Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most parents would be unhappy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice?

190 replies

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 24/02/2023 06:44

schoolsweek.co.uk/dfe-developing-teaching-apprenticeship-for-non-graduates/

The DfE are developing an apprentice scheme for teaching for people without degrees.

I think there are some serious problems with this idea, but this isn't about those, really.

I'm just thinking about the attitude that some posters have towards NQTs (IE they don't want their child taught by them) and I'm curious as to what posters think.

In terms of voting, I'd like people to vote not on whether they think it's a good idea overall, but just on whether they would be happy with their child being taught by a 19yo apprentice who's just left college/sixth form.

YABU - I would be happy with this for my children.
YANBU- I would not be happy with this for my children.

I do assume at least at the start, it would be under the supervision of an experienced teacher, hopefully with them in the classroom full time. But to make it viable for schools the apprentice would likely have to be unsupervised at least some of the time pretty quickly. I do think it would be much more involved than initial placements on primary teaching degrees AND this specifically targeting secondary level.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Benjispruce4 · 26/02/2023 10:00

We have lost a couple of very experienced teachers. They were told there was no money in the budget for a pay increase. Then it became apparent that their replacements had been paid significantly more and were less experienced. Heads won’t pay more unless they absolutely have to. It’s shit.

Iamnotthe1 · 26/02/2023 09:57

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/02/2023 19:29

Can’t see why anyone so freshly out of the trainwreck that is a large number of secondary schools would want to go back in there as a zookeeper. Teaching isn’t an attractive career prospect. You’re not going to make it attractive by consistently lowering the bar for people to get into it.

Why isn’t the government looking at why there’s such an issue with retention of existing teachers, and doing something about that?

This government isn't interested in keeping existing teachers in education. That would require putting a reasonable level of investment into education, properly managing the workload and paying a comparable graduate wage. They don't want to do any of that.

Instead, they are focused on making it as easy as possible to become a teacher (or even just to fill the classroom). They believe that it doesn't matter if experienced people are leaving, or even if the drop out rate of new people is high: if you can throw enough bodies at the wheel to keep it turning, it's all good.

It honestly is a crime what this government has done to education in the 13 years they've been in power.

Changechangechanging · 26/02/2023 08:42

Teaching isn’t an attractive career prospect. You’re not going to make it attractive by consistently lowering the bar for people to get into it

This is key. What we need is better pay, clear and fair progression, and a competitive edge to getting accepted into ITT.

Instead we have lower and lower pay, progression stagnated because schools cannot afford to reward success, younger and younger SLT with sod all life experience and ability to manage young people effectively, consequent worsening behaviour, bigger class sizes and therefore worsening working conditions and the need to drag in anyone off the street as a warm body in front of clases hence apprenticeships.

None of this is rocket science yet 12 years in, this Government insists on making it worse.

Piggywaspushed · 26/02/2023 07:52

in the past.

The past being the operative term? How many children were in school 'in the 1900s'? How many people proceeded to university?? What educational expectations did we have for children being taught?

Georgeandzippyzoo · 26/02/2023 01:27

PinkPantherPaws · 24/02/2023 07:00

I think it's fine for Primary teachers.

Learning the skills of teaching is far more important than the content IMO - you don't need to be degree educated to understand the content at primary level.

At secondary level I don't see how it would work at all.

You do realise that in Primary English uour child will have been taught, and expected to be using, ALL aspects of grammar. Secondary schools do NOT teach any new grammar topics, they may reinforce .
My friend taught a level English in a 6th form approx 8-10yrs ago and she didn't teach some of what y6 kids now know.
Same for maths. Topics which were normally taught in y8/9 are now taught in y5/6.

Corcory · 26/02/2023 01:17

This is what used to happen in the past. My Great Aunt became a pupil teacher at 16, this was in the 1900s. She then became infant teacher at another village school until she retired in the 1940s.

autastic · 26/02/2023 00:34

Good grief don't tell the OP about nurse apprenticeships.

IggysPop · 25/02/2023 20:08

This is not driven by cost-cutting. At all. No. Not at all.

noblegiraffe · 25/02/2023 19:58

The worrying thing is that at the same time as they are discussing this nonsense that won’t happen, they are actually closing down training providers and training routes for people who do actually have a degree.

It’s madness.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/02/2023 19:29

Can’t see why anyone so freshly out of the trainwreck that is a large number of secondary schools would want to go back in there as a zookeeper. Teaching isn’t an attractive career prospect. You’re not going to make it attractive by consistently lowering the bar for people to get into it.

Why isn’t the government looking at why there’s such an issue with retention of existing teachers, and doing something about that?

cravingtoblerone · 25/02/2023 18:18

I'm absolutely not OK with it. I don't think the average 19 year old has the maturity to deal with stuff that happens in a school classroom.

Malbecfan · 25/02/2023 18:04

@Hobbi I resent your assertion that I am patronising primary teachers. I have done 3 years of it and I take my hat off to anyone doing it long-term as it's exhausting. However, my point was that a well-educated 19 year old could do a good job in a primary classroom as their knowledge/skills are considerably beyond the children they are teaching. You appear to have ignored or misunderstood it completely so I'm out

noblegiraffe · 25/02/2023 15:46

This isn't a solution, it wouldn't solve anything. Take-up would be minuscule.

MiniEggsz · 25/02/2023 15:37

I think we are approaching a situation where classes, and perhaps whole schools, are unable to open simply because they haven't got enough teachers.
This is a temporary solution.
It will be another government's problem later down the road.
As some have said, we need to make it harder to be a teacher, much better pay. Make teaching a desirable role like it is in many other countries. But that is harder than this solution.

borntobequiet · 25/02/2023 14:55

I also think a teacher trained through an apprenticeship is likely to make a better teacher than one who did a media studies degree and a PGCE.

There’s nothing wrong with a media studies degree, it could be argued that it’s more relevant to education today than traditional Eng Lit.

Appuskidu · 25/02/2023 11:37

I can’t actually see many parents being thrilled that their class has got the 19 year old apprentice with a B in maths instead of Mrs X who’s been teaching A level for 25 years when it boils down to who gets which ‘teacher’.

Lisbeth50 · 25/02/2023 11:25

Reading this thread is so depressing. It really shows how little some people understand and value education.

Fairislefandango · 25/02/2023 11:12

Parents might see enthusiasm and think 'marvellous', but people who actually know how to teach know there's no substitute for actual experience.

This. There are enthusiastic and less enthusiastic teachers of all ages and experience levels. Youth is no guarantee of sparkling enthusiasm. Years of teaching are at least a guarantee of experience.

noblegiraffe · 25/02/2023 11:11

Yes, piggy, literally no idea who this is aimed at.

Still, they spent millions on Troops to Teachers and that got fuck-all teachers out of it too, so they're not averse to spending taxpayer money on setting up teacher training routes with no takers.

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 11:02

When I was a young teacher I was possibly enthusiastic. I also burned the candle at both ends , was in a state of reasonably permanent hangover and fairly lazy.

When I was 19 , I was still learning , but meeting new people, having fun, travelling around, experiencing life. Odd to want to shackle 19 year olds. And then 30 years later tell them on MN that their problem is they have never been in the Real World.

That said, I'd be surprised if most of these apprentices are 'young and enthusiastic'.

LadyGAgain · 25/02/2023 10:56

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 10:31

Is that secondary or primary ladyG out of interest?

Junior school

noblegiraffe · 25/02/2023 10:45

Olios · 25/02/2023 05:49

A 19 yo may have enthusiasm and energy that many older teachers disillusioned with the profession don't

Enthusiasm and energy don't actually beat subject knowledge, ability to teach and definitely not teaching experience.

We've seen this before, 'oh, the teachers moaning about their pay and conditions can just retire and be replaced by fresh, enthusiastic NQTs'. Aside from the fact that no one wants to be an NQT anymore, hence the grubbing around by the government for anyone who they might actually be able to get onto a teacher training course, experienced teachers know that all new teachers are a bit shit at the job.

Parents might see enthusiasm and think 'marvellous', but people who actually know how to teach know there's no substitute for actual experience.

Piggywaspushed · 25/02/2023 10:31

Is that secondary or primary ladyG out of interest?

LadyGAgain · 25/02/2023 10:27

Sorry my terminology might be incorrect and I apologise. TA not LSA.

LadyGAgain · 25/02/2023 10:25

*incorrectly