Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect parents to have life insurance as a matter of course?

313 replies

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 10:59

Is it not the first thing you think about when you first hold your newborn? How can I best care for this little one? What do I need to do/sacrifice to ensure their welfare? in any circumstances?

I appreciate you can't be insured for every eventuality, and with the best will in the world, you can think you have taken out adequate insurance, and in the event it doesn't actually pay out for some reason or other.

But it's about £2 a week, in most cases - surely this is factored into the cost of providing for a child, when you do your calculations? I expect there are a few that can't afford it, but most can.

I am just amazed to hear of someone recently, really struggling, with no life insurance payout for the children, because there was no policy.

Am I living in a fool's paradise? Don't most parents have life insurance? Am I just showing my ignorance? Why wouldn't a parent have life insurance? Do you? if not, why not?

OP posts:
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 23/02/2023 12:27

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 12:25

So I haven't provided the best care for my children.

I haven't done something I needed to do to ensure their welfare.

I haven't sacrificed enough.

Because I'm disabled and can't get life insurance.

Seriously what the fuck. How is this ok to say this on a thread?

Because mumsnet is an extremely abelist place with users who excuse both abelism and disablism constantly. MNHQ don't give a shiny shit.

Mummyboy1 · 23/02/2023 12:26

I constantly think about life insurance, I'm a single parent so fully aware of needing to leave money behind for my son/ for my friend who'll have him. However with a difficult upbringing I tried to take my life (18 years old) and most wont give me cover. I would never do anything now but it doesn't matter.

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 23/02/2023 12:26

Yes we have it.
already had it as it’s been a condition of every mortgage we’ve had…. enough to cover mortgage and some extra.
if we hadn’t then I’d have 100% taken some out when Dd was born.

but if people can’t afford to eat….. it’s not always that straightforward.

OnlyFannys · 23/02/2023 12:25

Mine is about £6 per month, I'm asthmatic but no other health conditions and no serious illnesses run in my family. I got mine when DS was born when I was 28 and I'm now 36. From what I'm reading here I'm glad I got it back then! Mine doesn't include critical illness but I pay for that separately through work and get a death in service payment as well of 3x salary so overall i think I am reasonably well covered

saraclara · 23/02/2023 12:25

My late husband and I went and sorted out life insurance when I was pregnant. We already had one with critical illness cover attached to our mortgage, but that was all it covered.
When we started a family we realised that if one of us died, the other would have far more to worry about than just the cost of the mortgage, so we took out an extra joint life insurance.

We had reason to be very grateful for both the critical illness cover and the life insurance. When my DH could no longer work, it helped ease his anxiety about not providing for us, and when he knew he was dying, knowing that the girls and I would be financially okay was also a reassurance to him.

So yes, when my adult children were taking on mortgages and starting a family, I checked with them that they'd sorted out insurances.

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 12:25

So I haven't provided the best care for my children.

I haven't done something I needed to do to ensure their welfare.

I haven't sacrificed enough.

Because I'm disabled and can't get life insurance.

Seriously what the fuck. How is this ok to say this on a thread?

gingercat02 · 23/02/2023 12:25

Ours was £43 com 20years ago. Both healthy non smokers on our early 30's.
It has just paid out as DH had a heart attack so I'm very glad we had it!
It is a lot of money for most people not less than £10 per month

xogossipgirlxo · 23/02/2023 12:23

I bought life insurance shortly before covid. We're expecting first baby now, so I might look if we need some changes in policy. I actually forgot about it, thanks for reminding me.

Thatsnotmybee · 23/02/2023 12:23

I know someone who died in his 30s leaving a wife and 2 children. He couldn't get life insurance due to his very complicated medical history. Don't assume it's available to everyone.

Maverickess · 23/02/2023 12:23

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:16

I think its like with most things in life, those people who need it most are in the least able position to have it.

Brilliantly summarised.

I'm another who can't get LI or CI because of various health conditions - ones that will almost certainly lead to me not making old bones, but I hope I can hang on until my DS is an adult.

Do you know how good it makes people feel to know that no insurer considers their life worth insuring, essentially because of the reason you are far more likely to need the insurance?

And then, on top of that, being told that you are irresponsible, stupid, reckless, not a loving, caring parent, add whatever other insults you like - it's not the nicest feeling to be had. Not just on threads like this, but the annual mailshots that turn on the emotional blackmail and stress the 'come on, it's time to be a GOOD parent now' message from companies that would instantly change their mind and turn me down point blank if I applied and they saw my medical record. They would then doubtless take me straight off their mailing list - not because of any compassion for me, but to save themselves a few quid in wasted printing and postage, of course.

Where does that leave us, then? What's the point in challenging attitudes like that? All that people can do is backtrack and say "Oh, I didn't mean YOU!" as if that makes it better. As PP said, disabled people are parents too; I shouldn't have to point it out, but we're also people too - and we love our kids just as much as able-bodied, fully healthy parents do.

Likewise with very poor people (even if able-bodied and healthy) who get the same criticism levelled at them. It's the same when it comes to pensions - how utterly stupid you must be if you want to put food on the table and shoes on your kids' feet now rather than store your pitiful funds away for a tomorrow that may never come.

By all means publicise it to those who may qualify and be interested/able to afford it; but enough already with the presumptuous, unthinking, uncaring, ableist, poor-bashing, sneery attitudes that come from a position of privilege - blaming and shaming people for 'making the choice' not to do something that they simply cannot possibly do.

Great post.

Maraudingmarauders · 23/02/2023 12:22

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 11:07

yes, I agree that in an ideal world, Critical illness cover is good to have too, but again, I think it comes attached to most mortgage agreements.

Of course, the difference is, some one unable to work will still be bringing in an income based on benefits, where as a deceased parent sadly won't

It really doesnt these days. The only insurance you are required to have on taking out a mortgage is buildings insurance. Our IFA recommended a policy to us, which we took. We pay circa £120 a month for a decreasing life insurance and critical illness cover, though I'm not covered for lifelong disability due to a pre-existing condition.
I agree it's very important, and I can't believe we didn't have it for a few years after buying our first house (we only took out the policy when we did our first mortgage renewal) but £120 a month isn't chicken feed!

TedMullins · 23/02/2023 12:22

Many people aren’t eligible. Mental health issues, sometimes even managed, medicated and long-ago ones, will disqualify you, as can many other diagnoses. I have a mortgage and I don’t have any life insurance or critical illness cover because no one will cover me.

bonzaitree · 23/02/2023 12:21

No DC but I have life insurance through my job. I think the policy is worth over £260,000 and it’s in my partners name. If I died at least he could pay off the mortgage 🤷‍♀️

Mulhollandmagoo · 23/02/2023 12:21

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 11:17

well, I just plugged in 30 year old non smoker to various price comparison sites, that is where I got the £2 a week from, and that was discounting the cheapest ones, of £6 a month

no critical illness cover

We are young (late 30's) healthy non smokers, and I cant get it that low, mine is around £25 per month for just life insurance, and we got critical illness for my husband, as he earns more than me and we couldn't afford both, and that is £65 per month.

Thoughtful2355 · 23/02/2023 12:21

im 29, never smoked. dont drink and am completely healthy with no family health issues known. Mine is £34 a month... thats actually a lot for most people

Kennykenkencat · 23/02/2023 12:20

ginnybag · 23/02/2023 11:34

Those of you saying you can't afford it - what's your plan for losing one of your incomes overnight?

If your finances are that tight as is, that would arguably mean that there's no way the household can carry the existing mortgage/potentially remortgage if you died.

If you're the SAHP, then maybe it's okay to only insure the earner - although there's suddenly going to be a lot of childcare etc bills in the mix - but if you're any part of the income to the household either via work, or via benefits if too unwell to work - how is the remaining partner covering the gap? You're setting up for a scenario where your children don't just lose a parent, they also lose their home. If that means eviction and council housing follows, that could also be schools, friends, hobbies etc

And, if you're a single parent, without an involved other parent, then you're leaving your child/children dependent on relative/friend/in care - whatever your plan is - with no way to compensate for the increased expenses of that and nothing to substitute for parental support for driving/uni/house deposits etc.

Where do you suggest the £720 per month comes from and that was 25 years ago.
If you haven’t got it and there is nothing to cut down on then you can’t afford it.

People told me to save for a pension which I did reluctantly. Money that could have helped me at the time went into the pension

I checked on my pension pot recently.

It is £0

Raided by a company I worked for years ago to pay off its debts and to stave off bankruptcy for a few more months.

Yes you can pay into a life insurance policy the issue is whilst I know they work for others, they don’t work for me and I could see paying dhs £720 per month life insurance policy and when he dies there would be £0 payout because there is always a loophole.

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 12:20

This is a seriously shitty thread. And it's ableist.

YesYou · 23/02/2023 12:19

@probablyoverinsured so you're of working age (in a school) and you were told you had to take life cover and critical illness cover with your mortgage. You were scammed.

Rather than sitting smugly judging the dead parents of pupils in your school, why don't you go and get some financial education yourself?

RedToothBrush · 23/02/2023 12:19

CloudPop · 23/02/2023 11:15

It's not £2 a week. It's more like £50 or so a month minimum.

Also most salaried people have death in service cover which may be considered adequate

It was £50 a month each for us, 15 years ago when we were in our early 30s with no health conditions. That was a lot of money for us at the time. It was one of the recommended cheap policies at the time.

£2 a week. Thats laughable. Cover would be farcial and probably wouldn't have covered our mortgage on our old house at todays prices, never mind our current house.

Sorry but I think this thread is MASSIVELY insensitive. And I HAVE cover.

whatkatydid2013 · 23/02/2023 12:19

We took out a joint policy for £100,000 on a level term basis years back to be able to cover our mortgage plus other costs on basis It’s about £5/month because we started at 23 to pay over 30 years. We changed to one for £250k on reducing balance basis in late 30s and that was £18/month. It covers most of our current mortgage and we both also have work benefits. In general if you take out a long term policy when young it’s not massively expensive. £200-300/year seems worth finding if at all possible for the security provided. I wish we’d taken £300k on level term for 35 years back in our mid 20s as at time that would have been less than £15/month and it would have lasted our whole mortgage paying time and left us with extra cover in later years.

mondaytosunday · 23/02/2023 12:18

Well I have type 1 diabetes, well controlled, yet my insurance calculation was almost £300/month.
I have done other things to make sure my children are provided for.

rambunctiousrapscallion · 23/02/2023 12:18

Im going to agree with you OP. I think everyone thinks it wont happen to them so it slips to the bottom of the list. However, last year I know of two healthy young people who died. One's heart failed suddenly and completely unexpectedly, the other was killed in a car crash when they were hit by a drunk driver.

Neither had wills or life insurance, they shouldnt have needed them as there was no reason to suspect the worst would happen. It has made an already awful situation worse. We were totally guilty and hadnt done it so immediately sorted it all out. If this thread prompts someone to sort it out then its worth it.

Lellochip · 23/02/2023 12:17

Who knew, I apparently have death in service with my pension - thought that was only for people with dangerous jobs! 😄

I'd like critical illness cover but that's expensive, life insurance is cheapest but I don't need that, I've settled for income protection only

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 12:17

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:16

I think its like with most things in life, those people who need it most are in the least able position to have it.

Brilliantly summarised.

I'm another who can't get LI or CI because of various health conditions - ones that will almost certainly lead to me not making old bones, but I hope I can hang on until my DS is an adult.

Do you know how good it makes people feel to know that no insurer considers their life worth insuring, essentially because of the reason you are far more likely to need the insurance?

And then, on top of that, being told that you are irresponsible, stupid, reckless, not a loving, caring parent, add whatever other insults you like - it's not the nicest feeling to be had. Not just on threads like this, but the annual mailshots that turn on the emotional blackmail and stress the 'come on, it's time to be a GOOD parent now' message from companies that would instantly change their mind and turn me down point blank if I applied and they saw my medical record. They would then doubtless take me straight off their mailing list - not because of any compassion for me, but to save themselves a few quid in wasted printing and postage, of course.

Where does that leave us, then? What's the point in challenging attitudes like that? All that people can do is backtrack and say "Oh, I didn't mean YOU!" as if that makes it better. As PP said, disabled people are parents too; I shouldn't have to point it out, but we're also people too - and we love our kids just as much as able-bodied, fully healthy parents do.

Likewise with very poor people (even if able-bodied and healthy) who get the same criticism levelled at them. It's the same when it comes to pensions - how utterly stupid you must be if you want to put food on the table and shoes on your kids' feet now rather than store your pitiful funds away for a tomorrow that may never come.

By all means publicise it to those who may qualify and be interested/able to afford it; but enough already with the presumptuous, unthinking, uncaring, ableist, poor-bashing, sneery attitudes that come from a position of privilege - blaming and shaming people for 'making the choice' not to do something that they simply cannot possibly do.

This!! Well said.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 23/02/2023 12:17

NamiSwan · 23/02/2023 12:13

I actually do have a disability but not something that affects my life expectancy (I am hard of hearing).

No long term health conditions.

Obviously you knew that or you wouldn't ask. But not everyone who has declared on here that it costs them £££ has said they have a disability or health condition, so just putting the alternative perspective out there- it isn't costly for everyone and some people certainly can get life insurance at an affordable price.

My RA shouldn't shorten my life expectancy but I still can't just get standard cheap cover.

I got turned down by quite a few and the ones that would were £££