Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect parents to have life insurance as a matter of course?

313 replies

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 10:59

Is it not the first thing you think about when you first hold your newborn? How can I best care for this little one? What do I need to do/sacrifice to ensure their welfare? in any circumstances?

I appreciate you can't be insured for every eventuality, and with the best will in the world, you can think you have taken out adequate insurance, and in the event it doesn't actually pay out for some reason or other.

But it's about £2 a week, in most cases - surely this is factored into the cost of providing for a child, when you do your calculations? I expect there are a few that can't afford it, but most can.

I am just amazed to hear of someone recently, really struggling, with no life insurance payout for the children, because there was no policy.

Am I living in a fool's paradise? Don't most parents have life insurance? Am I just showing my ignorance? Why wouldn't a parent have life insurance? Do you? if not, why not?

OP posts:
Alarae · 23/02/2023 12:16

DH and I have only recently sorted out our life insurance and our DD is nearly 3. It wasn't a condition of our mortgage but we spoke to someone during our remortgage process and put it through with them. I believe ours is £34 a month for £250k each until age 70. On top of this we have death in service from our jobs, and I pay for critical illness via mine as a taxable benefit (£150k me, £100k DH). Essentially, if we were to both kick the bucket my DD would probably be close to a millionaire if everything paid out (we are anything but!).

Insurance though just doesn't fit into some people's budgets. It's all well me saying 'it's only £30' but that's because I am fortunate enough to have the disposable income to say that. I am very well aware that there are loads of people out there who are struggling to afford food or energy, let alone life insurance!

Life Insurance is one of those things that unfortunately doesn't benefit those who really need it as they can't afford it in the first place.

AliceMcK · 23/02/2023 12:16

I agree, I have had health insurance for many years, long before I had children or own home. It’s there in case something happens to you. Anything can happen, you could be hit by a car, die of a sudden undiagnosed illness, cancer you don’t have to be old and full of ailments to need one. Funerals cost money and your family will be the ones paying for it if anything happens to you. Look at Nicola Bully, no one would dream of something like what’s happened to happen, but it has, now someone has set up a go fund me page for her children and although I am very sympathetic to her and her family my thoughts are, that it was hers and her partners responsibility to set up insurance policies to protect their children in case something happened to them, not for other to pay to look after them.

Im a SAHM, if anything happened to me my DH would have to take care of 3 grieving children while trying to work and cover the bills. My life insurance would allow him to pay off our mortgage and cover the cost of taking time off work to look after our children. The same with his, he has a policy that will cover the mortgage and a separate one that would allow me to continue to be a SAHM for a decent period of time before I would need to look for work and childcare.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:16

I think its like with most things in life, those people who need it most are in the least able position to have it.

Brilliantly summarised.

I'm another who can't get LI or CI because of various health conditions - ones that will almost certainly lead to me not making old bones, but I hope I can hang on until my DS is an adult.

Do you know how good it makes people feel to know that no insurer considers their life worth insuring, essentially because of the reason you are far more likely to need the insurance?

And then, on top of that, being told that you are irresponsible, stupid, reckless, not a loving, caring parent, add whatever other insults you like - it's not the nicest feeling to be had. Not just on threads like this, but the annual mailshots that turn on the emotional blackmail and stress the 'come on, it's time to be a GOOD parent now' message from companies that would instantly change their mind and turn me down point blank if I applied and they saw my medical record. They would then doubtless take me straight off their mailing list - not because of any compassion for me, but to save themselves a few quid in wasted printing and postage, of course.

Where does that leave us, then? What's the point in challenging attitudes like that? All that people can do is backtrack and say "Oh, I didn't mean YOU!" as if that makes it better. As PP said, disabled people are parents too; I shouldn't have to point it out, but we're also people too - and we love our kids just as much as able-bodied, fully healthy parents do.

Likewise with very poor people (even if able-bodied and healthy) who get the same criticism levelled at them. It's the same when it comes to pensions - how utterly stupid you must be if you want to put food on the table and shoes on your kids' feet now rather than store your pitiful funds away for a tomorrow that may never come.

By all means publicise it to those who may qualify and be interested/able to afford it; but enough already with the presumptuous, unthinking, uncaring, ableist, poor-bashing, sneery attitudes that come from a position of privilege - blaming and shaming people for 'making the choice' not to do something that they simply cannot possibly do.

SpecialK2023 · 23/02/2023 12:14

£2 per week? That depends on how much your mortgage is.
life insurance is generally for the amount outstanding on your mortgage - if you don’t have a mortgage what amount do you propose?

FlowersareEverything · 23/02/2023 12:14

When I got my mortgage (18 years ago) it was only compulsory for me to take out buildings and content insurance. However, I also took out redundancy, sickness, critical illness and life insurance. I pay £50 per month for the redundancy, sickness, critical illness and life insurance. I also have death in service of 2.5 x my annual salary. It gives me peace of mind.

Icannoteven · 23/02/2023 12:14

These are the first sort of payments people drop when they are broke. Sometimes people are too busy dealing with the problems in front of them for preparation for possible future problems. Poverty leads to short term thinking and planning, by necessity.

To put it another way, If you are fucked now and don’t have the time, energy and resources to unfuck the now, then you definitely don’t want to be wasting your resources on some possible future situation that may need unfucking.

Also, people don’t like to think about being disabled or dead in future, or their partner being disabled or dead in the future. They can’t contemplate that money would make that situation any easier (though in reality it would - I went through almost losing my partner to cancer last year - who has no life insurance -and I know just how stressful the financial implications of illness can be).

Lastly, some of us don’t have any earning power worth protecting.

AliasGrape · 23/02/2023 12:14

We don't have it.

DH is covered by 'death in service' at his work, and my pension would pay out a lump sum if I died -although not a particularly large one at this point.

We have paid off the mortgage.

We were quoted over £80 a month (that was the best quote!) - in our 40s, non-smokers, relatively healthy.

It may be that we need to move to a bigger house in the near future, which would require us to take out a mortgage again, in which case we would have a rethink.

NamiSwan · 23/02/2023 12:13

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 23/02/2023 12:03

So you're not disabled or have long term health issues?

I actually do have a disability but not something that affects my life expectancy (I am hard of hearing).

No long term health conditions.

Obviously you knew that or you wouldn't ask. But not everyone who has declared on here that it costs them £££ has said they have a disability or health condition, so just putting the alternative perspective out there- it isn't costly for everyone and some people certainly can get life insurance at an affordable price.

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 12:13

@probablyoverinsured

I can't even get a company to quote me. I just tried.

What do you suggest I do?

RedToothBrush · 23/02/2023 12:12

A friend of mine (without kids) bought a house a couple of weeks ago. Her partner isn't on the mortgage as he can't be and he wouldnt be able to afford it if she died. She hasn't found a life insurance policy that will accept her with her pre-existing. Certainly not one she can afford.

I suspect there are loads of people with problems not dissimilar.

And you come along and tell them how dreadful they are as parents for not protecting their kids / partner just in case something happens.

The reality is its unlikely even then though.

We have life insurance but not critical coverage. Its only until we are 50 though. The mortgage won't be paid off by then. DS will only be 18. It could leave me and DS up shit creek and we felt critical coverage was a con because of the number of reasons they won't pay up for on policies.

cocksstrideintheevening · 23/02/2023 12:12

I have life and critical illness through work and have done since way before I had kids.

However I just think it isn't on some people's radars, if you don't know about it or what it is then that's what happens. Also £££ mine certainly is £2 a week and plenty of people don't have £2 week. Same with pensions.

This accounts for the companies like Polly or the one fronted by Razor Ruddock. Do you work for them op?

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 12:11

some people say they cant afford it, or they have death in service cover through work, so don't need it, which is all fair enough.

But there are certainly people who can afford it that haven't bothered, and I see the consequences at school when a child is bereaved of a parent - it happens multiple times a year in an average secondary school

and one comment, recently, justifying it as "because we were young and not thinking about death" sort of misses the point, as it's when your young and healthy that you can take a cheap long term insurance policy out.

OP posts:
RemoteControlDoobry · 23/02/2023 12:11

I’m paying one that’s around the price you state and I was about 34 when it was taken out.

15 years later (two years ago) it was £41 for a shorter term. Both 200k I think.

IncompleteSenten · 23/02/2023 12:11

In an ideal world we would.

Actually, in an ideal world we wouldn't need it because we'd all be taken care of in times of need.

Wobblytrees · 23/02/2023 12:10

We have it but it’s £91 a month so not £2 a week. We also have death in service benefit through work

Senseofnopurpose · 23/02/2023 12:09

Insurance = the disease of the western peoples (to misquote John Cheese, the original quote would see me cancelled)

TheCatch · 23/02/2023 12:08

AutumnScream · 23/02/2023 11:08

I dont think life insurance is the first thing people think about when holding their bloody newborn for the first time 😂

Was going to say the same.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 23/02/2023 12:07

On UC, I can't afford £2 a week.

You sound like a control freak.

lechatnoir · 23/02/2023 12:06

We have £150k cover and it costs us about £50pcm each. I check/update this regularly so no idea where you're getting £2 cover! £150k would only cover our mortgage so would still leave over £1k of bills so certainly wouldn't allow either of us to take time out of work but we feel is necessary and can (just) about afford it at the moment. People are struggling to heat their homes and feed their kids so I'm struggling to see how you're so shocked people don't have LI.

Rollercoaster1920 · 23/02/2023 12:06

Most professional jobs include death benefit as part of the company pension. Usually 4x salary.
I have always relied on that, but had a gap when I was made redundant, so watch out for that.

Lcb123 · 23/02/2023 12:05

I agree but for a lot of people it’s another unaffordable expense. We got it when we bought our flat (no kids) and it’s about £20 a month. But that was a low-ish payout, both young and no health issues.

Senseofnopurpose · 23/02/2023 12:04

Senseofnopurpose · 23/02/2023 11:48

Ooh you've upset a lot of people!
Thank heavens you didn't ask if we'd all insured our homes, contents, cars and holidays!

And not forgetting pets either, poor things

Mitfordian · 23/02/2023 12:03

Like most people with a salary, I have a significant death in service benefit and so does my DH. We have family critical illness through DH work for around £50 per month.

Surely your need for life insurance depends on your other finances generally, too.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 23/02/2023 12:03

NamiSwan · 23/02/2023 12:01

Genuinely amazed at all these people saying its £100s of pounds?! I finally got round to getting my life insurance last year at age 37, it costs me £12 a month. Husband got a separate one for £13 a month.

Doesn't cover critical illness, just life insurance, but enough to cover our mortgage + a lot extra for expenses / children.

So you're not disabled or have long term health issues?

Maverickess · 23/02/2023 12:03

My DD is over 18 now, and we both had life insurance when she was born. And it wasn't £2 a week then either.

Unfortunately he fucked off not long after and I had to cut costs to be able to afford to keep a roof over our heads and food on the table, despite a ft job. I intended on banking the thousands he owed in maintenance for her future, but the CSA wrote that off so that was a no go.

I have my work pension (the one everyone gets) and I think that has a death in service benefit, so best hope I drop dead at work, also have now, a funeral plan. I've only been able to afford that in the last couple of years. There's been times in the past I've been tempted to stop my pension contributions too, bailiffs can be very 'persuasive' when they are collecting owed council tax, even when you're paying what you can afford.

I don't have a mortgage because the ex wrecked both our credit ratings so no cover there.

I'm in a better financial place that I've ever been right now, but still can't justify the premiums because I'm trying to support DD through university so she doesn't have to live the life I have.

So you can take your "It's the responsible thing to do as a parent" and stick it where the sun doesn't shine quite frankly because you have no idea what life is like for people not in a comfortable little judgemental bubble.