Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To those who didn't want Children by choice?

210 replies

girlfriend44 · 23/02/2023 12:43

Families are everywhere. Everyone seems to have Grandchildren which in turn leads to family parties and celebrations and get togethers. You either hear about it or see it on FB.

The world seems to be geared to Families.
If you didn't want children, do you worry about missing out on grandchildren etc?
Everyone seems to have them or am I only seeing the ones that do?
How do you feel about seeing people with children and grandchildren?
Do not wish to disclose my position as like to remain private before anyone asks why I'm asking.

OP posts:
PandasAreUseless · 23/02/2023 14:00

Children just aren't part of my world to be honest, so I don't really notice that they're everywhere.
DH and I holiday when they aren't around (because it's quiet and cheap then), eat out when they aren't around (because we like an 8.30pm table), and see our friends minus their kids (because the parents enjoy a night off, not because the kids aren't welcome).
I simply....forget that kids exist!
As for family get togethers, we've always hosted them because weve got the space and like to cook. And then every now and again we have christmas on our own, which is pure bliss.
My mum has a grandchild, but he lives overseas so she doesn't see him often - lots of people are in the same boat these days.
As I don't want/care about kids, I also don't want/care about grandkids either.
My SIL is currently pregnant so I'm soon to get a niece/nephew. We can always join in with their family get togethers if we want in future, but I don't imagine we'll be too fussed tbh.

Ir2urw · 23/02/2023 14:00

Knew even as a child myself that i didn't want children, wouldn't want grandkids as that involves children so...

I have friends with children and I'm happy for them but llthe whole world isn't geared towards it, there's lots of stuff, friends, things to do without children.

As for care issues, children doesn't guarentee any help with that, I haven't spoken to my mother in absolutely years, no idea where she lives or her I, so she will have to sort her own care out.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 23/02/2023 13:59

It’s interesting that when mums say on MN threads that they don’t like kids, only their own, the other posters all laugh and agree.

When childless women say it, we’re prejudiced, weird, or - as I saw on one particular bizarre thread - racist. Oh, and we shouldn’t be on MN.

I wonder what could possibly account for such a difference. I guess we’ll never know.

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/02/2023 13:58

gelatogina · 23/02/2023 13:51

Thanks for explaining what a child is 😂😂

I really don’t like them or have any interest in spending time with them. If that seems odd to you then I equally find you odd for liking them. I can appreciate both sides.

Jesus Christ the thread the other day about bum worms, that was enough to put me off for life!

and my plan for old age? All the money I save not having children will buy me a lovely retirement, a sheltered apartment when the time comes. And when the time REALLY comes, a lovely peaceful death at Dignitas. (Or hopefully at home if we ever get up to date with the law here)

no regrets whatsoever.

Yep. No children = nobody to worry about leaving an inheritance for. We’ll take out a lifetime mortgage or similar and use all the equity in our home and all our savings to have a blast during retirement, and to prepare for end of life care and arrangements. Surely having children, and having to spend money on them, and feeling like you want to leave them money and assets when you die, as most parents seem to, actually makes planning for a good old age more difficult rather than less?

And I don’t like children in the same way I don’t like dogs. In both cases, some are better trained than others and are tolerable in small doses, but broadly speaking, all small humans share a set of characteristics I find tedious and annoying in the same way as all dogs share a set of characteristics I find a bit gross. Although at last dogs come with the positive of being able to go on nice long walks. I can’t think of any positives to having a child, being that I’ve no interest in taking care of one or teaching it anything or watching it grow.

TheLeadbetterLife · 23/02/2023 13:58

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 13:56

@purpleboy I would assume that you saw those threads because you came to the site in the first place though. As such i wondered how the initial "intro" happened, as it were and people have responded to let me know.

If you google for almost anything at all, a MN thread will appear high up in the searches. That's how I got here.

thymee · 23/02/2023 13:58

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 13:07

I am curious why people who don't want children and never have done are posters on Mumsnet?

Can any of you elaborate please? I am genuinely curious about it. It just seems like an odd place for you to end up.

There are a lot of topics and threads on here which are nothing to do with children or parenting.

MyCousinsNotVinny · 23/02/2023 13:58

The problem with grandchildren is that you can't get them without the years of labour that having children involves!!!

So those of you who have chosen to be child-free, what’s your desire or hope for later life and care? Thanks

@Coolcoolcool Most people I think hope they will die quick and fast in the night without suffering dementia or serious physical ill health!

I think the child-free issue is a red herring because there are no guarantees in life. No one will children is guaranteed support and care in later life. Children do pre-decease parents. Children move abroad or to locations where they can't help. Some children don't have good relationships with their parents or fall out later in life and don't want to help.

The big problem is for everyone that this is becoming more unlikely because people are living longer. The longer you live the more likely you are to develop dementia of some type.

I know of two people who have been fine up until late 80s/early 90s and just started having failing memory and then been diagnosed with dementia. This is a problem because for most people as that progresses care at home will be beyond the capability of even the most loving family member - it needs things like catheters, incontinence management etc.

My hope for later life is that I am mentally well enough to select my own care preferences and that I am wealthy enough to pay for them.

purpleboy · 23/02/2023 13:58

theworldhas · 23/02/2023 13:35

Always strikes me as slightly odd when people say they don’t like children. Which is of course totally different to saying I don’t want responsibility for children or to be a parent. Children are just young humans, aged 0-17 and come in all different shapes, sizes and personalities. Just seems a bit prejudiced and narrow minded to me. It’s like someone saying they don’t like old people or they don’t like city people. I mean sure some old people can really encapsulate some of the worst traits of that demographic (maybe be a bit grumpy or a bit “I know best” etc) but the vast majority are just nice, normal people. Just as some kids might ask too many questions or have a quick temper, but that hardly wipes out all their positive traits!

I like my own children but I don't particularly like other children, TBF though it's probably more the way they are parented that I don't like.

EmmaEmerald · 23/02/2023 13:57

Peekatyourbeak · 23/02/2023 13:31

To me having grandchildren would be worse than having children so I don’t feel like I’m missing out on that.

This is interesting

mum has observed that - with the childfree people in her long standing circle of friends, they are struggling even more gatherings with other people's grandchildren running around, than when they were in their 40s and had to cope with their friends' children running around. I can see how that works,I feel quite protective of my friends' DC and coped with them because I had to.

Friends' grandkids probably feel very removed, if that makes sense?

in terms of age, I can't talk about it too much because I really don't want to get old. But dad and I have both advocated for oldies in care - both neighbours. Both had children. One neighbour, her DD died before her, the other one, her son lived abroad.

also, mentally my mum is kept going by me. It is a terrible, terrible burden. I love her to bits but would not wish it on anyone. Also, I wouldn't wish old age on anyone. Nothing much will make a difference to it, but friends and neighbours are a big factor in care even if you have kids. I know some people will cheerfully expect their kids to ruin their own lives though.

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 13:56

@purpleboy I would assume that you saw those threads because you came to the site in the first place though. As such i wondered how the initial "intro" happened, as it were and people have responded to let me know.

TheLeadbetterLife · 23/02/2023 13:56

It's a bit simplistic to say children are just small humans and everyone should therefore find them interesting.

Humans start off complete idiots, and gradually get slightly less idiotic as the years wear on.

I find it boring talking to kids and many teenagers, because I just think, "I had all these conversations 25-30 years ago".

Startuplife · 23/02/2023 13:56

We’re child free but have a close family member with a toddler. They have loads of friends and family but we still get a ridiculous number of requests for babysitting. I can imagine for the grandparents it’s a lot worse so definitely something I’d like to avoid!

chichichargrill · 23/02/2023 13:55

My dc has a lady who we were friends with and she's now the default grandparent figure as she loves it, has no dc and seems happy to fulfil the role. We've known her for over a decade so perhaps you could wedge your way into a family like ours who lacks an older generational figure for our dc?!
Only if you're missing out on this though. My MIL has no interest whatsoever in coming to anything dc related so even if you have dc doesn't mean you'd even relish the idea of gc.

purpleboy · 23/02/2023 13:55

FrostyFifi · 23/02/2023 13:29

@Dacadactyl there isn't really another large, busy, woman-focussed forum that I'm aware of. I initially wound up here for the Feminism section as it's a brilliant resource if you have GC views.
I'm more surprised that anyone should be surprised tbh - a big percentage of threads have nothing to do with parenting, in fact there's a specific parenting section for that which I never venture into.

Agree, I find the question odd, why wouldn't you come to this site if you didn't have children, I see far more topics discussed that don't involve children than do.

Meandfour · 23/02/2023 13:54

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 23/02/2023 13:53

Me neither, they're annoying, often dirty / nits / snotty; they fidget and prattle constantly, and never let you leave the house on time. I don't see any positive traits either in them really, though for the sake of politeness I do fake being interested in other people's brats from time to time! 😁

Thank god your mum didn’t feel the same or we’d of been one happy, positive person on earth down 😂

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 23/02/2023 13:53

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/02/2023 13:46

But I don't want to interact with children and to be honest I've struggled to see any positive traits!

Me neither, they're annoying, often dirty / nits / snotty; they fidget and prattle constantly, and never let you leave the house on time. I don't see any positive traits either in them really, though for the sake of politeness I do fake being interested in other people's brats from time to time! 😁

gelatogina · 23/02/2023 13:51

theworldhas · 23/02/2023 13:35

Always strikes me as slightly odd when people say they don’t like children. Which is of course totally different to saying I don’t want responsibility for children or to be a parent. Children are just young humans, aged 0-17 and come in all different shapes, sizes and personalities. Just seems a bit prejudiced and narrow minded to me. It’s like someone saying they don’t like old people or they don’t like city people. I mean sure some old people can really encapsulate some of the worst traits of that demographic (maybe be a bit grumpy or a bit “I know best” etc) but the vast majority are just nice, normal people. Just as some kids might ask too many questions or have a quick temper, but that hardly wipes out all their positive traits!

Thanks for explaining what a child is 😂😂

I really don’t like them or have any interest in spending time with them. If that seems odd to you then I equally find you odd for liking them. I can appreciate both sides.

Jesus Christ the thread the other day about bum worms, that was enough to put me off for life!

and my plan for old age? All the money I save not having children will buy me a lovely retirement, a sheltered apartment when the time comes. And when the time REALLY comes, a lovely peaceful death at Dignitas. (Or hopefully at home if we ever get up to date with the law here)

no regrets whatsoever.

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 13:51

Over40Overdating · 23/02/2023 13:47

Oh great another ‘just curious’ thread about being child free where the poster v conveniently won’t disclose their situation yet their bias is clear.

If you don’t have the wit or understanding to get that people without children can still have lives and families and a social life then I suggest you spend some time working on yourself as your world view is extremely limited.

And as for the ‘what will you do when you’re old’ - do you think care/retirement homes only have childless people in?
Honestly baffles me when people ask this.
Children grow up to be autonomous adults - just like you! - who have their own lives and plans, with no obligation to become a carer for a parent who had them as an insurance policy.

As for they ‘why do you childless people come to a site for mummies!’ - also please broaden your world view. It’s very sad that you seem to be so unaware of the breadth of topics on a site you have such weird ownership of : do you really think the only thing women who have proceeated talk about - or should be interpreted in - is children?

Talk about oversensitive!

I was curious about what would bring a person without children to a site called MUMSnet, so asked about it. Most posters responded with answers that I can understand, without any snappiness or rudeness.

SweetSenorita · 23/02/2023 13:51

girlfriend44 · 23/02/2023 12:43

Families are everywhere. Everyone seems to have Grandchildren which in turn leads to family parties and celebrations and get togethers. You either hear about it or see it on FB.

The world seems to be geared to Families.
If you didn't want children, do you worry about missing out on grandchildren etc?
Everyone seems to have them or am I only seeing the ones that do?
How do you feel about seeing people with children and grandchildren?
Do not wish to disclose my position as like to remain private before anyone asks why I'm asking.

Grandchildren? Hell, no. I never wanted any children so why on earth would I want grandchildren?

Am I supposed to have mellowed or something? Didn't happen 🤷

whumpthereitis · 23/02/2023 13:48

Coolcoolcool · 23/02/2023 13:33

I definitely understand why people may choose to be childfree, and am often jealous of you!

I have a question that a pp touched on to do with elderly care. Whilst I don’t agree per se that society is set up around families, it does seem to be so with elderly care. My aunt is widowed and didn’t have children, and I am her only niece, so responsibility for power of attorney etc has fallen to me, as it is best practice to have someone from a younger generation do it.

So those of you who have chosen to be child-free, what’s your desire or hope for later life and care? Thanks

Pay for it.

Honestly elder care is something that should be considered by all, not just the childfree. Having children is no guarantee of care in old age.

Meandfour · 23/02/2023 13:48

TedMullins · 23/02/2023 13:43

Laugh away! I'm aware this is totally me projecting but I also think 'well, there goes anything fun and interesting you could've done with your life'. I know plenty of people find parenting fun and interesting but it's never remotely appealed to me.

Absolutely valid to feel that way. It’s also fine for mums to think single, childfree people have nothing fun and interesting in their lives. Seems like there are members of both “sides” who pity the other.

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 23/02/2023 13:47

I don't have kids because I really don't like children. Therefore not having them around, or having future grandchildren around, is a great source of happiness and freedom for me. Women fought long and hard for the choice to be free of marriage and children, and this freedom is still comparatively recent in the UK (contraceptive pill invented in the 1960s). All over the world there are societies where women still don't have this choice. I am thankful and view it as a blessing that I am free to live a life where I don't have children.

Over40Overdating · 23/02/2023 13:47

Oh great another ‘just curious’ thread about being child free where the poster v conveniently won’t disclose their situation yet their bias is clear.

If you don’t have the wit or understanding to get that people without children can still have lives and families and a social life then I suggest you spend some time working on yourself as your world view is extremely limited.

And as for the ‘what will you do when you’re old’ - do you think care/retirement homes only have childless people in?
Honestly baffles me when people ask this.
Children grow up to be autonomous adults - just like you! - who have their own lives and plans, with no obligation to become a carer for a parent who had them as an insurance policy.

As for they ‘why do you childless people come to a site for mummies!’ - also please broaden your world view. It’s very sad that you seem to be so unaware of the breadth of topics on a site you have such weird ownership of : do you really think the only thing women who have proceeated talk about - or should be interpreted in - is children?

KimberleyClark · 23/02/2023 13:46

FrownedUpon · 23/02/2023 13:42

If you don’t want children why would you want grandchildren? Lots of people don’t like or want children & that’s including grandchildren and feeling obliged to look after them.

Very true. Many people spend more time looking after their grandchildren than they really want to.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/02/2023 13:46

theworldhas · 23/02/2023 13:35

Always strikes me as slightly odd when people say they don’t like children. Which is of course totally different to saying I don’t want responsibility for children or to be a parent. Children are just young humans, aged 0-17 and come in all different shapes, sizes and personalities. Just seems a bit prejudiced and narrow minded to me. It’s like someone saying they don’t like old people or they don’t like city people. I mean sure some old people can really encapsulate some of the worst traits of that demographic (maybe be a bit grumpy or a bit “I know best” etc) but the vast majority are just nice, normal people. Just as some kids might ask too many questions or have a quick temper, but that hardly wipes out all their positive traits!

But I don't want to interact with children and to be honest I've struggled to see any positive traits!

Swipe left for the next trending thread