Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just out of parents night - 11 years new novel is about a boy who wants to be a girl

346 replies

Workingmomof2 · 22/02/2023 17:54

And the teacher was talking about it as a great book. I’m seriously not happy. Would I be unreasonable to raise this with the school. Why is this kind of idea even introduced to our children so young. No wonder they are all so confused.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
SausageCat47 · 22/02/2023 19:03

I don’t know exactly which book it is, so I can’t comment on the teaching aims. However, historically censorship in schools has never gone down well when looked back on. Schools in the USA heavily censor many books in many states (my friend is a librarian there) and it helps no one. Censorship seems to be be a way of escaping teaching critical thinking skills/or a way of controlling messages, sadly common and many books with any hint of LGBTQ+ themes are banned, some with certain political messages are banned too in the USA…the history of banned books is an important part of librarianship studies. I’m just concerned as censorship is a slippery slope…

I don’t agree with the editing of old editions to fit modern ideals either even though I don’t agree with some of the phrases with my more modern mindset, again it’s better to have critical skills than to change the books themselves

thirteenfiftyeight · 22/02/2023 19:03

I asked @ourflagmeansdeath the same question but no reply. If not a mental illness, what is it?

Eyerollcentral · 22/02/2023 19:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

If gender dysphoria is not a mental issue what is the cause of someone being trans? What causes it then?

Eyerollcentral · 22/02/2023 18:59

ourflagmeansdeath · 22/02/2023 17:57

Confused really. I don't see an issue introducing the idea to young kids - they're 11 though, not young at all really! Off to secondary soon. They should know about these things as they're normal. Trans people are normal so I'm struggling to see the problem. What do you have against your child knowing about trans people???

Out of curiosity, what is the book called?

Totally disagree. There is no need to introduce this to children in primary school, especially in a way that means that there is no discussion around the issues. I sincerely doubt children will be allowed to say I don’t think girls can turn in to boys for example. I am all for open discussion but it won’t be that. It will be lies presented as unassailable fact.

thirteenfiftyeight · 22/02/2023 18:58

I'd love to know where it's all come from. What's the agenda?

bellac11 · 22/02/2023 18:57

ourflagmeansdeath · 22/02/2023 18:51

Sorry that was my fault. I do know what happens, I said before it wasn't alright. Really sorry. I misunderstood slightly, was more thinking about medically transitioning. I do know how awful it is, for example cases where rape cases aren't taken seriously because the man has now transitioned into a woman. It is horrible, I know this. I'm just trying to say this is certainly not all trans people, and they don't deserve this sort of stigma. Kids learning the basics of them in a friendly isn't a problem.

I would agree with you about kids learning about it, if there was some confidence that gender as a concept or gender ideology is not sold in a binary (no pun intended) fashion

But thats not what is happening in schools unfortunately. There isnt any recognition that the vast number of children feeling or thinking this way have co existing disorders, usually PTSD, ASD and/or an abusive background.

Children dont seem to be being taught about biology, every single mention of male and female or men and women is spoken about inn terms of gender. Why is sex not recognised, where has it gone, what does it mean now. You cant fill out a form these days without gender being the option and sex has disappeared. Its unthinking and dangerous and Im not entirely sure I understand where its all come from.

Dacadactyl · 22/02/2023 18:54

I would be kicking up an almighty fuss and going mad about this if (God forbid) this nonsense was introduced at my kids school. Totally ridiculous.

Soontobe60 · 22/02/2023 18:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

And you, dear, are ignorant. Most research, which is limited, shows that those who transition in early adulthood retain the same degree of mental health concerns that caused them to be steered towards transition in the first place. Primarily because for the vast majority no consideration was given to co-morbidities that existed at the time they identified as trans.
there are whole swathes of detransitioners who’s lives have been blighted by being encouraged to have their breasts removed, or take opposite sex hormones leading to irreversible changes.

Anything that glorifies such brutal practices has no place in schools.

Sarahcoggles · 22/02/2023 18:53

Hearing people say that kids need to learn about this stuff at school makes me think I'm living in a parallel universe. Do you not know that kids already know about it? You'd have to live in a cave to be unaware of trans issues.

If my kids had been given that book then I'd make a point of telling them it's just a silly story and boys can't become girls or vice versa.

BetterArf · 22/02/2023 18:51

@SausageCat47

But there is a difference between giving children access to a variety of books and putting a book on the curriculum. The latter is a deliberate act. What is the school trying to teach the children through studying this book? That’s the question.

ourflagmeansdeath · 22/02/2023 18:51

bellac11 · 22/02/2023 18:47

You're accusing others of being uneducated and you really are asking that question?

I cant spell it all out for you, you sound incredibly naive. What do you think is happening in toilets or changing rooms or single sex spaces when they are 'socially transitioning'.

Sorry that was my fault. I do know what happens, I said before it wasn't alright. Really sorry. I misunderstood slightly, was more thinking about medically transitioning. I do know how awful it is, for example cases where rape cases aren't taken seriously because the man has now transitioned into a woman. It is horrible, I know this. I'm just trying to say this is certainly not all trans people, and they don't deserve this sort of stigma. Kids learning the basics of them in a friendly isn't a problem.

SausageCat47 · 22/02/2023 18:49

I have a 12-year-old DC and would have no issue with this book, we discuss everything with them in person and good to read things that offer differing experiences. Problems arise when parents don’t speak to their children about the world.

I’m not for censorship and these things open good discussions over the dinner table. Most books are fine, whatever you believe, if you spend time talking to your children and give them good critical thinking skills.

I have no problem with my children learning about any aspect of the LGBTQ+ experience, I talk my children about all kinds of relationships and have done since they were young using age appropriate language.

I’m not sure keeping children in the dark about the variety of life is helpful, when they will experience it anyway on social media or the playground. Difference is, if you don’t talk about some topics early on, they won’t feel comfortable coming to you when they encounter things they don’t fully understand and just read about it online or ask their friends anyway

thirteenfiftyeight · 22/02/2023 18:49

Boomboom22 · 22/02/2023 18:45

Therefore I don't really accept trans as a concept. We're all trans or non binary. You are you. I don't even really buy that women have an understanding of other women. You only know your own experience. Biology still exists and is relevant to sports, Prisons and toilets

My mum says she 'thinks like a man' I told her she thinks like herself and no one else. How could anyone possibly know what it's like to be anyone but their self?

PriOn1 · 22/02/2023 18:48

KrisAkabusi · 22/02/2023 18:33

We all survived reading The Famous Five. An ongoing theme of every one of the books was how George wanted to be a boy. I don't recall anyone's mind being warped by that!

Wanting to be a boy is one thing. Being told you actually can be one is quite another.

And actually I grew up with the idea that boys were better than girls, because that was what George believed and I bought into it, not least because Ann was a terrible female role model. It took me a long time to realize that was internalized misogyny and that women are amazing too.

bellac11 · 22/02/2023 18:47

ourflagmeansdeath · 22/02/2023 18:40

Yes, quite aware that's what social transitioning is. That's why I said if you are just socially trans you shouldn't be explicitly allowed into biological women only areas. I personally don't see how just changing pronouns and names does anything really, it doesn't affect you. I know a few trans males who still present themselves very feminine.

I am interested on how it reinforces sexist sterotypes about sex? Why do you believe that?

You're accusing others of being uneducated and you really are asking that question?

I cant spell it all out for you, you sound incredibly naive. What do you think is happening in toilets or changing rooms or single sex spaces when they are 'socially transitioning'.

OMG12 · 22/02/2023 18:47

MaggieMagpie357 · 22/02/2023 18:36

@PriOn1 wow. Not every person experiencing gender dysphoria is "jumping on a bandwagon" you know. You do realise that because of attitudes like this, some people are still afraid to be themselves? Or explore what their lives might be like if they didn't have to live in fear of being judged and persecuted?

I will never, ever understand how people can be so judgmental, when how someone else lives their life is of absolutely no concern to anyone else.

Oh god it’s you. If people admitted it’s a mental illness then appropriate treatment could be made available.

it’s the children who have been sterilised and mutilated I’m worried about who will never have chance to find out what could have been.

it’s the women scared to access what should be their safe spaces because some bloke thinks it’s his right to be in there

its the women put off sport because blokes think they can just decide to enter the women’s category

its the lesbians being told that they shouldn’t be bigoted and suck a man’s dick.

not someone with an untreated mental health illness thinking the world should compromise so they can live their best life.

Boomboom22 · 22/02/2023 18:45

Therefore I don't really accept trans as a concept. We're all trans or non binary. You are you. I don't even really buy that women have an understanding of other women. You only know your own experience. Biology still exists and is relevant to sports, Prisons and toilets

Chickenkeev · 22/02/2023 18:45

Just wondering for those people who are against the idea, how would you deal with the fact that there could trans kids in your child's school? It's an issue that can't be escaped then even though the children are young.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 22/02/2023 18:44

thirteenfiftyeight · 22/02/2023 18:42

Of course they have to wear a skirt! Cos females wear skirts don't they! And they like pink and pretty things

My thoughts exactly. The child in question is a lovely child. They live nearby so all the DC play out together and everyone gets on lovely. I think because conversations have been had at school and home

PriOn1 · 22/02/2023 18:44

MaggieMagpie357 · 22/02/2023 18:36

@PriOn1 wow. Not every person experiencing gender dysphoria is "jumping on a bandwagon" you know. You do realise that because of attitudes like this, some people are still afraid to be themselves? Or explore what their lives might be like if they didn't have to live in fear of being judged and persecuted?

I will never, ever understand how people can be so judgmental, when how someone else lives their life is of absolutely no concern to anyone else.

I didn’t say everyone experiencing gender dysphoria was jumping on a bandwagon. I said there’s a risk of social contagion. Don’t put words in my mouth please.

Many children experiencing gender dysphoria are gay, many are autistic, many have been abused, some of them sexually.

Seriously, go and read up about GIDS. This is not about someone being themselves. If a boy wants to wear a dress, that ought to be fine. It doesn’t make him a girl.

This is not a zero sum game. We have separate spaces for boys and girls. How a teenage boy lives his life is very significant to many teenage girls if living his life means he wants to get changed in their changing room and the school are foolish enough to believe that’s okay.

Boomboom22 · 22/02/2023 18:44

Personally I don't believe in gender it's just a set of stereotypes therefore gender dysphoria could, as the dsm says, not be a mental illness. However, like the remaining diagnosis of being so unhappy with your sexuality you hate yourself perhaps this should be reinstated. Men and women exist and have different bodies. That needn't lead to gender stereotypes as we are all individuals who have a personality and can dress and act how we want to.

bellac11 · 22/02/2023 18:43

PriOn1 · 22/02/2023 18:37

Pretty sure in time, it will return to being seen as the mental illness it is. Huge distress because you feel there is something wrong with your body (when there is nothing physically wrong with it) is surely, by definition, a mental illness.

I’m not sure how we got to a place where anyone thinks it’s normal. In all other circumstances, psychiatrists and other medical professionals dealing with psychiatric illness are taught that if someone believes they are something they are not, they should never be affirmed in that false belief, yet girls are being told they are boys, if that’s how they feel. It has no similarity whatsoever to falling in love with someone of the same sex. They have been falsely linked, but sexuality and feeling like you are the opposite sex are wholly different. However much hormone you pump in, girls are not boys and never can be.

Agree

And Im not sure how it became termed 'gender dysphoria' either when surely its body dysmorphia given that gender is not a real thing, its something you make up in your head. So you've made something up about yourself in your head (I must wear trousers and enjoy football) but I dont agree with that because I want to wear sparkles and lipstick so Im suffering dysphoria from that?

It literally makes no sense.

BetterArf · 22/02/2023 18:42

@MaggieMagpie357

”I will never, ever understand how people can be so judgmental, when how someone else lives their life is of absolutely no concern to anyone else.”

Except it is of serious concern to me, as a parent and educator, that gender ideology is being pushed on our children by schools in the curriculum. It DOES effect children, all children.

And it isn’t in any way progressive to me. It’s sinister. It puts ideas that are not true (that you can ‘change sex’) into children's heads and it grooms children into believing that because they don’t fit narrow gender stereotypes there is something wrong with them that needs changing or fixing. It’s majorly creepy.

It also teaches girls that if a boy says he is a girl you have to be kind and accept it, unquestioningly, including him being in your toilets and changing rooms and sports teams etc, or you will be vilified and branded a bigot.

Fuck all that.

NeedToChangeName · 22/02/2023 18:42

Nooyoiknooyoik · 22/02/2023 18:32

In the book, George wants to play the lead female role in the school play but the teacher says only girls can play it and gives the role to George’s female friend, (who, presumably, also really wants it).

But on the night of the play the friend gives the role to George cos she’s kind.

@Nooyoiknooyoik In other words, boy's preference takes priority over girl's wishes. Again. This isn't something to celebrate, IMHO

thirteenfiftyeight · 22/02/2023 18:42

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 22/02/2023 18:40

My 11 yo DS has a trans girl in his class. They come back from lockdown with a new name and wearing a skirt. Even though most of the girls wear trousers.

My DC know that people can't change sex. But I am very open to discussing trans people etc. Use it to open a conversation

Of course they have to wear a skirt! Cos females wear skirts don't they! And they like pink and pretty things

Swipe left for the next trending thread