Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect parents to have life insurance as a matter of course?

313 replies

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 10:59

Is it not the first thing you think about when you first hold your newborn? How can I best care for this little one? What do I need to do/sacrifice to ensure their welfare? in any circumstances?

I appreciate you can't be insured for every eventuality, and with the best will in the world, you can think you have taken out adequate insurance, and in the event it doesn't actually pay out for some reason or other.

But it's about £2 a week, in most cases - surely this is factored into the cost of providing for a child, when you do your calculations? I expect there are a few that can't afford it, but most can.

I am just amazed to hear of someone recently, really struggling, with no life insurance payout for the children, because there was no policy.

Am I living in a fool's paradise? Don't most parents have life insurance? Am I just showing my ignorance? Why wouldn't a parent have life insurance? Do you? if not, why not?

OP posts:
Oneborneverydecade · 23/02/2023 13:36

@lummsnetave life insurance cover, DH has death in service. Ex DH had neither and so was only able to leave the sale value of his mobile home to our son. It's a shame bc he could have set him up for life with uni fees and house deposit. I don't suppose he thought about it before he became ill though.

Starlightstarbright1 · 23/02/2023 13:36

No. I looked at it. Was far more than I could afford and yes I work but Lp

Nanny0gg · 23/02/2023 13:34

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 10:59

Is it not the first thing you think about when you first hold your newborn? How can I best care for this little one? What do I need to do/sacrifice to ensure their welfare? in any circumstances?

I appreciate you can't be insured for every eventuality, and with the best will in the world, you can think you have taken out adequate insurance, and in the event it doesn't actually pay out for some reason or other.

But it's about £2 a week, in most cases - surely this is factored into the cost of providing for a child, when you do your calculations? I expect there are a few that can't afford it, but most can.

I am just amazed to hear of someone recently, really struggling, with no life insurance payout for the children, because there was no policy.

Am I living in a fool's paradise? Don't most parents have life insurance? Am I just showing my ignorance? Why wouldn't a parent have life insurance? Do you? if not, why not?

In my brother's case, because he's got a life-limiting illness and he couldn't get insurance. He might survive to a good age but there's no guarantee

So think before you post. His wife will be screwed if anything happens to him

lapasion · 23/02/2023 13:33

I can’t get it. I had a suicide attempt pre-kids and also have a very mild condition that shouldn’t shorten my life. Every provider has turned me down.

Luckily I do have death in service benefits so that will cover the rent for a couple of years but it’s not great. It’s so depressing to think about.

Wobblytrees · 23/02/2023 13:33

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 12:16

I think its like with most things in life, those people who need it most are in the least able position to have it.

Brilliantly summarised.

I'm another who can't get LI or CI because of various health conditions - ones that will almost certainly lead to me not making old bones, but I hope I can hang on until my DS is an adult.

Do you know how good it makes people feel to know that no insurer considers their life worth insuring, essentially because of the reason you are far more likely to need the insurance?

And then, on top of that, being told that you are irresponsible, stupid, reckless, not a loving, caring parent, add whatever other insults you like - it's not the nicest feeling to be had. Not just on threads like this, but the annual mailshots that turn on the emotional blackmail and stress the 'come on, it's time to be a GOOD parent now' message from companies that would instantly change their mind and turn me down point blank if I applied and they saw my medical record. They would then doubtless take me straight off their mailing list - not because of any compassion for me, but to save themselves a few quid in wasted printing and postage, of course.

Where does that leave us, then? What's the point in challenging attitudes like that? All that people can do is backtrack and say "Oh, I didn't mean YOU!" as if that makes it better. As PP said, disabled people are parents too; I shouldn't have to point it out, but we're also people too - and we love our kids just as much as able-bodied, fully healthy parents do.

Likewise with very poor people (even if able-bodied and healthy) who get the same criticism levelled at them. It's the same when it comes to pensions - how utterly stupid you must be if you want to put food on the table and shoes on your kids' feet now rather than store your pitiful funds away for a tomorrow that may never come.

By all means publicise it to those who may qualify and be interested/able to afford it; but enough already with the presumptuous, unthinking, uncaring, ableist, poor-bashing, sneery attitudes that come from a position of privilege - blaming and shaming people for 'making the choice' not to do something that they simply cannot possibly do.

Very good post

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 13:32

Overthebloodymoon · 23/02/2023 13:30

Agreed @ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

It’s part and parcel of being a responsible parent. Why would you leave the future of your child to chance? Much more chance of a family member or friend stepping up if the worst were to happen if your child is set up financially too.

Because I'm disabled and I can't get cover.

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 13:32

*low paid

lummsnet · 23/02/2023 13:31

So op. Let's get this straight.

When I left their abusive dad I wasn't caring properly for my kids. Coz I didn't have life insurance then.

When I went to university to qualify myself in a subject that has me earning a good wage now - a very good wage - I wasn't doing the right thing by my kids or adequately caring for them. Because I didn't have life insurance.

When I was in law paid training jobs I wasn't working my way up with an end plan in sight to do the right thing for my kids so I could better provide for them. Because I didn't have life insurance?

I can't get fucking life insurance. I can't even get a bloody quote. But I am a shitty disabled parent

Ok. Got it.

Overthebloodymoon · 23/02/2023 13:30

Agreed @ZeldaWillTellYourFortune

It’s part and parcel of being a responsible parent. Why would you leave the future of your child to chance? Much more chance of a family member or friend stepping up if the worst were to happen if your child is set up financially too.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 23/02/2023 13:25

AutumnScream · 23/02/2023 11:08

I dont think life insurance is the first thing people think about when holding their bloody newborn for the first time 😂

But it should be.

TedMullins · 23/02/2023 13:25

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 13:22

but thats when you take it out! when you are young and healthy.

I started self harming when I was 14. Many policies won't cover you if you have self-harm on your medical records. By the time I was old enough to take out life insurance, I was already ineligible. As PP have said you're showing ableist privilege thinking everyone can 'just' get it that easily.

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 13:22

FrangipaniBlue · 23/02/2023 13:08

That is just a rough guide if you are young and healthy and don't smoke, obviously other factors can raise the price.

A young healthy non-smoker is one of the least likely to need life insurance so why would they prioritise it over other expenditure?

but thats when you take it out! when you are young and healthy.

OP posts:
Sunsetintheeast · 23/02/2023 13:20

We do have life insurance but like most of these policies there’s plenty of loopholes for providers to worm their way out of

Total rubbish. Life insurance will always pay, EXCEPT if you lied on your applications. Other than that it's simple: you're dead or alive.

In all my years in the industry I have never had a claim declined, even when the person insured killed themselves.

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 13:19

LividNC · 23/02/2023 12:53

I’m paying about £35 a month I think for life and critical illness.

Nearly ex-DH has his own similar policy.

To be honest, I think there is a difference between people who could afford it but don’t care or choose not to, and people who are already cut to the bone/using food banks.

Yes, it was the sort of thing we worried about and wanted sorted when I was pregnant. I suppose there’s a privilege in being able to afford it, but if you could afford it and don’t bother then you’re a fool.

Same as those people who have accidents abroad on luxury holidays and then have to start a Go Fund Me. But I’m the person who bought insurance for two nights in Dublin, cos better safe than sorry 😳

yes of course, there is a huge difference between parents that look into it and decide it is not for them, maybe because of the price, or because they have death in service benefits already...

and the parents who could take it out, but have just never bothered

OP posts:
StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 13:17

StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 13:16

Do you mean for life cover?

Because if so, that's what I was waffling on about to you above 😅 The life insurance companies I know won't put any exclusions on life cover because it's not fair, it's complicated and often there's no clear-cut answer.

Lots of life cover has a 12 month exclusion clause for suicide. But after the 12 months, suicide is covered. If you had a really really risky job or hobby, accidental death MIGHT be excluded - but they'd be more likely to either decline it or charge you more.

They don't put exclusions on life cover. Because dealing with that would be messy, and just awful for driving families. Usually with life cover, they'll either give it to you for whatever price they think is suitable, or they won't. No exclusions.

Driving???

That's supposed to say grieving families. My computer hates me.

StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 13:16

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 13:09

I mean this genuinely - no insurance company I know deliberately tried to avoid paying out. The whole industry is really tightly regulated and a lot of the misconceptions are unfair.

OK, maybe I was a bit scathing and unfair in how I framed it; but surely, if you have one of a number of conditions that does/can affect/spread to your whole body, they would have every right to legitimately refuse to pay out under the clear terms of the policy - you're effectively a human write-off - but still, how does that help the family of the deceased person (assuming no unequivocal steamroller-related incident)?

Do you mean for life cover?

Because if so, that's what I was waffling on about to you above 😅 The life insurance companies I know won't put any exclusions on life cover because it's not fair, it's complicated and often there's no clear-cut answer.

Lots of life cover has a 12 month exclusion clause for suicide. But after the 12 months, suicide is covered. If you had a really really risky job or hobby, accidental death MIGHT be excluded - but they'd be more likely to either decline it or charge you more.

They don't put exclusions on life cover. Because dealing with that would be messy, and just awful for driving families. Usually with life cover, they'll either give it to you for whatever price they think is suitable, or they won't. No exclusions.

Beachbabe1 · 23/02/2023 13:15

Just got a mortgage and ours is £50 p/m. You wont get one for £2 per wk! When monies tight this isnt a high priority for people. I wanted it for security of having mortgage paid if one of us dies. Touch wood!

redpatternedquilt · 23/02/2023 13:15

To be honest you sound as if you look down on people who don't buy into your way of "doing life".
Please remember that not everyone is in agreement with or can manage to cope with the idea of complete individual responsibility for every single part of their life.
In 2023 Britain, there seems to be a type of person who idealises the individual so much so, that they pride themselves on never once having relied on another person for any task, big or small. Things they take pride in are:
Paying rent to parents from 16 through a part time job( even when it isn't needed)
Working throughout university
Not accepting any money from family
Pension worked out from first starting work.
Having completely separate bank accounts from partners and being completely financially independent, at all times, even saving for any maternity leaves.
Having a child based on career progression and not feelings or health/ age.
Downsizing at the appropriate time.
Financial planning so as to ensure care can be bought and organised at appropriate time, without asking for any help.
Now I can add, life insurance the day first child is born to the list.
I'm not saying these people are wrong, far from it, just that there is often a tendency for them to consider this the minimum to be a worthy part of society. That anyone who isn't capable of this level of organisation is somehow a burden, or anyone who doesn't agree is backward thinking.
Being seemingly in control of life is also a response to the anxiety we feel living in this modern age. Some people respond to it like you, others in other ways.

luckylavender · 23/02/2023 13:13

probablyoverinsured · 23/02/2023 10:59

Is it not the first thing you think about when you first hold your newborn? How can I best care for this little one? What do I need to do/sacrifice to ensure their welfare? in any circumstances?

I appreciate you can't be insured for every eventuality, and with the best will in the world, you can think you have taken out adequate insurance, and in the event it doesn't actually pay out for some reason or other.

But it's about £2 a week, in most cases - surely this is factored into the cost of providing for a child, when you do your calculations? I expect there are a few that can't afford it, but most can.

I am just amazed to hear of someone recently, really struggling, with no life insurance payout for the children, because there was no policy.

Am I living in a fool's paradise? Don't most parents have life insurance? Am I just showing my ignorance? Why wouldn't a parent have life insurance? Do you? if not, why not?

Many people don't have it. And money is relative.

Beautiful3 · 23/02/2023 13:12

We started off with this. But it kept going up. Ended up being £50 per month for both of us. Wasn't worth it, and made us struggle a bit, so ended it. Actually wasted 3 years paying into it. You can't control how much it rises by, and you waste any money that went into it, before cancelling.

StalkedByASpider · 23/02/2023 13:11

Magentax · 23/02/2023 13:01

Customers often end up paying in more than is paid out.

That's the basis of all insurance products though - they need the majority to pay in more than they get out or underwriters would be bankrupt.

No, it's not. Not in the same sense as the over-50s policies. In those types of life insurance, you will personally get out less than you put in - that's not the case with other types of insurance. Overall, the company will get more in premium income, but that's not because you end up paying more for your policy than you'd receive.

Surplus premium income is invested for the insurer plus there's money from policies where people stop paying halfway through so never get round to claiming, or term assurance which very often doesn't pay out at all.

People don't pay in more than is paid out in a proper life insurance policy - the over-50 policies are structured differently, hence why people end up paying more.

With term assurance people pay to be covered, just in case. In most cases they don't die while they're covered by the policy - but if they did, they'd receive a lot more than they paid in.

Whole of life insurance will pay out if you continue to pay your premiums. The amount paid in doesn't come close to the potential benefits a policy provides. There's often an investment element to whole of life policies too.

AllWorkYoPlait · 23/02/2023 13:11

DH gets some sort of cover through work. I also have a work policy which costs me about £15 a month and covers my death, severe injury and I think injury of my spouse.

Does annoy me somewhat that I'm worth more dead than alive 😅considering an amazonian canoe trip... 🤔

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/02/2023 13:09

I mean this genuinely - no insurance company I know deliberately tried to avoid paying out. The whole industry is really tightly regulated and a lot of the misconceptions are unfair.

OK, maybe I was a bit scathing and unfair in how I framed it; but surely, if you have one of a number of conditions that does/can affect/spread to your whole body, they would have every right to legitimately refuse to pay out under the clear terms of the policy - you're effectively a human write-off - but still, how does that help the family of the deceased person (assuming no unequivocal steamroller-related incident)?

FrangipaniBlue · 23/02/2023 13:08

That is just a rough guide if you are young and healthy and don't smoke, obviously other factors can raise the price.

A young healthy non-smoker is one of the least likely to need life insurance so why would they prioritise it over other expenditure?

TheWayTheLightFalls · 23/02/2023 13:07

I've looked into it in the time since I replied on this thread - just over £100/month for us both, with some critical illness cover.

Swipe left for the next trending thread