Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you'd class as cooking?

145 replies

Mouldyfoodhelp · 23/02/2023 19:57

Having a discussion with someone and their stance is: just getting a chicken breast out the pack and into the oven with a few potatoes is good enough cooking, doing the same with a ready meal, or buying a pie.

My stance is that whilst that's cooking in its absolutely most basic sense ( bar the ready meal), it's not what most people mean when they cook. Now I'm not being snobby we have more than our fair share of crap food but I say actual cooking has more processes like let's say a roast even though you're putting a chicken in the oven you're seasoning it, portioning it afterwards and you've got the veg to sort out, Yorkshire, stuffing etc. Other food ideals are for example a carbonara, shepherds pie, lasagne type stuff meals.

And even if some people do just put stuff in the oven I argue it's not literally just a plain chicken breast normally and they generally do some work for the meal.

It's more about expectations of results when each is cooking because I know they wouldn't be happy If that's all I did all the time as well.

OP posts:
5foot5 · 24/02/2023 00:57

Mouldyfoodhelp · 23/02/2023 20:28

Not exactly that, but sort of. We prepare a menu every Thursday for shopping and stick to it reasonably well, there's a few people cooking, but one decides they aren't going to try, that they can't cook and won't attempt something with any real steps. So we give them say chicken and chips with Coleslaw, but the coleslaw has to be ready made and moan if its a whole chicken as they have to portion it out.

Same if we give them sausages and mash they'll moan about mashing the potatoes and if we ask for some onion gravy its a big ordeal, and their retort that I' must have heard 500+ times is " normal/ most people wouldn't do this they'd just get a piece of chicken sling it in the oven and be done with it with some potatoes"

So you have adult children living at home and have a cooking rota?

We have a similar situation and proper cooking happens.

YANBU but I wonder when you say "we give them chicken and chips with Coleslaw" or "we give them sausages and mash" do you mean that you decide the meals and tell them what you are expecting them to cook? What would happen if you ask them to just decide the menu themselves?

On Thursdays we decide the menu for the week ahead and adult DC have their days when they cook. They write on the menu what they will cook and put ingredients on the shopping list. Frankly, they are more adventurous than me or Dh and we all like cooking!

But, yeah, they are BU to moan about mashing potatoes or making gravy!!

midgemadgemodge · 23/02/2023 22:52

Cooking to me is the minimum required to get something you like to eat

If that's putting a piece of chicken and a
Potato in the oven that's great

I think more people realised how easy lots of cooking can be they might be happier to avoid junk and ready meals

Faffing around - who had time for that when kids are needing fed and it s late and your tired ?

Delectable · 23/02/2023 22:41

Scrambled pancake.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 23/02/2023 22:41

CantFindTheBeat · 23/02/2023 21:04

Genuinely interested that you would not consider mince, sauce and pasta, cooking, yet your use the word 'cooked' in your description.

@OchonAgusOchonOh - why did you use that word?

The pasta is cooked but it's not cooking per se to my mind. I would think the same about throwing a spud in the microwave or oven to make baked potato. Basically, you end up with cooked food, the same way you end up with cooked food if you bung a ready meal in the oven but it doesn't count as cooking it yourself.

I think I,explained my logic re the sauce and meat. I don't consider it cooking if you haven't done the main part of the meal yourself. I would describe that as preparing food using convenience food.

Pseudonamed · 23/02/2023 22:40

I will agree with a roast dinner being an easy one and I make me own yorkies and stuffing but they are not hard to all cook together.

Days in this house it will be a takeout, another day could be anything on toast and i mean anything (fish fingers and peas, super noodles, literally anything) and then I have days where every spice and herb is out on the island being used.

When dp 'cooks' it is pasta with chilli or tabasco sauce added to it. This is what he considers cooking. The odd time he will BUY a cooked chicken and just throw frozen spuds and yorkies in the oven and boil peas and again calls it cooking. Maybe it is just a personal thing!

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 23/02/2023 22:21

Coffeecoffeeinmytummy · 23/02/2023 21:38

Blimey. I’ve seen it all on here now. Making a roast dinner from scratch doesn’t count as cooking? Ok.

Yeah but what do you mean ‘from scratch’ ? you mean peeling some veg and unwrapping a chicken, bit of oxo and some oil, all in the oven and feet up for an hour? Kettle on for the bisto and Roberts your fathers brother? It’s a lazy Sunday washing up generator, not a culinary masterpiece.

User158432907 · 23/02/2023 21:58

Raw food is cooked
Cooked food is heated up

caringcarer · 23/02/2023 21:55

Popping a shop bought pizza or pie in oven is warming not cooking. Using fresh ingredients from scratch is cooking. Chicken breast, potatoes and fresh veg or even frozen peas is basic cooking in my book.

coconotgrove · 23/02/2023 21:42

Interesting question OP.

If I'm cooking, then I'm using either the hob and/or oven, and cooking something (usually) from scratch, so this can range from boiling eggs, baking a cake, pan-frying fish/meat, sauces, roasting a chicken and everything in between.

If I'm making something to eat, then the components are usually all cold - I'm assembling something be it a salad, a sandwich etc etc. There's rarely, if ever any heat involved.

(I don't have a microwave and rarely buy anything ready made, but if I do, this I would class as heating up something to eat!)

twinkleto · 23/02/2023 21:42

Cooking is whatever it takes to get a meal down on the table in the evening.

Anything made before 4pm is not cooking 😆 no idea why.

The opposite of cooking is phoning for a takeaway.

User158432907 · 23/02/2023 21:40

It doesn't really make any difference if it's homemade or from the freezer if it goes in the oven, air fryer or microwave it's cooked as a lot of frozen food is raw so you have to cook it to eat it.

Coffeecoffeeinmytummy · 23/02/2023 21:38

Wanttotryaplugbutpartnernotkeenwwyd · 23/02/2023 20:19

A roast is hardly ‘cooking’, you just shove everything in the oven? Even if you have to peel the veg first, that not a huge step away from reheating a ready meal. For me, ‘ cooking’ must utilise the hob and raw ingredients. Otherwise you’ve basically done nowt

Blimey. I’ve seen it all on here now. Making a roast dinner from scratch doesn’t count as cooking? Ok.

Camilliatile · 23/02/2023 21:33

If it involves adding heat to food items before they are eaten, then it's cooking. HTH.

CrystalCoco · 23/02/2023 21:33

To answer the question, no, I don't think most people would eat chicken and potato every day (if that was the question)

The person you're discussing clearly doesn't like cooking, wants to put in minimal effort and get a pass for literally putting 'something on the table'.

You're unlikely to change this person / their opinion, no matter how hard you try, some people just can't be assed 'cooking' - I have two relatives and a friend who are like this, luckily for me, their opinions/actions don't impact me but I can see why it'd be irritating if everyone else is making more of an effort and this one person isn't.

However, if the food is edible (even if it's repetitive & boring) I don't think I'd pick this hill to die on.

Yessiricanboogiebutineedacertainsong · 23/02/2023 21:31

What would you class my dinner tonight as?
Brocolli, cauliflower, carrots, homemade wedges & fishfingers?
The veg is all from fresh and chopping etc..I’d consider that cooking 🤔 but it feels weird to call the opening the packet and putting the fishfingers on a baking tray cooking 😬

snowbellsxox · 23/02/2023 21:31

For those who provide fresh cooked meals everyday, do you have young children?! Hmm if so what do you do when you are prepping the food? Are they watching screen or getting involved? Curious..
I don't stand around with fresh veg,
I tend to get frozen pre sorted veg and just boil it! Time saver. Or I will do a lot of frying..

BatildaB · 23/02/2023 21:28

I crossposted with your recent updates.. sounds like the former then, but if it is a young adult child then good luck arguing him out of it! Maybe he needs to live independently to realise how much work others are doing?

Jobalons · 23/02/2023 21:28

Roasting is cooking as far as I'm concerned, give two people the exact piece of meat and ask them both to roast.

One may well come out beautifully succulent, or pulled with gorgeous gravy with superbly done crisp roast vedge and the other who chucked it in at all in, in one go with zero prep or care can come out like cardboard with burn roast veg.

Big difference.

TangledWebOfDeception · 23/02/2023 21:25

God he sounds infuriating! Is this your DH/DP? I couldn’t respect someone so whiny and immature.

BatildaB · 23/02/2023 21:22

Sounds like you have different standards for meals and cleanliness and probably can’t live harmoniously together. Does everyone else care/feel he’s taking the piss as much as you do? Sounds like a group living situation and there’s always going to be a range of people with different attitudes that have to rub along in that scenario, and a certain amount of letting things go. Hard to tell from your description if he’s a problematic freeloader or if you’re being dictatorial.

Everyotherone · 23/02/2023 21:22

Honestly I’d argue that what tv chefs and restaurant chefs do isn’t cooking- it’s performative food art. Cooking, in my opinion,is the considerably more complex art of keeping a family fed despite rising costs, food shortages and sensory issues, while trying to impart life skills to children.

Sometimes I use a portion of ragu I batch cooked and froze months before. Sometimes I open a jar of dolmio. It’s bonkers to suggest that one is cooking and one is not.

Pallisers · 23/02/2023 21:20

If it is one of your children so you are concerned about diet and nutrition for them, why not get them off the rota, feed them with everyone else, but only do it on the basis they must do something else - clean up or hoovering or whatever.

If it is roommate, who cares what they eat.

WandaWonder · 23/02/2023 21:18

If it involves heat to me it is cooking

Even heating baked beansto me is cooking I will happily make a salad and eat that for tea but it is not cooking as it is not cooked

Sticking something in the oven is cooking to me or even in the microwave as the heat is the cook part

LolaSmiles · 23/02/2023 21:17

Mouldyfoodhelp
It seems like it's not the technicalities of cooking Vs not that's got your irritated. It's the attitude.

Take two similar scenarios:

Scenario 1: person cooks some pasta, stirs in a jar sauce. They either aren't a fan of cooking or are busy and can't/don't have interest in making a sauce from scratch. They've put a frozen garlic bread in the oven. They serve up dinner and offer some cheese on top / have a bowl of cheese for people to help themselves (which they might have grated or might have bought pre grated).

Scenario 2: person cooks some pasta, stirs in a jar sauce. They serve it out and when someone mentions some grated cheese, the person huffs and puffs because waaah that involves getting a grater out the cupboard and grating cheese or having to go all the way to the fridge and get some scissors to cut the packet of pre grated cheese open, and anyway I've already cooked a sauce. Most people would have been happy with plain pasta.

Both are pasta and jar sauce, but the person in scenario 1 has thought about others and the person in scenario 2 is like a whiny child.

Mouldyfoodhelp · 23/02/2023 21:17

Pallisers · 23/02/2023 21:11

Is this an adult? Why don't you simply tell them to cook for themselves from now on and do your own thing with the other adults in the house. Just take them off the rota and don't cook for them.

To answer the original question no, I don't think most people cook like that for every meal. Nor do most people think you need to clean the house once a month (although of the minority who do, 3 of them are roommates of my dd's)

It is an adult and we've actually done that for a few weeks the first week they got ready meals for themselves and rolls for lunch, the second didn't get any carbs just protein until I put it on the shopping for them unprompted and they used it but no veg. Whilst moaning about the meals we were having and that when it finished we'd have to have those meals again as they'd missed out.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread