Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To only drive places I know?

211 replies

Lis1992 · 22/02/2023 17:58

So I am driving around two years now. Passed my test first time and while I know I am a competent driver; I am still nervous. It’s others on the road who make me worry- if that makes sense. Like tailgaters,I try to ignore them but it’s a horrible feeling. I think it’s disgusting that irresponsible people do this just because you are driving safely. Anyway, I only drive when I need to- to work daily and local shops/appointments, I drive the dog to the local park or whatever. All routes I know and I have practice on.

If there is any kind of roadworks diversion etc I feel instant panic set in. I stick to routes I know and don’t drive anywhere else. Is there anyone else like this with driving? I’m happy I have the skill but I do only use the car when it’s essential.

OP posts:
neverknowinglyunreasonable · 22/02/2023 20:56

I'm sure someone has said this already but I sometimes look at new journeys (or at least the tricky bits - turnings, decision points etc) in Google maps street view and drag it along like I'm driving.

Obviously not the real deal but it might help?

Lovesacake · 22/02/2023 20:56

FurAndFeathers · 22/02/2023 20:42

I’m genuinely confused. If you’re a competent driver and have access to a navigation system/Google maps, what’s the difference between driving familiar versus unfamiliar routes @Lis1992

This wasn’t directed at me but I’m another driver who will only drive very short and familiar routes. The difference for me is I can pay 100% attention to the road, I find looking at/listening to a satnav very distracting whilst driving.

On an unfamiliar route my brain is tring to listen to the instructions, look at the screen, read every road sign, dodge every unexpected pothole, look out for speed bumps, worry about what the parking will be like etc etc. it feels like an overwhelming amount of new information to process and numerous unknowns to worry about.

on one of my familiar routes I drive in silence, I know every pothole, every speed bump, every change of speed limit, every sharp bend, where I will park etc so my brain is much quieter and 100% of my attention is on the road and the cars/pedestrians around me….it’s a very different experience and feels much safer.

mistermagpie · 22/02/2023 20:54

slamfightbrightlight · 22/02/2023 20:47

It’s a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy I find. I worry that my lack of confidence makes me a bad driver (as comments here would suggest!), feeling like a bad driver makes me question my decision making while driving, which then undermines my confidence and round and round. I use SatNav everywhere, even for familiar journeys, like a safety blanket. Other drivers really don’t help sometimes - I was driving to exit a busy car park recently, one I’ve been in loads of times - ensured I checked all around me before turning for the exit but immediately after the manoeuvre there was a car behind me beeping and a male driver gesticulating. I genuinely have no idea what I was supposed to have done wrong to justify his behaviour, that knocked my confidence again and made me want to avoid going to the same car park. And then transfers to being anxious about other car parks!

As a previous poster said, I’m pretty competent in other areas of my life but for driving and it is a pain in the arse. I don’t think learning to drive later in life helped, but when I started learning at 17 it coincided with several people from my year being killed or seriously injured in car accidents and I think that put me off learning for so long that I’ve struggled to enjoy driving at all.

I feel very similar to you. It's often quite difficult to admit you aren't a 'natural' driver and people knock your confidence even more when you do.

A friend hit and killed a pedestrian while I was learning to drive. It wasn't my friends fault (inquest said so anyway) but that didn't really change anything. It freaked me out completely and although I did pass my test, I never drove again for years.

MsMarch · 22/02/2023 20:53

watcherintherye · 22/02/2023 20:30

Tailgaters are usually because the car behind wants to go faster... are you genuinely doing the speed limit?

Yeah, tailgaters are usually arseholes who are crap drivers. You don’t have to ‘do’ the speed limit. It’s a limit, not a target, and you have to take into account things such as visibility and road conditions. People who think you have to ‘do’ the speed limit, no matter what, and who drive up the backside of the car in front are many things, a good driver not being one of them.

I am always bemused by this, "its a limit, not a target" thing. Its the speed at which it is safe to drive in normal conditions and so, to keep traffic moving, most drivers should, under most conditions be at, or close to that speed. I mean, driving 28 in a 30 zone is fine, but driving 20 in a 30 zone when the conditions are good, daylight etc, is arguably as dangerous as driving 40. Other drivers are instinctively making decisions based on an understanding of the standard speed etc. And yes, some will get impatient and drive erratically. That IS their fault, but let's be honest, the slow poke at 20 needs to bear some responsibility.

It's like people who say they can't navigate roundabouts. Don't drive then. Some are easier than others so I am sympathetic (I have been known to go round a big one more than once), but you can't just avoid them or expect other drivers to miraculously know that actually, you are going to yield when it's not your turn or go whenever you feel like it.

JaffaMCCakey · 22/02/2023 20:51

FurAndFeathers · 22/02/2023 20:47

Well, having a panic attack at roadworks in a familiar area doesn’t really indicate competence or confidence

I think most drivers in this situation if they felt panicked would pull over and reassess

FurAndFeathers · 22/02/2023 20:47

Birdsbirdsbirds · 22/02/2023 19:08

Based on?

Well, having a panic attack at roadworks in a familiar area doesn’t really indicate competence or confidence

slamfightbrightlight · 22/02/2023 20:47

It’s a bit of a self-fulfilling prophecy I find. I worry that my lack of confidence makes me a bad driver (as comments here would suggest!), feeling like a bad driver makes me question my decision making while driving, which then undermines my confidence and round and round. I use SatNav everywhere, even for familiar journeys, like a safety blanket. Other drivers really don’t help sometimes - I was driving to exit a busy car park recently, one I’ve been in loads of times - ensured I checked all around me before turning for the exit but immediately after the manoeuvre there was a car behind me beeping and a male driver gesticulating. I genuinely have no idea what I was supposed to have done wrong to justify his behaviour, that knocked my confidence again and made me want to avoid going to the same car park. And then transfers to being anxious about other car parks!

As a previous poster said, I’m pretty competent in other areas of my life but for driving and it is a pain in the arse. I don’t think learning to drive later in life helped, but when I started learning at 17 it coincided with several people from my year being killed or seriously injured in car accidents and I think that put me off learning for so long that I’ve struggled to enjoy driving at all.

mistermagpie · 22/02/2023 20:42

I should add - I had severe driving phobia for 15 years and thought I would never ever drive again. I know drive most days and I genuinely never thought I could. If I only drive to maybe ten different places regularly, then I don't care, it's more than I ever thought I would do.

FurAndFeathers · 22/02/2023 20:42

I’m genuinely confused. If you’re a competent driver and have access to a navigation system/Google maps, what’s the difference between driving familiar versus unfamiliar routes @Lis1992

mistermagpie · 22/02/2023 20:40

I started like this but I made it my goal to gradually add a new route every couple of months. I've got three kids who often need taking to random venues for parties and clubs, so that helps as I have no choice.

As to how I do this, I look at google maps and street view to see what kinds of roads and things I'll be dealing with and so I can visualise the route better. I feel calmer when there aren't surprises! I have a sat nav which helps.

There will be people who say you shouldn't be driving but I really fail to see why not? Only driving to certain places doesn't make you less safe. I do not drive on the motorway, not because I would be unsafe but because I find it stressful and I don't need to.

I don't put anyone else out though, and if a friend wanted to me meet me somewhere that I didn't want to drive to then I'd just get public transport.

Iwillhavealargeone · 22/02/2023 20:32

Sorry, you are neither a competent or confident driver if you are unable to drive on unfamiliar areas.

watcherintherye · 22/02/2023 20:30

Tailgaters are usually because the car behind wants to go faster... are you genuinely doing the speed limit?

Yeah, tailgaters are usually arseholes who are crap drivers. You don’t have to ‘do’ the speed limit. It’s a limit, not a target, and you have to take into account things such as visibility and road conditions. People who think you have to ‘do’ the speed limit, no matter what, and who drive up the backside of the car in front are many things, a good driver not being one of them.

DarlingCoffee · 22/02/2023 20:29

I do this. You’re not alone OP!

mozzyworries · 22/02/2023 20:17

You need to gradually build your confidence OP. Can you start by doing a short drive out of your comfort zone/known roads, just a couple of minutes.

Then keep building up to longer durations/distances.

You can pick a place you'd like to go to to give your journey purpose, like a cafe, cinema, specific shop. Also gives you a break before you do the return journey.

The more you drive to places you don't know and get comfortable using the sat nav while driving, the more you'll feel comfortable going further.

When I first started driving (several years after passing my test) I was scared to even drive to the train station 5 mins away or supermarket 10 mins away, but I pushed myself in this way and now feel comfortable driving anywhere, but it did take time.

pluggee · 22/02/2023 20:17

I get this a bit, not on new roads outside of London but places in London i'm not familiar with & I live in London. The lanes/box junctions, one way etc give me anxiety

BooksAndHooks · 22/02/2023 20:15

I’ve been driving ten years and still like this. It’s like any other fear it’s not logical, telling someone afraid of spiders they can’t hurt you doesn’t stop their body reacting with fear. I can’t explain the logic behind it and why I cannot transfer the skills from one road to another, I just can’t. It’s not something I’m proud of it’s embarrassing. But it is what it is and I’d rather drive safely where I am comfortable than risk an accident by driving when I’m in no fit state to drive.

pictoosh · 22/02/2023 20:13

It’s up to you but you’re completely restricting your options. Being able to drive means freedom. Seems a shame to curtail it.

FictionalCharacter · 22/02/2023 20:10

Frabbits · 22/02/2023 19:30

You are either a safe, competent driver or you are not.

If you are not capable of following a sat-nav or following signs and reading the road ahead properly, you fall into the second category and if you could just stay off the roads entirely that will be better for everyone.

I agree. If you’re so lacking in confidence you won’t go anywhere unfamiliar, would you cope in an emergency? What happens if there’s a diversion, or someone needs you to pick them up somewhere else, or the police direct you away from an accident?
You would benefit from expanding your familiar area as soon as possible, because staying in your comfort zone will reinforce your lack of confidence. Or you could get some extra driving lessons.
The people who never build up their confidence and become the driver who only drives to the local shops / when it’s daylight and not raining or does 50 mph on the motorway are not safe drivers.

Gremlins101 · 22/02/2023 20:09

I should have said in my previous message that I think youre doing fine. I appreciate a safe driver 🙂

Gremlins101 · 22/02/2023 20:07

I think you are fine once it doesn't impede other's freedom.

My MIL won't drive in the dark or anywhere with traffic, or on a narrow single lane road, and we live in very rural area. So her husband has to take the day off work if she has an appointment even though she has a beautiful car and has been driving 40 years or so. He has to fuel the car for her too as she won't do it. I'd actually find it cute if she didn't makes me and DH feel a bit rubbish about how we spend our time and raise our kids.

Anyway it is to my advantage. we are moving to a house very close by theirs, and the road between their house and ours, she can't drive on it!!

Grizzledstrawberry · 22/02/2023 19:54

bozzabollix · 22/02/2023 19:14

I’m currently training to become a driving instructor and this fascinates me, I think it’s something I’d like to specialise in if the market is there. It seems to be a predominantly female source of anxiety (maybe because males aren’t so open, traditionally driving has been a male dominated area).

Is it something any of you who are experiencing this worry would seek help for? It must be very empowering to drive where you want without fear if you have previously suffered. Or are you happy to carry on as is sticking to the same routes etc?

As you can probably guess I love driving so no I don’t share this fear, but feel sad for others that such a liberating activity is such a source of anxiety. It shouldn’t be an AIBU really, you can’t be unreasonable for feeling fear. It’s a common problem too.

My second instructor was female, my first male instructor shouted 'for gods sake' at me on my first lesson because I kept stalling, his obvious annoyance at me didn't help me to stop stalling, he was awful, was the first time I had ever sat in the drivers seat, I gave up and didn't try again for years, he had made me feel like I was just crap and would never drive, My second instructor (female) was incredibly patient with me, talked me down when I was feeling anxious, wrote down anything I was struggling with, with diagrams for me to take home and study and was just generally really kind and lovely, I don't think I would have passed with anyone else.

(Not saying men can't be lovely instructors too, I just felt like the female instructor understood my anxiety with driving better)

I would definitely seek help with a instructor like that, it made all the difference for me.

tinytemper66 · 22/02/2023 19:54

I will drive anyway as long as there is a guaranteed parking space. This is my only 'anal' thing about driving m!

Can2022getanyworse · 22/02/2023 19:51

My ex mil thought I was nuts for visiting family 3 hours drive away. She'd go crazy if she knew some of the adventures I've been on! Yet she wouldn't drive any more than a few miles from home.

Another friend used to use a satnav that took them on a wierd and unnecessary diversion EVERY time she visited - like a 3 mile diversion off a main road, round the lanes, and back onto the same road. Wouldn't be told that she could stay on the same road and save 10 minutes by not turning off.

I suspect you are not the competent driver you think you are OP if a diversion causes you that amount of anxiety.

Dontlistitonfacebook · 22/02/2023 19:50

OP I was nervous driving new places at first. But I had places I needed to go to, so just had to do it. No satnav in those days so I used to plan my route with maps.

Been driving over 30 years now and am fine with it. It's just practice! If you want to improve your confidence then yabu for only driving known routes. Honestly it's worth it to learn the skill and PP have given some good suggestions about how to build your confidence.

pigsDOfly · 22/02/2023 19:47

NevieSticks · 22/02/2023 19:41

When i was learning to drive the instructor slanted the mirror so that I could not see behind me - he said "forget about who is behind you , concentrate on who is in front of you". Not sure if that is necessarily good advice but it was 48 years ago 😂

It's not only not good advice, it's actually extremely dangerous advice.