Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most parents would be unhappy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice?

190 replies

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 06:44

schoolsweek.co.uk/dfe-developing-teaching-apprenticeship-for-non-graduates/

The DfE are developing an apprentice scheme for teaching for people without degrees.

I think there are some serious problems with this idea, but this isn't about those, really.

I'm just thinking about the attitude that some posters have towards NQTs (IE they don't want their child taught by them) and I'm curious as to what posters think.

In terms of voting, I'd like people to vote not on whether they think it's a good idea overall, but just on whether they would be happy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice who's just left college/sixth form.

YABU - I would be happy with this for my children.
YANBU- I would not be happy with this for my children.

I do assume at least at the start, it would be under the supervision of an experienced teacher, hopefully with them in the classroom full time. But to make it viable for schools the apprentice would likely have to be unsupervised at least some of the time pretty quickly. I do think it would be much more involved than initial placements on primary teaching degrees AND this specifically targeting secondary level.

OP posts:
LadyGAgain · 25/02/2023 10:25

IME the LSA's are doing so much of the teaching these days. Poorly paid. DD's maths homework has been marked I correctly twice (same one which I challenged) by the LSA. Teacher was oblivious. Education system is failing for many reasons. Pay, lack of diversity in the curriculum, all attention on SEN so those children who are doing ok are largely ignored, tick box mentality. I feel for teachers and understand the strikes. This country is utterly fucked.

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 10:25

I love the idea some people have that these apprentice teachers (or nay teachers for that matter) has A*s in the A level they teach and 7+ in Eng/Maths. You think apprenticeships will set the bar higher than undergraduate degrees and PGCEs?

It's all about the warm bodies...

noblegiraffe · 25/02/2023 10:24

Gove in 2010 wanted all teachers to have at least a 2:2. They wanted to make teaching a masters level profession.

Now the Tories have got rid of the literacy and numeracy tests because that weeded out too many teachers who couldn't pass them, and they're also looking at trying to get people to train as teachers who haven't even got a degree. Bursaries have gone through the roof.

All these emergency provisions to try to shore up the training of teachers and nothing about trying to retain teachers once trained.

The announcement a few days ago that experienced teachers will, this September get another enormous pay cut is just the icing on the cake.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 10:23

Serialcatmum · 25/02/2023 10:06

@Hobbi id ask for a refund. You are wrong.

it’s an alternative route into teaching. You are a qualified teacher as long as you keep your membership with the SET in place as this ensures you have QTLS status.

You are given a QTS number once you’re employed in a school as a teacher.

i won’t be responding to your condescending messages again. I don’t care what YOU think you know I just wanted others to be aware ✌🏻

How can I get a refund for something I was paid to do? I said you mentioned a niche route, and you did. QTLS represents less than 4% of the potential workforce (only in the years it has existed) and isn't a qualification in its own right.

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 10:22

MelchiorsMistress · 25/02/2023 09:58

I can’t see how an apprentice on a good training programme would be worse than having completely unqualified TAs regularly teaching whole classes or groups which is currently what is happening in many primary schools.

I also think a teacher trained through an apprenticeship is likely to make a better teacher than one who did a media studies degree and a PGCE.

Even a media studies teacher??

Astounding subject snobbery there. Well done.

This person might even have A levels in , you know. English. Fat lot of use they'd be to teaching.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 10:19

Fairislefandango · 25/02/2023 10:11

There are too many primary teachers who are under confident at maths/science, or whose english grammar and spelling is poor.

Definitely. My dc used to correct their (lovely) primary teacher's spelling and grammar or tell me about mistakes he made. He was the Headteacher too (tiny primary)! I can't get too worked up about an otherwise good secondary school science or PE teacher not having impeccable SPaG, but when it's actually part of what you're supposed to be teaching children, it's really not ok.

It's not ok. That's why we need to attract the best candidates, as they do in countries with good education systems. We also need to recognise that we can't keep looking for quicker and cheaper routes into the job.

Fairislefandango · 25/02/2023 10:11

There are too many primary teachers who are under confident at maths/science, or whose english grammar and spelling is poor.

Definitely. My dc used to correct their (lovely) primary teacher's spelling and grammar or tell me about mistakes he made. He was the Headteacher too (tiny primary)! I can't get too worked up about an otherwise good secondary school science or PE teacher not having impeccable SPaG, but when it's actually part of what you're supposed to be teaching children, it's really not ok.

Fairislefandango · 25/02/2023 10:07

Surely the best way to learn to be a teacher is actually teaching - in the classroom? I'm not sure why teachers need a degree, other than maybe for knowing their subject well enough at secondary.

You add the last bit as though it's an unimportant afterthought Confused. Teachers need to be more qualified in their subject than the people they're teaching (including A Level students). They need mastery, depth and breadth in their subject. That is a separate element from the ability to manage behaviour, use different teaching methods etc, and you don't get it through teaching.

Serialcatmum · 25/02/2023 10:06

@Hobbi id ask for a refund. You are wrong.

it’s an alternative route into teaching. You are a qualified teacher as long as you keep your membership with the SET in place as this ensures you have QTLS status.

You are given a QTS number once you’re employed in a school as a teacher.

i won’t be responding to your condescending messages again. I don’t care what YOU think you know I just wanted others to be aware ✌🏻

Benjispruce4 · 25/02/2023 10:06

Absolutely agree @brilll .

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 10:03

MelchiorsMistress · 25/02/2023 09:58

I can’t see how an apprentice on a good training programme would be worse than having completely unqualified TAs regularly teaching whole classes or groups which is currently what is happening in many primary schools.

I also think a teacher trained through an apprenticeship is likely to make a better teacher than one who did a media studies degree and a PGCE.

It's not a good comparison. Good education administrations train teachers via an undergraduate program, recruiting the best candidates by making the profession attractive. A route that produces slightly better teachers than in a terrible situation is not the answer.

brilll · 25/02/2023 10:01

Benjispruce4 · 25/02/2023 09:49

I thought teaching hadn’t always required a degree. Didn’t there used to be teacher training colleges?

The thing is, the bar for getting a degree used to be higher. Now, the entry criteria for some degrees are so low that it isn't necessarily a good benchmark for the skills needed to teach core primary school subjects. There are too many primary teachers who are under confident at maths/science, or whose english grammar and spelling is poor. The entry criteria for teaching needs higher grades for these basics, more than it needs a degree.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 10:01

Serialcatmum · 25/02/2023 09:59

@Hobbi do your research before you tell someone what they’ve said is nonsense.

Look up QTLS status. Many teachers have achieved a diploma in teaching in the lifelong learning sector and have then completed the bridging assignment to gain QTLS.

No degree. Qualified teacher.

I would be surprised if my paid research in this area was inferior to yours. You are talking about a niche route, which doesn't lead to QTS.

Serialcatmum · 25/02/2023 09:59

@Hobbi do your research before you tell someone what they’ve said is nonsense.

Look up QTLS status. Many teachers have achieved a diploma in teaching in the lifelong learning sector and have then completed the bridging assignment to gain QTLS.

No degree. Qualified teacher.

MelchiorsMistress · 25/02/2023 09:58

I can’t see how an apprentice on a good training programme would be worse than having completely unqualified TAs regularly teaching whole classes or groups which is currently what is happening in many primary schools.

I also think a teacher trained through an apprenticeship is likely to make a better teacher than one who did a media studies degree and a PGCE.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 09:58

Benjispruce4 · 25/02/2023 09:49

I thought teaching hadn’t always required a degree. Didn’t there used to be teacher training colleges?

If you go back nearly 60 years you could find a non graduate approach. Your second question is a non sequitur.

Benjispruce4 · 25/02/2023 09:49

I thought teaching hadn’t always required a degree. Didn’t there used to be teacher training colleges?

Commah · 25/02/2023 09:47

This is about money. They want cheap teachers, not smart people with degrees who demand graduate salaries. They want people who don’t have better options and can’t earn more elsewhere, so they won’t leave. Quality of education is not being considered.

I don’t agree with teaching being de-professionalised. It’s going to lead to a two-tier education system where kids at state schools are taught by unqualified apprentices while private schools employ proper graduate teachers. And that will have a knock-on effect on social mobility. It’s also going to lead to a decline in living standards, because parents who previously would have been happy to send their kids to a state school, are now going to scrimp and scrape to afford a private school with proper teachers.

brilll · 25/02/2023 09:46

And why do you think primary teaching should be a profession suited for low qualified people?

I don't. Read my post. I don't think they nevessarily need a degree, but I said they need to be more highly qualified than many currently are in the subjects and skills they are teaching.

Lostinalibrary · 25/02/2023 09:46

The way in which people are able to dismiss primary is outstanding really. Primary age is where children are set up for their adult lives. Key milestones in development, teachers are expected to be experts across the whole curriculum and teach all subjects to a high standard. All of that whilst keeping the same children on track and focussed all day. That’s before you focus on the actual basics of learning to read/write/apply mathematics. Not anyone can just ‘do’ that.

In other countries, there is a reason that teachers are selected from the best of the best (used to be the case here). Where only the brightest grads are teachers and they study on average 5-7 years. Most other developed countries are a minimum masters and specific ed degree. We already have some of the lowest requirements to teach in the world because we are desperate.

How are parents happy with that accolade? This thread kind of proves what teacher say. Parents don’t care about their children’s education and they see primary as childcare. If parent’s cared, they’d be horrified at these proposals which is offering a poorer provision to children. It’s already in a state as it is, we are competing to have the lowest standards of entry into teaching throughout the world. 👏🏻

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 09:41

brilll · 25/02/2023 09:39

@Hobbi I suggest you work on your comprehension skills as I think you may have misread my post. I said they needed experience of higher education or another pathway, not both. I have no problem with a history grad going straight into teaching secondary history, and I have no problem with a non-graduate with relevant practical skills developed in the workplace going into teaching those skills either, but I do have a problem with a 19yo going straight into an apprenticeship for secondary school teaching.

And why do you think primary teaching should be a profession suited for low qualified people?

brilll · 25/02/2023 09:39

@Hobbi I suggest you work on your comprehension skills as I think you may have misread my post. I said they needed experience of higher education or another pathway, not both. I have no problem with a history grad going straight into teaching secondary history, and I have no problem with a non-graduate with relevant practical skills developed in the workplace going into teaching those skills either, but I do have a problem with a 19yo going straight into an apprenticeship for secondary school teaching.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 09:30

brilll · 25/02/2023 09:23

@Hobbi which other professions have so much influence on children's futures? I believe that at secondary schools the responsibility for higher education or careers guidance extends far beyond the designated careers teacher. It is a collective responsibility. The wider the range of experience the better.

I suggest you research what countries successful with successful education systems do. They want their teachers to be teachers only, a professional vocation, available only to the brightest and of a very high status. In Finland, they're not even very keen on training people who have other experience of working with children, same with Taiwan. There is zero evidence that having experience outside the classroom gives you any advantage at all. It's just cliched nonsense, intended to make people feel superior to teachers.

Fairislefandango · 25/02/2023 09:26

Not all teachers have a degree nowadays. They are qualified teachers.

Yes, but that doesn't mean we all agree they should be. There is nothing 'fun' about this fact.

Hobbi · 25/02/2023 09:23

Malbecfan · 24/02/2023 21:56

I'm a teacher and don't see a problem with it for primary years. It's a bit different for A level where you do need specific knowledge, although what I studied in my degree and at school doesn't have a lot in common with the current GCSE or A level.

I want to put another perspective. DD at 22 started her PhD at Cambridge. She was asked if she wanted to supervise groups of 1st years in her subject. One of the 1st years was older than her. She is paid a set rate for prepping and delivering the supervisions (tutorials) which is comparable to that of an experienced qualified teacher. If it's good enough for Cambridge to have people who only studied that course 4 years ago teaching & supporting, why not a 19 year old in a primary classroom with an experienced teacher alongside?

Of course, supporting undergraduates at Cambridge is exactly the same as taking bottom set year 9s on a Thursday afternoon. Or maybe it's so far removed as to be a ludicrous comparison. And your comment about primary teaching is patronising and very misinformed.