Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do we do it?

39 replies

Bunnyfuller · 22/02/2023 18:01

Possibly IABU but I’m mystified:

middle income family, managing just about in current climate.

DD almost 17 is champing at the bit to learn to drive. We’ve said we can buy her a set of 10 lessons this year instead of giving her the money on her 18th. Then I said to her how will you buy a car? We can’t run to buying a car and insuring it, even if we did our one year older daughter would want the same ‘treating’

How do people do it? We’re shitting ourselves at the thought of university- it seems due to income we won’t get much help, and again, how the hell do people afford it? We have no savings and no money in the family at all on either side.

Do I need to break it to her that we can’t do uni, let alone the car!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IfYoureGonnaBreakMyHeart · 22/02/2023 23:00

Bunnyfuller · 22/02/2023 18:06

Yes, we have said that to her. She does have a part time (very part time!) job now, which she moans about constantly. I guess this will make her realise she needs to work more if she wants a car. Doesn’t help her best friend is from a wealthy family and her dad has already said he will buy her a car when she passes her test.

My neighbours daughter just started at Sainsburys part time around uni. she's on £11 an hour. She's funding her own driving lessons once her first pay comes through.

clary · 22/02/2023 20:53

Only DS2 of mine has wanted to learn to drive. I paid for his lessons and tests. He is on the insurance for my tiny car and is welcome to drive it when he is home; he is also OK to borrow it as needed (for a weekend away for example). If he wants his own car he will have to save up.

Some of my DCs' friends saved up their money to buy a car; some had one bought by parents.

When you say middle income OP, what sort of ballpark? DS2 gets a pretty high loan (£7k) and our household income is around £60k. I top it up a bit and buy him things as and when to make up the rest. It's doable for us but we are careful with money. What sort of loan would DC get? Many unis have lower-budget accommodation which may make it feasible, or yy are there any local that would be good. DD commuted in her final year for various reasons and that saved a lot of money (esp as she only needed to go in twice a week (arts degree)).

BrendaWearingBaffies · 22/02/2023 20:37

I worked to afford the lessons aged 20/21. My parents could not afford to pay for them. But I just got on with it and didn't complain. I had a part time job from the age of 14. At uni they did the odd grocery shop but I also had a student loan and a bursary. I had part time work as a student too. I am expecting my own DC to follow in a similar vein.

Pieceofpurplesky · 22/02/2023 20:31

DS is in his first year at university, in his flat of 8 only 2 drive and only one has a car. Parents couldn't afford. He didn't really work for two years with lockdown so didn't have the chance to save up. No way I could afford, like many others. Added to that the time missed during lockdown when he would have been driving. I couldn't even afford to insure him on my car.
He gets the full loan and maintenance loan for university and I buy him some food shopping as and when. He manages, just as I have as a single mum.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 22/02/2023 20:30

It's a waste of money going to university.

She should look at apprenticeships.

aibutohavethisusername · 22/02/2023 20:29

Most students won’t need a car anyway so she can buy one once she has a job…

Artemis20 · 22/02/2023 20:26

Well I had to get a job and pay for my own driving lessons and my parents gave me a car but it was an old one not worth much!

I also had to take out student loans and took me till I was about 30 to pay them off.

These days with fees loans will be the norm.
interest rate will be low still I imagine.

lottie198 · 22/02/2023 20:24

I went to university with hardly any help from my parents. They helped all they could but couldn't afford much. I got an interest free overdraft which helped and applied for the student loans I was eligible for and got a job. I couldn't afford to learn to drive until I left uni and started working full time. I then paid for all my driving lessons myself.
If she wants something she can still do it , even if you can't afford to help. It's not your responsibility to fund your adult child for the rest of her life.

icanneverthinkofnc · 22/02/2023 20:21

Oh, and I was 23 when I learnt and a parent of 2.

Findyourneutralspace · 22/02/2023 20:05

What car do you have? I drive a mini and plan to put DS on my insurance when he passes his test. It will cost an extra £40 a month which I can stretch to. Means he can be taxi for me (he doesn’t drink) and can pop over to visit his dad or grandma to practise his driving. By the time he can afford his own car he’ll have a bit of no claims built up.
That only works if you have a cheap enough car though.

Vitriolinsanity · 22/02/2023 20:04

@Iudncuewbccgrcb I could have written your exact post.

icanneverthinkofnc · 22/02/2023 20:01

Driving is a privilege, not a right.

We couldn't afford to buy cars for our DC. DD had 7 lessons but hated it at 18. She waited until she was 30 to learn. Neither DSs drive, the 34 yr old rides a motorbike. He is looking into getting lessons in the near future. Oldest DS doesn't drive and is happy to get train, bus or taxi when needed.

Uni, unless they intend to go into a professional career requiring a degree is also a luxury.

She wants those things she needs to start earning.

Talipesmum · 22/02/2023 20:01

My parents paid for my driving lessons, I was lucky, but there was absolutely no question of them buying me a car. I bought my own when I got a job age 23. I was lucky enough to be insured on their car before then and was allowed to use it if they didn’t need it, but we were one car household so it was just in evenings sometimes. I only knew of a very few of my friends who had full time use of a car at that age, and only one or two whose parents bought them one. That would have been v flash. People tended to be on their parents insurance.

CaptainMerica · 22/02/2023 20:00

I would prioritise uni over driving lessons. I didn't learn to drive until after I had graduated and could pay for it myself.

You need to seriously sit down with her and work out the finance for uni though, so she understands the limitations. If she is not going to be able to borrow enough to live on due to your income, and you can't make up the difference, then she needs to understand, ASAP.

WhamBamEatYourSpam · 22/02/2023 19:56

I came from a working class family, I had 3 part-time jobs at one point during studies. My parents gave me £500 towards a car, everything else was down to me. Financial support towards university? You're having a laugh! Again that was on me!

PaigeMatthews · 22/02/2023 19:53

A driving licence is important. Far more important than having a car. That can come at any point. So id definitely pay for lessons.

tell her asap about uni so she can look at courses in commuting distance. A friend of mine was told ON RESULTS DAY her parents couldnt afford for her to go. She was devastated. Wtf the parents were thinking i dont know.

WorriedMillie · 22/02/2023 19:49

It’s ok for her not to have a car until she can fund it herself
I had one, as we lived way off any public transport routes and my parents were fed up of playing taxi. Had they not been able to afford it, there’s no way I’d have expected to have one
Lots of my fellow uni students didn’t own cars. I didn’t take mine to uni either
And re funding uni, I worked during holidays, almost every day. During my masters, I worked weekends.

Smoky1107 · 22/02/2023 19:47

I have paid for driving lessons but now she's passed she uses my car.
Uni - she stays home and commutes into the city for her course.

That's how I afford it

NoSquirrels · 22/02/2023 19:43

Unless you’re really rural (& then it’s a more pragmatic thing to pay for a car so you’re not taxiing them everywhere) then most people don’t buy their 17 year olds a car, in my experience. They add them to the insurance on the family car, and they can use it when it’s not needed by others. Ideally you wouldn’t have a flash car on credit for this!

Overthebow · 22/02/2023 19:38

She works for it. I bought my own car at 17, I had part time jobs from the age of 14 and saved for my car and university, then worked during the holidays whilst at uni to supplement my student loan. Loads of people do this.

MoomiMama · 22/02/2023 19:36

She is old enough to know your money limitations and there will be others at school in similar position. I knew people who got a brand new car for their 18th birthday; I had a weekend job and paid for some of my driving lessons, my parents then insured me on their car and in return I picked them up from the odd night out. There were other kids at school in my situation or similar too. I never questioned it and certainly never sulked about it. (Obviously I sulked about plenty of other things though, I was a teenager after all!)
On the other hand, I am a bit surprised that it sounds like you haven’t planned for, budgeted for or discussed how things like driving lessons, insurance and uni will be paid for. We had those conversations when I was growing up, and do with my kids too.

Sarahcoggles · 22/02/2023 19:07

I'm paying for DS driving lessons but I can't afford a car for him. I passed my test at 19 and didn't get a car till I could buy my own age 24. It's not compulsory to buy your teen a car.

Chevyimpala67 · 22/02/2023 18:37

Car - ds1 paid for his lessons and he's insured on my car.
Univerity - Tuition fee loan and basic maintenance loan. Any other money he needs he works for.

Bunnyfuller · 22/02/2023 18:31

Thanks guys, it makes sense. I think we’re surrounded by people with more money than us. At the moment she’s seething because I’ve said she needs to work more if she wants these things. Her sister works at Mac Donald’s part time, and it’s pretty good money for teenagers, but she works at a little cafe on just over minimum wage for 16 yr old, only 7 hours a week. I’m not saying anything else now, will let it all sink

OP posts:
BackToWhereItAllBegan · 22/02/2023 18:22

@Whammyyammy that's how we do it in the US too. Generally kids will have a lesson or two at most to learn how to use the controls then they just drive EVERYWHERE they or their parents need to go over the next year (with an adult in the car of course).
I reckon DS has driven 1000's of miles by the time he took his test and we only paid for 2 days worth of formal lessons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread