Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of school residential trips...

242 replies

StrongerThongs · 22/02/2023 16:05

Full prepared to be told IABU because Covid, teacher stress, cost of living crisis etc BUT I have a DD in Y9 who has never been on a residential school trip, either in the UK or overseas. Her primary school were unable to offer a Y6 trip due to Covid.

Pre-covid the secondary school she is now at offered several opportunities a year but this has been reduced to one massively oversubscribed and prohibitively expensive ski trip every two years (the last one was to Colorado!) and a couple of subject-specific trips for KS4 (eg. languages trips, geography field trips).

Instead school have decided to run an activities week in the summer term for all pupils which includes a bunch of paid days out (eg theatre trips, museums, escape rooms) or the opportunity to stay in school for free activities (sports). This seems like a bit of a crap alternative and frankly a waste of a week's education!

I get that school trips take a lot of planning and I am NOT knocking teachers but I believe they offer really important opportunities for developing confidence, resilience, independence etc particularly for children who have missed so much due to Covid.

FWIW this is a successful oversubscribed state school. At my own bog-standard comprehensive I was able to go skiing in Italy, canoeing in France, fell-walking in the Lakes as well as field/language trips and I'm not from a wealthy background - trips were affordable/subsidised. Obviously times have changed.

Interested to know what other schools offer? And if IABU for thinking DD's school could do better?

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 22/02/2023 18:10

I’ve just come back from a 3 day trip with girl guides. We’ve had parents complain re cost. Parents complain re paperwork (if they’d only seen the amount of risk assessment etc) A Sunday evening parents meeting. So many hours planning, booking, spent answering parents questions. The stress of keeping children safe. There was that case of teachers being prosecuted in France recently when a water activity at an centre went wrong - charges dismissed but hung over them for years. All unpaid I’m am a volunteer. I needed to use a days annual leave to recover! We did have a fabulous time and some parents thanked us.
There’s an international guides trip next year and take up is low - cost and fact parents/children are more wary going away now post Covid I think. I certainly wouldn’t be rushing to offer a trip as a teacher.
Pgl does offers - mine went on a 2 night taster booked last minute.

Nimbostratus100 · 22/02/2023 18:06

UWhatNow · 22/02/2023 16:20

School trips are often the best part of secondary life. They leave lifelong memories. It’s such a shame and if parents cover costs (for say skiing) I don’t see why they don’t run them. Maybe teachers have had enough and don’t want to volunteer any more? I agree with you though op. It’s a sad for children to miss out on those experiences, especially disadvantaged kids whose parents can’t afford holidays or trips away.

you dont see why teachers dont volunteer to take on the endless hours of planning and paperwork for the dubious pleasure of giving up their holiday and weekend time to be in charge of a bunch of teens who could get themselves hurt, killed or in serious trouble with the local police, and then have their parents make a complaint against them?

Decorhate · 22/02/2023 18:06

My school is running loads this year, (too many imo), there was a deliberate effort to make up for the Covid years & the fact that many students such as OP’s dc had never been on a residential.

They do take a massive amount of organising & as most are non curriculum, are reliant on parents ability to pay.

Because of the cost of supply teachers many schools now restrict these to weekends or school holidays. But as others have said, then teachers have to give up their own time to go.

I would guess many schools are also wary because of the huge problems getting refunds for trips that were cancelled during the first lockdown (PGL were particularly unhelpful). Covid is still very much going round though obviously restrictions have been lifted.

Fairislefandango · 22/02/2023 18:05

I don’t see why they don’t run them.

Really?! They take a massive amount of organisation and teachers don't have spare time to do this. Plus schools are finding it almost impossible to get enough supply staff to cover the lessons of teachers who are absent due to sickness or training. Voluntarily creating more need for cover is not something schools will do lightly.

My school still runs exchange trips in all three of the languages we teach. That's a whole other level of paperwork and organisation, what with all the communication with the foreign school, pairing students with suitable partners, running DBS checks on parents etc. I'll probably be in charge of one of the exchanges next year and I'm absolutely dreading it tbh. The trip itself is great, but there is do much potential for things to go wrong.

donttellmehesalive · 22/02/2023 18:01

I think morale is also very low at the moment, so many teachers will be reluctant to go above and beyond for parents and children who don't appreciate it (in fact, honestly, parents are the worst part of my job and I am not currently inclined to do any extras)

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 22/02/2023 17:55

Dd is year 10.
There was a ski trip this half term. Massively oversubscribed, about £1000.
Vastly overpriced netball/football trip to Dubai. Doubt they will get the numbers. Originally this was a trip to Sri Lanka.
Language trips. Spanish to Barcelona.
French to Normandy for a week £350 ish?

BeanCounterBabe · 22/02/2023 17:55

The activities week you are complaining about seems completely normal and a great opportunity for kids to have some fun experiences with school friends.

it is disappointing that more trips are being run but I can understand why. So many risk assessments and safe guarding issues to consider. Parents demand more. My DC are at two different schools. One had her first trips in year 10 to Germany and also and overnight to London as a reward for volunteering at school (although we paid). She is going on a Geography field trip to Iceland in Year 11. She has ASD and the school has bent over backwards to accommodate her including sending an additional TA. I am beyond grateful and made that very clear to the staff.

My other DD is in year 8. She just about managed her year 5 residential, in year 6. But they all got sent home early when someone's sibling at home got CoVID. She is doing her year 8 activity week abroad and going away in Autumn term in year 9 as well. I am really grateful to the school for this. Her year group is very challenging so I admire any teacher brave enough to take them anywhere.

Ilovetocrochet · 22/02/2023 17:50

Springintoabetterlife · 22/02/2023 16:23

Schools haven’t got the money to employ supply teachers to cover the lessons of those on trips. Teachers are over worked and are running out of good will to volunteer at their job.

At my school, staff going on a residential trip during term time had to organise their own cover for lessons missed by begging for favours from other teachers! Nightmare situation which pretty much stopped term time trips from being organised.

I went on one to Paris which was mainly in the holidays but the final days travelling meant the coach got back to the school at 7am after driving through the night. I had to teach that day as normal, after being awake most of the night! That was the last time I volunteered to go on a residential trip!

Spendonsend · 22/02/2023 17:46

My sons school is similar in that they have a week towards the end of the summer term, when all teachers and all students are off timetable. There is a range of activities from trips abroad, to unusual crafts in the classroom that teachers run. Parents pay so the less you can afford, the less interesting your week is! But i assume payment can be compulsory as there are free alternatives.

I think staffing trips must be very hard. I would not want to be responsible for a load of teens away from home.

Sherrystrull · 22/02/2023 17:42

JimBobbin · 22/02/2023 17:38

I think teachers who give up days of their own holidays to run these things are a vanishing breed. It's a huge amount to give over and above a demanding day job, and morale is just too low these days.

I emailed the teacher who ran the one trip my Dd's been on to say thank you, and she replied saying I'd made her day. A thank you should be standard from everyone, it should not have made her day. (Maybe she was just being polite? 🤷‍♀️)

It's very true. I took 60 children away last year and one parent said thank you. It was really appreciated.

JimBobbin · 22/02/2023 17:38

I think teachers who give up days of their own holidays to run these things are a vanishing breed. It's a huge amount to give over and above a demanding day job, and morale is just too low these days.

I emailed the teacher who ran the one trip my Dd's been on to say thank you, and she replied saying I'd made her day. A thank you should be standard from everyone, it should not have made her day. (Maybe she was just being polite? 🤷‍♀️)

TwilightSilhouette · 22/02/2023 17:35

I am a TA in a primary school (I know the OP post is about secondary school but the points, I believe, are still valid).
I work part time (mornings only) but there is no extra pay for a residential - I am still only paid for mornings, despite working pretty much 24hrs a day on a residential.
I am woken most nights by kids upset/homesick/friend issues/unwell/wanting attention/wanting comfort.
It is mentally and physically exhausting.
DH has to use his precious annual leave to cover my absence - within our family my role is looking after the kids after school and ferrying them to their activities. This means sacrificing one week of time together as a family on annual leave.
Parents always moan - it’s either too costly or we seen doing enough.
Parents always complain about something- they have unrealistic expectations of what we can do as teachers regarding friendships/homesickness/getting kids to eat or sleep or anything you can think of really.

Bobbybobbins · 22/02/2023 17:34

I am a secondary school teacher and I have organised week long camps in the past, taken large groups on DofE expeditions etc.

My school has also cut back on visits (though still run DofE which is brilliant) for all the reasons listed above including staffing and parental income.

Just to add from my personal experience, having run 5 residential visits: 2 parents ever said thank you; average 4 hours sleep a night; often 1 hospital visit per week long camp adding a lot of extra stress; dealing with typical teen behaviour all week.

The kids always got lots out of the visits but I couldn't countenance it now.

gogohmm · 22/02/2023 17:30

My children didn't go on any school organised trips, too expensive, but they toured with their choir and their orchestra (not the same year!) this year dd is touring to the far east, fully funded by corporate sponsors

Hintofreality · 22/02/2023 17:26

Our school has just done a 3 night / 4 day trip to Barcelona over half term, cost £895.

donttellmehesalive · 22/02/2023 17:26

The ski trip will take place because it will not be linked to the curriculum - so we are allowed to insist on payment.

PennyRa · 22/02/2023 17:25

Your childs education is your responsibility. You can choose to take them to the theatre, museums, escape room ect whenever you like.

If you had the means to send them on a school ski trip you have the means to send them yourself.

UnctuousUnicorns · 22/02/2023 17:25

I'm also reminded that at on the last day of my school residential trips, we were allowed to wander around the town, in groups of around five or six, for a couple of hours, with spending money, with strict orders to be back at the coach for a certain time. Of course, no mobile phones then, just watches, and no teachers supervising. We were ten and eleven. That would be unthinkable now, but it did us good, more opportunity to learn some independence.

donttellmehesalive · 22/02/2023 17:25

I'm a teacher in a school that has reduced the number of residential trips.

The main reason is that the number of parents who are unable or unwilling to pay is increasing significantly. We have traditionally covered the non-payers but can't afford to do that now - there are too many of them, including many who have regular family holidays abroad.

In addition, but secondary to that by a long way, is the fact that it is so utterly thankless. Parents now query and complain about every possible aspect of any trip whilst implying that you are getting a free holiday and should consider it a delightful treat.

StrongerThongs · 22/02/2023 17:24

MrsHamlet · 22/02/2023 17:18

We fund PP places on curriculum trips. We wouldn't be able to fund a ski trip.
It's interesting that you've gone from complaining about not enough trips to now complaining about the ski trip.

I wasn't complaining, I was simply pondering why, given the many very valid reasons PPs have given about why trips are not offered, a school should decide it's a good plan to offer just one very exclusive trip (which I will be entering the ballot for when the time comes and keeping everything crossed!).

OP posts:
TwilightSilhouette · 22/02/2023 17:24

BibbleandSqwauk · 22/02/2023 16:12

take a look at the many threads on here complaining about the cost of such trips, how the school is wrong for offering them as not everyone can afford to go, how the teachers are getting a "jolly" for free and should pay for themselves to go - that's just to start with as to why many schools just won't bother. Add in the cost of cover and work required to set the cover work, much much more rigorous paperwork and safeguarding requirments now and the last minute "requests" AKA demands from parents about diet / rooming etc and organising your own childcare whilst away, usually for literally NO thanks upon return (but usually a few complaints) and you might start to see why. I actually do still run them - 3/4 nights in Europe usually but they are a MASSIVE hassle.

This in bucket loads.

Aleaiactaest · 22/02/2023 17:22

My niece and nephew are at really expensive well known private schools and they have both done several trips in the last 2 years (loads on this year in all holidays), Florida, Canada skiing, French Exchange, History Trip coming up to the US, massive Geography trip, 2 music trips, 1 sports trip, Duke of Edinburgh, mini Duke of Edinburg etc…

It is the one big thing my state school DC are jealous about. And yeah, they both had amazing times and memories. Our state schools used to do loads of trips too, slightly less now.

Grumpybutfunny · 22/02/2023 17:18

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/02/2023 16:44

+It will increasingly be private schools and schools in affluent areas that offer them, because those parents will be prepared to pay what it costs*

l taught in an affluent area. There were no residential trips in school terms. Affluent parents want their kids to get hood GCSE’s. Taking students away for a trip was not allowed as it removed them from essential lessons.

No parents complained. All students managed to function and get to university without any trips.

Interestingly the secondary we are looking at has moved them to Easter holidays and October half term. <5% free school meals in our primary so they just ask for the money honestly it would be easier to set up a direct debit. Wish they would just ask for the money they need rather than cutting things.

ilovesooty · 22/02/2023 17:18

VickyEadieofThigh · 22/02/2023 16:18

I'm retired now but wouldn't do residential trips now if I got a gold clock for doing them. I cite all the reasons raised already.

If you want your child to go on residentials - do as the parent above is doing and pay for PGL.

Absolutely.

Why would teachers necessarily be prepared to be away from home and run trips in their own time in the current climate?

MrsHamlet · 22/02/2023 17:18

We fund PP places on curriculum trips. We wouldn't be able to fund a ski trip.
It's interesting that you've gone from complaining about not enough trips to now complaining about the ski trip.

Swipe left for the next trending thread