Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of school residential trips...

242 replies

StrongerThongs · 22/02/2023 16:05

Full prepared to be told IABU because Covid, teacher stress, cost of living crisis etc BUT I have a DD in Y9 who has never been on a residential school trip, either in the UK or overseas. Her primary school were unable to offer a Y6 trip due to Covid.

Pre-covid the secondary school she is now at offered several opportunities a year but this has been reduced to one massively oversubscribed and prohibitively expensive ski trip every two years (the last one was to Colorado!) and a couple of subject-specific trips for KS4 (eg. languages trips, geography field trips).

Instead school have decided to run an activities week in the summer term for all pupils which includes a bunch of paid days out (eg theatre trips, museums, escape rooms) or the opportunity to stay in school for free activities (sports). This seems like a bit of a crap alternative and frankly a waste of a week's education!

I get that school trips take a lot of planning and I am NOT knocking teachers but I believe they offer really important opportunities for developing confidence, resilience, independence etc particularly for children who have missed so much due to Covid.

FWIW this is a successful oversubscribed state school. At my own bog-standard comprehensive I was able to go skiing in Italy, canoeing in France, fell-walking in the Lakes as well as field/language trips and I'm not from a wealthy background - trips were affordable/subsidised. Obviously times have changed.

Interested to know what other schools offer? And if IABU for thinking DD's school could do better?

OP posts:
StrongerThongs · 22/02/2023 17:14

Thanks for all the replies. Interesting to know that this is pretty much across the board and it's not just DD's school that have scaled back trips.

Totally understand the many reasons given for teachers/schools not wanting to organise them. Under these circumstances it seems inappropriate for some teachers to decide they're happy to organise a £3k ski trip to Colorado during Feb half term with only 30 places (offered to three year groups - so 630 pupils). Unless all these places are offered to Pupil Premium kids who would never otherwise get the opportunity. Somehow I doubt that's the case...

Agreed with PP who said the main issue for me is that Y6 residential (only one offered through my D's primary school) was cancelled in 2020. They have brought it back now - she was just unlucky. Will look into PGL!

OP posts:
OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 22/02/2023 17:12

Posted too soon. But they will survive. Our 11s were wingeing that they didn’t get the Belgium trip. I pointed out it was in lockdown. “Well why cant we go now?” Because you’ve got exams. “So, why can’t you arrange it in the summer holidays?”
Im the evc at my school, now there’s a thankless task. All the work for none of the pleasure.(not that 30 year 9s climbing in each other’s rooms at 3 am and parents ringing up to say their kid didn’t like the food/roommates/activities is too much fun)

UnctuousUnicorns · 22/02/2023 17:09

"How many emails from parents complaining about rooming"

A problem not encountered on my own school residential trips, as all the girls were in one large dormitory, the boys in another, around 45 boys and girls each iir. I think it was old barracks buildings. We just turned up, claimed a bed, and that was it for the week. But that was over forty years ago, very different back then.

Battlecat98 · 22/02/2023 17:05

Tbh I am quite glad, too much money and pressure to go. Not sure it's anything to do with teachers'stress though, just a horrible comment for no reason.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 22/02/2023 17:02

My school always ran a trip to France for yr 7 and Belgium for 9s. The price has almost doubled, a hotel we used to use has closed for school trips and no way can we source any supply teachers. We are doing activities week when the 10s are on work experience and the 11s have left just so we can staff it. It’s really sad.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2023 17:01

I honestly found running trips the most stressful thing as a teacher .

Chading money, chasing parents who forgot to sign the permission slip/ cross out the right bit of the reply form about photographs, forgot to date the form.

Risk assessments, booking coaches, setting cover, answering endless emails, staying late to ensure every child is picked up safely when one parent is ‘just running a bit late’ by an hour and a half.

Just not worth it.

Lightstoasteraction · 22/02/2023 16:57

Trips are more complex to plan and run than they used to be because more children have needs and they are increasingly complex. More students with physical, social and emotional issues, from all year groups.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 22/02/2023 16:54

I teach and would never run a residential. Too much extra work for no extra money and little / no appreciation from parents or students. These things have always been run on the goodwill of staff, and unfortunately there is not much of that in schools at the moment.

AnnPerkins · 22/02/2023 16:52

I voted YANBU because I do think it is a shame your DD has never experienced a school trip. But I completely understand why they aren't happening, as already explained in detail in this thread.

DS is in year 9 and his upper school only offers a ski trip for all year groups (£1600 for a week in France- oversubscribed apparently!) and subject specific trips in later years. Fortunately he did manage two UK trips in middle school and one in lower so at least he had the experience.

Perhaps get your DD to join an out of school group such as guides, cadets or a local rugby team. DS was briefly in the army cadets and had a great weekend away with them.

WombatChocolate · 22/02/2023 16:51

How many emails from parents complaining about rooming, or asking for unrealistic special treatments for their child, do you think organisers of trips abroad get?

How many extra emails do you think a teacher organising such a trip has to send and phone calls do they need to send - to management if the school, to accounts, to groups of parents, to individual parents, to travel companies, to coach companies, to activity providers, to restaurants etc etc. It is honestly hundreds….on top of the very full on job of teaching.

How pressured and tight do you think the budgeting is? The push to get the cost right down for parents, whilst ensuring the cost if fully covered and the school doesn’t face a bill for last minute drop-outs or unforeseen costs that arise, when it can’t even afford enough exercise books. So staff go on those trips without sufficient contingency and when a student is ill and needs taking to the doctors in a taxi, the teacher knows the funding will go into the red and they will be in trouble when they return to school……having already given up their own half term to do the trip, and the many many hours of organisation.

How much stress do you think can exist on a trip - where inevitably someone or several are illand you can’t take any chances, so a key member if staff is often having to take them to see a Doctor or to hospital? Where a student loses their passport or their purse? Where poor behaviour creates issues of safeguarding? And all of these can be much worse if the teacher has organised the trip fully themselves without a tour company, in order to keep costs down.

Honestly, until schools are far better resourced and goodwill rebuilt for teachers, why would any teacher feel in a position to put themselves through this, even when they know kids enjoy these trips and some get a lot from them.

Book your kids onto a PGL holiday or take them on the trips yourselves as parents. Sorry, but teachers are having to back-off from this stuff.

Bleese · 22/02/2023 16:48

I'm surprised at all this talk of Y6 residential as though that's the only one primary children go on. I've never taught in a school that doesn't offer a residential annually from Y3, and some even did overnights in infants (why?!?!). It's easier for primary teachers to do as it's in school time not the holidays. I think it's the old primary you should be more frustrated with!

Katsucurrysauce · 22/02/2023 16:48

Our school start residentials in year 2.

Think my DC missed out on one residential so we were quite lucky. They have a big trip every year too so our school are quite proactive really.

theveg · 22/02/2023 16:47

I took a group of y10 students to Spain once.

When we got back to school after 5 days of being in loco parentis, not a single parent said thank you.

One day we got a phone call from school one day saying a parent had been in touch and their son had hurt his knee and they were angry as we hadn't offered him any help. We didn't know as he hadn't told us. Just text his parents who had rang school to complain.

CatOnTheChair · 22/02/2023 16:44

I've got a Y9.
Nothing at primary due to Covid. There has been one optional Geography trip in Y8 - they left on Saturday morning, went to Edinburgh (a couple of hours drive) zoo and a geology museum, came back Sunday night, and went into school for the last 2 days of term. Basically, the Staff gave up their weekend to make it happen.

My current Y7 got his Y6 residential.

I think it's probably something that, as parents, we need to facilitate in the school holidays rather than rely on school.

ApathyMartha · 22/02/2023 16:44

Mobile phones never used to be on school trips. Now they are. I wouldn’t want my unguarded moments filmed as a teacher, nor would I want pupils phoning parents because something had happened that could be sorted out by staff.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2023 16:44

+It will increasingly be private schools and schools in affluent areas that offer them, because those parents will be prepared to pay what it costs*

l taught in an affluent area. There were no residential trips in school terms. Affluent parents want their kids to get hood GCSE’s. Taking students away for a trip was not allowed as it removed them from essential lessons.

No parents complained. All students managed to function and get to university without any trips.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2023 16:41

Can’t believe the people moaning about trips on here.

Schools are scarcely functioning, they have no staff, no support staff and can’t get supply. They are trying, despite this to get kids through GCSE. And parents whining that their little darlings can’t go on trips!

What would you rather have? A trip or a functioning school, because that’s what they are down to.

WombatChocolate · 22/02/2023 16:40

The reason any remaining trips are so expensive is because most schools now use travel companies and these need to make a profit. Why? Firstly because teachers are now so stretched covering the work of colleagues who are leaving, that they haven’t got the time to put into the hundreds of hours that arranging such a trip takes. Goodwill is increasingly lost as people are stretched, so people who would have given up their holiday to run them, just are less likely to do it now. And lots of schools won’t allow residential without a company organising them because the risk assessments and dangers of being sued make it impossible.

Remember the price you pay isn’t the price of an EasyJet flight for one. You have to cover your child’s share of covering the staff places on flights, accommodation, activities. You have to cover their share of possibly infilled places which push the price up. You have to cover their share of the travel operators fee/profit that is built in. You have to cover their share of the contingency fund it’s vital to have so teachers can deal with an emergency if it happens.

These trips look extortionate….and yes they are expensive. BUT a key reason why they aren’t running is people saying this and therefore a desire to not offer things most can afford, or because people just aren’t realistic about the cost of providing a trip with the equipment and staffing required.

It will increasingly be private schools and schools in affluent areas that offer them, because those parents will be prepared to pay what it costs. Remmeber, when you pay for a trip,your child gets to have that experience of skiing or whatever it is, without you having to pay the cost of taking the whole family. Even though it’s very expensive to send the child, it’s far cheaper than the family going….which is why for so many kids, their only experience ever if skiing is on a sschool ski trip.

tortoise2022 · 22/02/2023 16:40

As a teacher who has run many trips abroad and in the UK over the years, I'll be completely honest and say that post pandemic, I haven't organised any trips as I simply don't feel it is actually appreciated how much time, effort and responsibility teaching actually takes, never mind extras like trips.

I work bloody hard and cannot do my day-to-day job without if affecting my family life so I can't take on the extra work of a residential trip. My school expects us to go during 'holiday' time so I'm not going to put my own child in childcare in their holidays while I'm off with a bunch of teenagers who will often walk through my classroom door without even paying me the courtesy of greeting me.

Until the post-pandemic behaviour of a lot of my students improves, it's not worth the risk to take them anywhere. If they have difficulty following basic instructions in the classroom, there's no way I'd risk taking them abroad. Sad for those kids who are polite and do behave but that's just the way I feel.

EarthlyNightshade · 22/02/2023 16:39

Oblomov23 · 22/02/2023 16:25

I feel similar. Makes me sad. Ds2 list out on yr 6 camp due to covid. They did have a PGL in year 8 so that was good. I can't believe the prices of ski trip. Some got offered a French trip (ds2 doesn't because he does Spanish) and it was so expensive, and poor, I felt like offering to organise a cheaper one myself with a £39.99 EasyJet/Ryan air flight! Wink

Why not do this, families would be really grateful.

Theraffarian · 22/02/2023 16:38

After seeing the correspondence to a teacher trying to prepare a day trip for her secondary school students , I wonder how any of them have the heart to plan any trips anymore . It duly reminded her that if the trip went over budget ( ie cost the school anything and was not student/parent funded ) it would be considered gross misconduct.
So taking into account the trip has to be costed and travel booked etc to confirm the date they needed prior to obtaining payment , she is then at the mercy of parents to actually pay the cost of the trip .

WombatChocolate · 22/02/2023 16:31

Sorry, it it’s a reflection of the constant narrowing of the curriculum due to resources.

Less popular subjects get dropped at GCSE level as they can’t attract the high numbers needed to justify a teacher, more students are offered fewer GCSEs, less art, music, drama and creative subjects earlier on as they often need to be taught to smaller classes and use expensive equipment, less swimming, less practical experiments in science due to cost….it’s heading towards a very narrow curriculum taught through PowerPoints.

Support the teacher strikes for more funding for schools. This is what it’s about. Remember staff are leaving in droves…..that means fewer permanent staff and more supply. Supply aren’t going to run trips and the remaining teachers are more stretched than ever covering more lessons. Anything beyond the most basic teaching gets dropped. Education is becoming more and more utilitarian.

Write to your MP about it. It will continue to get narrower.

WindscreenWipe · 22/02/2023 16:29

I used to a be teacher. You know what trips my school offered, none. Not one. Why? Because we were in an area where it wasn’t affordable and where the budget for “poor kids” was spent on getting them shoes and pens, not on trips. Because about 50% of the students couldn’t be trusted not to be violent or take drugs or carry knives so taking them abroad would be a terrifying prospect considering that foreign law enforcement is a lot less friendly than in the UK. Because most students didn’t have passports, or were young carers who were needed at home, or looked after younger siblings every day, or worked part-time after school/weekends to help support the family. I appreciate that most schools do have trips but having multiple trips abroad is not “bog-standard” at all. We didn’t offer geography because we had no geography teachers, we didn’t offer any languages except Spanish and we didn’t have any actual Spanish teachers - we had a PE teacher and Spanish-speaking TA.

Trips have been reduced because:

  • Families can’t afford as many in a cost of living crisis
  • Prices have gone up
  • They aren’t efficient time-wise for education and there’s huge pressure on schools getting students the grades they want
  • Schools can’t use term-time for non-academic trips
  • Staff are working in their “holidays”, they can’t do trips in that time.
  • Parents complain about everything - it’s a ballache (anyone remember the thread on here about the parent who complained her DD couldn’t take nuts on a trip to France because another pupil was allergic and might die).
  • Student behaviour is at an all-time low and they can’t be trusted to follow instructions, not break the law, not put themselves or others in danger and not cause trouble.
  • Since Covid, people don’t trust they’ll necessarily happen.

Regardless, a ski trip and subject specific trips is all that was offered at my Outstanding Ofsted rated schools when I was a pupil (the two that I went to) so I think you sound a bit odd for thinking that’s insufficient.

Oblomov23 · 22/02/2023 16:25

I feel similar. Makes me sad. Ds2 list out on yr 6 camp due to covid. They did have a PGL in year 8 so that was good. I can't believe the prices of ski trip. Some got offered a French trip (ds2 doesn't because he does Spanish) and it was so expensive, and poor, I felt like offering to organise a cheaper one myself with a £39.99 EasyJet/Ryan air flight! Wink

Springintoabetterlife · 22/02/2023 16:25

I forgot the admin staff. When I wanted to run a trip I would contact the admin staff who dealt with trips who would get all the quotes and book everything. All I needed to do was write the risk assessment, letter, chase payment and set over work so still a fair bit of work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread