Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of school residential trips...

242 replies

StrongerThongs · 22/02/2023 16:05

Full prepared to be told IABU because Covid, teacher stress, cost of living crisis etc BUT I have a DD in Y9 who has never been on a residential school trip, either in the UK or overseas. Her primary school were unable to offer a Y6 trip due to Covid.

Pre-covid the secondary school she is now at offered several opportunities a year but this has been reduced to one massively oversubscribed and prohibitively expensive ski trip every two years (the last one was to Colorado!) and a couple of subject-specific trips for KS4 (eg. languages trips, geography field trips).

Instead school have decided to run an activities week in the summer term for all pupils which includes a bunch of paid days out (eg theatre trips, museums, escape rooms) or the opportunity to stay in school for free activities (sports). This seems like a bit of a crap alternative and frankly a waste of a week's education!

I get that school trips take a lot of planning and I am NOT knocking teachers but I believe they offer really important opportunities for developing confidence, resilience, independence etc particularly for children who have missed so much due to Covid.

FWIW this is a successful oversubscribed state school. At my own bog-standard comprehensive I was able to go skiing in Italy, canoeing in France, fell-walking in the Lakes as well as field/language trips and I'm not from a wealthy background - trips were affordable/subsidised. Obviously times have changed.

Interested to know what other schools offer? And if IABU for thinking DD's school could do better?

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 23/02/2023 09:30

The National Curriculum objective that underpins most residential trips for primary is a KS2 PE one relating to ‘outdoor and adventurous activities’.

There is no curriculum requirement for these to be residential, but the facilities at most centres used by primary schools are more set up to meet this goal.

KS3 PE has pretty much exactly the same statement, which means that if their KS3 PE curriculum has always been set up to cover this objective, there is no curriculum gap from primary to fill.

Given the curriculum gaps that DO exist across the whole range of other subjects, and the fact that the requirements of the ‘end point’ of GCSEs / A-levels haven’t changed, it is very hard to argue that running ‘extra residential trips, taking children out of the teaching of other subjects but not filling any curriculum gaps, is in any way good use of time or staff.

EarthlyNightshade · 23/02/2023 09:29

Retreat · 22/02/2023 22:32

We are paying for the summer residential trip. The school dd attends is a state school.

Could your DD go to the school you teach at?
Then she would get to go on school trips.

Sherrystrull · 23/02/2023 09:15

I instantly lose compassion when a poster takes against a teacher who puts limits on the free time they give and says 'I hope you're not a teacher'.

NoDairyNoProblem · 23/02/2023 09:10

I came here to somewhat support @StrongerThongs, however after reading your follow up posts I feel your attitude is downright rude!

NorthStarRising · 23/02/2023 09:04

StaunchMomma You misread my post and my intentions.
I am a primary teacher. I know exactly what it feels like to step off a particular treadmill and realise that getting back on is optional.
That considering all the other expectations and burdens teachers and schools are carrying, choosing not to restart residentials in a hostile climate reduces the load.

noblegiraffe · 23/02/2023 08:48

Yes, deliberately goady it seems.

echt · 23/02/2023 08:14

StrongerThongs · 23/02/2023 07:45

Do you feel this about all aspects of a child's education? That it's not secondary school's job to 'mop up' things that were missed in primary school? Or is it just when it comes to enrichment that they're off the hook? I do hope it's not the former. And if it is, I do hope you're not a secondary school teacher.

Don't be ridiculous.

Of course the poster is referring to residentials, the subject of this thread. You are being extremely mischievous in inferring anything different.

StrongerThongs · 23/02/2023 07:45

StaunchMomma · 23/02/2023 00:02

It's not really secondary's job to mop up things missed in primary, IMO.

3- 5 days away for a whole year group puts a hell of a lot of stress on multiple departments in terms of curriculum catch up. Hence they usually occur in primary, where they have one teacher, usually in year 6 once SATS are over.

Do you feel this about all aspects of a child's education? That it's not secondary school's job to 'mop up' things that were missed in primary school? Or is it just when it comes to enrichment that they're off the hook? I do hope it's not the former. And if it is, I do hope you're not a secondary school teacher.

OP posts:
StaunchMomma · 23/02/2023 00:07

NorthStarRising · 22/02/2023 23:14

Covid gave teachers a break from the whole, insane chaotic mess and the paranoia of school residentials. No being on alert 24/7, no wrangling of children, no relentless, ridiculous parental demands and paperwork.
No Sword of Damocles waiting to fall.
Then the world started back up again, children’s behaviour has deteriorated, schools can’t afford trips…and teachers realised that not having residentials was a fantastic choice.
So many positives for a teacher. So few negatives, if any.

You do realise schools were open for key worker kids the whole way through lockdown, right? Plus teachers had to prep work for kids at home. It was hardly a fun time of skiving off at home for the vast majority of teachers!

It's also not the case that schools have decided to not do residentials since. What the OP is saying is that her child missed theirs due to lockdown and now wants the secondary to run one. Primaries are back to running residentials.

StaunchMomma · 23/02/2023 00:02

It's not really secondary's job to mop up things missed in primary, IMO.

3- 5 days away for a whole year group puts a hell of a lot of stress on multiple departments in terms of curriculum catch up. Hence they usually occur in primary, where they have one teacher, usually in year 6 once SATS are over.

BeaverLeader · 22/02/2023 23:22

Appuskidu · 22/02/2023 23:15

any children who want to go will be paid for

Wow-could the PTA cover every single child?

Yes. I do the fundraising. There is a healthy account and we are fortunate to have a lot of parents who can match raised funds with work place charity allowances.

So the vast majority of the parents can, and will afford it, and those who struggle will be subsidised/paid for. Most don't take the piss financially.

But it's two days in mid Wales, not skiing in the Alps.

Appuskidu · 22/02/2023 23:15

any children who want to go will be paid for

Wow-could the PTA cover every single child?

NorthStarRising · 22/02/2023 23:14

Covid gave teachers a break from the whole, insane chaotic mess and the paranoia of school residentials. No being on alert 24/7, no wrangling of children, no relentless, ridiculous parental demands and paperwork.
No Sword of Damocles waiting to fall.
Then the world started back up again, children’s behaviour has deteriorated, schools can’t afford trips…and teachers realised that not having residentials was a fantastic choice.
So many positives for a teacher. So few negatives, if any.

BeaverLeader · 22/02/2023 23:13

My school sent out a letter about a primary school residential happening in eight/nine months. Heavily subsidised by the PTA fund and with the caveat that any children who want to go will be paid for.

The first bit of feedback we got was ;

"my mum's angry about it. She said you didn't ask her first"
"Oh dear, righto"
"Yeah, she said you should have told the parents about it first"
"That's what the letter was for..."
"No, you should have phoned or something first to ask"

Because we're so swimming with free time that phoning 60 childrens adults to pre-ask if they might want a letter about a residential which will be offered to all of that year group regardless and is the better part of a year away is a reasonable request...

DanglingMod · 22/02/2023 23:02

I would never organise and almost definitely never run a residential trip, especially abroad. It's not just significant hours (like hundreds) of unpaid admin time and stress, it's also massively stressful whilst on the trip.

I have organised and gone on numerous day trips and they are enough work, stress and responsibility. You can never relax and enjoy even one moment. Go to the theatre and barely notice the play because you are worrying about the coach turning back up, or Gretel with the nut allergy inhaling something and not being able to find her epipen on time. And parents are always late collecting. Every. Single. Time there will be one child an hour late being collected. And no one ever says thank you. The kids, very occasionally. The parents, never.

So, I will continue to organise or go on day trips, theatre, author talks, museum trips, etc. I can do because my own dc is adult now and I don't think it's fair to ask colleagues with small dc to do it. But I always say never again because it is just so much (unpaid) work and hassle beforehand. And during. And guilt of other staff covering your lessons because there's no money for supply. And then I remember how some kids have never been to London, or the theatre, and I want to give them those experiences and I get sucked in for just one more.

Hercisback · 22/02/2023 22:40

Who is "we" and whose trip are you paying for? Your DDs school doesn't do trips...

Retreat · 22/02/2023 22:32

We are paying for the summer residential trip. The school dd attends is a state school.

LolaSmiles · 22/02/2023 22:25

As a teacher who has run many trips abroad and in the UK over the years, I'll be completely honest and say that post pandemic, I haven't organised any trips as I simply don't feel it is actually appreciated how much time, effort and responsibility teaching actually takes, never mind extras like trips
Same here.
I've always volunteered for extracurricular, weekend trips, UK and overseas residentials, but I just want time with my family now.
I'm over prioritising other people's children over my own.

TheNefariousOrange · 22/02/2023 22:24

I ran a residential trip every year pre-covid. This year I also will but I regret it deeply and it will be my last. The behaviour of both parents and children post-covid is getting worse. There's no way I'm taking kids abroad that can't behave in a classroom, and there's no way I'm dealing with all the admin just to be spoken to like crap from parents. I'd much rather spend my unpaid time with my own DD.

Appuskidu · 22/02/2023 22:23

Retreat · 22/02/2023 20:17

I agree op. I’m sick of the excuses. My Dd is in Y9 and no school trips. That was the best thing about school and created such great memories for me. The schools need to do better. I’m hoping they do something for next year. We have just applied for a summer intensive outside of school just so she does something.

…and you are paying for your DD to
go to this school?

Sherrystrull · 22/02/2023 22:21

Retreat · 22/02/2023 21:56

I suppose I just enjoy teaching and seeing young people grow and develop. I also enjoy seeing them outside the school environment. It’s rewarding in my opinion.

Hmmmm.

Goady point scoring.

S72 · 22/02/2023 22:07

School residential are so expensive. I haven't been able to send my son on one.

Thankfully, Scouts is reasonable. Last year was a 7 night Jamboree for £250.

This year a 7 night summer camp including adventure activities, a day trip and all food for less than £300.

Our scout group fundraised some of the above, so the actual cost per participant is less.

Plus much cheaper weekend camps and activity days throughout the year.

noblegiraffe · 22/02/2023 22:06

Advanced search throws up questions.

yeetingbird · 22/02/2023 22:01

Retreat · 22/02/2023 20:55

I’m a teacher and happily run school trips as I know how enjoyable they are and how important for creating memories. My dd school has done nothing. Hence why I can say it’s laziness. No one can be bothered anymore. Such a shame.

And if you actually read many of the responses on this thread you would learn that it's not simply laziness.

eatdrinkandbemerry · 22/02/2023 21:56

Schools can't win 🤷‍♀️
My child's school do a residential every year and parents moan about cost very savagely! They don't offer one and the parents moan their children are missing out!