Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most parents would be unhappy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice?

190 replies

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 06:44

schoolsweek.co.uk/dfe-developing-teaching-apprenticeship-for-non-graduates/

The DfE are developing an apprentice scheme for teaching for people without degrees.

I think there are some serious problems with this idea, but this isn't about those, really.

I'm just thinking about the attitude that some posters have towards NQTs (IE they don't want their child taught by them) and I'm curious as to what posters think.

In terms of voting, I'd like people to vote not on whether they think it's a good idea overall, but just on whether they would be happy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice who's just left college/sixth form.

YABU - I would be happy with this for my children.
YANBU- I would not be happy with this for my children.

I do assume at least at the start, it would be under the supervision of an experienced teacher, hopefully with them in the classroom full time. But to make it viable for schools the apprentice would likely have to be unsupervised at least some of the time pretty quickly. I do think it would be much more involved than initial placements on primary teaching degrees AND this specifically targeting secondary level.

OP posts:
brilll · 25/02/2023 09:23

@Hobbi which other professions have so much influence on children's futures? I believe that at secondary schools the responsibility for higher education or careers guidance extends far beyond the designated careers teacher. It is a collective responsibility. The wider the range of experience the better.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 09:20

Serialcatmum · 24/02/2023 21:59

Fun fact. Not all teachers have a degree nowadays. They are qualified teachers. A degree isn’t everything. 😊

Fun fact. This is nonsense.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 09:17

brilll · 25/02/2023 08:54

I wouldn't mind for primary, so long as the apprentice had high grades (7+) for Maths, English and Science GCSE's and a spread of good passes at A level that included quantitative skills and evaluative writing skills. Sadly, many primary school teachers with degrees don't have those qualifications.

At secondary I would expect all teachers to have experience of higher education or an alternative pathway (including apprenticeship) outside of teaching. Otherwise they have spent their entire life in school and have no specialism to offer.

Which other professions should require you to have spent time in another job? Should medical professionals have done something else first? Accountants? If not, why not?

borntobequiet · 25/02/2023 09:01

By'older' , Born, I'm just unconvinced there are many people under even 60 with A levels but no degree any more

I met a quite a few when working in Apprenticeships. Some had started degree courses and dropped out, some hadn’t gone to University for personal or financial reasons, some had pursued alternative lifestyles and fallen into their current employment by chance. Meeting these people was a fascinating aspect of the job. For quite a while they had to gain Functional Maths and English as part of their apprenticeship because their original O level or GCSE had “expired” (this subsequently changed). Some, with their experience, skills and personal qualities might have made good teachers if a teaching apprenticeship had been available.

Fairislefandango · 25/02/2023 08:57

It's not the 19 year-old bit per se that I have a problem with, it's the lack of a degree and the devaluing of teaching, which is an important job which should done by respected, well-qualified professionals. Instead of trying to solve the issues which are driving thousands of experienced teachers out of the profession and also making new teachers quit after a couple of years (or sometimes straight after their training), the government is just cynically looking for ways of getting more and cheaper young cannon fodder. Quelle surprise.

brilll · 25/02/2023 08:54

I wouldn't mind for primary, so long as the apprentice had high grades (7+) for Maths, English and Science GCSE's and a spread of good passes at A level that included quantitative skills and evaluative writing skills. Sadly, many primary school teachers with degrees don't have those qualifications.

At secondary I would expect all teachers to have experience of higher education or an alternative pathway (including apprenticeship) outside of teaching. Otherwise they have spent their entire life in school and have no specialism to offer.

Appuskidu · 25/02/2023 08:46

I’m presuming this will be aimed at maths and physics posts. My DC’s school has so few teachers in either of those subjects that the departments are being held together by biology and business teachers. I can’t imagine for a minute that the few maths/physics teachers left have got a spare second in the day with which to ‘teach’ people who have only A levels themselves, how to be good maths teachers. I’m sure any of us that have been PGCE mentors know how much time/money/support we are given to do the role!

I would be very interested to know the entry grades needed and the salary they’d be on. If they want to teach A level maths, would they need an A*? Or would a B do? Would you need physics as well? I’m presuming they’d still have just three chances to pass the timed skills tests in maths/English like anyone else? Would they be on £15k? £25k? What if they hated it and left-would there be anything to pay back? Who would teach them the subject content of their degree? Mark their essays? Be their tutor?

I won’t spend any more time thinking about it though as I really can’t see it happening! I’m just intrigued to see if there actually is a plan or if it’s just desperate straw-clutching!

Crumpetdisappointment · 25/02/2023 08:39

Redebs · 24/02/2023 08:28

I think you're confirming our concerns. 😟

wow Shock
bit uncalled for
what a mean post

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 08:36

By'older' , Born, I'm just unconvinced there are many people under even 60 with A levels but no degree any more... I have been teaching for years and years and it's been a graduate profession since the 80s. Very few people since about 1992 ish have done A levels and not got a degree.

For those talking about unqualified teachers upthread. They don't have QTS. But they do have degrees.

I'm trying to get my head round what the subject component of the degree would be. I can only imagine English. I think it would include modules on YA and children's lit, a Shakespeare in education module, stuff on writing grammar. All of this exists in BA degrees but there should also be way more at a higher level of demand. It will be very narrow and utilitarian.

borntobequiet · 25/02/2023 08:25

I think it’s limited but there will be some older people who gained A levels but then passed on University for some reason and are expert in certain fields who could take up a teaching apprenticeship, for example lab technicians, people working in some aspects of IT (which isn’t as well paid as people think) and certain business roles.

PaigeMatthews · 25/02/2023 08:17

Malbecfan · 24/02/2023 21:56

I'm a teacher and don't see a problem with it for primary years. It's a bit different for A level where you do need specific knowledge, although what I studied in my degree and at school doesn't have a lot in common with the current GCSE or A level.

I want to put another perspective. DD at 22 started her PhD at Cambridge. She was asked if she wanted to supervise groups of 1st years in her subject. One of the 1st years was older than her. She is paid a set rate for prepping and delivering the supervisions (tutorials) which is comparable to that of an experienced qualified teacher. If it's good enough for Cambridge to have people who only studied that course 4 years ago teaching & supporting, why not a 19 year old in a primary classroom with an experienced teacher alongside?

But your daughter has a degree. In that subject. That’s the whole thread.

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 08:08

Yes, but he wasn't teaching classes full of children.

We have this too but they are never allowed anywhere near a class. The material has already been taught.

I think this is probably about capturing more mature entrants but I'm not sure where they are. The example of the SW degree apprenticeship is different : you don't need near expert knowledge in a specific subject in SW and aren't teaching that knowledge to others.

It's been a while now since most A level school leavers went to university. Where are the people with A levels in maths , physics, whatever but no degree who then decide they want to be teacher? This is not for career changers with relevant first degrees.

I can see , however, that they might think this is a way of harnessing people with A Levels in relevant subjects. That said, I bet loads of them won't.

We do have some young people in our school working with students (some interns doing a degree some recently qualified graduates earning a bit of money , and some sixth formers. The 18 year owls are under constant supervision . None of them work in groups bigger than 4 and none of them are actually teaching. None of our undergraduate summer interns with their A levels in maths, economics, MFL , physics have then gone on to teaching!

For those who think their DCs would like to be a teacher and are drawn to this route to save uni debt ... what happens if they change their mind and hate it?

MistyMooninabluesky · 25/02/2023 07:24

bruffin · 24/02/2023 09:22

when my DS stayed on in 6th form to retake A levels they used let him teach the occasional maths class, he also mentored the younger students in Maths

My DS taught remedial maths when he was in the 6th Form. He enjoyed helping younger pupils, was highly thought of by his teachers, the pupils did well and he had a lovely letter of thanks from the headmistress when he left.

borntobequiet · 25/02/2023 06:09

A 19 yo may have enthusiasm and energy that many older teachers disillusioned with the profession don't

They may. Of course, within a few years they too may become dispirited and disillusioned and leave, like so many have done already.

Olios · 25/02/2023 05:49

A 19 yo may have enthusiasm and energy that many older teachers disillusioned with the profession don't

ponyinmud · 24/02/2023 22:54

How many 19 year old would want to teach a roomful of kids?
Sounds an absolute disaster and just another way of dismantling state provision.

RuthW · 24/02/2023 22:09

Sounds a great idea.

Serialcatmum · 24/02/2023 21:59

Fun fact. Not all teachers have a degree nowadays. They are qualified teachers. A degree isn’t everything. 😊

Malbecfan · 24/02/2023 21:56

I'm a teacher and don't see a problem with it for primary years. It's a bit different for A level where you do need specific knowledge, although what I studied in my degree and at school doesn't have a lot in common with the current GCSE or A level.

I want to put another perspective. DD at 22 started her PhD at Cambridge. She was asked if she wanted to supervise groups of 1st years in her subject. One of the 1st years was older than her. She is paid a set rate for prepping and delivering the supervisions (tutorials) which is comparable to that of an experienced qualified teacher. If it's good enough for Cambridge to have people who only studied that course 4 years ago teaching & supporting, why not a 19 year old in a primary classroom with an experienced teacher alongside?

Winter41 · 24/02/2023 21:32

I don't know enough about primary training to comment. But I wouldn't be happy if it was secondary. They would not have anywhere near as much subject knowledge as a teacher with a degree in the subject they are teaching. Admittedly, many schools are already unable to have subject specialists teaching all classes and it does lead to lower standards.

noblegiraffe · 24/02/2023 21:11

Well, to be clear, the proposals suggest a degree is part of the training- so it's not like you could skip the degree level content entirely. It's just for 3 (?) years you could be teaching students with that level of content.

Who would be teaching the class while the apprentice is off learning degree level maths? Also teacher training plus degree is 4 years, so I guess the maths would be watered down?

Lostinalibrary · 24/02/2023 20:35

We already have some of the lowest academic and training requirements in the world for teachers. The fact people are happy with that and want to lower it further boggles the mind.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 20:03

Survey99 · 24/02/2023 12:48

Why would anyone need, for example, a STEM degree learning much more complex topics to then only teach A-level level content? If you obtain the grades to show competence at A level content and further embed that A level content learning through a well structured apprenticeship and on job training, I don't see the added value of the degree if the degree level complex topics are superfluous to the requirements of the role.

Well, to be clear, the proposals suggest a degree is part of the training- so it's not like you could skip the degree level content entirely. It's just for 3 (?) years you could be teaching students with that level of content.

But also, it wouldn't work. A bright A-level class would find you out if you didn't have any more subject knowledge than they did. Most A-level classes are obviously pretty compliant, but I have seen A-level classes turn on teachers they do not respect and it's not good for anyone.

The best case scenario is the students would just stop attending the lessons.

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 20:01

PeekAtYou · 24/02/2023 10:10

An 18 year old at university could be in the classroom too and I don't think that a uni student would necessarily be any better than an apprentice.
The cynic in me thinks that this is about paying teachers less long term. They desperately need teachers and creating them younger is a Hail Mary attempt to sort this out.

The difference is most likely the level of supervision and the length of time on the placement. There is a difference between an 8-12 week placement and being taught by that person all year...

The majority of BEd courses are primary, these days.

It is different, and there is no guarantee apprentices would be supervised in the same way.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 24/02/2023 18:38

My degree knowledge has come in handy when non-subject specialists start telling me how to teach and trying to tell me how to plan a curriculum.
The range of perspectives I gained on my PGCE come in handy when asking awkward questions to quickly promoted leaders who think their latest initiative, with additional workload, is the next big thing.

I can see why people of fast tracked management types who've left the classroom wouldn't want well educated and critically thinking classroom teachers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread