Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents tracking their children

280 replies

intrestedvic · 23/02/2023 23:58

I am always reading on threads how people know where their children are due to apple air tags or, apps, or location sharing on a phone.

Not just on mumsnet but in my circle I know lots of parents who use maps or share location with children.

I am a parent to small children currently but I was wondering opinions on this situation. If you track your children and why and if not why not?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThatsAboutEnoughOfThat · 25/02/2023 22:33

TheaBrandt · 24/02/2023 18:04

I think parenting teens is different now. I don’t see the fearful doom mongering parenting of teens that I and my friends had. Our parents were always quick to think the worst of us and were quite authoritarian which led to even good kids lying and sneaking about . I don’t know anyone that parents like that now. It’s much more collaborative and adult - reasonable type of relationship hence the odd find my phone doesn’t bother either party as the parents aren’t trying to over control the teens and the teens are perfectly open and happy about their movements. That’s my experience anyway.

I think you are on to something there.

The relationship DH and I have with our two teenage DSs is so different to the ones we had with our parents are the same age it is like night and day.

DS1 is 19 this year and at Uni, though lives at home because we are in a Uni city and that is pretty standard here. He has a job and comes and goes as he pleases obviously. But he is so chill and happy to hang out with us. We spend zero time wondering what he is up to or assuming he is up to no good. And he knows that. He takes the car regularly and doesn't need to tell us where he is going (though to be far if I wanted to know I can track the car itself - but I don't, because I know I can) though he does need to pop in the shared calendar if he wants it as it is MY car.

DS2 is 13 and is coming along the same path, he comes and goes with his mates who all seem to be a pretty good crew. He gets his school work done, hangs out with us, has freedom etc.

We are more involved in their lives than our parents were at the same age. Google hangouts, calendar, locations etc and yet at the same time they have far more freedom than we did.

Who knows I may be delusional and DS2 might be up to no good with his mates. But if DS1 is any 'proof of pudding' then it will probably be fine.

The only anxiety the shared locations thing relieves here is when I am up at 4am with my insane menopausal clock. I like to have a peek and see that all 4 of us as where I expect.

strivingtosucceed · 25/02/2023 21:22

I don't have kids but I have Find my Iphone on with my sister. We both travel a lot so it makes sense to be able to track each other in case of the worst. I hardly ever check it tbh, maybe sometimes if she's on her way to my house and I want to see if she's left yet so I can time food.

I can be anxious around planes though so I do admit to tracking my family's planes while they're in the air.

Justgorgeous · 25/02/2023 21:00

My son is 20 and does loads of driving. I just like to know he’s safe. He has said he doesn’t care if I have it on. My other son won’t entertain it, which is fine.

pettyprudence · 25/02/2023 20:56

I had no intention of "tracking" my son and he was the last one in his y6 class to get a phone. He was already walking home from school and out and about in the park with his friends and I never felt worried (and we live in a slightly less desirable area 🙃) before he got a phone as I would know broadly where he was.... but then he was diagnosed with Type 1 Diabetes right before his birthday and getting a phone and then he HAD to have a phone to monitor his glucose and I have to follow that, phone for help with calculating insulin etc.... and then it became necessary to find him when he was out with friends and his glucose was low etc.... Now I have Tile trackers on many of his belongings (because he also has ADHD and loses EVERYTHING) so I pretty much know where he, or at least his phone and belongings, are at anytime.

Saltywalruss · 25/02/2023 19:37

P3N · Today 13:54

We as a family of 4 have life360. We can all see each other. It helped us recently when my DD got lost with her mates when she went out (not very street wise)

That does sound useful in this situation. However, what would your not-very-streetwise daughter have done if she'd lost her phone?

RampantIvy · 25/02/2023 19:29

On the WIWIKAU Facebook group some parents are complaining that their student DC have switched off parental tracking.

When will these parents learn to let go? These students are adults without any extra needs BTW.

cravingtoblerone · 25/02/2023 18:16

My DS only 9 currently so not out alone. But I absolutely will when he's older. He'll have to get the bus home from secondary school when he goes but he has SEND and is emotionally is much younger than his peers. I will absolutely be tracking him. I'm completely fine with this decision.

Ladysodor · 25/02/2023 15:39

I’d have hated the idea of my parents tracking my every move during my teens. It’s weird parental behaviour IMO. Surely part of growing up is doing things that your parents don’t know about? I’m not suggesting criminal behaviour but just having an area of your life (as you get older) that your parents have no part in. Once you start tracking your kids you’re on a slippy slope. Kids need boundaries but they also need freedom.

P3N · 25/02/2023 13:54

We as a family of 4 have life360. We can all see each other. It helped us recently when my DD got lost with her mates when she went out (not very street wise). It also gives me a rough estimation when to start tea for my DH when he's finishing a 12hr shift.
When it comes to my 13 Yr old she knows if she doesn't answer the phone after so many rings, we come looking for her. She also knows if she sends a certain emoji or codeword we come straight to her. Our area isn't a nice one unfortunately 😕
My son is 8 this year and has a cheap smart phone. He has life360 on it but isn't really away from us unless he's at grandparents or friends houses. Still useful to have.

Lindy2 · 25/02/2023 13:44

We as a family use Life360. It's just handy to be able to quickly check when someone has arrived safely, is on their way home etc.

I also have a teen with ASD and ADHD. I feel a lot happier knowing where she is. She knows we can see her location and is OK with it. She can often be anxious so has some security in knowing we know where she is if she needs us to go to her.

It's just part of our way of life now and also helpful to locate misplaced phones.

TheaBrandt · 25/02/2023 13:36

Mine were utterly confident in my swotty behaviour so all parental firepower was directed at my poor sister! I basically did what I wanted.

Greatly · 25/02/2023 13:32

My parents were very strict. I had to lie to them constantly or I would have never been able to leave the house other than to go to school or sanctioned activities

Then I can understand why you feel the way you do. Conversely my parents couldn't have given a shit where I was!

redskydelight · 25/02/2023 13:24

Greatly · 25/02/2023 13:07

How do you know yours don't 😉

We don't track them so they don't need to use burner phones ....?

Are they lying about where they are going? Potentially. I always think any parent of a teen who definitively says their teen never lies to them is probably deluding themselves.

Although DS is 18 and we don't insist on knowing where he is at every point of the day anyway. Only if he's going to be home for dinner :) And DD is disabled so her physical ability to get to many places is quite limited, although once her friends start to drive, who knows?

My parents were very strict. I had to lie to them constantly or I would have never been able to leave the house other than to go to school or sanctioned activities (e.g. swimming lessons, volunteering). If I was a teen in today's generation they would absolutely be tracking me and I would absolutely be leaving my phone at my friend's house and sneaking out.

If you have a great relationship with their teen (and it's not just you that thinks it's great) and you have phone tracking enabled, for use in an emergency only, I can see this can be of value. But no one needs to know where anyone else is at every point of the day, and the reasons given on here are mostly due to control/lack of communication than actual need.

Saltywalruss · 25/02/2023 13:23

*growing up.

Lots of teens and young adults follow each other on Snapchat and can see each other's location via the snapmaps feature.
I don't think they see 'tracking' in the same way those who didn't grow up with the ability do.
Many chose to be visible to their friends and choose to be able to view their friend's locations*

No they don't. They have already effectively been "groomed" into thinking that it's a good thing

Abraxan · 25/02/2023 13:18

LetThemEatTurnips · 24/02/2023 00:07

I don't know what the psychological impacts would be of being surveilled as a teen. I would have hated it when I was growing up.

Lots of teens and young adults follow each other on Snapchat and can see each other's location via the snapmaps feature.
I don't think they see 'tracking' in the same way those who didn't grow up with the ability do.
Many chose to be visible to their friends and choose to be able to view their friend's locations.

We all have a linked Apple family account - it also means we can share app, music, film purchases and have a shared iCloud which is cheaper when done that way. We can all see each other's location if we wish. It isn't something we do on a regular basis and anyone who wants to can turn their location off if need be (all 3 of us are adults now) but no one has felt the need.

When dd was younger it was a condition of having a mobile phone, along with us having the right to monitor her phone use. This gradually lessened as she got older and stopped entirely.

Greatly · 25/02/2023 13:07

redskydelight · 25/02/2023 13:00

16 year olds that are trying to avoid controlling/over-strict/whatever you want to call it parents either don't share their social media with their parents or have both a parent-friendly and a real version of it.

My teen DC both know children that do this. I doubt that their friends are unique among teenagers so I assume others do it to.

It's only really a tech version of you telling your parent you're at Susie's house while Susie tells her parent that she's at your house.

How do you know yours don't 😉

redskydelight · 25/02/2023 13:00

Notmycircus · 24/02/2023 21:38

All the posters talking about "burner" phones are making me laugh! How exactly do you think it would work? Most location apps need the phone number to register on them. So, the burner phone would have to be the one they take with them when they leave their real phone "at their friends house" as a decoy. As if a teenager would want to be out and about with a second phone that has to attachment to their social media, friends etc. Or are you actually implying that a 16 yr old would be so devious that they have a second complete identity for their parents??

16 year olds that are trying to avoid controlling/over-strict/whatever you want to call it parents either don't share their social media with their parents or have both a parent-friendly and a real version of it.

My teen DC both know children that do this. I doubt that their friends are unique among teenagers so I assume others do it to.

It's only really a tech version of you telling your parent you're at Susie's house while Susie tells her parent that she's at your house.

RampantIvy · 25/02/2023 12:49

You clearly have a specific need though @teaandcake123. Technology like this can help with independence in this case.

If I could see where DD was all the time it would probably cause me too much anxiety.

teaandcake123 · 25/02/2023 08:57

We use Findmy iPhone and me, my husband and our 18 year old son are on it. Our boy is autistic and just starting to travel independently. It means we can check where he is and get to him if he needs help. It’s a big reassurance for all of us. It’s not “surveillance” because it doesn’t spy on him and what he’s doing, it’s just letting us know where he is. It suits all 3 of us.

SilverGlitterBaubles · 25/02/2023 08:51

The thing with these tracking apps is that you are in control and can turn it off if you want.

Greatly · 25/02/2023 08:36

I remember dc once saying they much preferred having life 360 as I didn't text them. A friend that she went riding with didn't have it and her mum messaged her a few times checking all was OK. I didn't need to text as could see she was moving and on her normal horse riding route. Obviously messaging mum is not always that easy when you need to keep both hands on the reins!

CleaningOutMyCloset · 25/02/2023 08:34

I do with my 15 yr old, but I don't actively look at it all the time, only if I'm picking her up from somewhere

She's just started getting the bus and train on her own, so it's handy rather than me 'checking up on her' she can also see me as it's a family apple app

Smoky1107 · 25/02/2023 08:33

My daughter put me on life 360 so she knows how far I am if I'm picking her up. She tracks me!!

Greatly · 25/02/2023 08:29

RampantIvy · 25/02/2023 08:24

DD is 22 and living in the city she went to university in. We don't track each other and never have.

I know of parents of university age students who do and think it is unhealthy unless there is a specific need for it.

There's no real need at all, unless you both find it useful.

RampantIvy · 25/02/2023 08:24

DD is 22 and living in the city she went to university in. We don't track each other and never have.

I know of parents of university age students who do and think it is unhealthy unless there is a specific need for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread