Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think a lot of the Uk looks like a state

763 replies

Novembermummy88 · 23/02/2023 23:10

Not sure if I am being dramatic or if years of austerity are really starting to show…? Lately I’ve really started to notice how filthy, run down and falling apart everywhere looks! I live in a town in the south east on the borders of the M25. Every where there are gapping pot holes (can hardly avoid the volume there are now and genuinely concerned I will lose a wheel at some point!), broken lamp posts, the volume of litter / filth on the roads seems very high and can’t remember the last time I saw a road sweeper, and things like pathways are a state, road markings worn out, SO many closed/dilapidated shops….the town just looks awful as do many of the nearby towns! Is it just the South East looking like this? Aibu?! Or have I watched too much Selling Sunsets and setting my expectations too high…???

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Passthechocolatesplease · 24/02/2023 11:07

Catspyjamas17 · 24/02/2023 10:48

The government is responsible for creating the backdrop to allow people to do that. To have enough leisure time to be able to maintain their surroundings, and not be so fucking tired and worn out and ill that they can barely haul their arse out of bed to work, and their lives are eating working and sleeping (barely) just so they can pay the gas bill like a good little worker bee and make a bit more profit for Shell.

If the government isn't prepared to do that, then what is the actual fucking point of them? We may as well just do our own thing and not bother with paying taxes.

So people can’t take their dog poo home because of the government, can’t take control of their own litter or spend twenty minutes a week tidying their front garden because of the government.

if people spent even a tiny fraction of their time doing something positive instead of sitting browsing the internet or watching crap TV, it’s called taking responsibility.

And do you have to swear to make a point, the English language is rich in available acceptable expletives!

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 11:06

Could also try the BBCs ‘Century of the Self’, but I’d be here all day creating reading lists!

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 11:05

A very good single book on economic history, focusing on land ownership but covering other issues, if anyone does want to try thinking beyond “but it was ever thus” and other such crap, is “Owning the earth” by Andro Linklater.

megletthesecond · 24/02/2023 11:01

amused our town in North Hampshire is money laundering / modern slavery central. Dodgy tanning shops, cake and ice cream shops, nail bars and hairdressers.

MarshaBradyo · 24/02/2023 10:57

Catspyjamas17 · 24/02/2023 10:51

People drop litter and behave like tossers because they are selfish and don't care.

Perhaps it would help if those in charge set a better example and weren't such tossers who don't care and are happy to drop the entire UK in the shit. In a company the tone and ethos is set by the leadership. It's the same with government and the country.

So if Labour get in those that just throw litter will stop?

TheOldLadyOfThreadneedleStreet · 24/02/2023 10:57

That’s what 10 years of austerity does. It was bad in the 1990s too when council budgets were cut for a long time. It got better under Labour in the 2000s.

ladykale · 24/02/2023 10:54

Crazy people are blaming government for people having dropping litter everywhere.

It's more to do with the culture of individualism (v. somewhere like Japan)

Would anyone encourage their child to pick up random litter from the street that wasn't theirs?

This translates to when people get council homes they are paying little for, they don't care whether they leave it in a tip as they don't see anything as their problem, and can wait for it - blame the government for everything..!

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 10:54

And yes ^, the constant attitude from the rich that poorer people should be better than they themselves are, does not help matters. You don’t care a shiny shot about their lives, reality and plight: so don’t ask them to care about your precious appearances.

taxguru · 24/02/2023 10:53

Uncertain12345 · 24/02/2023 10:41

Whilst I agree in principle that taking ideological politics out of the NHS would be no bad thing, giving to private enterprise to sort out isn’t the answer. “Looked at pragmatically” for shareholders means “increase our profits, with growth year on year by whatever means necessary”. The needs of the public it’s meant to serve would be secondary to shareholders need to make ever-growing returns. Bonuses literally take priority over cancer wards.

We’re already seeing the outcome of this with the Water sector. Privatisation was supposed to bring in business long-term investment, so that they would fund new sewers, reservoirs, etc because - in their ideology - the market would demand it.

In reality, the market gets shafted in favour of profit with businesses only addressing problems that could have been avoided earlier because they’ll only spend the money required (and thus reduce potential profit) when they absolutely have to - which often at crisis point. And we’re seeing this exactly now with overflowing sewage because water companies have opted to provide profit over replacing a rapidly declining sewage system.

That's pseudo privatisation though isn't it? Customers have no choice who they "buy" their water from or which firm takes away their waste. There is only one infrastructure, so there can't be competition. Same with the railways where the govt still control which firms can run trains on each line, which trains can stop at which stations, fares, and even what type of trains are allowed to be used by each firm - that's not proper privatisation. Same with Royal Mail who are hog-tied by govt prescribed rules as to delivery timescales, "single fee anywhere", etc - they've fallen by the wayside whilst other couriers have picked up the more profitable work because they're free to do things differently!

For genuine privatisation, you need genuine competition and genuine freedom to operate, innovate, etc. That's the exact opposite of the pretend-privatisation of the utilities (and to an extent other public services such as GP practices!).

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 10:51

it doesn’t give you an immediate right to allow the outside to deteriorate into a filthy tip.

It does exactly that, because the responsibility to fix the outside belongs with the owner. Not the poor sod who is merely paying for the owner to acquire an asset. When we were much much younger my partner was scammed and ripped off along those lines: he took on a tenancy at a slightly cheaper rate on condition he decorated and cleaned up. As soon as the place looked nice, the landlord choked him out and got someone in who paid triple the rent. No one is going to invest in a place where they have no security. This is a basic fact that has driven land economics in the past, eg enclosures : initial enclosure thinking was that giving private ownership to named individuals gave them an incentive to invest.

But as soon as those individuals are too wealthy to need direct involvement, or to big to feel any consequences, that thinking will fail and you have the situation that @Uncertain12345 describes, with no market incentive to do anything but cream off profit.

No e of this is rocket science, and in Britain of all places, it has all happened before during the Industrial Age. It has been incredibly frustrating to watch it happen again.

Catspyjamas17 · 24/02/2023 10:51

People drop litter and behave like tossers because they are selfish and don't care.

Perhaps it would help if those in charge set a better example and weren't such tossers who don't care and are happy to drop the entire UK in the shit. In a company the tone and ethos is set by the leadership. It's the same with government and the country.

TimandGinger · 24/02/2023 10:48

Passthechocolatesplease · 24/02/2023 10:42

Well that’s my point exactly, just because a house is rented and ‘not yours’ it doesn’t give you an immediate right to allow the outside to deteriorate into a filthy tip.
Where has the pride in our surroundings gone, are we now a nation whose attitude is ‘it’s not mine so what do I care’. Every person who dumps litter, fly tips, chucks dog poo bags has been raised and educated. If we are failing to in-still a sense of common decency into every child to facilitate them growing up into decent human beings with a sense of conscience and moral responsibility then we are failing miserably and it won’t matter what government is in charge.

I lived in London for a long time. We lived within walking distance of the river, so centrally in one of the most interesting cities in the world, and yet people said the teenagers (some, not all obviously) behaved like shitheads because they had nothing to do. I found that one a bit hard to believe tbh.
People drop litter and behave like tossers because they are selfish and don't care.

user1465390476 · 24/02/2023 10:48

I think this is inevitable. All the idiots who talk about ‘plague island’ and how rubbish we are have convinced everyone else the UK isn’t worth looking after.

Catspyjamas17 · 24/02/2023 10:48

Passthechocolatesplease · 24/02/2023 10:42

Well that’s my point exactly, just because a house is rented and ‘not yours’ it doesn’t give you an immediate right to allow the outside to deteriorate into a filthy tip.
Where has the pride in our surroundings gone, are we now a nation whose attitude is ‘it’s not mine so what do I care’. Every person who dumps litter, fly tips, chucks dog poo bags has been raised and educated. If we are failing to in-still a sense of common decency into every child to facilitate them growing up into decent human beings with a sense of conscience and moral responsibility then we are failing miserably and it won’t matter what government is in charge.

The government is responsible for creating the backdrop to allow people to do that. To have enough leisure time to be able to maintain their surroundings, and not be so fucking tired and worn out and ill that they can barely haul their arse out of bed to work, and their lives are eating working and sleeping (barely) just so they can pay the gas bill like a good little worker bee and make a bit more profit for Shell.

If the government isn't prepared to do that, then what is the actual fucking point of them? We may as well just do our own thing and not bother with paying taxes.

amusedbush · 24/02/2023 10:48

I'm in Glasgow and parts of it look like the post-apocalyptic cities in The Last of Us.

Recently there was a protest outside the council HQ because the roads are an absolute disgrace. Any report via the council app gets a standard response of "we've assessed it... low risk... blah blah", they fill the pothole with cheap shite and the second it gets cold, all the rainwater that has seeped into it freezes, expands, breaks up the tar and the crater is back three weeks later. There is a facebook group for drivers to warn each other when they've had another blown tyre or buckled alloy.

The council also installed a load of speed bumps in our street (which they had to completely re-do because they used shite materials and the first set of bumps all crumbled within three months) but never painted markings on them and didn't bother to sweep up, just left gravel strewn the length of the road. Perfect for taking out someone's windscreen one dark morning!

"Leave the car at home" says the radio advert. Okay, but if the bus actually turns up at all, it's extortionate and fucking filthy on the inside.

Not that there's anywhere to go around here now. Maybe to the tip, because bin collection has been changed from fortnightly to every three weeks. Or I could go to the main street, where every other shop is a money laundering front tanning salon or bookies.

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 24/02/2023 10:47

Total shit hole here and no buses to boot.

Passthechocolatesplease · 24/02/2023 10:42

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 10:23

So many people don’t take a pride in their own surroundings any more, they don’t bother keeping their own gardens tidy,

For so many millions, it isn’t their surroundings. Every inch of Britain is owned, much of it by foreign interests, the rest by private landlords. Our work isn’t benefitting us. Trust has gone.

Well that’s my point exactly, just because a house is rented and ‘not yours’ it doesn’t give you an immediate right to allow the outside to deteriorate into a filthy tip.
Where has the pride in our surroundings gone, are we now a nation whose attitude is ‘it’s not mine so what do I care’. Every person who dumps litter, fly tips, chucks dog poo bags has been raised and educated. If we are failing to in-still a sense of common decency into every child to facilitate them growing up into decent human beings with a sense of conscience and moral responsibility then we are failing miserably and it won’t matter what government is in charge.

Uncertain12345 · 24/02/2023 10:41

ImWearingReallyJudgyPants · 24/02/2023 10:13

I think that any government of any political hue is actually doomed because there are too many other factors that come into play. However good you make state schools, there will always be children whose family backgrounds are too chaotic for school to make much difference.

The NHS is a money pit: you could give every penny earned by every single person in the country to the NHS and it would just swallow it up and nobody would see any change.

In a way, what is needed is for party politics to be taken out of health and education. If they could both be looked at pragmatically, rather than through an ideological lens, it might be possible to make some improvements. They would have to be very radical in the case of the NHS in particular: the NHS isn't fit for purpose as the needs of the population are now so different, but the mawkish sentiment attached to "our NHS" makes it impossible for anyone with any kind of power to do anything to improve healthcare.

On a more local level, we would probably all benefit from party politics being taken out, too. I live in a beautiful, well-tended place that's a safe Tory seat - but a lot of that is nothing to do with the Tory MP and everything to do with most of the people who live here caring about their environment, doing their bit to keep it nice, using outdoor spaces for their intended purposes (i.e. as children's playgrounds, not as drug/drinking zones), and bringing their children up to see why they in turn need to keep things nice for everyone else.

Sorry - rambling, but I'm stuck at home with a rotten cold!

Whilst I agree in principle that taking ideological politics out of the NHS would be no bad thing, giving to private enterprise to sort out isn’t the answer. “Looked at pragmatically” for shareholders means “increase our profits, with growth year on year by whatever means necessary”. The needs of the public it’s meant to serve would be secondary to shareholders need to make ever-growing returns. Bonuses literally take priority over cancer wards.

We’re already seeing the outcome of this with the Water sector. Privatisation was supposed to bring in business long-term investment, so that they would fund new sewers, reservoirs, etc because - in their ideology - the market would demand it.

In reality, the market gets shafted in favour of profit with businesses only addressing problems that could have been avoided earlier because they’ll only spend the money required (and thus reduce potential profit) when they absolutely have to - which often at crisis point. And we’re seeing this exactly now with overflowing sewage because water companies have opted to provide profit over replacing a rapidly declining sewage system.

SnuggleBuggleBoo · 24/02/2023 10:40

Novembermummy88 · 23/02/2023 23:10

Not sure if I am being dramatic or if years of austerity are really starting to show…? Lately I’ve really started to notice how filthy, run down and falling apart everywhere looks! I live in a town in the south east on the borders of the M25. Every where there are gapping pot holes (can hardly avoid the volume there are now and genuinely concerned I will lose a wheel at some point!), broken lamp posts, the volume of litter / filth on the roads seems very high and can’t remember the last time I saw a road sweeper, and things like pathways are a state, road markings worn out, SO many closed/dilapidated shops….the town just looks awful as do many of the nearby towns! Is it just the South East looking like this? Aibu?! Or have I watched too much Selling Sunsets and setting my expectations too high…???

I absolutely agree OP! It's been in decline for years but it's got much worse post Brexit/Covid. So many homeless people too now. 10 years ago you were quite taken aback to see one in my town, now they're just everywhere. So many independent shops have closed, with betting, payday loan or vaping shops in their place. It's really very sad.

Catspyjamas17 · 24/02/2023 10:39

I certainly wouldn't blame the current lot for everything - yes lots of things have long roots and got back more than 13 years.

I do blame them however for:

  • Utter incompetency and economic mismanagement
  • Greed and corruption, being into politics for themselves, and giving away billions of public money to mates and cronies
  • Deliberately, ideologically under funding all public services
  • Getting the NHS and the state of the nation's health into such a mess that it was completely unprepared to cope with a pandemic and the aftermath of that
  • Soaring poverty levels and rising crime
  • The utter shitshow that is the current education system - particularly what they have done to secondary schools
  • The searing waste of time and money on Brexit and selling the next generation down the line with it and all the absolute shit heaped upon small businesses that was utterly, utterly unnecessary
  • Making lots of lovely, hard working people leave and go back to live in the rest of Europe, creating massive labour shortages
  • Creating a more divided national where voicing racist views in public has become more normal
  • Paying only lip service to tackling climate change
  • Not doing anywhere near enough to tackle the total imbalance in the economy created by the absolute greed of energy companies
  • Allowing the super rich to get massively richer and the majority of people to be much poorer

I'm sure I've forgotten a few things, but it's quite a list of achievements in a decade and a bit.

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 10:39

TrinnySmith · 24/02/2023 10:23

But it was ever thus.

That is trolling or gaslighting. No it was never this bad, not until you go back to the 1920s and before. There’s actually a reason for that: this is exactly what happens when you let private financial interests run rampant and ignore the plight of real actual people. This is why most societies hold a balance of public and private interests.

And even then there was not so much foreign involvement: that was the native British ruling elite stamping down on its own working classes as well as the rest of the world. Now the rest of the world is getting in on the act too, with British collusion.

horseyhorsey17 · 24/02/2023 10:38

RaspberriesToYouToo · 24/02/2023 10:23

So many people don’t take a pride in their own surroundings any more, they don’t bother keeping their own gardens tidy,

For so many millions, it isn’t their surroundings. Every inch of Britain is owned, much of it by foreign interests, the rest by private landlords. Our work isn’t benefitting us. Trust has gone.

Lots of people are working so many hours to try and keep afloat that they don't have time for gardening.

TimandGinger · 24/02/2023 10:34

MarshaBradyo · 24/02/2023 10:30

If people compare tourist spots to every day towns it’s not going to be similar. It’s more the towns you mention that are comparable

Yes - I agree Britain is in a state, but trying to say that all of France is pristine is absolutely ridiculous. Plenty of Europe also has that 'held together by sticky tape' feeling that we see here too.

ladykale · 24/02/2023 10:34

PurpleButterflyWings · 24/02/2023 10:30

@ladykale

I am not going to blame immigrants for the state the country is in, indeed I don't. But it's a bit of a reach to say they're the ones holding the country together. That's as ludicrous as saying the country being a shitshow is their fault. Confused

I'm talking about public services and frontline services specifically, so in particular

• NHS - immigrants (or expats as many should actually be called given they are so skilled) constitute a v high % both doctors and nurses
• supermarkets
• cleaners etc
• fruit & veg pickers etc

We have emergency post Brexit because there are no fruit and veg pickers as people in the uk don't want to do it.

Don't know if you work or know anyone who works in the NHS, but ask them - if you took away all immigrants and second generation, the system WOULD crumble.

FixundFoxi · 24/02/2023 10:31

I certainly don't live in a 'naice' town. Absolute disgrace and many articles written about its sad decline. Manchester which is booming has sucked the place dry as well as years of under investment. Ironically our joke of a council missed the deadline to apply for the levelling up funds lottery which in itself is a bl*y joke. Rishi Sunaks constituency Richmond in north yorks being more deserving
Here are a few choice photos of the actual town centre shopping experience

To think a lot of the Uk looks like a state
To think a lot of the Uk looks like a state
To think a lot of the Uk looks like a state
To think a lot of the Uk looks like a state
Swipe left for the next trending thread