Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of the Uk looks like a state

763 replies

Novembermummy88 · 23/02/2023 23:10

Not sure if I am being dramatic or if years of austerity are really starting to show…? Lately I’ve really started to notice how filthy, run down and falling apart everywhere looks! I live in a town in the south east on the borders of the M25. Every where there are gapping pot holes (can hardly avoid the volume there are now and genuinely concerned I will lose a wheel at some point!), broken lamp posts, the volume of litter / filth on the roads seems very high and can’t remember the last time I saw a road sweeper, and things like pathways are a state, road markings worn out, SO many closed/dilapidated shops….the town just looks awful as do many of the nearby towns! Is it just the South East looking like this? Aibu?! Or have I watched too much Selling Sunsets and setting my expectations too high…???

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MadeleineMummy · 26/02/2023 15:43

Because anyone who has an interest is doing just about OK and like a lobster in a pot of cold water has scant realisation that the heat is being turned up so very gradually that there is no time to panic until the inevitable happens. Thatcher also destroyed society so that no one really gives a damn about anyone else as long as, “I’m alright jack”.

The ones at the bottom of the pile are less visible so most people do not really care.

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 15:11

It's SO frustrating that so many people seem to want to complain about the issues they see but be unable/ unwilling to take a step back and look at WHY the UK is struggling so much compared to its historical comparators, and push for the things which would actually change that. We don't need to reinvent the wheel here. It's very clear what needs to be done. The most baffling part is why, as @MarshaBradyo observed, most people say they are unhappy but aren't pressuring their MPs to make the necessary changes which would - over time - improve things. Why not?

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 15:03

But regardless of the efforts of individuals, as I've explained, significant improvements to quality of life will not, cannot, happen unless productivity rises.

People want the Council to ensure little is collected, potholes are filled, antisocial behaviour and "low level crime" like intimidation, burglary, theft, fly tipping, etc is dealt with?

That requires funding. People in the UK are taxed to death already vs cost of living, at every level of earnings (outside the super rich and while a moral issue, will make NO difference to fixing these problems on a national scale so while I agree, that is not the pressing issue so I'll leave that aside in this comment as it is a moot point in terms of whether standards of living for everyone else improves). This situation will only get worse as the demographic time bomb explodes. We know this, it is fact, and has been known to be coming for many years. People can't afford to pay more tax, but services need more funding for things to improve and salaries need to rise across the board.

How do we achieve this? People can either squabble over dividing up the every shrinking amount of resource it's possible to extract through rising taxes to meet ever growing needs, and watch while their living standards drop continuously for the next few decades. Or, they can lobby MPs for obvious economic reforms that will increase productivity and gradually raise living standards and mean there is also more money available for public services.

That is the choice. If people want to moan and endure it, then this will continue. If people want to change it then lobby for the tax reforms I described, rejoining the single market and customs union and a proper long-term strategy on industrial policy, infrastructure and education.

If you choose not to do so, then effectively you are condemning yourselves and your children to more of the same.

dcthatsme · 26/02/2023 14:50

Perhaps it's not that difficult to stop people just chucking their litter away without a second thought. The dog poo problem has really improved through fining and various campaigns. The problem is a lot of people just don't think - they assume that a street cleaner will clear it up for them. We managed to stamp out spitting and dog fouling is a lot better than it used to be (in London anyway). We're getting a bit better gradually on our plastic bag consumption. This problem isn't insurmountable! But we do need to put pressure on councils and MPs to do something on our behalf. Publicity campaigns, fining, shaming, plentiful and regularly emptied bins. I love the MacDonalds car reg idea if it's feasible.

MarshaBradyo · 26/02/2023 13:35

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 13:03

I rarely see posts that concentrate on economics over politics so it’s good to have some.

This is what we all need: clear understanding of the causes and how to improve things. It can be done. But it won't be if people squabble amongst themselves or insist changes must only benefit them personally rather than make wholesale changes to improve the system so it is functional at all levels. It very much suits those in power to divide and rule rather than have clear, evidence-based thinking on what policies are required, sadly.

Brexit threads have been running a while and I have asked if posters who are unhappy have written to their MPs but no one has said yes.

I have. But yes it is immensely frustrating that these posts come up with increasing frequency and yet when someone attempts - as I have here - to explain what needs to change to make things better, I can imagine that few will get behind it and lobby their MPs for it. Ultimately MPs want to keep their jobs so if their inbox is filled by emails from constituents all saying the same thing then they will listen, with a GE coming next year! The problem is people not doing so as you say.

I’m wondering why the Brexit vote is still so important if people are this unhappy. And I can only think 13 years out has made the opposition too cautious to talk about it.

The opposition are cowards. They also have no faith in the British public (perhaps justifiably?) to be sensible and rational. People have been promised change too many times so many perhaps might not believe them if the program I described was set out, that this would in fact change things for the better for everyone. But ultimately one would hope that enough people are intelligent enough to realise that it would? Idk. We don't seem to have any politicians with any conviction anymore in any party who are prepared to speak truth and fight to get support for something that will actually work. Instead they play the game trying to figure out what policies would be popular, rather than effective. Then once elected their hands are tied and they cannot implement the effective ones. Very depressing.

Yes to all this. Well said

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 13:11

With a demographic time bomb about to go off, time is running out to do this. If productivity does not rise significantly, then obviously there will be nothing in the long-term but ever-rising living costs in proportion to real-terms earnings and continual cuts in services. This is the most basic economics: raising productivity is the only solution.

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 13:03

I rarely see posts that concentrate on economics over politics so it’s good to have some.

This is what we all need: clear understanding of the causes and how to improve things. It can be done. But it won't be if people squabble amongst themselves or insist changes must only benefit them personally rather than make wholesale changes to improve the system so it is functional at all levels. It very much suits those in power to divide and rule rather than have clear, evidence-based thinking on what policies are required, sadly.

Brexit threads have been running a while and I have asked if posters who are unhappy have written to their MPs but no one has said yes.

I have. But yes it is immensely frustrating that these posts come up with increasing frequency and yet when someone attempts - as I have here - to explain what needs to change to make things better, I can imagine that few will get behind it and lobby their MPs for it. Ultimately MPs want to keep their jobs so if their inbox is filled by emails from constituents all saying the same thing then they will listen, with a GE coming next year! The problem is people not doing so as you say.

I’m wondering why the Brexit vote is still so important if people are this unhappy. And I can only think 13 years out has made the opposition too cautious to talk about it.

The opposition are cowards. They also have no faith in the British public (perhaps justifiably?) to be sensible and rational. People have been promised change too many times so many perhaps might not believe them if the program I described was set out, that this would in fact change things for the better for everyone. But ultimately one would hope that enough people are intelligent enough to realise that it would? Idk. We don't seem to have any politicians with any conviction anymore in any party who are prepared to speak truth and fight to get support for something that will actually work. Instead they play the game trying to figure out what policies would be popular, rather than effective. Then once elected their hands are tied and they cannot implement the effective ones. Very depressing.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 26/02/2023 12:48

I think a clear very strict policy on crime is desperately needed. There is so much low level crime in my area that we’ve all accepted it. Local mp gives no shits as she’s a woke narcissist who only cares about her pet projects.

MarshaBradyo · 26/02/2023 12:45

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 12:37

People have told them very clearly what the problem is: if they work more hours/ go for promotions then they are penalised so heavily by benefit withdrawal/ higher rate tax and withdrawal of child benefit/ withdrawal of personal allowance plus 30 hrs childcare plus tax free childcare (that one can result in an effective tax rate of over 85%!) that it isn't worth them doing. Single people and particularly single parents are massively penalised by the tax system being taxed far more on the same household income. So, that is an easy fix. Remove the bottlenecks. He can do that overnight, if he wishes. Totally within his power.

The results of investment in a proper energy security strategy and infrastructure and scaffolding for small businesses to grow so that business investment is viable again will take longer to bear fruit, but first you have to create the conditions for this to be possible. I.e. fix the tax system and rejoin the single market and customs union. This is entirely within Government control so if people want things to start to improve that's what they need to lobby MPs for.

I rarely see posts that concentrate on economics over politics so it’s good to have some.

Brexit threads have been running a while and I have asked if posters who are unhappy have written to their MPs but no one has said yes.

I’m wondering why the Brexit vote is still so important if people are this unhappy. And I can only think 13 years out has made the opposition too cautious to talk about it.

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 12:42

The deliberate fiscal drag is also making it much worse, obviously. They need to automatically uprate all thresholds for benefits, tax, pensions and savings with inflation every year. Starting with a large catch up adjustment.

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 12:37

People have told them very clearly what the problem is: if they work more hours/ go for promotions then they are penalised so heavily by benefit withdrawal/ higher rate tax and withdrawal of child benefit/ withdrawal of personal allowance plus 30 hrs childcare plus tax free childcare (that one can result in an effective tax rate of over 85%!) that it isn't worth them doing. Single people and particularly single parents are massively penalised by the tax system being taxed far more on the same household income. So, that is an easy fix. Remove the bottlenecks. He can do that overnight, if he wishes. Totally within his power.

The results of investment in a proper energy security strategy and infrastructure and scaffolding for small businesses to grow so that business investment is viable again will take longer to bear fruit, but first you have to create the conditions for this to be possible. I.e. fix the tax system and rejoin the single market and customs union. This is entirely within Government control so if people want things to start to improve that's what they need to lobby MPs for.

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 12:29

Agreed. We need some competent people prepared to do what is needed, acknowledge and remove the Brexit elephant in the room, and implement long-term plans even if they are not initially popular because the electorate has such scant understanding of economics. We need grown ups, with proper expertise. Little sign of them anywhere in the HOC, so the decline in living standards will continue unfortunately. People can moan and fight amongst themselves of the crumbs if they wish but nothing will improve unless proper economic plans are implemented.

The fact the chancellor had to ask for research on why the economy is flatlining says everything. At every level of the tax and benefits system there are absurd disincentives to increasing productivity. Anybody with a brain would remove them.

amp.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

LocatioLocationLocomotion · 26/02/2023 12:24

Pottedpalm · 24/02/2023 08:43

I live in a pleasant village where people group together to maintain/improve the local environment. Litter picks round the village, group gathering to tidy the garden at the village hall etc. Local villages all have active facebook groups which alert members to suspicious behaviour, vandalism, fly tipping, dog fouling…
The majority of residents maintain their homes and gardens very well and contribute to upkeep of communal areas. Several local villages have little libraries in their old red phone boxes. Events at the village halls contribute to a community feel.
I appreciate this is difficult to accomplish in a town.

This is the kind of place I’m desperate to live in

MarshaBradyo · 26/02/2023 11:24

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 11:14

Oh and obviously, rejoining the single market and customs union. But that's so obvious I didn't think it needs saying...

Unfortunately not even the opposition party can say it. And Brexit wasn’t their idea.

Without that I can’t see Labour magicking much up for massive investment.

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 11:14

Oh and obviously, rejoining the single market and customs union. But that's so obvious I didn't think it needs saying...

ThatOldHag · 26/02/2023 11:12

FruHagen · 25/02/2023 15:53

This is a lot of people commenting on this thread. One of the most comments I've seen in a long time.

This should be another thread and maybe it will be, but what can we do about it? It's our country. Our beautiful country, that we are to give to our children and have our parents grow old in.

I don't have any answers. I picked litter in my street and kids laughed at me and I pulled all the dumped stuff from the alley behind my street alone and my neighbour asked me what on earth I was doing. Every week after bin day I would pick up everything the bin men left. I only did it because it made me so depressed to see, I don't want any praise or recognition. I hate that "aren't I kind" culture, I just hate litter.
What I am trying to say is my small actions did nothing much - a drop in the ocean.

How can it change. How can we all come together to enact change? Politically or something else.
I don't know, just asking what others think we can do.

The only way to improve living standards is to raise productivity. We've had 15 years of no productivity growth or real-terms salary growth which is unprecedented in recorded economic history. What you are seeing is the result of that. As to what can be done about it, I answered that upthread:

And nothing will improve until you have a Government that invests in improving productivity. This means decent education, infrastructure, and industrial strategy for key high-margin growth sectors, and removing ridiculous bottlenecks in the tax system at £50k, £100k etc and equalises it to remove the penalisation of single adult households.

No chance this will happen because the average British citizen has no grip of even the most basic economics so there is no pressure on MPs to do so. People seem happier fighting over how they divide up the remaining crumbs or resorting to xenophobia.

megletthesecond · 26/02/2023 09:26

trinny it has been suggested on the various litter picking FB sites that fast food drive thru's should be able to print the car reg on the bag so it can be traced back if littered.

dcthatsme · 26/02/2023 08:09

Novembermummy88 · 23/02/2023 23:55

I never used to agree on the immigration topic - but over the past couple of years I really feel the tide has turned and everywhere I look there are people hanging around, who have no care for this country or homes they live in and in turn the “pride” this country used to have really seems to be disappearing and is becoming a little unrecognisable in some areas. I fear it is getting to a point of no return on all aspects…!!

I agree with a lot of what you say in your original post and add-ons but this I can't agree with. It's too easy to blame immigrants @Novembermummy88 rather than demand better from our government and local authorities. Chewing gum all over the pavement is a big pet hate of mine. Councils need special equipment to get rid of the stuff which must be really costly. Why don't people wrap it up, put it in their pocket and then bin it at the next opportunity?

TrinnySmith · 26/02/2023 06:12

About once a month I see local people picking up litter near us - unfortunately that area is just beyond McDonalds so people get their take away and either finish it on the way home and chuck the rubbish or sit in the laybys eating it then chucking the rubbish - I feel takeaways should be charged to cover the discarded packaging.

Novembermummy88 · 26/02/2023 00:07

Wow I’ve just come back to check this thread and amazed how many people feel similar to me that things have gone down hill. I’m so pleased that people are bothered though, it shows there is still some people that care about this country!!

I agree (as my last post on her where I mentioned no one cleared the snow from their own pathways before Christmas except me and my neighbour) that many, MANY people do not look after their own homes anymore. The house opposite me is rented and is the worst kept on the street (the majority are owned/mortgage). I suppose some people who rent may feel it’s not their responsibility to pay for windows to be cleaned, gutters to be cleared I guess…??

my original post though I was more looking at the roads, general grime on streets/leaves not cleared etc, general litter, state of fencing along public roads (not been painted/bent out of shape etc), broken/mucky street lights, things like that. The majority of which is surely down to council funding although we seem to be paying more than ever for our council tax??

personally I feel, more than ever, that the government are “against” us the people and there is no one legitimate left to vote for (don’t start me on Tories re electing leaders that none of us voted for). How do we change this?? Or are we left to keep facing parties that really don’t have this countries best interest at heart…. :(

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 25/02/2023 23:17

All the fault of the Tories?
It certainly is. The fuckers have wrecked the country.Angry

nopuppiesallowed · 25/02/2023 22:21

We're not the only country suffering. Madrid has a huge tent city outside it - the largest in Europe. America has many tent cities. Our country spent billions on the furlough scheme during covid and now is spending billions more supporting Ukraine. We're also spending 7 million a day on housing illegal immigrants. All the fault of the Tories? You could be right but somehow i don't believe a Labour government will wear a halo and wings either

echt · 25/02/2023 21:49

I should have made it plain that I'm not objecting to Sedaris as a US citizen getting a UK rubbish truck named after him, just applauding his attitude.

echt · 25/02/2023 21:48

There's always this:

www.theguardian.com/books/shortcuts/2014/jul/31/david-sedaris-litter-picker-rubbish-waste-vehicle-pig-pen-west-sussex

And he's not even a UK citizen!!!! Will be soon though.

Nanalisa60 · 25/02/2023 21:25

sydneysunset

Stop looking for someone else to blame and change your own environment if you don’t like it.

So true , I can’t fix the pot holes I can’t mend the NHS , but I can pick up litter, so that what I do , every day I take the dog for it’s walk I pick up a carrier bag fall. My street does not have any litter as I pick it all up.

if there is loads of litter on a street then dropping more seems more acceptable, if there is none then people think twice about it.

there is a nursing home near me and I realised that when the staff were leaving that they must be dropped there masks so I phoned up and asked to speck to the manager, well that problem has now stopped.

a few years ago I email local secondary school about the litter being dropped round the school apparently they now have a litter picks once a month.

go to my local beach clear up and other litter picks and other parts of the city I live.

I live in Scotland at this year they are starting a Bottle and can deposit return scheme, I’m hoping this is going to help

Swipe left for the next trending thread