Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect parents to have life insurance as a matter of course?

313 replies

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 10:59

Is it not the first thing you think about when you first hold your newborn? How can I best care for this little one? What do I need to do/sacrifice to ensure their welfare? in any circumstances?

I appreciate you can't be insured for every eventuality, and with the best will in the world, you can think you have taken out adequate insurance, and in the event it doesn't actually pay out for some reason or other.

But it's about £2 a week, in most cases - surely this is factored into the cost of providing for a child, when you do your calculations? I expect there are a few that can't afford it, but most can.

I am just amazed to hear of someone recently, really struggling, with no life insurance payout for the children, because there was no policy.

Am I living in a fool's paradise? Don't most parents have life insurance? Am I just showing my ignorance? Why wouldn't a parent have life insurance? Do you? if not, why not?

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 13:03

Looked into it. It wasn't £2 a week. They didn't like many of my health conditions. Wouldn't have been able to afford the mortgage.

That's the crux of it, isn't it? I remember a (very) old Paul Merton sketch where he was playing a community police officer and he was advising a man to buy a dummy TV to fool burglars, by swapping it with his actual TV and hiding the latter under the floor boards every time he went out. This was long before flat-screen TVs were a thing, so even more gloriously silly.

The man asked what the price of the dummy TV was and, on being told, exclaimed that it cost a lot more than his actual TV - to which the officer suggested buying the dummy TV and then hiding that under the floorboards, safe from burglars!

Magentax · 23/02/2023 13:01

Customers often end up paying in more than is paid out.

That's the basis of all insurance products though - they need the majority to pay in more than they get out or underwriters would be bankrupt.

riotlady · 23/02/2023 13:00

I tried to get it but was turned down due to a combo of weight + a history of mental health issues. I’ve been mentally well for 5 years now but the broker told me to try in another 5 (and hopefully I will have lost a bit of weight by then too)

Ive been tempted by Dead Happy insurance as they just don’t insure for suicide, which means they ignore mental health stuff- ideal for me. But the price is only guaranteed for 10 years so could find myself with a chronic condition in 10 years time with no way of getting insurance. So not sure really.

My husband is insured on a basic decreasing cover for the cost of our mortgage, and I have death in service benefits so that will have to do for now

StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 13:00

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:35

when he dies there would be £0 payout because there is always a loophole.

I haven't read all the small print, but one thing I've noticed with those over-50s adverts that fund all of commercial daytime TV is that they state you will be covered as long as you keep up your payments.

Obviously, nobody would be claiming that the policy protection should still stay in place if you actively decide to stop paying - or even if you can simply no longer afford to pay for it - but I always wonder how long it takes for you to stop paying before it's voided. Do they allow people to pay manually/at the post office etc., or is it direct debit only? Because if they allow the former, considering that a great many people would end up missing making payments in the weeks before their death for obvious myriad reasons, I'd have thought there would be scores of people paying faithfully for years - decades, even - and then the claim being refused, just because they were very ill/in hospital/just ran out of time to sort everything in the two week decline before their death. Is this how it works? Does anybody know?

Those over-50 life policies are nearly always a giant rip-off. Customers often end up paying in more than is paid out. And usually, if there's a death within the first couple of years, you only get a premium refund, not the full payment.

They're extremely dodgy, as a rule.

StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 12:58

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:49

There are lots of specialist brokers around and it's very much worth going in that direction – we did for a condition my DH had. There's no saying that he might die of the condition - he could get run over – so worth exploring.

The problem is, though, that even if you can get 'second-class sub-person special limited life insurance' that will supposedly pay out if you die of something unconnected, with a lot of conditions, almost every cause of death short of being squashed by a runaway steamroller can be potentially attributable to your condition.

Insurance companies are just fancy bookies with an office in central London, so of course they will use any excuse possible to avoid paying out.

It's not much of a choice to be left with, but I'd rather at least know the score rather than die with the false assurance that my family would be looked after financially, when they most likely wouldn't be at all.

I mean this genuinely - no insurance company I know deliberately tried to avoid paying out. The whole industry is really tightly regulated and a lot of the misconceptions are unfair.

I don't work in insurance any more so I'm not bound to defend them. But I worked in the Claims and Underwriting areas of this industry for a very long time - all the companies get together regularly to talk about how to do things better, how to make things fairer, and how to be clearer to customers.

The problem is that lots of insurance is poorly sold, and people don't really understand what they're buying, or what exclusions there are. And that's where the problems lie.

For life cover, most reputable companies won't offer exclusions because it's not fair. Exclusions would be applied for health cover - some types anyway - but for life cover, many companies would either charge a higher premium, or just decline the application. And it's for exactly the reasons you said, at least in part, because it can be very difficult to untangle whether the excluded condition contributed. It would be very contentious and time-consuming. The other reason is that the chances are that the family members wouldn't know about the exclusion because the person who took the contract out would be dead. So the family would think they were covered, only to discover they weren't - that's not a situation the industry wants to find itself in because it's generally thought to be pretty unfair to the family. So they usually - and I am generalising here - usually, won't offer exclusions on life cover. If you do a high risk job or hobby, you might have Accidental Death excluded but all other causes of death are not generally excluded. And I wouldn't recommend any life cover that does.

Magentax · 23/02/2023 12:57

We have life insurance to cover the mortgage (£51 a month on decreasing cover for a big mortgage). I have a big death in service benefit, DH doesn't work.

Critical illness doesn't seem worth it to me when I've run the numbers. To cover the mortgage amount for the next 20 years of mortgage term (as a healthy 45 year old) would cost me £160 a month. I think I'm better off keeping increasing savings amounts. It is a tricky call though and I do worry about what would happen if I was too ill to work. Downsize massively I suppose and live on benefits.

Liesovertheocean · 23/02/2023 12:57

Our life insurance which admittedly covers critical illness too is c£180 a month for us both. Non smokers. Very lucky we can afford it - can see why people don’t have it, especially right now.

Greenbeans123 · 23/02/2023 12:57

I always had it linked to my mortgage, then became ill/disabled overnight and when it came up for renewal I was refused because my treatment was still ongoing (nhs wait lists mean 8 years later I'm still awaiting some treatments). I also had sickness benefits which were really helpful and critical illness cover which wasn't useful because my illness didn't conform to the list of illnesses that are critical (even though i was critical and had a life changing event). I tried more recently when I renewed my mortgage and still couldn't get any. So not all people can get insurance and not all people can afford it. I worry even if I can get insurance if I'll be able to afford it (I only have disability benefits and an ill health pension).

monomatapea · 23/02/2023 12:55

Looked into it. It wasn't £2 a week. They didn't like many of my health conditions. Wouldn't have been able to afford the mortgage.

greenbackers · 23/02/2023 12:55

We cannot get it. My husband is too disabled and no life insurance companies will touch him.

However, we have death in service benefit, no mortgage and substantial savings. I also work FT and am able to pay our household bills on my own.

I tend to assume that people don't have life insurance for good reason and do not judge people who cannot get it either for financial reasons or because of disability.

Straightsidedcircle · 23/02/2023 12:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

afinishedkiss · 23/02/2023 12:54

Ohh yawn, wind your neck in. Everyone has their own circumstances. Rest on your laurels that you have your own life insurance and keep your beak out of everyone else's. It doesn't concern you are your passive aggressive if not, why not bollox is grating. keep your own side of the yard clean.

LividNC · 23/02/2023 12:53

I’m paying about £35 a month I think for life and critical illness.

Nearly ex-DH has his own similar policy.

To be honest, I think there is a difference between people who could afford it but don’t care or choose not to, and people who are already cut to the bone/using food banks.

Yes, it was the sort of thing we worried about and wanted sorted when I was pregnant. I suppose there’s a privilege in being able to afford it, but if you could afford it and don’t bother then you’re a fool.

Same as those people who have accidents abroad on luxury holidays and then have to start a Go Fund Me. But I’m the person who bought insurance for two nights in Dublin, cos better safe than sorry 😳

Shamoo · 23/02/2023 12:53

I don’t, because I have a fantastic death in service benefit at work (12 x salary). My wife doesn’t as I wouldn’t need her income if she sadly died. People have lots of reasons for not having it.

Lellochip · 23/02/2023 12:53

@StalkedByASpider What about income protection Vs critical illness? This is what I've got but never see it pushed as much as the others? It would cover my outgoings, but obviously no nice lump sum, but wonder if I've missed something important. (No dependants so life cover not worth it for me)

Iyjd · 23/02/2023 12:53

I must be living through 20 week months then based on the cost of mine and it supposedly being £2 a week. I’ve never smoked, don’t drink, I’m 31, work out for an hour a week 5 days a week, walk my dog 3 miles a day (sometimes more), never had an illness. I must be being ripped off! I only got it last year because I’ve never been able to afford it before, what takes priority, definitely needing food or maybe dying young?

Out of my school friends every single one of us has a good job, there are 8 of us. Only 2 own our houses because we can’t afford the deposit, so needing one for your mortgage is irrelevant for 3/4 of the group. 5 have children though.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:49

There are lots of specialist brokers around and it's very much worth going in that direction – we did for a condition my DH had. There's no saying that he might die of the condition - he could get run over – so worth exploring.

The problem is, though, that even if you can get 'second-class sub-person special limited life insurance' that will supposedly pay out if you die of something unconnected, with a lot of conditions, almost every cause of death short of being squashed by a runaway steamroller can be potentially attributable to your condition.

Insurance companies are just fancy bookies with an office in central London, so of course they will use any excuse possible to avoid paying out.

It's not much of a choice to be left with, but I'd rather at least know the score rather than die with the false assurance that my family would be looked after financially, when they most likely wouldn't be at all.

StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 12:48

I was the Underwriting Manager for a big life insurance company for 10 years+. I can't even begin to describe how much the OP has oversimplified things.

Only very certain types of life cover will be that cheap - such as decreasing term assurance - and only for certain people who fit into a very narrow category. The better types of life cover - such as whole of life - will be way, way more expensive than that and of course, it won't cover critical illness cover either which some would argue is more important than life cover. Also, some insurance policies have increasing premiums which rocket drastically - the low start premium can just be an incentive to take it out. Plus if you're older, or unwell, or need a higher amount of cover for your mortgage/debts it will be more expensive.

If you take out the cheap term assurance now, unless it has a renewable option, it will expire and then you'll have to take out life insurance when you're older - and you won't be getting a quote for £6 per month then....

There are all sorts of reasons why people can't get life cover, and why they might be declined. Health, occupation, hobbies - I can't get life cover because of my family history. Nothing to do with my health at all. Certain conditions in your family history will make you uninsurable, even if you're completely well yourself.

I am in my 40s and life cover has never been an essential for a mortgage. They like to imply it is, but it's not the case.

Of course life insurance is a good idea. And definitely, absolutely critical illness cover. But it's not always possible and it can be bloody expensive. Big assumptions you've made there OP.

Lmgify · 23/02/2023 12:48

We don’t have life insurance, but we both have decent death in service payment which will pay off the mortgage if one of us dies

SpecialK2023 · 23/02/2023 12:47

I looked at critical illness. Decided it wasn’t a good investment. For - £30k decreasing payout it would cost £10k over the course of the term. So I’d need to get an illness in the first or second third of the policy to actually benefit beyond the cost. We have some savings so think they’re better in high interest account than a depreciating and expensive policy.

OutofEverything · 23/02/2023 12:43

Simplethingsmarcg · 23/02/2023 12:41

£2 a week? It'll be utterly crap

Utterly crap or term life insurance for a healthy 20 year old that runs out when they hit 30.

OutofEverything · 23/02/2023 12:42

Also all those saying get insurance when you are very young - I am in my late fifties. When I was young critical assurance had only just been designed, was very expensive and had so many exclusions even the experts said it was not worth taking out. Life insurance was also way more expensive and only came down sharply in price once internet use became common.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 23/02/2023 12:41

We don't have it, and should - late 30s/early 40s, three kids, oppressive mortgage. It's perpetually on my to-do list, though I'm going to stop and look into it properly now. I've just looked up DH's employer and they have death in service benefit, at least.

Zipps · 23/02/2023 12:41

Never had it because imo it's a waste of money. We always saved instead and paid down the mortgage which had critical illness cover.
Death in service and I have always worked.
Plus pensions that pay out.
Ridiculous OP.
I agree it sounds like a really bad advert for life insurance.

Simplethingsmarcg · 23/02/2023 12:41

£2 a week? It'll be utterly crap