Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To those who didn't want Children by choice?

210 replies

girlfriend44 · 23/02/2023 12:43

Families are everywhere. Everyone seems to have Grandchildren which in turn leads to family parties and celebrations and get togethers. You either hear about it or see it on FB.

The world seems to be geared to Families.
If you didn't want children, do you worry about missing out on grandchildren etc?
Everyone seems to have them or am I only seeing the ones that do?
How do you feel about seeing people with children and grandchildren?
Do not wish to disclose my position as like to remain private before anyone asks why I'm asking.

OP posts:
SunsetStrip · 23/02/2023 15:57

My sister had no children by choice, she's perfectly happy with her life, she is 60 and is very active, physically and socially and has a rewarding career.

I have dc but I'm not bothered if I get grandchildren or not. I'd love them if they arrived but not bothered if they don't. I'll have a rewarding life, just like my sister.

dumbstruckdumptruck · 23/02/2023 15:51

girlfriend44 · 23/02/2023 14:16

Always one has to try and take the Mick and trying to get a laugh on what I'm saying. You obvs don't understand the thread. Perhaps it's not for you.

We all understand what you said. It's just most of us who fall into that camp find the premise of the question short-sighted at best, and at worst, downright insulting.

I could have taken a much less light-hearted tack, and I'm pretty sure you'd have liked that even less than my joke.

TodayInahurry · 23/02/2023 15:50

Never wanted any, never had any. Most of my friends and acquaintances don’t have any, a couple have grown up ones who do not have children of their own. We have horses!

Merangutan · 23/02/2023 15:43

The problem arises when people view childless people as failing to give them something that they feel will make their lives complete, such as grandchildren, despite them not being the ones that have to be pregnant, give birth or raise those children.

Given the sad tone of your post and unwillingness to say who you are in this situation, I’m guessing your child has decided not to have their own children and you feel resentful that you are no longer able to have the related celebrations such as birthdays?

Otherwise, I can’t see your POV at all. You seem to suggest that childless people are lesser within the family and somehow can’t participate properly in ‘family gatherings’. Saying ‘everyone has grandchildren and that leads to family parties’ is odd because adults have plenty of their own things to celebrate such as birthdays, engagements, weddings, promotions, anniversaries, Christmas etc etc. Can you only enjoy yourself with children present?

Not sure if I’m missing something here but YABVU if you seriously think that choosing not to have children deprives the rest of the family of child-centred celebrations. The only thing that matters is whether the couple involved are happy or not. Nobody should have children with other people’s happiness in mind, and far too many do.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/02/2023 15:37

I do have a child but I find the premise of this question odd (and the bias clear, despite what you say).

I love my child dearly and am very happy that she came into my life, but I have never been particularly interested in “families” or having a family. I had a child with a man who was either uninterested in or incapable of having a family in the traditional sense and found great joy in bringing my child up outside of that structure.)

I prefer not to socialise only with other nuclear families. I have no illusion that having had a child is any kind of support to my social life or an insurance policy for old age. Children are their own people, not simply extensions of their parents and certainly not status symbols or props.

Your post assumes that there is a clear divide between “family people” and “non family” people and that the former gravitate towards living in a family setup while the child free shun society.

It’s actually much more fluid than that. Many people have children on their own or outside of the traditional setup and thrive. Other people remain child free by choice but love being part of a family structure.

It’s also not true that there are people who like children and people who don’t. I love my own child and like certain other children I know but I don’t like them generically and I had no interest in them whatsoever before I had them.

I think these sorts of attitudes are a large factor which puts many people off having children; they have no desire to become enmeshed in the whole culture of child rearing and all the judgement that goes with it. Honestly it very nearly stopped me from having a child.

quinceh · 23/02/2023 15:29

I didn’t really make a conscious decision not to have kids, but didn’t meet ‘the person’ and it didn’t happen. I don’t really mind, just enjoy the life I have, but I’m at a stage where a few of my friends are having grandchildren, and I sometimes get a slight twinge about that, knowing I’ll go into older age without a bigger family.

Notimeforaname · 23/02/2023 15:19

I work with young people and families all day, every day.
How do I feel about it? I feel the same as when I interact with any person..theyre just people. It doesn't make me feel anything 🤷‍♀️

mydogisthebest · 23/02/2023 15:16

I am happy I don't have grandchildren. Quite a few friends have grandchildren and moan about feeling obliged to help with childcare.

Friends with older grandchildren moan because the grandchildren so often want to borrow money from them or pester them to buy them trainers, video games etc.

My family quite often have get togethers which I love. One of our nieces has a child who is just over a year old and me and DH love seeing her.

Our other nieces and nephews do not have children and all say they are not going to have any. In our families there are quite a few childfree couples. DH's 2 siblings do not have children. Our brother in law has 2 sisters and 3 brothers all married and none of them have children (we see quite a lot of them all)

Liorae · 23/02/2023 15:09

Considering the adversarial mil/dil relationships that seem to be the norm on Mumsnet, I suspect that grandchildren cause more stress and unhappiness than joy.

FrostyFifi · 23/02/2023 14:56

@PandasAreUseless my next-door neighbour a few years ago was in her late nineties and still at home. She had various bits of help like carers and meal delivery but the main source was other neighbours, she had about three retired guys in their late sixties/early seventies who did loads for her including all her paperwork, keyholders for carers etc.
She'd apparently been hugely active in the community for decades and in turn the community cared for her when she needed the help. She got her wish to die at home.

Peekatyourbeak · 23/02/2023 14:54

yeetingbird · 23/02/2023 14:48

Quite frankly I can't get my head around why people would have children when instead they could have cats.

My cat goes to the toilet outside, lets himself in and out of the cat flap, I put food and water down for him twice a day, and he's my fabulous cuddle buddy. He doesn't argue with me, get detentions, need ferrying to school or activities daily, and he doesn't require me to watch hideous tv or go to soft play.

He's also far more beautiful than a human child.

It's obvious to me why I wouldn't want children or grandchildren 😄

I’m catfree as well as childfree but your cat sounds lovely!

Carlycat · 23/02/2023 14:54

I'm 60. Never wanted them for a nano second. Got sterilised at 30
Most of my friend circle ( females and males ) are child free by choice.
We're all living the dream 👌

BellePeppa · 23/02/2023 14:53

Well obviously the world is geared to have families otherwise it would become extinct but if someone doesn’t want children that is a perfectly valid (and sane) choice. I have children, I love my children to bits, they are adult now but if I had a second life to live I would choose to be childless in that one.

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 14:53

Polis · 23/02/2023 14:52

I come here to gloat.

😂love this!

Polis · 23/02/2023 14:52

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 13:07

I am curious why people who don't want children and never have done are posters on Mumsnet?

Can any of you elaborate please? I am genuinely curious about it. It just seems like an odd place for you to end up.

I come here to gloat.

Billoddiesbeard · 23/02/2023 14:52

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 13:07

I am curious why people who don't want children and never have done are posters on Mumsnet?

Can any of you elaborate please? I am genuinely curious about it. It just seems like an odd place for you to end up.

I found Mumsnet while searching a beauty product on Google. Initially I mainly browsed and posted in the style and beauty board, later on I realised how hilarious AIBU can be and I also enjoy the chat and telly addicts boards.
I've never once bothered with any of the parenting topics as they're not relevant or of interest to me.
Being childless doesn't stop us having the same "other interests" as people with children.....what a strange question as clearly Mumsnet is a much broader discussion forum than just parent/children related issues🙄

PandasAreUseless · 23/02/2023 14:49

FrostyFifi · 23/02/2023 14:37

what about when you need help maybe when your older whose going to look out for you?

Plenty of people with children will face the same issue. They may be estranged, or the children may live too far away, even on a different continent, or the child they had might have died, or just be too busy with their own lives, or anything really.
That would probably be really hurtful as well, whereas if you've always known you need to make your own arrangments then it's simply a matter of practicalities and you're probably likely to be more proactive about it earlier on as well.

This.

And I'll add that the old people on our street are looked after by neighbours, not their family.
It's neighbours who do a bit of shopping for them, cut the lawn if they're struggling, look after the dog for a few nights if they're taken ill.
For me it's infinitely more important to build a local community around me than it is to have kids who might move to New Zealand!
DH and I moved to a small market town at 35. By the time we need a little bit of help, we will have lived here for 30+ years and may know a few people willing to help out. And if we dont, we'll pay for it.
And, knowing from the off that we don't have anyone concrete to lean on, we'll absolutely move ourselves into a retirement community when we're at an appropriate age for it.

Dacadactyl · 23/02/2023 14:49

RichardHeed · 23/02/2023 14:37

You’ve been around here long enough to know full well why. Stirring the pot again.

You can think what you like. I couldnt care less if someone has children or not, but i wonder about their motivations, which is why I clicked on the thread. I wondered whether people without kids ever thought fleetingly about parenthood and whether that was their driver to join the site (in the same way that I wonder about not having kids sometimes, although I dont think id join a childfree by choice forum, unless, like posters have said, id come to it by another direction).

It is the case that I was curious and it is a legitimate question, whether you like it or not.

yeetingbird · 23/02/2023 14:48

Quite frankly I can't get my head around why people would have children when instead they could have cats.

My cat goes to the toilet outside, lets himself in and out of the cat flap, I put food and water down for him twice a day, and he's my fabulous cuddle buddy. He doesn't argue with me, get detentions, need ferrying to school or activities daily, and he doesn't require me to watch hideous tv or go to soft play.

He's also far more beautiful than a human child.

It's obvious to me why I wouldn't want children or grandchildren 😄

MovieQueen12 · 23/02/2023 14:48

Hated the idea of being pregnant
Labour terrifies me
Worried about passing down health conditions
Don't want to pass on my looks
World we live in today, would not want to bring a child into it.
As others have already said, there are no guarantees that you will be looked after into old age or given grandchildren. My parents have 3 of us and none of us have given them grandchildren.

Nagado · 23/02/2023 14:48

Talk about oversensitive!

I was curious about what would bring a person without children to a site called MUMSnet, so asked about it. Most posters responded with answers that I can understand, without any snappiness or rudeness

It’s not over-sensitivity. Every single time there is a post about women who don’t have children, someone pops up to ask what we’re doing here. As if we need to have given birth in order to understand the complexities of parking diagrams or horrible mils. It’s tiresome and short sighted.

To answer the original question, I don’t feel like I’m missing out on family celebrations and get togethers. We have lots of nieces, nephews, god children and cousins with young children, and we’re the ‘fun’ aunt and uncle who spoil them, feed them E numbers and then send them back to their parents safe in the knowledge that we’ll be able to have a lay in the next morning. I do child care once a week for my nephew. I’m obsessed with this child; he’s absolutely wonderful and I love seeing him. But he’s bloody knackering. Everything we do revolves around keeping him fed, changed, entertained and safe. It’s relentless. And boring. There is no way I’d want to do that every day, even if he does melt my heart. It has never occurred to me to think about not having grandchildren. Why would it? And surely us child free people are proof that having a child of your own doesn’t guarantee grandchildren?

Billoddiesbeard · 23/02/2023 14:47

Billoddiesbeard · 23/02/2023 14:42

I found Mumsnet while searching a beauty product on Google. Initially I mainly browsed and posted in the style and beauty board, later on I realised how hilarious AIBU can be and I also enjoy the chat and telly addicts boards.
I've never once bothered with any of the parenting topics as they're not relevant or of interest to me.
Being childless doesn't stop us having the same "other interests" as people with children.....what a strange question as clearly Mumsnet is a much broader discussion forum than just parent/children related issues🙄

Oops sorry, I quoted the wrong post......but I totally agree with HeadacheEathquake 🤣

Billoddiesbeard · 23/02/2023 14:42

HeadacheEarthquake · 23/02/2023 13:10

Came for the AIBU hilarity, stayed for the drama

I found Mumsnet while searching a beauty product on Google. Initially I mainly browsed and posted in the style and beauty board, later on I realised how hilarious AIBU can be and I also enjoy the chat and telly addicts boards.
I've never once bothered with any of the parenting topics as they're not relevant or of interest to me.
Being childless doesn't stop us having the same "other interests" as people with children.....what a strange question as clearly Mumsnet is a much broader discussion forum than just parent/children related issues🙄

EmmaEmerald · 23/02/2023 14:38

I'm guessing OP doesn't want to say why she asked

perhaps it's like my old flatmate, she told me "you'll have to get married amd have kids because everyone else will". Confused

I know some posters seem to be in tune with what OP is thinking, I wonder if anyone can elaborate?

FrostyFifi · 23/02/2023 14:37

what about when you need help maybe when your older whose going to look out for you?

Plenty of people with children will face the same issue. They may be estranged, or the children may live too far away, even on a different continent, or the child they had might have died, or just be too busy with their own lives, or anything really.
That would probably be really hurtful as well, whereas if you've always known you need to make your own arrangments then it's simply a matter of practicalities and you're probably likely to be more proactive about it earlier on as well.