Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of school residential trips...

242 replies

StrongerThongs · 22/02/2023 16:05

Full prepared to be told IABU because Covid, teacher stress, cost of living crisis etc BUT I have a DD in Y9 who has never been on a residential school trip, either in the UK or overseas. Her primary school were unable to offer a Y6 trip due to Covid.

Pre-covid the secondary school she is now at offered several opportunities a year but this has been reduced to one massively oversubscribed and prohibitively expensive ski trip every two years (the last one was to Colorado!) and a couple of subject-specific trips for KS4 (eg. languages trips, geography field trips).

Instead school have decided to run an activities week in the summer term for all pupils which includes a bunch of paid days out (eg theatre trips, museums, escape rooms) or the opportunity to stay in school for free activities (sports). This seems like a bit of a crap alternative and frankly a waste of a week's education!

I get that school trips take a lot of planning and I am NOT knocking teachers but I believe they offer really important opportunities for developing confidence, resilience, independence etc particularly for children who have missed so much due to Covid.

FWIW this is a successful oversubscribed state school. At my own bog-standard comprehensive I was able to go skiing in Italy, canoeing in France, fell-walking in the Lakes as well as field/language trips and I'm not from a wealthy background - trips were affordable/subsidised. Obviously times have changed.

Interested to know what other schools offer? And if IABU for thinking DD's school could do better?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wishawisha · 25/02/2023 14:58

I think the activity week sounds fantastic.

Realising my experience of high school (and primary actually, come to think about it) must have been unusual then. We didn’t do residentials. We didn’t even have a single day trip other than the free museum which was less than a mile away from the school which we went to once.

ladyofshertonabbas · 25/02/2023 14:49

we had Activities Week! It was so good, some of the best times of my young life (or life- sad). teachers must be stressed and scared of litigation if anything goes wrong.

WombatChocolate · 25/02/2023 14:46

Kenyan school. Okay.

In the UK, MUN is typically attended by private school students.

Sherrystrull · 25/02/2023 14:43

@Gwen82

You do realise that all trips are different and therefore your experience wouldn't automatically fit other children / trips / ages?

I'm not sure what point you're trying to make.

marcopront · 25/02/2023 14:39

@WombatChocolate

*MUN conference trip = Model United Nations.

Likely to be private school. Some trios will bill for individual expenses.*

Why does going to MUN mean it is a private school?
We are a few paying school but about 40% of our students are on scholarships including some of those I took. This was in Kenya which might make a difference.

marcopront · 25/02/2023 14:36

@Gwen82

Did you miss the three currencies part?

We felt it was easier to pay as a group rather than have each student change money individually and then all pay separately for each meal. They will not need Kenyan shillings again and so having lots of small change would be a problem.

We are a residential school most of their parents are in a different country which makes money more of an issue.

WombatChocolate · 25/02/2023 14:14

MUN conference trip = Model United Nations.

Likely to be private school. Some trios will bill for individual expenses.

Regardless, anyone running a trip has to pay for a variety of things during the trip - could be entry fees, food, odd bits of medicine, food, drinks, supplies the kids lose or forget, taxi to hospital etc etc. It all has to be accounted for and documented on return. There will be a float of cash that will need documenting and use of school credit card. Lots of paperwork.

ThinWomansBrain · 25/02/2023 14:12

sounds as if the school are using funds and resources to benefit those who most need it - not the elite few whose parents can afford expensive trips.
from other posters suggestions there are alternatives that you can organise and pay for independently.

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 14:10

marcopront · 25/02/2023 13:51

@Gwen82

Out of interest… how old were these children?

They are 14 to 16.

I'm still with them.
We left the hotel at 7 am, we'll get to school in about half an hour which will be just after 5.

I only ask because at those ages… surely In charge of own finances? Are you saying you are paying for everything hence having to sending itemised bill?

my ds went to France last year for 4nights. He was 12. Accom and activities paid for. Breakfast included. Other than that… spending money. No bloody way was the school paying and then being reimbursed. And no bloody way was I expecting an itemised bill from my son.

Changechangechanging · 25/02/2023 14:09

OP, I have not read the thread and imagine I am simply going to add to many teacher voices.

You couldn’t pay me enough to take children away overnight. There are too many who are badly behaved, ill mannered and ungrateful. The parents are worse. I will not use my own precious family time to deal with such behaviour.

As long as you expect children who are badly behaved to not be responsible for that behaviour, there will be teachers, like me, who refuse to do anything other than the job they are paid to do.

JMSA · 25/02/2023 14:06

Pretty sure one of our kids once tried to take a knife abroad ...

JMSA · 25/02/2023 14:04

I work at a secondary school. I get the impression that, these days, residential trips are more trouble than they're worth.

MatronicO6 · 25/02/2023 14:01

Honestly, I can't see much difference in what your daughters school offers than I was in Secondary. But I can completely understand why secondary teachers aren't going out of their way to arrange more.

No matter what you do, you get complaints! Why so expensive? Why is there not enough space for everyone to go? Why was my child not selected? Why not go here instead?

Then there is the issue of teacher shortages. A lot of schools are reliant on short term contract or supply teachers.

Schools may not have the budget for supply teachers to cover the class teaching.

Any behavioral issues are difficult to deal with as there is not support system abroad. Likewise health/medication requirements seem to be increasing.

Teachers are expected to be away from their families, which they may not be willing to do do or afford as it may incur childcare costs.

Add in possible covid restrictions/tests and likely more expensive travel. Which will just get more complaints.

If none of that is a problem, the amount of work that goes into organizing a trip, from comparing companies/flights/hotels/prices/travel then all the safeguarding/risk assessment/medical information etc on top of an already high workload would be enough to put me off organising one.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/02/2023 13:58

Older doesn’t make it easier. It’s just different risks. They still need supervision and checking they are safe.

marcopront · 25/02/2023 13:51

@Gwen82

Out of interest… how old were these children?

They are 14 to 16.

I'm still with them.
We left the hotel at 7 am, we'll get to school in about half an hour which will be just after 5.

Sherrystrull · 25/02/2023 13:41

What does it matter?

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 13:28

marcopront · 25/02/2023 12:34

I am going to provide a record of what each student ate at each meal, as parents will get a personalised bill.

I am not an accountant.

That is not a major task, the constant supervision was the hardest part but it was one of the things I had to do.

As someone else said this was all on top of my normal professional duties.
I had to plan for my classes and reply to emails the whole time I was away.

Out of interest… how old were these children?

WombatChocolate · 25/02/2023 12:55

I think that the point is, that after you get back from a trip, the work isn’t over. You might have spent tens or hundreds of hours on the admin in advance, the hundreds of hours over the 24/7 periods of the trip, then return to spend many further hours on post-trip stuff. That could involve expenses stuff and collecting receipts and chasing receipts from other staff, filling in forms for accounts, dealing with lost property and contacting parents, dealing with complaints from parents or questions, filling in school paperwork reviewing the trip, writing up accounts of the visit for the school newsletter and so on.

People want trips for their kids. As they say, it’s something most kids Remmeber most about from school. But honestly, most parents either don’t have any idea of the hours of work invovled to make it happen because they haven’t thought about it/can’t comprehend the task invovled, or just as likely, feel trips are something schools should provide so doing the work to make them happen is part of the teachers job, regardless of the unpaid hours invovled.

Where do people draw the line in terms of how many hours they think teachers should work to provide the stuff they consider part of an ‘education’ for their children?

Trips have always been labour intensive, but over time have got moreso, with increased need for safeguarding, risk assessments and demands of parents. So it’s a bigger job now than ever. And that’s in the context of teachers being hugely stretched in their day-to-day work due to a lack of resources and staff, so they are less able than ever to go above and beyond, especially as the above and beyond needed is bigger than ever. And given the government resistance to improving resourcing, any goodwill remaining is rapidly drying up.

I guess parents simply think ‘my child would love a trip, like I did’ and don’t think about these kind of things that are stopping it happening.

Almsot all of the problems and reducing things in education are down to lack of resourcing. This lack of resourcing is impacting the day to day and year to year experience of children at school and it’s becoming increasingly visible to parents, after schools have worked hard for so long, to keep things going and not show the widening cracks. Parents start to see the reduction in trips, reduction in textbooks, fact their child doesn’t always have a qualified teacher in front of them …..it’s gradual but the trend is in the same direction. In winder when parents will start to get angry and tell the government that, or will they just blame schools?

JaceLancs · 25/02/2023 12:45

I’m nearly 60 and as my parents had very little money never did any residential trips
My DC had one in primary school (outward bound centre) and one in high school (history battlefields)
As a lone parent I paid weekly instalments to afford it
I think with the current cost of living it’s quite sensible and sensitive to consider alternatives
Schools budgets are stretched beyond belief - one local to me is struggling with an increase from £5k to £24k a year energy bills and is cutting staffing across the board from admin to TAs as they cannot balance their budget any other way
I am sure we have all noticed huge increases in consumables - where I work our stationery budget has increased by 400% in 2 years - we have not had any increase in income in fact it has reduced

marcopront · 25/02/2023 12:34

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 10:46

I don’t get it.

I am saying I’m in awe of teachers taking kids on residential

what I’m not in awe of is the listing of stuff like expenses tracking.

I am going to provide a record of what each student ate at each meal, as parents will get a personalised bill.

I am not an accountant.

That is not a major task, the constant supervision was the hardest part but it was one of the things I had to do.

As someone else said this was all on top of my normal professional duties.
I had to plan for my classes and reply to emails the whole time I was away.

CakeCrumbs44 · 25/02/2023 11:20

Maybe you could consider signing her up for Guides or Scouts? Most of the groups near us run residentials and trips

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 11:03

EarthlyNightshade · 25/02/2023 10:52

What's the longest stretch you've worked unpaid?
Have you done a week in one go?

Not. A. Chance

Pizzaholic · 25/02/2023 10:58

Instead school have decided to run an activities week in the summer term for all pupils which includes a bunch of paid days out (eg theatre trips, museums, escape rooms) or the opportunity to stay in school for free activities (sports). This seems like a bit of a crap alternative and frankly a waste of a week's education!
🤔
Not sure how what you said above equates to a waste of a weeks education. All the paid days out are in fact educational so not sure what you are actually wanting tbh.

EarthlyNightshade · 25/02/2023 10:52

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 10:43

Yes. I have never been paid overtime in my professional role. The expectation has been you pull in the hours necessary 🤷‍♀️

What's the longest stretch you've worked unpaid?
Have you done a week in one go?

Gwen82 · 25/02/2023 10:51

Good heavens, coffee time for you! 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread