Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents tracking their children

280 replies

intrestedvic · 23/02/2023 23:58

I am always reading on threads how people know where their children are due to apple air tags or, apps, or location sharing on a phone.

Not just on mumsnet but in my circle I know lots of parents who use maps or share location with children.

I am a parent to small children currently but I was wondering opinions on this situation. If you track your children and why and if not why not?

OP posts:
ILiveAt64ZooLane · 25/02/2023 08:20

Greatly · 25/02/2023 08:06

I think there's a big difference between a weird boyfriend tracking your every move and a mum wanting to know you've got home safely. Most teens and young adults can tell the difference- if some can't they have bigger problems than life 360.

I’m a mum, I want to know my children are home safely, I’ve lost count of the times I’ve told them to text if they were staying at a friends when they were going out into town but they didn’t. The thought of using their phone to track them never even crossed my mind as an option and I certainly wouldn’t guilt trip them into it which some PP have done. Like I’ve said it’s normalising being tracked for someone else’s benefit not that of the tracked person. That’s the slippery slope.

TheaBrandt · 25/02/2023 08:14

Agree with everything Greatly posts on this!

Greatly · 25/02/2023 08:06

ILiveAt64ZooLane · 25/02/2023 08:04

And there's no evidence it leads to coercive control

The point I was making earlier is that we’re normalising tracking someone because “I just want to know you’re safe” “I can put dinner on when I know you’re nearly home” “I feel better knowing you caught your connecting train” “I can come and pick you up without directions or disturbing you” some people will use it to their advantage and even the people providing innocent examples given need to question their motives. It shouldn’t be about us it should be about the person being tracked and in a lot of examples it’s sold to them as a benefit yet it’s someone else benefiting not them..

I think there's a big difference between a weird boyfriend tracking your every move and a mum wanting to know you've got home safely. Most teens and young adults can tell the difference- if some can't they have bigger problems than life 360.

ginsparkles · 25/02/2023 08:04

I think the phrase "tracking" makes it sound like families and couples are watching these apps constantly, monitoring where each other are.

I can go for days without actually specifically opening the app. It alerts me when DD DH or DM have arrived home so I know they have got home safely, no need to the text when you get home conversations. I can remember even before apps and mobiles having to give a couple of rings to let mum know I had arrived somewhere safely so this isn't a new thing. It tells me they have completed a journey, so now instead of texting my DH I have arrived safely at my destination, he gets an alert. It makes our life easier.

The last time I actually opened it to check where someone was, was when DD 10 was shopping with her friend and they were not back a little bit after we were expecting them to be. I opened it, saw they were still in smith's so we knew they had just lost track of time. They were back 10 mins later having been stuck in a long queue.

For us and I think most families it's in the background as a back up, not a constant big brother surveillance

ILiveAt64ZooLane · 25/02/2023 08:04

And there's no evidence it leads to coercive control

The point I was making earlier is that we’re normalising tracking someone because “I just want to know you’re safe” “I can put dinner on when I know you’re nearly home” “I feel better knowing you caught your connecting train” “I can come and pick you up without directions or disturbing you” some people will use it to their advantage and even the people providing innocent examples given need to question their motives. It shouldn’t be about us it should be about the person being tracked and in a lot of examples it’s sold to them as a benefit yet it’s someone else benefiting not them..

Greatly · 25/02/2023 08:03

MissedItByThisMuch · 25/02/2023 08:00

What the hell are you on about?? Did you miss the bit where I’m NOT a conspiracy theorist? FFS if you’re going to argue with me at least make some attempt to read and understand what I’m actually saying. I actually despair about peoples’ comprehension skills.

So where is the slippery slope leading?

MissedItByThisMuch · 25/02/2023 08:00

Greatly · 25/02/2023 07:45

@MissedItByThisMuch if companies/big pharma/big brother/China want to track us through our phones they can already, without hacking into Life 360 and stealing their data.

And there's no evidence it leads to coercive control- there's no evidence it improves community cohesion either but that scenario is just as likely.

What the hell are you on about?? Did you miss the bit where I’m NOT a conspiracy theorist? FFS if you’re going to argue with me at least make some attempt to read and understand what I’m actually saying. I actually despair about peoples’ comprehension skills.

TheaBrandt · 25/02/2023 07:54

Lcb the issue is with teens most of whom are able to consent or not. I would be fine for mine to not consent but then it would be incumbent on them to let me know their whereabouts if I needed to and frankly being lazy teens who we have an easy open relationship with they prefer it I use find my phone. They would think I was weird if I stopped using it and went back to directly contacting them.

Greatly · 25/02/2023 07:45

@MissedItByThisMuch if companies/big pharma/big brother/China want to track us through our phones they can already, without hacking into Life 360 and stealing their data.

And there's no evidence it leads to coercive control- there's no evidence it improves community cohesion either but that scenario is just as likely.

Lcb123 · 25/02/2023 07:25

No I’d never do that unless they can consent, I.e as a teenager. It’s so statistically rare to have a child taken. Going in a car is statistically much more dangerous but no one fusses over that.
I find it so weird when couples track each other to…

Greatly · 25/02/2023 07:22

MissedItByThisMuch · 24/02/2023 23:34

Well of course you don’t think it’s a slippery slope. That’s the whole point about slippery slopes. You don’t recognise you’re on them until you’re too far down to get back up

Look I realise I’m not going to convince people on this. But it’s a little depressing how few people are seemingly interested in looking beyond their own specific circumstances to the wider issues and engaging in debate beyond “well I do it and mean no harm so it must be ok”.

I've got plenty of things to worry about and this isn't one of them.

TheaBrandt · 25/02/2023 06:53

Why though? Why stop doing something that makes your life a little easier because of others (imo anyway over dramatic) opinions? Its like my uncle who refuses to use his Sat nav so keeps getting lost <goes on find my phone which links to google maps to get exact address of where 14 year old is currently to go and pick her up >

MissedItByThisMuch · 24/02/2023 23:34

Greatly · 24/02/2023 22:53

I don't think checking whereabouts someone is, or making sure they haven't fallen off their horse (or if they have, knowing where they are) is a slippery slope to anything.

I expect people felt like this about the telephone when it was first invented.

It's something that can make life easier and more relaxing for both parties.

Well of course you don’t think it’s a slippery slope. That’s the whole point about slippery slopes. You don’t recognise you’re on them until you’re too far down to get back up

Look I realise I’m not going to convince people on this. But it’s a little depressing how few people are seemingly interested in looking beyond their own specific circumstances to the wider issues and engaging in debate beyond “well I do it and mean no harm so it must be ok”.

DancingDaughter50 · 24/02/2023 23:21

Oh.

Painful to write in detail really, I'd already been asking her for the pick up place and it was just a quick walk somewhere with friends who are quite new.
So I didn't really want to keep nagging her as to time and where she was. Ie ruin the short time she had so whilst I had done that truing to get an adress I was then able to see where she was and just wait!?.. Does that explain it further for you 🙄

verdantverdure · 24/02/2023 23:19

We all share our location with the rest of the family.

Saltywalruss · 24/02/2023 23:12

DancingDaughter50 · 24/02/2023 23:07

Eg tonight she asked me to collect her from somewhere in didn't know... At a particular time.
So it was great to pull up press a button and see she was there near by and I didn't have to disturb her.

She asked you to collect her. I can't see how you would be disturbing her by asking where she wants to be collected from!

TheaBrandt · 24/02/2023 23:09

I think this is one of those polarising debates. You either think looking at the locations of your teens via their phones is outrageous / the new 1984/ gateway to coercive control relationships / tool for neurotic helicopters or a useful feature to check your teens are vaguely where they are supposed to be / what time they will be home for tea / where you need to drive to get them. And never the Twain shall meet!

DancingDaughter50 · 24/02/2023 23:07

Eg tonight she asked me to collect her from somewhere in didn't know... At a particular time.
So it was great to pull up press a button and see she was there near by and I didn't have to disturb her.

DancingDaughter50 · 24/02/2023 23:05

I track dd and she's not bothered in the slightlest but then she doesn't really have anything to hide!

Greatly · 24/02/2023 22:53

MissedItByThisMuch · 24/02/2023 22:12

Well if actually thinking about issues and being concerned about the largely subconscious erosion of hard-fought for civil liberties which are not the norm everywhere in the world makes me a conspiracy theorist so be it. No doubt you think my language is overly dramatic, you’re “only” using it to see if people are on their train or whatever but that’s how slippery slopes work.

I don't think checking whereabouts someone is, or making sure they haven't fallen off their horse (or if they have, knowing where they are) is a slippery slope to anything.

I expect people felt like this about the telephone when it was first invented.

It's something that can make life easier and more relaxing for both parties.

ILiveAt64ZooLane · 24/02/2023 22:24

CheeseDreamsTonight · 24/02/2023 17:48

I track dd, 12, as she is just finding her feet being out and about and she likes that I know where she is and can see it she gets in trouble / kidnapped and zooms off in a car! She's very good at telling me where she is and asking etc and I don't expect to still be doing it in a few years

Has she ever got into trouble/kidnapped or zoomed off in a car? Do you just watch the app constantly while she’s out so you can respond as soon as she gets into trouble/kidnapped or zoomed off in a car? If she is only 12 though it’s probably in a few years when she could be zooming off in a car with friends. If she’s very good at telling you where she is you could cut her some slack and trust her.

MissedItByThisMuch · 24/02/2023 22:12

Greatly · 24/02/2023 21:37

And I’m definitely not some crazy conspiracy theorist at all, promise!

You sound like one.

Well if actually thinking about issues and being concerned about the largely subconscious erosion of hard-fought for civil liberties which are not the norm everywhere in the world makes me a conspiracy theorist so be it. No doubt you think my language is overly dramatic, you’re “only” using it to see if people are on their train or whatever but that’s how slippery slopes work.

Notmycircus · 24/02/2023 21:38

All the posters talking about "burner" phones are making me laugh! How exactly do you think it would work? Most location apps need the phone number to register on them. So, the burner phone would have to be the one they take with them when they leave their real phone "at their friends house" as a decoy. As if a teenager would want to be out and about with a second phone that has to attachment to their social media, friends etc. Or are you actually implying that a 16 yr old would be so devious that they have a second complete identity for their parents??

Greatly · 24/02/2023 21:37

And I’m definitely not some crazy conspiracy theorist at all, promise!

You sound like one.

WandaWonder · 24/02/2023 21:33

I have yet to find my son hiding anything so I don't need to track him in the first place

Swipe left for the next trending thread