgement for if they were any good.

KittyTitty · 24/02/2023 09:10

Nothing wrong with this. They’ll be degree educated by the end of it. Makes me laugh as there’s LOTS of unqualified teachers these days without degrees but it doesn’t create quite such a fuss on here.

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 24/02/2023 09:08

I think highly skilled joiners are probably better teaching woodwork than someone with a degree in teaching, it is subject dependent, I think you need a physics degree to teach high school physics, academic subjects a degree, practical subjects not so much

multicolouredbunting · 24/02/2023 09:08

@Appuskidu she has a degree but not in any field that would be anywhere close to education of children or young people. Not even a relevant teaching subject for a say, a secondary school teacher. Has zero experience of working with children, has no children etc etc. walked into a teacher training year because she has a degree and five months in realised she hates it.

Hope551 · 24/02/2023 09:04

I don't mind at all. Age and a degree isn't always an indicator of a good teacher. I'd rather they had a screening or assessment to make sure they are sound of mind or something.

If it's the right person for the job I'm happy. I'd rather a kind loving personality guiding my child's interests and supporting them than an intelligent person who would upset them constantly and thinks the cane should be back in haha.

Also a mix of student teachers and older would be ideal. Therefore there's more chance the kids would find a person they relate too. I like diversity

Appuskidu · 24/02/2023 09:01

My sil on the other hand is a teacher, no relevant degree in childcare

Degree in childcare?!

multicolouredbunting · 24/02/2023 08:59

I'd of gone into teaching if I had this route available to me when I left school. Instead I've worked in multiple day nurseries and playgroups.

I'm now a sahm working towards my degree via home learning. I'd love to teach but now my family comes first and the idea of still having to go through a pgce year is putting me off and I'm just looking at alternative job opportunities I can go straight into.

My sil on the other hand is a teacher , no relevant degree in childcare, (in another subject entirely) but had done her years teacher training, absolutely hates it. Wonders why she ever got into teaching.

I think this way you'd weed out the teachers who it really didn't enjoy it, quite early on and the ones who were doing it for the love of teaching would continue.

Appuskidu · 24/02/2023 08:54

Anyone who thinks this will be a well run scheme with schools being given enough funding and experienced teachers being given enough release time to support an apprentice to gradually gain the skills and experience to be a teacher on the job is being utterly naive.

I would imagine that we won’t have a Conservative government for very much longer though, and this will allquietly be dropped.

If whoever is in government started to seriously look at reducing workload-and remove or significantly reform Ofsted, they might find the recruitment and retention issues in teaching can be resolved. Then, we can keep the teachers we have (and maybe even get back some that have left) rather than just creating a stream of non-graduate fodder for Year 9 to eat alive until they completely burn out and leave.

ilovesooty · 24/02/2023 08:50

Iamnotthe1 · 24/02/2023 07:07

Given current rules and regulations, you could already teach in any academy or free school if they wished to employ you. You don't need a degree nor a teaching qualification.

Exactly. Some parents are unaware of this or don't care as long as there's someone with a pulse available to child mind their offspring

Runningonempty01 · 24/02/2023 08:44

Sounds great, my daughter is considering teaching. She is working at the moment, had very good A level results. If she went to university it would be to a redbrick/ Russell group one. If she decides on primary school teaching a degree level apprenticeship would be financially a far better option than a degree with QTS or a degree+ a pgce.

borntobequiet · 24/02/2023 08:42

Sindonym · 24/02/2023 06:55

TBh I suspect career changers will use the apprenticeship route more than school leavers.

That’s what I thought.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/02/2023 08:40

Everydayimhuffling · 24/02/2023 06:53

It's a way of further devaluing teaching. It won't be a profession, just a poorly paid job along with the rest of childcare. You can guarantee that these apprentices won't be in the schools of the MPs kids.

Did you read the link? It's a degree apprenticeship so after the course they will have a degree, the same as any other teacher

Lisbeth50 · 24/02/2023 08:39

PinkPantherPaws · Today 07:00

I think it's fine for Primary teachers.

Learning the skills of teaching is far more important than the content IMO - you don't need to be degree educated to understand the content at primary level.

At secondary level I don't see how it would
work at all.

As a primary school teacher, your expertise is the way young children learn and develop not the subject specific content of the primary curriculum. It never ceases to amaze me how little people understand this, often despite having children themselves.

Spendonsend · 24/02/2023 08:36

In principle, a well structured degree apprenticship where the trainee has lots of support isnt a terrible idea. They would have a degree and qts by the end of the course just like any other teacher and presumably would be a trainee until that point. But i know it wont be well supported and would be cheap labour and I expect quite time consuming for other teachers in the school to support

GordonShakespearedoesChristmas · 24/02/2023 08:35

There's already an Apprenticeship route into teaching 14+, so this is just an expansion of that.
The teachers I had in the 60s were not degree educated, but they were passionate teachers who were good at their jobs.
Oh, and Apprentices can be any age whatsoever. From 16-67. So what makes you think they'll all be 19?

saraclara · 24/02/2023 08:34

Primary isn’t easy just because they are younger and the content is simple for us as adults.

Thank you @Iyjd . Coming from a secondary teacher, that's appreciated.
I taught complete with severe learning difficulties, and bizarrely I had someone think that that must be "even easier" than primary!

lljkk · 24/02/2023 08:30

5 days a week sole teacher doing lesson planning unsupported: No

3-4 hour spells on each of 2-3 days a week with colleague support in all areas, especially at primary age: Fine, good thing, even

Redebs · 24/02/2023 08:28

Crumpetdisappointment · 24/02/2023 07:58

when i was a 14 year old doing o levels, i english teach was 22
i had no idea of his youth.
he is now head of english and a lot older, as am i

I think you're confirming our concerns. 😟

Redebs · 24/02/2023 08:25

Everydayimhuffling · 24/02/2023 06:53

It's a way of further devaluing teaching. It won't be a profession, just a poorly paid job along with the rest of childcare. You can guarantee that these apprentices won't be in the schools of the MPs kids.

Nobody should be teaching without QTS, but they can't retain teachers, so have to look further afield for cannon-fodder

Iyjd · 24/02/2023 08:22

Nimbostratus100 · 24/02/2023 08:04

one hundred percent is in mine

It wasn’t in mine either

Iyjd · 24/02/2023 08:19

PinkPantherPaws · 24/02/2023 07:00

I think it's fine for Primary teachers.

Learning the skills of teaching is far more important than the content IMO - you don't need to be degree educated to understand the content at primary level.

At secondary level I don't see how it would work at all.

I’m a secondary teacher that did a primary placement. I would argue the opposite.

I know the content of my own subject from my GCSEs and A-levels because I have an interest in it. I could not switch to primary without some level of training because I couldn’t differentiate to that level and I would have no idea how to teach the basics of literacy and numeracy properly. Primary isn’t easy just because they are younger and the content is simple for us as adults.

barbrahunter · 24/02/2023 08:19

Iamnotthe1 · 24/02/2023 06:58

Recruitment in teaching has become so bad that initial teacher training providers are forced to accept candidates that would never have been allowed close to a classroom ten years ago. But at least those candidates have already studied successfully at degree level, if it's a PGCE or similar.

I could see the entry requirements for this being driven lower and lower, as has been the case for other routes into teaching, just so the DfE could try to meet their recruitment targets. As such, the quality of 18 year old thrown in front of your child's class could end up becoming truly dire.

agreed

LaPassegiata · 24/02/2023 08:19

It’s about lowering the standards and doing things cheaply. It’s happening in nursing too. Some barely literate nurses are graduating as the bar has become so low. It’s terrifying. The senior nurses I speak to are horrified. The same is happening in teaching.

Helenloveslee4eva · 24/02/2023 08:18

Reinventing the wheel time.

my dad (born 1923) worked in labs during the war and went to teacher training collage after.
hid best mate was in the RAF and because of that went straight into a school and trained “ on the job “ whilst being paid. Dad resented him not bring a “ proper teacher “😂

Whilst I feel 19is pretty young , i think with supervision it’ll work for the right kids.

as for “they won’t be teaching the children of mps “ I suspect most people don’t know that private schools are free to employ people with no teaching qualification at all ! My PhD historian kid has been interviews for some 6th form posts in private schools ( didn’t get cos no experience but they were willing to consider )