Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to lose my rag completely with my employer?

183 replies

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 13:16

I was a science teacher in a secondary school. When I fell pregnant, I told my employer early on because I had a high-risk pregnancy and needed lots of appointments as well as obvious issues of my role (chemicals, fire, fumes but also working in a school with poor behaviour and very frequent physical alternations and incidents). Within a week, my school posted an advert online for a new science teacher to start as soon as possible. I raised it and was told that they’re intending to expand the department - first time that’s been mentioned and the school isn’t growing in student numbers (it’s not a school of choice locally). Not to mention, they wouldn’t expand a department mid-year because they’d have to reshuffle all the timetables and room allocations etc. But, the state of teaching being what it is, they didn’t get any applicants so no one was hired. I’m currently on maternity leave and I won’t be returning - I have a job that’s not in teaching lined up. I just gave my employer my notice to leave at the end of the Easter holiday - giving the required notice. Just got my payslip via email and the bastards haven’t paid me anything this month. AIBU to be absolutely sick to death of this shit now?

OP posts:
BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 23/02/2023 14:46

think you might work where I work @mincedtart - someone started, had a child and took mat pay, came back for literally a month, had another kid, was due to return then handed her notice in.Her team has been doing her job and constantly having to pick up slack (headcount would not allow for even a mat leave temp) and is now in a scramble trying to replace her. Total pisstake.

Trying81 · 23/02/2023 14:41

I assume you have emailed them now?

Look back on your payslips, when SMP started - what dates did they pay the 90% element for the first 6 weeks? This should make it easier to figure out how many weeks left if you haven’t a pay schedule detailing it

Point out that although you won’t be returning following maternity leave, that didn’t constitute an immediate resignation, rather that you were giving notice and as such you are still due your remaining SMP - and if no enhanced maternity was paid then you have nothing to pay back.

If they disagree, speak to acas - you probably have a good case for constructive dismissal should you want to take that route with them advertising your job right away and not as maternity cover (if I read that correctly anyway, I’ve not got the original post still open)

Additionally, you’re due to holidays and bank holidays to be paid for which have accrued whilst on maternity - I know schools are a little different so you’d want to check your contract on that one.

BellePeppa · 23/02/2023 14:40

ArmchairAnarchist2 · 23/02/2023 13:20

Yes and no?

I would assume yes to the first question and no to the second?

Pinkdelight3 · 23/02/2023 14:37

Not sure how it whiffs of constructive dismissal when she's not been dismissed, she handed her notice in, and they haven't hired anyone else. She has her own theories about them recruiting, but that's about the size of it.

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 14:36

Ssmiler · 23/02/2023 14:31

I work in payroll - not in a school but public sector. You keep saying you didn’t “claim” enhanced maternity pay op. What do you mean by that? do you mean that you said at the start that you only wanted statutory pay, and then only got statutory, as you weren’t returning after maternity? If so, ignore the rest of my post. If not then read on!

So everyone gets the statutory pay they are entitled to, then some employers, including mine and yours, enhance that under the contractual terms of employment. No one claims that - its like your salary in that it’s automatically paid to those that have been there long enough to be eligible. We don’t ask people if they plan to return - that’s not allowed - so we pay everyone statutory AND the enhanced contractual element on the assumption that they plan to return.

It is usually in the contract that it does then have to be repaid if the person doesn’t return / advises they won’t return. So in a position like yours of resignation during maternity period, we would reduce the pay to nil to claw back the overpayment of the contractual element. You are still in effect receiving statutory pay during this nil pay period - but you have received it early / up front within the contractual element which you are now not due - hence nil pay now.

The final result should be that you are at nil pay until the total you receive for the maternity period is down to the statutory amount only. You will stay on nil pay for the rest of the 39 week period until the total you’ve been paid equates to the statutory amount due for the 39 weeks. If the period of 39 weeks ends before full repayment of occupational, you may have to repay the balance directly.

The tax figure you see on your nil pay payslip will be a refund amount as it’s the tax you already paid that’s no longer due as a result of clawing back overpayment. You accrue your tax allowance monthly - as you’ve no taxable pay this month that’s set against previous months pay on a cumulative basis so it triggers a refund. You should see that tax amount in your bank on pay day

What do you mean by that? do you mean that you said at the start that you only wanted statutory pay, and then only got statutory, as you weren’t returning after maternity?

Yes - exactly that. I’m still supposed to be on statutory pay but I’ve not received anything all on my payslip this month. Whilst payroll/admin/reception were aware I wouldn’t be returning and so was my HoD, the SLT only found out within the last month.

OP posts:
RichardHeed · 23/02/2023 14:34

Good grief the responses on this thread are so unhelpful!

Why is everyone so bitchy and rude today?

Welcome to Mumsnet. You’ll also find it’s the same mouthpieces arias threads too.

Ssmiler · 23/02/2023 14:31

I work in payroll - not in a school but public sector. You keep saying you didn’t “claim” enhanced maternity pay op. What do you mean by that? do you mean that you said at the start that you only wanted statutory pay, and then only got statutory, as you weren’t returning after maternity? If so, ignore the rest of my post. If not then read on!

So everyone gets the statutory pay they are entitled to, then some employers, including mine and yours, enhance that under the contractual terms of employment. No one claims that - its like your salary in that it’s automatically paid to those that have been there long enough to be eligible. We don’t ask people if they plan to return - that’s not allowed - so we pay everyone statutory AND the enhanced contractual element on the assumption that they plan to return.

It is usually in the contract that it does then have to be repaid if the person doesn’t return / advises they won’t return. So in a position like yours of resignation during maternity period, we would reduce the pay to nil to claw back the overpayment of the contractual element. You are still in effect receiving statutory pay during this nil pay period - but you have received it early / up front within the contractual element which you are now not due - hence nil pay now.

The final result should be that you are at nil pay until the total you receive for the maternity period is down to the statutory amount only. You will stay on nil pay for the rest of the 39 week period until the total you’ve been paid equates to the statutory amount due for the 39 weeks. If the period of 39 weeks ends before full repayment of occupational, you may have to repay the balance directly.

The tax figure you see on your nil pay payslip will be a refund amount as it’s the tax you already paid that’s no longer due as a result of clawing back overpayment. You accrue your tax allowance monthly - as you’ve no taxable pay this month that’s set against previous months pay on a cumulative basis so it triggers a refund. You should see that tax amount in your bank on pay day

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/02/2023 14:31

viques · 23/02/2023 14:13

That’s a bit pants, I would have expected them at the very least to do a quick check that all the dates worked out. Hope you get it sorted. Enjoy the baby.

I don't think it's "pants" in the slightest. Any union would surely expect an employee to at least ask their employer first! Surely that's just basic common sense!

Mustnotbeleftblank · 23/02/2023 14:30

YANBU to be pissed off. It is not ok for any employer to not pay SMP or any salary you are entitled to. Might be worth contacting Pregnant then Screwed for advice about them trying to replace you when you were pregnant too, has the whiff of constructive dismissal about it.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/02/2023 14:28

I honestly can't understand why you'd come to rant on MN and call your union before you have even asked your employer what's going on. Do you always over complicate things in this way?

If you had called your employer and they were refusing to pay what you were owed, then fair enough, but this just seems like an unnecessary drama when you might be able to ring up and get it sorted in 5 mins.

I just can't understand the mindset where talking to your employer wouldn't be your first response.

Pinkdelight3 · 23/02/2023 14:27

They haven't refused to pay you yet. It's most likely an error.

The rag-losing seems to be anger about what happened in the first half of your post, but that also seems misplaced, as by your own account you told them you would be absent a lot and unable to cover some duties so they quickly got on with adding more staff. What did you expect them to do? Not have any teacher or back up plan while you were off or unable to teach?

ScrantonDunderMifflin · 23/02/2023 14:25

This is insane how many people can't read the OP didn't claim occupational pay.

OP, I would imagine it's some kind of error with the payroll department? I'd contact them

ShimmeringShirts · 23/02/2023 14:24

They can’t pay you minus, that means you’re due a tax refund not that they’ve charged you tax.

ScramblePud · 23/02/2023 14:23

mincedtart · 23/02/2023 14:19

Yep, that’s the entire extent of it…

Nothing to do with someone agreeing to a start date, keeping up pretences that they’re committed to it for almost a year, while having zero intention of returning.

The employer agreed to a notice period. And, in teaching, a return date is decided with less notice than a leave date. So, all this committing for a year in advance is bollocks.

Chickenly · 23/02/2023 14:19

Viviennemary · 23/02/2023 14:14

You still haven't answered when your maternity leave started. This might be the explanation why they didn't pay you this month. It's either an error (in which case it will be paid) or you aren't entitled to the last payment.

Actually she did answer that. Why is everyone so bitchy and rude today?

mincedtart · 23/02/2023 14:19

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 14:10

So, you just have a general issue with people leaving their jobs at the required notice then?

Yep, that’s the entire extent of it…

Nothing to do with someone agreeing to a start date, keeping up pretences that they’re committed to it for almost a year, while having zero intention of returning.

2bazookas · 23/02/2023 14:18

Why lose rag?
Polite firm written reply "There appears to have been a clerical error on my recent payslip, could someone please check this and correct it please."

cherish123 · 23/02/2023 14:18

Don't know specific details, but I would think you are due holiday pay.

Viviennemary · 23/02/2023 14:14

You still haven't answered when your maternity leave started. This might be the explanation why they didn't pay you this month. It's either an error (in which case it will be paid) or you aren't entitled to the last payment.

viques · 23/02/2023 14:13

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 14:08

Thanks, I phoned them and they just said to call them back if I’ve spoken to my school and they still refuse to pay me… not massively useful but I’m not sure what I fully expected to be honest. Never used them before.

That’s a bit pants, I would have expected them at the very least to do a quick check that all the dates worked out. Hope you get it sorted. Enjoy the baby.

BumpySkull · 23/02/2023 14:13

Coffeellama · 23/02/2023 14:09

What more can they say when you haven’t checked if it’s an error or not yet? Are you going to contact payroll and ask?

I’m not massively invested but, in theory, they could’ve given advice on how best to contact or who to contact, they could’ve said if it’s a regular or rare occurrence, they could’ve indicated if there are any loopholes or exceptions to be aware of… there were plenty of options of things that they could have said.

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 14:10

mincedtart · 23/02/2023 14:07

Supporting people for months on the understanding they’re coming back and then realizing last minute that I have to find someone new, onboard them to the role, figure out the knock-on effects on other teams, negotiate salaries etc, is super frustrating when I could have been doing so months earlier.

So, you just have a general issue with people leaving their jobs at the required notice then?

OP posts:
Coffeellama · 23/02/2023 14:09

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 14:08

Thanks, I phoned them and they just said to call them back if I’ve spoken to my school and they still refuse to pay me… not massively useful but I’m not sure what I fully expected to be honest. Never used them before.

What more can they say when you haven’t checked if it’s an error or not yet? Are you going to contact payroll and ask?

Edumacator · 23/02/2023 14:08

viques · 23/02/2023 14:06

Are you in a Union, the Burgundy Book rules are very clear so a Union adviser should be able to clear this up for you. Call your regional office, that way you will have some ammunition in your weapon of choice when you speak to your payroll people.

Thanks, I phoned them and they just said to call them back if I’ve spoken to my school and they still refuse to pay me… not massively useful but I’m not sure what I fully expected to be honest. Never used them before.

OP posts:
burnoutbabe · 23/02/2023 14:07

No idea on maternity pay but the tax thing makes sense if it is negative.

The tax system assumes you get whatever you get is sane for rest of the tax year. And now you get nil, it needs to refund you sone tax for that year. Hence you should receive can actual payment this month into your bank of the tax amount.